151. Empowering patients or general practitioners? A randomised clinical trial to improve quality in reproductive health care in Belgium.
- Author
-
Peremans L, Rethans JJ, Verhoeven V, Coenen S, Debaene L, Meulemans H, Denekens J, and Van Royen P
- Subjects
- Adult, Attitude of Health Personnel, Attitude to Health, Belgium, Decision Support Systems, Clinical, Female, Health Plan Implementation, Humans, Male, Medical Records Systems, Computerized, Middle Aged, Practice Guidelines as Topic, Patient Participation psychology, Physicians, Family psychology, Power, Psychological, Quality Assurance, Health Care, Reproductive Health Services standards
- Abstract
Background: Evidence-based clinical guidelines on contraceptive use were developed and distributed among all Flemish general practitioners (GPs) in Belgium., Objectives: To evaluate the effectiveness of two strategies for implementing a guideline on oral contraceptives in order to enhance the quality of the first contraception consultation in general practice, by either empowering patients or by introducing a computer decision support system (CDSS)., Method: A random sample of 45 GPs was distributed among three study groups. One group was visited by an 'empowered patient', one group's electronic medical record was supplemented with a CDSS, and one group served as the control group. Simulated patients (SPs) assessed the performance of GPs in daily practice before and after the interventions, using a validated 48-point checklist., Results: The baseline mean score of the 43 GPs was 26.16 (SD = 5.76). The SPs received sufficient information about correct pill usage, but not concerning factors associated with pill failure and drug interaction. After the intervention, the GPs' mean score was 26.39 (SD = 6.86). Only the intervention group with the 'empowered patient' scored significantly better (29.92 [SD = 7.11]). The computer group and control group scored lower (24.36 [SD = 6.60] and 24.82 [SD = 5.65], respectively)., Conclusion: Developing and distributing an evidence-based guideline did not change GPs' behaviour. However, empowering patients to participate more proactively significantly improved GPs' performance during a contraception consultation. A CDSS did not.
- Published
- 2010
- Full Text
- View/download PDF