151. Dynamic Patterns of Sex Chromosome Evolution in Neognath Birds: Many Independent Barriers to Recombination at the ATP5F1A Locus.
- Author
-
Kimball, Rebecca T. and Braun, Edward L.
- Subjects
- *
SEX chromosomes , *Y chromosome , *HUMAN chromosomes , *X chromosome , *LOCUS (Genetics) , *NATURAL selection , *CHROMOSOMES , *AMINO acid sequence - Abstract
Simple Summary: The evolution of distinct sex chromosomes, such as the X and Y chromosomes of humans, has long been of interest. Unlike most chromosomes, sex chromosomes do not fully recombine during meiosis. The non-recombining region is typically small early in their evolution, but additional regions stop recombining over time. Avian sex chromosomes, where males are ZZ and females ZW, show several evolutionary strata. Previous studies have demonstrated variation in barriers to recombination among bird species in the youngest strata. However, previous studies have sampled relatively few avian orders. Here, we examine one locus (ATP5F1A) from species in 22 different avian orders. Our results indicate that this locus has stopped recombining in almost all orders sampled. However, our results also show that the recombination stopped independently in each order of birds, highlighting the dynamic nature of avian sex chromosome evolution. The cessation of recombination is thought to have functional consequences because it is expected to weaken natural selection. We compared the proteins encoded by the recombining Z chromosome with those on the W chromosome. Most W chromosome proteins appeared to be functional, but they also appeared to be subject to weaker selection than the Z chromosome proteins. Avian sex chromosomes evolved after the divergence of birds and crocodilians from their common ancestor, so they are younger than the better-studied chromosomes of mammals. It has long been recognized that there may have been several stages to the evolution of avian sex chromosomes. For example, the CHD1 undergoes recombination in paleognaths but not neognaths. Genome assemblies have suggested that there may be variation in the timing of barriers to recombination among Neognathae, but there remains little understanding of the extent of this variability. Here, we look at partial sequences of ATP5F1A, which is on the avian Z and W chromosomes. It is known that recombination of this gene has independently ceased in Galliformes, Anseriformes, and at least five neoavian orders, but whether there are other independent cessations of recombination among Neoaves is not understood. We analyzed a combination of data extracted from published chromosomal-level genomes with data collected using PCR and cloning to identify Z and W copies in 22 orders. Our results suggest that there may be at least 19 independent cessations of recombination within Neognathae, and 3 clades that may still be undergoing recombination (or have only recently ceased recombination). Analyses of ATP5F1A protein sequences revealed an increased amino acid substitution rate for W chromosome gametologs, suggesting relaxed purifying selection on the W chromosome. Supporting this hypothesis, we found that the increased substitution rate was particularly pronounced for buried residues, which are expected to be more strongly constrained by purifying selection. This highlights the dynamic nature of avian sex chromosomes, and that this level of variation among clades means they should be a good system to understand sex chromosome evolution. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF