151. Discussion of "Experimental and a dual-scale analysis of the influence of coating on humidity control ability of hygroscopic materials with different porosity".
- Author
-
Janssen, Hans
- Subjects
- *
DISTRIBUTION isotherms (Chromatography) , *HUMIDITY control , *PERMEABILITY measurement , *VAPORS , *PERMEABILITY , *HYGROTHERMOELASTICITY - Abstract
In May 2024, this journal published the paper "Experimental and a dual-scale analysis of the influence of coating on humidity control ability of hygroscopic materials with different porosity", in which a series of hygrothermal properties of foamed concretes are primarily measured, and subsequently used in a interior-humidity-levels performance evaluation via hygrothermal simulation and buffering correlations. This post-publication discussion voices concerns on the sorption isotherm and vapour permeability measurements performed on the foamed concretes. Concerning the sorption isotherms, it is established that these differ from other results on the same materials, and their overly high 75 %RH moisture contents are doubtful. Regarding the vapour permeabilities, the execution and interpretation of the cup tests differ from the relevant standard, and plausibly an incorrect element of the set-up has been weighed. As these hygroscopic properties are the crucial factor in the hygrothermal performance simulations, the findings on that front are equally jeopardised. • This post-publication critique expresses concerns on a previously published paper. • The paper's sorption isotherm measurements deviate from other literature results. • They furthermore bring about an excessively high moisture content at 75 %RH. • The paper's vapour permeability measurements deviate from the relevant standard. • They moreover are based on weighing of the wrong element of the cup set-up. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF