Search

In line with the increasing economic developments and, as a consequence, the expansion of companies in the current post-competitive era, companies have turned to marketing more than ever to gain a competitive advantage. Contracts that have a marketing function can be divided into different types; One of the most common types of contracts is the selective distribution contract. In the EU legal system, the contract is a binding agreement whereby the supplier undertakes to supply products (goods and services) to authorized distributors (distributors who are qualified according to selected criteria) and in return for distribution, the buyer undertakes to resell the products among authorized distributors or final consumers. By concluding selective distribution contracts between the supplier and the distributors, a distribution network is created. This network is called the selective distribution system. Selection criteria are divided into different types: 1) quantitative or qualitative criteria; 2) objective or personal criteria; and 3) commercial or technical competence. The purpose of choosing a selective distribution system is branding, maintaining brand value and maintaining standards and quality in the distribution phase so that the customer gains a quality shopping experience by purchasing the product. In the Iranian legal system, despite the widespread use of the contract, its legal meaning and nature remain unknown and cannot be analyzed in the form of any specific contract, but according to the principle of freedom of contract in Article 10 of the Civil Code, it is accepted.

In the context of the COVID-19 pandemic, considering the restrictions on the population’s free movement, e-commerce has become a real “lifeboat”, in a permanent development and evolution, acquiring extremely wide market niches. This article aims to briefly present the financial and accounting mechanism of e-commerce transactions for the entire related chain: supplier, platform, courier, client.

Industri konveksi saat ini menjadi salah satu klaster industri prioritas di Indonesia. Saat ini tidak semua perusahaan dapat memproduksi bahan baku utama sendiri namun didapat dari supplier. Cathead Apparel merupakan perusahaan konveksi yang beroperasi di Yogyakarta. Pemilihan supplier yang dilakukan Cathead Apparel masih bersifat subyektif dan konvensional hanya berdasarkan pengalaman menjadi mitra. Kriteria dan sub kriteria yang dipakai dalam menentukan supplier yang banyak dalam kasus ini bertujuan memberi solusi atau hasil dari beberapa alternatif untuk diambil sebuah keputusan. Penelitian dilakukan untuk mengetahui kesesuaian penerapan metode Promethee dalam kasus sistem pendukung keputusan pemilihan supplier konveksi agar dapat membantu pemilik konveksi maupun masyarakat umum dalam memilih supplier konveksi. Subyek penelitian ini adalah pemilihan supplier konveksi menggunakan algoritma Promethee. Sistem ini diimplementasikan menggunakan bahasa pemrograman PHP dan database MySQL. Tahap penelitian ini meliputi subyek penelitian, spesifikasi kebutuhan yang berupa perangkat keras serta perangkat lunak yang digunakan, metode pengumpulan data yang meliputi studi pustaka, teknik wawancara, serta observasi, analisis kebutuhan sistem terdiri dari analisis kebutuhan data, analisis kebutuhan user serta analisis kebutuhan sistem, perancangan sistem yang meliputi perancangan manajemen data, subsistem manajemen model, subsistem antar muka pengguna, serta subsistem manajemen berbasis pengetahuan, implementasi sistem, dan pengujian yang menggunakan pengujian beta test dan black box test menggunakan teknik equivalence partitions yang dilakukan berdasarkan lima tahapan, yaitu menentukan kriteria, data uji, kasus uji, pengujian, dan evaluasi. Hasil dari penelitian ini adalah aplikasi SPK pemilihan supplier yang menerapkan algoritma Promethee. Teknik equivalence partitions Dari hasil uji yang telah dilakukan kepada karyawan dan pemilik, diperoleh hasil 79% atau 3,95/5 diterima. Hasil pengujian menghasilkan feedback berupa rekomendasi untuk masukan bagi pemilik konveksi.

This study focuses on MSMEs performance evaluation because they have unique features such as not having a quantifiable objective, not having a record of company operations, but being able to absorb surrounding labor and improve the community's welfare. MSMEs' short-term objective is to annex the company's profit and sales performance. This research aims to construct a measurement model of MSMEs Performance based on resource factors, customers, suppliers, and characteristics of MSMEs in influencing MSMEs' performance. The data was collected by spreading questioner through google form to MSMEs managers assisted by PLUT Batu city and Malang City. The data analysis techniques are carried out qualitatively, and hypothesis testing is carried out with SEM-PLS analysis. The results showed that the factors of resources, customers, and characteristics of MSMEs could measure MSMEs performance, while the supplier factor does not affect the performance of MSMEs

Business-ecosystem is a rather new organizational form of interaction on market between customer and producer, which is used widely today by business-organizations of different organization and legal forms and types of economic activity. The article provides the analysis of business-ecosystems in view of the theory of transaction costs. The terms ‘ecosystem' was initially proposed to describe the environment of mutual existence of different biological beings. Later it was used for depicting the environment of business-organization. In this environment various antipodes exist and interact. At first sight they should avoid collaboration with each other, but in fact mutual coexistence intensifies every participant and fosters their development, therefore, they shall find forms and means of co-existence. In spite of the fact that business-ecosystem is a rather new trend in research in the field of economy and management, certain approaches to research and classification of the phenomenon have been created. The author in view of neo-institutional theory proves that business-ecosystem meets all classical canons, therefore it functions as a classical business-organization with similar goals and relevant tools.

Transfer of technology (TOT) is a contentious issue in the international defence trade. In 2019 it was estimated to form at least 40%, or $123 billion USD, of total international defence trade. Whilst purchasing nations set requirements for TOT within their industrial participation (IP) policies, there is often a mismatch between the scale and type of technology suppliers can offer and the buyer's technological absorption capability (TAC). This persistent tension between ambition and reality frequently strains the buyer-supplier relationship. Thus, understanding how TAC can be enhanced is of vital importance. This paper defines TAC in the international defence acquisition and offsets context and determines the factors for successful TAC. The paper focusses on the potential challenges for successful TAC and offers recommendations on how to enhance TAC. This research is limited to the context of Southeast Asia. The respondents consist of industry, government and academics who operate in the Southeast Asian defence and security sector. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Copyright of Manajemen IKM: Jurnal Manajemen Pengembangan Industri Kecil Menengah is the property of IPB University and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. This abstract may be abridged. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the copy. Users should refer to the original published version of the material for the full abstract. (Copyright applies to all Abstracts.)

This article addresses the development of a model for the material supply planning and management in the construction industry, using System Dynamics, supported by AHP supplier selection methods, evaluation and monitoring with ABC classification, all mediated by Vensim data analysis software. The supply management in the construction industry is studied and analyzed based on a collaborative model between suppliers and builders, under the CPFR model and the integration of the Last Planner System, which contributes to optimize the use of resources that allow completing all social interest housing (VIS) construction projects. The model simulates the impact and performance produced in the collaborative system, compliance with planning and profitability in VIS projects, appropriate selection, and supplier evaluation and monitoring. Finally, this model allows those who make strategic decisions in VIS projects to identify the most critical variables, assess their contribution, and make the right decisions to eliminate waste due to waiting time. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The aim of the study is to create an effective and standard risk assessment tool that provides the company with support and security in purchasing of new products. The goal was to create a tool that complements and standardizes risk assessment forms and shows rapid results. Using the procurement risk management system, the risk associated with a given product can be determined easily and in a short time. In the process, critical areas where hazards may occur can be clearly identified and the risk can be minimized if properly managed. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The study assessed the effect of supplier collaboration on product innovation. In addition, most studies that examine the relationship fail to highlight the effect of the individual practices of supplier collaboration on product innovation, and are on developed nations. A descriptive research design and a cross-sectional survey approach was adopted to distribute questionnaire copies to the respondents. A sample of 29 firms was selected from a population of thirty-eight 38 big manufacturing firms and the analysis was done using descriptive statistics and structural equation model. The results reveal that product innovation is greatly influenced by supplier collaboration, however, only incremental product innovation is influenced. Radical product innovation is not influenced by supplier collaboration, though resource sharing practice influenced it exclusively. The study reveals the effect of exclusive supplier collaboration practices on product innovation and the model could be replicated in other developing nations to see if the outcome will be similar. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Copyright of Journal of Economic Research & Business Administration is the property of Al-Farabi Kazakh National University and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. This abstract may be abridged. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the copy. Users should refer to the original published version of the material for the full abstract. (Copyright applies to all Abstracts.)

Limited empirical and qualitative studies focus on the detailed processes and obstacles for coordinating off-site prefabrication between builders and suppliers. This research aims to identify and address the obstacles that currently prevent the further expansion of off-site prefabrication, with a research scope on timber and mechanical/electrical/plumbing (MEP) services in construction projects. The focal point of this research is to highlight their obstacles. A total of forty interviews were conducted and analyzed from four builders' organizations and four suppliers' organizations to ascertain their obstacles in coordinating the practice of off-site prefabrication. The results found the builder's obstacles were sustainability, quality assurance (QA), mass production, CAD/BIM, technological support, commercial arrangements, system building, buffering in supply, schedule monitoring, productivity, flexibility, engagement, risks, and multiple supply arrangements. The supplier's obstacles were design, financing and subcontracting, coordination, recognized practices, risks, multiple supply arrangements, and constraints. Moreover, the builders and suppliers had identified some ways to harmonize off-site prefabrication of timber. Some examples of timber prefabrication technology include joinery, doors and/or windows, structural floor/wall/roof frames, partitions, trusses, stairs, balustrades, and others. MEP services with in situ construction comprise the use of power sources and working coordination. The most important outcome of this investigation is that these obstacles can be addressed through collaboration and coordination. This is because there is a traditionally a lack of collaboration amongst builders and their suppliers. Furthermore, there is a lack of coordination between them in general. The research contributes to the improved timber and MEP services collaboration and coordination in off-site prefabrication, which can be referred to by other approaches of modular construction. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The aim of the article is to identify, on the basis of the analysis of the literature and the results of empirical research, the expectations of enterprises towards suppliers regarding the improvement of their operational processes. It can be noticed that manufacturing companies, while improving their processes, also require actions in this area from suppliers. The article presents the results of empirical research conducted using the computer-assisted telephone interview (CATI) technique in medium and large manufacturing companies operating in Poland. The results of these studies show that manufacturing companies focus their expectations towards suppliers mainly on the improvement of quality control processes (deliveries, semi-finished products, as well as the finished products). The research results presented in the article have several important implications for representatives of science and business. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The objectives of this research are: (1) To simplify business processes so that supply chain management starts from raw materials to finished materials and distributes these products to end consumers effectively and efficiently; (2) Build a web-based supply chain management application system to make it easier for companies in their business processes. This research method uses qualitative methods. The final results of this study: (a) Application of supply chain management information system designed for PT. ABCD can reduce supply chain uncertainty in companies. Because the implementation of the system can help the company in controlling the procurement of raw materials that must always be available in accordance with the company's needs; (b) The supply chain management information system application that is designed can describe the correlation between suppliers and companies, companies and users who can facilitate ordering goods from suppliers to companies and vice versa, so that the delivery of ordered goods is in accordance with the order and arrives at the company on time and in the right amount; (c). Provide opportunities for suppliers to participate in the implementation of the system to provide online price quotes. Tujuan Penelitian ini adalah untuk: (1) Mempermudah dalam proses bisnis sehingga dalam pengelolaan rantai pasok mulai dari bahan mentah sampai bahan jadi dan mendistribusikan produk tersebut kepada konsumen akhir dapat berjalan secara efektif dan efisien; (2) Membangun suatu sistem aplikasi manajemen rantai pasok yang berbasis website sehingga lebih memudahkan perusahaan dalam proses bisnisnya. Metode penelitian ini menggunakan metode kualitatif. Hasil akhir penelitian ini antara lain (a) Penerapan sistem informasi manajemen rantai pasok yang dirancang untuk PT. ABCD bisa mengurangi ketidakpastian rantai pasok pada perusahaan. Sebab, penerapan sistem tersebut bisa membantu perusahaan dalam pengadaan dan mengendalikan bahan baku yang mesti selalu tersedia sesuai dengan keinginan perusahaan; (b) Aplikasi sistem informasi manajemen rantai pasok yang dirancang tersebut dapat menggambarkan korelasi pemasok dengan perusahaan, perusahaan dengan pemakai yang bisa mempermudah pemesanan barang dari pemasok ke perusahaan maupun sebaliknya sehingga pengiriman barang yang dipesan sesuai dengan pesanan dan sampai ke perusahaan tepat waktu dan tepat jumlah; (c) Memberi peluang kepada pemasok agar ikut serta ke dalam penerapan sistem tersebut untuk memberikan penawaran harga secara online

Currently, companies are required to improve supply chain performance. One of the main problems in the supply chain is the proper supplier selection. Supplier selection has an essential role in improving supply chain management performance. Supplier selection requires the proper criteria. However, the relationship between criteria is rarely considered in the selection of suppliers in the textile industry. This study tries to propose integrating the Decision Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory (DEMATEL) and the Analytic Network Process (ANP) for supplier selection in the textile industry. Both methods are multi-criteria decision making (MCDM) tools DEMATEL is used to assess the relationship between criteria. Furthermore, ANP is used to evaluate and weigh the importance of criteria and suppliers. A case study was carried out in a textile company located in Indonesia. The results show that this procedure can identify the relationship and effect of each criterion. The results show that the product price criteria are the criteria that have the most significant weight. The criteria for conformity to specifications and consistency of quality are in second and third place. Finally, suppliers are selected based on weight assessment on each criterion by ANP.

Purpose: This study also aims to determine suppliers who have the best performance in providing raw material supplies according to analysis and calculations using the Analytical Hierarchy Process method for CV. Gangsar. Design/methodology/approach: The type of research used in this research is quantitative with the Multi-Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) method, more specifically the Analytic Hierarchy Process method. This research is located in CV. Gangsar which is located on Jl. Demuk No. 37 Ngunut Village, Ngunut District, Tulungagung Regency, East Java. Sampling in this study used a non-probability sampling method with a purposive sampling technique. Data analysis technique using AHP. Findings: The results of the study indicate the criteria that can be considered to choose the best flour supplier for CV. Gangsar is price, quality, delivery accuracy, quantity accuracy, and customer care. Quality is the most important criterion with a weight of 0.326, then the price criteria with a weight of 0.289, then the criteria for accuracy of delivery with a weight of 0.171, then the criteria for accuracy of quantities with a weight of 0.140, and the last criterion of customer care with a weight of 0.074. Which flour supplier is the most appropriate to support the production performance of CV. Gangsar can be seen from the greatest weight. The highest weight is Indotapioka with a value of 0.378, followed by Sari Bumi with a weight of 0.330, and finally Sungai Budi with a weight of 0.292. Therefore, Indotapioka Jaya is the most appropriate company to support the production performance of CV. Gangsar. The company should use the research results as input when choosing the right supplier. Paper type: Research paper

Worldwide it is estimated that more than 85% of the main companies used external logistics services, with growth rates of this services market projected between 18 and 22 percent per year. This trend has generated a growing interest in supply chain researchers to propose different approaches for the selection and evaluation of the performance of third party logistics (3PL). This article proposes a systematic review analyzing a sample of articles published in indexed journals in order to identify the main contributions on this topic. This study shows the evaluation and selection of a 3PL is a critical and complex decision, due to the existence of several criteria of imprecise and subjective basis. As a result, methodological characteristics, approaches used, models applied, attributes of the magazines, and industries that use external logistics providers are presented. Cost, information technology implemented by logistics providers, and the effectiveness of shipments and deliveries on time, are the most valued criteria by companies for the evaluation and selection of 3PL. The results of this study provide support to researchers, as a reference that allows identifying some possibilities for future research in the field of providers that offer external logistics services, promoting competitiveness in the supply chain.

The main objective of the present study is to characterize the methodologies employed to select suppliers in the supply chain of copper mining companies in Chile. The case study approach is applied and data is gathered in the year 2021 by surveying executives from copper-producing mining companies in Chile. The results show that mining companies have a supplier selection process with a high degree of evaluation and analysis. It considers economic, social, and environmental criteria. It also uses support management technologies and multi-criteria decision methods (MCDM) such as SMART, AHP, and ANP. It is concluded that copper mining companies use sustainable supplier selection methodologies for their supply chain, which increases the added value of mining businesses in Chile. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The main objective of this research is to evaluate how the relationship between customer and supplier, through the perspective of integrated logistics, can contribute and optimize the production processes of a company. The methodology used was applied research and, in accordance with its objectives is considered exploratory and descriptive, as it aims to report the phenomena of the studied reality and create better understanding of the problem through literature searches and data collection through the analysis of texts published both in the literature, as in printed materials and/or made available on the Internet. The strategies of organizations are increasingly focused on efficiency and effectiveness and for this reason seeks to use appropriate tools as alternatives to achieve those goals. The relationship with suppliers is a procedure that favors the performance of processes. However, it is necessary to conduct a job evaluation and a selection of service providers turning them into partners that will contribute to better performance of activities. It is a vision that is incorporated into the integrated logistics, which seeks to optimize the resources in order to obtain better results and convert in increasing the level of competitiveness of the organization. Every organization has its operational strategy; therefore, the company focus of the study implemented the HSE program to maintain and monitor the relationship with its suppliers, aimed, among other things, measure performance and commitment to Safety, Health, and Environment. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The aim of this article is to identify the benefits perceived by individual recipients that are achieved by consumer energy suppliers on the market, through multilateral trade cooperation, and to define the structure of these benefits according to the declared readiness of recipients to cooperate with the suppliers. The results of the analysis of the available literature on the subject indicate that there is a cognitive and research gap in relation to the perceived benefits achieved by the suppliers through joint marketing activities. The benefits are not being analyzed; especially from the perspective of individual recipients' readiness for this cooperation. This gap is noticeable not only in relation to the energy market, but also in other areas of the consumer market. In an effort to reduce the identified gap, an online survey was conducted among 1196 adult individual energy recipients in Poland. The primary data collected was subjected to quantitative analysis using the following research methods: average grade analysis, comparative analysis, and exploratory factor analysis. The Kruskal–Wallis test was also conducted. The results of the quantitative analysis indicate, inter alia, that the majority of the respondents declared their readiness to cooperate with energy suppliers on the preparation of marketing offers. This variable statistically significantly differentiated nine out of twelve analyzed benefits that, according to the respondents, suppliers obtain as a result of cooperation. This differentiation was not found only in the case of three benefits related to the cost-free acquisition of recipient potential. For all respondents, as well as for the respondents willing to cooperate with suppliers and for those who did not express such willingness, three sections were identified, including the respondents who saw the same benefits achieved by suppliers. The conclusions drawn on the basis of the analysis results constitute a significant contribution to the theory of marketing and the theory of market behavior of individual recipients in the energy market. They also bear clear application advantages, making it easier for energy suppliers to effectively initiate cooperation with individual recipients and/or strengthen this cooperation. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Copyright of Avances is the property of Instituto de Informacion Cientifica y Tecnologica and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. This abstract may be abridged. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the copy. Users should refer to the original published version of the material for the full abstract. (Copyright applies to all Abstracts.)

Copyright of Journal of Engineering Management / Gongcheng Guanli Xuebao is the property of Journal of Engineering Management Editorial Office and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use. This abstract may be abridged. No warranty is given about the accuracy of the copy. Users should refer to the original published version of the material for the full abstract. (Copyright applies to all Abstracts.)

Rough set theory is a powerful mathematical technique of decision making, which can be exploited to feature selection and rule induction from uncertain and ambiguous data. Generally, the attribute significance degree is one of the fundamental metrics used to measure the contained information of each attribute. However, in the most existing rough based methods, some attributes share the identical or zero significance degrees, that cannot reflect the situations in the realistic scenarios. We are then motivated to improve the attribute significance degree of rough set, based on the new attribute significance degree of rough set, a new method of supplier evaluation and selection is presented, it solves the problems existing in current research and verifies the scientific nature and effectiveness of the method with a case. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Pemilihan supplier merupakan salah satu keputusan strategis dalam manajemen rantai pasok yang berpengaruh terhadap peningkatan keunggulan kompetitif suatu perusahaan. Setiap pabrikan perlu memiliki kriteria standar dalam pemilihan supplier sesuai dengan kebutuhan perusahaan. Tujuan dari penelitian ini adalah mengetahui kriteria-kriteria yang paling berpengaruh dan urutan alternatif supplier Rail Pad 158-7 terbaik yang bisa digunakan untuk menjadi bahan pertimbangan oleh PT. Pindad (Persero) dalam memilih supplier di masa yang akan datang. Bobot dan prioritas kriteria yang diuji dengan Metode Analytical Network Process (ANP) juga dimaksudkan untuk memunculkan hubungan timbal balik yang saling berpengaruh antar kriteria. ANP dapat digunakan untuk membantu membuat keputusan untuk memilih supplier dan untuk mengelola kinerja rantai pasokan. Makalah ini menunjukkan kriteria yang mempengaruhi keputusan pemilihan suatu supplier yaitu faktor biaya, delivery, kualitas, dan service sebagai prioritas utama produksi perusahaan. Adapun jika terdapat perbedaan maka perbedaan perspektif dipengaruhi oleh tingkat minat dan tanggung jawab yang berbeda. Perbedaan penilaian ini membentuk dasar pengambilan keputusan dan kebijakan strategis rantai pasokan sesuai dengan kondisi perusahaan. Abstract [Analysis of Supplier Selection Using Analytical Network Process (ANP) Method in Procurement of Rail Pad 158-7 Components (Case Study: PT. Pindad (Persero))] Supplier selection is one of the strategic decisions in supply chain management that affects the improvement of a company's competitive advantage. Each manufacturer needs to have standard criteria in the selection of suppliers according to company needs. The purpose of this paper is to find out the most influential criteria and the best alternative order of Rail Pad 158-7 suppliers that can be used as a material for consideration by PT PINDAD (Persero) in selecting future suppliers. The weight and priority of the criteria tested by the Analytical Network Process (ANP) Method are also intended to bring up mutually influential relationships between criteria. ANP can be used to help make decisions to choose suppliers and to manage supply chain performance. This paper shows the criteria that influence a supplier selection decision, which are cost, delivery, quality, and service as the main priority of the company's production. As for if there are differences, differences in perspective are influenced by different levels of interest and responsibility. This difference in valuation forms the basis of supply chain strategic decision-making and policy according to company conditions. Key words: ANP; Criteria; MCDM; Supplier

The article focuses on the scope of the Directive (EU) 2019/633 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 April 2019 on unfair trading practices in business-to-business relationships in the agricultural and food supply chain. It discusses recent developments in regulatory approach to unfair trading practices. It analyses steps taken towards uniformity in this area of law within the EU and contemplates whether there is a need for further harmonisation. The article attempts to evaluate the scope of the UTP Directive, focusing mainly on a material scope inherently linked to the notion of “agricultural and food products” and characteristics of unfair trading practices. It also discusses whether Member States should consider widening the national regulations beyond food supply chain so that their scope would cover vertical relationships in every sector of the economy.

The paper analyses unfair trading practices that arise as a result of imbalance in bargaining power between suppliers and buyers of agricultural and food products. Considering that unfair practices also exist in the relations established between consumers and traders, that special rules have been adopted in this regard, the peculiarities and differences that exist between these rules were first pointed out, i.e., in terms of the approach to regulating these practices. Furthermore, the classification of unfair trade practices as absolutely and relatively prohibited was performed, and, finally, the rules on the way in which suppliers are protected from unfair practices were set out. Basically, the method of protection (administrative protection, at the initiative of the competent authorities or at the request of relevant organizations and associations) justifies the adoption of special rules that establish an effective system of protection of suppliers from unfair trading practices.

Supplier performance evaluation is one of the important factors in the supply chain because it is one of the company's strategies for increasing customer satisfaction and also maintaining the company's services in meeting consumer demand. This study proposes the integration of the Analytic Network Process (ANP) and the Preference Ranking Organization Method for Enrichment Evaluation (PROMETHEE) to evaluate supplier performance. The integration of the two methods is proposed to obtain more complex assessment results because the combination of the two methods considers various criteria derived from ANP and various preferences from PROMETHEE, so both methods are very good to use instead of using just ANP or PROMETHEE or other methods. ANP exhibit more complex relationships between criteria and levels in the decision hierarchy, while PROMETHEE provides decision-makers with flexible and straightforward outranking to analyze multi-criteria problems. In this study, ANP is used to weight the criteria, and PROMETHEE is used to rank suppliers in evaluating supplier performance. Integrating these two methods provides more objective and accurate results in multi-criteria decision-making. The proposed method is validated by solving an industrial case of supplier evaluation problem using the real data from the skewer industry. Finally, some useful implications for managerial decision-making are discussed.