Wipapat Kladwang, Mélanie Meyer, Grzegorz Chojnowski, Alla Peselis, Jinwei Zhang, Michal J. Boniecki, Pablo Cordero, Marta Szachniuk, Stanislaw Dunin-Horkawicz, Peinan Zhao, Tomasz Zok, José Almeida Cruz, Arpit Tandon, François Major, Katarzyna J. Purzycka, Marc Frédérick Blanchet, Alexander Serganov, Mariusz Popenda, Andrey Krokhotin, Dorota Matelska, Ryszard W. Adamiak, Rhiju Das, Marcin Magnus, Siqi Tian, Nikolay V. Dokholyan, Benoît Masquida, Juliusz Stasiewicz, Grzegorz Lach, Zhichao Miao, Thomas H. Mann, Xiaojun Xu, Eric Westhof, Fang-Chieh Chou, Adrian R. Ferré-D'Amaré, Feng Ding, Janusz M. Bujnicki, Shi-Jie Chen, Yi Xiao, Jian Wang, and Clarence Yu Cheng
This paper is a report of a second round of RNA-Puzzles, a collective and blind experiment in three-dimensional (3D) RNA structure prediction. Three puzzles, Puzzles 5, 6, and 10, represented sequences of three large RNA structures with limited or no homology with previously solved RNA molecules. A lariat-capping ribozyme, as well as riboswitches complexed to adenosylcobalamin and tRNA, were predicted by seven groups using RNAComposer, ModeRNA/SimRNA, Vfold, Rosetta, DMD, MC-Fold, 3dRNA, and AMBER refinement. Some groups derived models using data from state-of-the-art chemical-mapping methods (SHAPE, DMS, CMCT, and mutate-and-map). The comparisons between the predictions and the three subsequently released crystallographic structures, solved at diffraction resolutions of 2.5–3.2 Å, were carried out automatically using various sets of quality indicators. The comparisons clearly demonstrate the state of present-day de novo prediction abilities as well as the limitations of these state-of-the-art methods. All of the best prediction models have similar topologies to the native structures, which suggests that computational methods for RNA structure prediction can already provide useful structural information for biological problems. However, the prediction accuracy for non-Watson–Crick interactions, key to proper folding of RNAs, is low and some predicted models had high Clash Scores. These two difficulties point to some of the continuing bottlenecks in RNA structure prediction. All submitted models are available for download at http://ahsoka.u-strasbg.fr/rnapuzzles/.