101. TAKING LEAVE OF THE PHAEACIANS: ON ODYSSEY, XIII,125–187.
- Author
-
VAN DER MIJE, SEBASTIAAN
- Subjects
- *
PHAEACIANS , *GREEK mythology , *ZEUS (Greek deity) , *PROPHECY , *POSEIDON (Greek deity) - Abstract
What happens when the Phaeacian ship returns to Scheria in book XIII of the Odyssey has been a vexed question ever since Antiquity. It is clear that Poseidon turns it into stone on Zeus’ advice, but does Zeus advise anything beyond that, and does Poseidon do anything beyond that? In v. 158, where Zeus gives his advice, the text is uncertain: according to the vulgate reading, Zeus approves of Poseidon’s intention to place a mountain on top of (or around) the city, but according to an ancient variant, he advises against it. Modern scholarship is no less divided on the issue (or issues) than the ancients. Considerations from Homeric “theology” have dominated the debate: must the prophecy given to Nausithous, which included the mountain, be fulfi lled, or would it be out of character for Zeus to go along with Poseidon’s ruthless punishment? This paper argues that the conversation between Zeus and Poseidon leading up to v. 158 shows that Poseidon will do what Zeus advises, and that Zeus’ advice in v. 158 must have been “no”. That Poseidon in 162f. petrifi es the ship and then leaves confi rms this. “Theological” and other non-contextual considerations that have been advanced against this reading are scrutinized and found to be unconvincing. If the issue can thus be decided from the context alone, the outcome may in turn inform wider “theological” and other discussions. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2020