Search

A solar energetic (E 50 MeV) particle (SEP) event observed at 1 AU began about 15000 UT on 1981 December 5. This event was associated with a fast coronal mass ejection observed with the Solwind coronagraph on the P78-1 satellite. No metric type 2 or type 4 burst was observed, but a weak interplanetary type 2 burst was observed with the low frequency radio experiment on the International Sun-Earth Explorer-3 satellite. The mass ejection was associated with the eruption of a large solar quiescent filament which lay well away from any active regions. The eruption resulted in an H alpha double ribbon structure which straddled the magnetic inversion line. No impulsive phase was obvious in either the H alpha or the microwave observations. This event indicates that neither a detectable impulsive phase nor a strong or complex magnetic field is necessary for the production of energetic ions.

In the morning of February 16, 1984 a solar cosmic ray event (GLE) was recorded by the world wide network of neutron monitors (NM). The counting rate vs. time profile of the Goose Bay NM (geog. lat. = 53.3 deg. N, deog. long. = 299.6 deg E) where the increase is expressed as percent of the counting rate of an equatorial sea level NM is presented. The Goose Bay NM was observed to have the maximum response to the solar particles. Its counting rate vs. time profile exhibits a rapid increase to maximum, has a large amplitude (approx. 170%) and decays rapidly to background in approx. 90 min. In Fig. 1 we also show the counting rate vs. time profile for the Tixie Bay NM (71.6 deg, 128.9 deg) which recorded an increase of only a few percent. Since the NMs at Goose Bay and Tixie Bay have asymptotic viewing directions approx. 180 deg apart in longitude, the anisotropy of the solar particle flux at Earth from these stations.

Solar energetic particle events observed in space have different properties depending on the class of associated flare. Impulsive flares, which occur low in the corona in regions of high energy density, are associated with particle events which are deficient in protons. These events are rarely associated with coronal mass ejections and interplanetary shocks. The vast majority of large, high energy proton events are associated with long duration flares, many of which are also associated with fast coronal mass ejections and strong interplanetary shocks. Such flare events originate relatively high in the corona.

A comparison between proton events and coronal mass ejections (CMEs) based on nearly three years of observations around the recent maximum of solar activity is presented. Peak proton fluxes are found to correlate with both the speeds and the angular sizes of the associated CMEs. It is shown that CME speeds do not significantly correlate with CME angular sizes, so that peak proton fluxes are correlated with two independent CME parameters. With larger angular sizes, CMEs are more likely to be loops and fans rather than jets and spikes and are more likely to intersect the ecliptic.

Neutron monitor data from the IMP 7 and 8 satellites are used in the present analysis of the cosmic ray events of Nov. 22, 1977, and May 7, 1978, in order to determine the energy spectra of the solar protons from 50 MeV to 10 GeV, together with pitch angle distributions, intensity-time profiles, and anisotropy-time profiles. The solar proton energy spectra obtained agree with the overlapping energy range when the pitch angle distribution is taken into account, and it is noted that the energy spectra covering three decades of energy and eight of intensity, together with their time variations, were very similar for the two events. The May 1978 event is important for the study of solar particle acceleration and their subsequent injection into the interplanetary medium. Although the solar proton propagation of the November 1977 event was diffusive, the solar particle injection was also time-extended and energy-dependent.

A survey of recent results on the shapes and relative slopes of the spectra of various solar energetic particle populations is presented, with emphasis on the more extensive results currently available for protons, alphas and electrons. From previous work, it is found that proton spectra 0.8 to more than 400 MeV and alpha spectra 1.4 to 80 MeV/nucleon are best characterized, on average, by a functional form involving a Bessel function in momentum/nucleon. However, proton and alpha spectral slopes using this form are not equal, and there is significant variation from event to event. From other studies, electrons 0.02 to 20 MeV are also found to have curved spectra, but seem to be better fit with a double power law in energy. The spectral properties in both cases correlate with other measures of solar particle acceleration; e.g. gamma-ray line production, hard X-ray burst spectra and microwave fluxes.

The present review has the objective to cover major developments in American research related to solar energetic particles, both observational and theoretical, taking into account the period from late 1978 to late 1982. It is pointed out that particular progress has been made in the area of solar energetic particle composition with respect to elemental, isotopic, and the distribution of charge states. This progress is primarily the result of improved instrumentation available at a time of higher solar activity. An important aspect of solar particle studies is to understand the propagation of particles from the vicinity of the sun through interplanetary space to wherever the observing instruments are located. Almost all mathematical models for the transport of solar cosmic rays are derived in some sense from the same general Boltzmann or Vlasov equations. Attention is also given to advances related to an understanding of coronal propagation, and acceleration and injection processes.

From February 1980 - February 1982, the Gamma Ray Spectrometer on the Solar Maximum Mission satellite observed the impulsive phases of sixteen western hemisphere flares that were associated with prompt solar proton events. Six of these flares had a detectable excess in the 4-8 MeV window and four others had detectable continuum emission above 300 keV. As indicated in earlier studies based on fewer events, a lack of correlation is found between the peak 10 MeV near-earth proton fluxes and prompt gamma-ray-line fluences. The two largest proton events in the sample did not have detectable emission above 300 keV. For the 9 December event, an upper limit for the density of the ion acceleration region of 8 billion/cu cm or less is obtained for an acceleration time constant of 1500 s.

Proton events of energies of at least 4 MeV presumed due to solar flares are compared with coronal mass ejections (CMEs) observed with an orbiting coronagraph. H alpha flares are associated with 27 of the 50 flare proton events of the study. Each of these 27 flares is then associated temporally and spatially with a CME, confirming the earlier conclusion, based on Skylab data, that a CME may be a necessary condition for a flare proton event. Peak 4-22 MeV proton fluxes correlate with both the speeds and the angular sizes of the associated CMEs. CMEs of larger angular sizes are more likely to be loops or fans rather than jets or spikes and are more likely to intersect the ecliptic.

Proton fluences in contemporary solar-flare events (1965-82) are analyzed to obtain values of average flux and characteristic rigidity R0 (MV). Both proton fluences F (E greater than 10MeV) and R0 (in the energy interval 10-30 MeV) values for individual events follow log-normal distribution. Comparison of contemporary average flux and R0 values with long-term averaged values, based on lunar sample data, indicate that the ancient solar-flare proton spectra were harder compared to that observed in contemporary flares. The contemporary and long-term (greater than 10,000 yr) averaged fluxes are similar, although such a comparison may not be meaningful because the contemporary averages suffer from uncertainty due to statistics of a single event. The long-term average data suggests a secular variation in solar-flare activity with enhanced proton fluxes during the last 100,000 years.

The analysis and interpretation of the multiple-spacecraft observations of a collection of flare events in six energy bands between 3 and 60 MeV/nucleon are presented. The longitudinal and radial dependence of the times of maximum flux, the relative maximum fluxes, and the decay constants, are determined; and the propagation model is compared with a simplified single-spacecraft model. The analytical model developed accounts for the effects of diffusion, convection, adiabatic deceleration, and corotation. The intensity time profiles are calculated for hypothetical spacecraft spaced at 60-deg longitude intervals between -120 and 120 deg. It is concluded that the large value of k(IP) (greater than or equal to 6 x 10 to the 21st sq cm/s) indicates the nonnegligibility of focused diffusion in the interplanetary modeling of these events.

Satellite data for solar flare particle events during solar cycle 21 (up to July 1982) have been analyzed to obtain event-integrated fluxes of energetic protons and alpha particles. Thirty nine events with proton fluences (E greater than 10 MeV) greater than 10-million/sq cm occurred during 1976-1982. The average flux of protons with kinetic energy greater than 10 MeV is 65 per sq cm/s for this period. The event averaged alpha to proton ratio, in the energy interval 1-22 MeV/n, varies between 0.006 to 0.04, with an average value of about 0.02 for the whole cycle. The flux of protons (with energies greater than 10 MeV) averaged over cycle 21 is lower than those for solar-cycle 20 per sq cm/s based on satellite data, and for solar-cycle 19 378 per sq cm/s based on lunar sample data. There is no definitive correlation between solar-cycle averaged proton fluxes and sunspot numbers.

An investigation is conducted concerning an occurrence of effects related to energy dependence in studies of solar flare particle composition, taking into account eight large solar-flares associated particle events. The ratios C/O (carbon/oxygen), (MG plus Si)/O, and Fe(group)/O as a function of energy/nucleon are presented in a graph. A wide range of variation in the Fe(group)/O ratios is found from event to event. While the energy dependence is consistent in most events with individual element spectra, several events show unusual behavior in the Fe(group)/O ratio, due to the existence of several distinct spectral components. These multiple spectral components may imply multiple phases of acceleration or substantial interplanetary shock contamination at low energies at times well below the arrival time of these shocks at 1 AU.

Attempts to systematically measure and fit a large sample of flare spectra from IMP 7 and 8 satellite data to determine the spectral forms that characterize the data and the range of spectral slopes are reported. Proton spectra are constructed covering the range 0.9 to over 400 MeV, and alpha fluxes from 1.4-80 MeV/nucleon. The event spectra are composed of fluxes measured at different times at each energy, and fitting procedures were employed such as a power law in kinetic energy, an exponential in rigidity, an exponential in energy, and a Bessel function of momentum/nucleon. Best fits were obtained with the exponential in rigidity and the Bessel function, with the Bessel function having a better numerical accuracy for all 21 proton spectra considered.

We present maps of the lunar surface remanent magnetic fields detected by the electron reflection method. These maps provide substantial coverage of the latitude band from 30 N southward to 30 S with a resolution of about 40 km and a sensitivity of about 0.2 gamma at the lunar surface. Regions of remanent magnetization are observed ranging in size from the resolution limit of 1.25 deg to above approximately 60 deg. The largest contiguous region fills the Big Backside Basin where it is intersected by the spacecraft orbital tracks. Preliminary analyses of the maps show that the source regions of lunar limb compressions correspond to regions of strong surface magnetism, and that there does not appear to be sharply discontinuous magnetization at the edges of maria. We also analyze the electron reflection observations to obtain information on the direction and distribution of magnetization in the Van de Graaff anomaly region.

The paper describes the technique of planetary electron reflection magnetometry (PERM), a method for measuring the magnitude, direction, and scale size of magnetic fields near the surface of the moon and other planetary bodies with weak and small-scale-size surface fields. It is noted that the PERM technique is based on the ability of magnetic fields to reflect charged particles. A qualitative account of the implementation of the technique is presented along with some results obtained by the Apollo 15 and 16 Particles and Fields subsatellites. The quantitative aspects of PERM are treated by examining solutions to the equation of motion of a charged particle in a magnetic field, computing reflection coefficients on the basis of trajectory calculations, and determining the direction of the lunar surface magnetic field. The sensitivity of the PERM technique is calculated, and effects of lunar electric fields and spacecraft potentials on the measurements are described. Extension of the technique to Mars and Venus is discussed.

A technique is described for mapping areas of lunar surface magnetism by observing ambient low-energy electrons from lunar orbit with a detector that is sectored to distinguish directions of arrival with respect to the ambient magnetic field and the lunar surface. It is noted that the ambient electrons provide a probe along the ambient magnetic-field lines down to the lunar surface for remote sensing of the presence of surface fields. Unlike direct magnetometer measurements, this probe does not require low altitude or a very stable ambient field in order to map the occurrence regions of such fields. Preliminary maps generated for the surface magnetic areas underlying the orbit of the Particles and Fields Satellite deployed from Apollo 16 are presented to demonstrate the feasibility of this technique.

Direct observations of convection electric fields in the earth's magnetotail are reported. The electric fields have been measured from lunar orbit by detection of the E x B/B-squared drift displacement of low-energy electrons at the limb of the moon. It is found that electric fields range in magnitude from a value less than or equal to 0.02 mV/m, the limit of sensitivity of the method, to 2 mV/M. The typical value is 0.15 mV/M, and the corresponding convection velocity is 15 km/s. The sense of the electric field is almost always dawn to dusk. The electric field is often variable on a time scale of hours and sometimes minutes. The observations indicate that the electric field is not uniform across the magnetotail. If it is assumed that the typical measured electric-field value represents an average over the inhomogeneities, the potential drop across the entire tail is of the order of 40 kV.

Enhancements in 2-300 keV electron flux and 40 keV-2 MeV proton flux lasting for periods from about 1 to more than 5 days have been observed by the Apollo 15 and 16 subsatellites. Many of these enhancements appear to be associated with the passage of flare-producing active regions on the solar disk. Boundaries of these flux enhancements are sometimes correlated with the passage of sector boundaries in the interplanetary magnetic field. The energy spectra of the observed low energy particles suggests that continual acceleration occurs at coronal heights over solar active regions.

Particle measurements made by the lunar-orbiting Apollo subsatellites have shown that electron energy spectra in the range 0.55-320 keV in the high-latitude magnetotail often fit a power law with an exponent of -3 and a flux at .5 keV of 200,000 to 700,000 el/sq cm s sr keV. In the magnetosheath, electron energy spectra are similar to the high-latitude magnetotail spectra. In the plasma sheet, electron energy spectra often fit the high-energy tail of a Maxwellian distribution with Eo of about 200-500 eV. During times of substorms a number of cases where the plasma sheet appears to thin at onset have been observed. In addition, cases of plasma sheet expansion at onset have also been observed.

Description of a new technique for the detection of surface remanent magnetic fields from lunar orbiting spacecraft. Energetic (approximately 14-keV) electrons in the particle population surrounding the moon are observed by the Apollo 15 and 16 Subsatellite particle experiments to be scattered back up from the lunar surface by remanent magnetic fields. The regions of intense lunar remanent magnetization discovered by the Apollo 15 and 16 Subsatellite magnetometers are observed to strongly scatter the 14-keV electrons. In addition, several previously unreported regions of surface remanent magnetization on the lunar near-side are evident from the electron observation.

The lunar particle shadows and boundary layer experiments aboard the Apollo 15 and 16 subsatellites and scientific reduction and analysis of the data to date are discussed with emphasis on four major topics: solar particles; interplanetry particle phenomena; lunar interactions; and topology and dynamics of the magnetosphere at lunar orbit. The studies of solar and interplanetary particles concentrated on the low energy region which was essentially unexplored, and the studies of lunar interaction pointed up the transition from single particle to plasma characteristics. The analysis concentrated on the electron angular distributions as highly sensitive indicators of localized magnetization of the lunar surface. Magnetosphere experiments provided the first electric field measurements in the distant magnetotail, as well as comprehensive low energy particle measurements at lunar distance.

We present the first observations of protons down to 44 keV and electrons down to less than about 2 keV emitted in an impulsive solar particle event. The observations are from the Apollo 15 Subsatellite during a flare event which began on September 1, 1971. We obtain a lower limit estimate of the energy contained in protons above about 0.05 MeV in the flare. The effects of adiabatic deceleration in the interplanetary medium and dE/dx energy loss in the corona are discussed. We conclude that energetic protons may constitute a major energy release in large solar flares.

The main purpose of this article is to describe the plasma and particle populations in the magnetotail near 60 earth radii geocentric distance. Both the plasma sheet and the high-latitude portions of the magnetotail are discussed. Electron and proton spectra at energies above about 20 keV and electron spectra down to 0.5 keV have been obtained. Another topic of importance is the comparison of the deep magnetotail plasma sheet with the Vela satellite measurements at about 20 earth radii geocentric distance.

In five years of observations between 1974 and 1978, at least 17 He-3 enriched events have been identified in the energy range 2 to 13 MeV/nucleon, with He-3/He-4 ratios ranging from less than 0.1 to greater than 4. The scarcity of H-2 in He-3 events found by other workers is confirmed in this data. Flattening of He-3 spectra relative to He-4 is identified in several of the events. Many but not all of the sampled events are found to have small H-1/He-4 ratios. A sum of the sampled events shows not only Fe enrichments but abundances enhanced relative to oxygen of all heavier elements. No substantial depletion of carbon is identified. A dependence of the enhancements in He-3 events on atomic number like that found in other Fe-enriched solar cosmic ray events suggests a common mechanism producing the enhancements.

Data on solar particle composition from the Goddard experiment on IMP 8 now spans a period of five years. During this time, detailed abundances and spectra have been obtained for elements through the Fe group and isotopic abundances have been obtained for H and He from a number of the largest flare-associated solar particle events. In the energy range 6.7-15 MeV/nucleon, a systematic enhancement of solar cosmic ray over solar photospheric Na, Mg, Al and Si abundances relative to oxygen is shown to exist in all these large flare events. An additional enhancement of abundances in the elements beyond carbon relative to oxygen that is correlated with atomic charge (or mass) occurs in certain events and produces a variability in Fe/O greater than a factor of 10. Summed over these eight large flares, the Be/O and B/O ratios are shown to be less than 0.0002 and Li/O to be less than 0.001 between 4.2 and 15 MeV/nucleon.

The relative abundances of 1.5-23 MeV per nucleon ions in corotating nucleon streams are compared with ion abundances in particle events associated with solar flares and with solar and solar wind abundances. He/O and C/O ratios are found to be a factor of the order 2-3 greater in corotating streams than in flare-associated events. The distribution of H/He ratios in corotating streams is found to be much narrower and of lower average value than in flare-associated events. H/He in corotating energetic particle streams compares favorably in both lack of variability and numerical value with H/He in high-speed solar wind plasma streams. The lack of variability suggests that the source population for the corotating energetic particles is the solar wind, a suggestion consistent with acceleration of the corotating particles in interplanetary space.

A numerical model of interplanetary propagation is used to reconstruct the shape of particle spectra near the sun shortly after release, from the proton and electron fluxes observed at 1 AU after the solar cosmic-ray event of September 1, 1971. A calculation of the spectral changes that would be produced by collisional energy losses is employed to estimate the amount of matter through which the particles passed, the height at which they were accelerated, and, for the proton, the temperature of the plasma. A temperature of about 2.4 million K in the proton acceleration region is obtained, along with a column density of material traversed equal to about 140 micrograms/sq cm for the protons and a column density of less than 4 micrograms/sq cm for the electrons. These results are shown to imply proton acceleration near the base of the corona and electron acceleration at a height greater than about 1 solar radius.

Solid-state detectors on IMP 7 and IMP 8 provide measurements in interplanetary space of ion energy spectra and relative composition from He through Ni in the energy range 2-40 MeV/nucleon. The large solar events of July 3-9, September 11-16, and September 20-26, 1974, are analyzed in detail. Spectra are fit by either power laws in energy or by momentum-dependent exponentials. Spectral slope is independent of ion charge for elements beyond C. Substantial time variations in the He/O and (Fe + Ni)/O ratios are noted. New limits are derived for the abundances of Li, Be, B, F, Na, Al, P, S, Ar, and Ca. Analysis of additional events from 1973 through 1976 suggests a systematic enhancement of the He/O and C/O ratios in low-energy corotating flux increases compared with flare-associated particle fluxes.

Measurements of the magnetic fields by the electron reflection method in the neighborhood of the long structural rille Rima Sirsalis show that a magnetic field with a strength of at least 100 nT (100 gammas) is present over a region of the order of 10 km in width and at least 300 km long. The center of the magnetized region closely parallels and is centered on the rille. The linear magnetization feature extends at least to latitude 8 deg S, 60 km beyond the place where the rille disappears at the edge of Oceanus Procellarum. This extension is coincident with the extrapolation of the rille based on photographs. However, the magnetization is much weaker or entirely absent at 5 deg S and has vanished at 0 deg latitude. These results suggest that the rille is indeed a structural feature and has associated with it magnetization, either in the form of intrusive magnetized rock or of a gap in an otherwise more or less uniformly magnetized layer of rock of large extent in two dimensions. Furthermore, the rille structure evidently is present for some distance beneath the lava flows of the Oceanus Procellarum basin.

DC electric fields and solar electrons were simultaneously measured by the Apollo 15 subsatellite in the earth's magnetotail at lunar orbital distance and by rocket and balloon experiments in the polar ionosphere. The magnetotail and polar ionosphere transverse electric fields are found generally to agree in magnitude and direction. The electron spectra from 0.5 to 200 keV are essentially identical, indicating that the potential difference due to parallel electric fields between the magnetotail and the rocket located in the polar ionosphere did not exceed approximately 500 V during the time of the measurements.

The experiment with the small scientific subsatellite which was launched into lunar orbit from Apollo 15 is described. The subsatellite was designed to measure plasma and energetic-particle fluxes, vector magnetic fields, and velocity of the subsatellite for determining lunar gravitational anomalies. The theory of particle-shadow formation by the moon solar wind electrons, and energetic-electron fluxes in interplanetary space are discussed along with an analysis of the initial data.

The Apollo 16 particles and fields subsatellite is instrumented to measure (1) plasma and energetic-particle fluxes, (2) vector magnetic fields, and (3) velocity of the subsatellite to a high precision for the purpose of determining lunar gravitational anomalies. Results from the magnetic-field and gravitational-field experiments are discussed. The results obtained from the plasma and energetic-particle detectors are discussed briefly. The plasma and energetic-particles experiment describes the various plasma regimes in which the moon moves, and determines how the moon interacts with the plasma and magnetic fields in the environment.

The observations were from the particle experiment aboard the Apollo 16 subsatellite which was ejected April 24, 1972 into an approximately equatorial lunar orbit from the Apollo 16 lunar science module. The proton fluxes vary by a factor of about 5 over a six-month period. The proton measurements were made with a pair of surface barrier semiconductor telescopes. The accuracy of the proton flux measurements during times when electrons are present is highly dependent on the accuracy of the electronic channel matching.

Measurements of high-energy solar-wind electrons have been made from a low orbit around the moon. Solar-wind electrons can be identified up to energies of about 3000 eV, at which an electron population of entirely different characteristics becomes dominant. The solar-wind cavity on the moon's antisolar side shows evidence of being filled by plasma coming from the downstream direction. When the direction of the interplanetary field corresponds to solar ecliptic azimuth angles of about 90 deg, a partial solar-wind cavity extends across most of the eastern sunlit side of the moon within 20 deg of the moon meridian. There are localized increases in the 500-eV electron flux over much of the sunlit hemisphere. These increases are interpreted to be the result of an interaction between the solar wind and the moon that deflects some of the solar-wind flow and results in limb shocks.

The interaction of particles having non-zero gyroradii with a spherical absorber such as the Moon is theoretically treated. The Moon is assumed to have no effect on ambient magnetic or electric fields, and collective interactions of the particles are ignored. Properties of particle shadows are investigated in a uniform magnetic field and also in the presence of a uniform particle drift normal to this field (as might be produced by a uniform electric field transverse to the magnetic field). Shadow properties are calculated for particles in specified narrow energy and pitch angle intervals. Numerous results are derived for the specific case of a detector in a low lunar orbit as well as some results on the structure of particle shadow as a general function of spatial position.