101. The effect of ethnicity on physician estimates of pain severity in patients with isolated extremity trauma
- Author
-
Todd, Knox H., Lee, Tony, and Hoffman, Jerome R.
- Subjects
Pain -- Measurement ,Ethnicity -- Health aspects ,Emergency physicians -- Practice - Abstract
Patient ethnicity does not appear to affect doctors' estimates of the severity of a patient's pain. Researchers evaluated pain estimates using a visual scale for 138 non-Hispanic white and 69 Hispanic patients. The two sets of patients differed in their language use, insurance status and cause of injury. However, the average patient pain estimate did not differ between white and Hispanic patients. Pain estimates averaged 39.8 millimeters (mm) on a 100 mm visual scale for whites and 39.0 mm for Hispanics. On average, doctors estimated pain at 33.6 mm for white patients versus 29.7 mm for Hispanic patients. The average difference between patient and doctor estimates of pain was 6.1 mm for whites and 9.4 mm for Hispanics, but this difference was not significant. Further analysis revealed that only patient pain estimates and injury type could predict a disparity in patient and doctor assessments of pain., Objective. - To determine whether physician estimates of pain severity are influenced by patient ethnicity. Design.- Prospective cohort study. Setting. - UCLA Emergency Medicine Center, a level I trauma center, Los Angeles, Calif. Participants. - Hispanic and non-Hispanic white patients presenting to the emergency department with extremity trauma when research assistants were present. Exclusion criteria were patient refusal, altered mentation, or severe injury interfering with the interview process. Main Outcome Measures. - The difference between patient and physician estimates of pain severity as assessed on a visual analog scale for Hispanics and non-Hispanic whites. Results. - A total of 138 non-Hispanic white and 69 Hispanic patients participated in the study. The groups differed in language use, insurance status, and proportions suffering occupational injury. There were no differences between non-Hispanic white and Hispanic patients in patient pain assessments (mean, 39.8 mm vs 39.0 mm, respectively; P=.86), physician pain assessments (mean, 33.6 mm vs 29.7 mm; P=.23), or the disparity between patient and physician pain assessments (mean 6.1 mm vs 9.4 mm; P=.38). The degree of disparity between patient and physician pain assessments remained similar for both groups even after controlling for multiple potential confounders. Conclusions. - Physician ability to assess pain severity does not differ for Hispanic and non-Hispanic white patients. Other explanations for a difference in analgesic practice as a function of ethnicity should be explored.
- Published
- 1994