51. Is the double-guidewire technique superior to the pancreatic duct guidewire technique in cases of pancreatic duct opacification?
- Author
-
Reina, Tanaka, Takao, Itoi, Atsushi, Sofuni, Fumihide, Itokawa, Toshio, Kurihara, Takayoshi, Tsuchiya, Shujiro, Tsuji, Kentaro, Ishii, Nobuhito, Ikeuchi, Junko, Umeda, Ryosuke, Tonozuka, Mitsuyoshi, Honjo, Shuntaro, Mukai, and Fuminori, Moriyasu
- Subjects
Adult ,Aged, 80 and over ,Cholangiopancreatography, Endoscopic Retrograde ,Male ,Pancreatic Ducts ,Contrast Media ,Middle Aged ,Catheterization ,Cohort Studies ,Pancreatitis ,Humans ,Duodenoscopes ,Female ,Aged ,Hyperamylasemia ,Retrospective Studies - Abstract
Pancreatic duct guidewire placement (P-GW) techniques include both the injection cannulation technique with a contrast medium and wire-guided cannulation without contrast injection for selective biliary cannulation; the latter is the so-called "double-guidewire technique" (D-GW). The aim of this study was to compare the outcomes between P-GW and D-GW for biliary cannulation.The procedures for biliary cannulation with a naïve papilla were performed in a total of 363 cases. We divided the patients chronologically, according to the time period during which the procedures were performed, into two groups: group A, P-GW performed from March 2008 to June 2009; and group B, D-GW performed from July 2009 to December 2010. The success rates and complication rates were evaluated in each group.Biliary cannulation was successful in 31 (81.6%) patients in the P-GW group and 34 patients (82.9%) in the D-GW group. The onsets of postendoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography pancreatitis (PEP) occurred in the P-GW and D-GW groups were four (10.5%) and three (7.3%) patients, respectively, and all were mild cases (P = 0.616). The frequency of hyperamylasemia and the serum amylase level tended to be lower in the D-GW group than in the P-GW group (P = 0.213). There was a statistically significant difference on the onsets of PEP in the GW and non-GW groups (P = 0.04, 8.9% and 1.1%, respectively).Both the D-GW and P-GW techniques were equally effective for difficult biliary cannulation. Furthermore, the complication rates, including PEP, were similar in both techniques. A prospective randomized trial is warranted.
- Published
- 2013