51. Intensive Imaging-based Follow-up of Surgically Treated Localised Renal Cell Carcinoma Does Not Improve Post-recurrence Survival: Results from a European Multicentre Database (RECUR)
- Author
-
Grant D. Stewart, Thomas B. Lam, Paimaun Zakikhani, Christian Beisland, Axel Bex, Eirikur Gudmundsson, Lorenzo Marconi, Börje Ljungberg, Michael Staehler, Sergio Fernández-Pello, Saeed Dabestani, Richard P. Meijer, Christian Torbrand, Karim Bensalah, Serenella Monagas, William Gietzmann, Erik van Werkhoven, Samuel P Williams, Thomas Powles, Alessandro Volpe, APH - Methodology, Graduate School, APH - Personalized Medicine, Stewart, Grant [0000-0003-3188-9140], and Apollo - University of Cambridge Repository
- Subjects
Letter ,Time Factors ,Databases, Factual ,medicine.medical_treatment ,Radical surgery ,030232 urology & nephrology ,computer.software_genre ,Nephrectomy ,Imaging ,Neoplasm Recurrence, Local/diagnostic imaging ,0302 clinical medicine ,Renal cell carcinoma ,Overall survival ,Prospective cohort study ,Carcinoma, Renal Cell/diagnostic imaging ,Tomography ,Ultrasonography ,Database ,medicine.diagnostic_test ,Follow-up ,Kidney cancer ,Magnetic Resonance Imaging ,Kidney Neoplasms ,Kidney Neoplasms/diagnostic imaging ,Multicenter Study ,Europe ,Treatment Outcome ,030220 oncology & carcinogenesis ,Predictive value of tests ,Tomography, X-Ray Computed/standards ,X-Ray Computed/standards ,Nephrectomy/adverse effects ,Local/diagnostic imaging ,Urology ,03 medical and health sciences ,Renal Cell/diagnostic imaging ,Databases ,Predictive Value of Tests ,medicine ,Humans ,Carcinoma, Renal Cell ,Factual ,business.industry ,Magnetic Resonance Imaging/standards ,Carcinoma ,Magnetic resonance imaging ,medicine.disease ,Regimen ,Neoplasm Recurrence ,Ultrasonography/standards ,Neoplasm Recurrence, Local ,business ,Tomography, X-Ray Computed ,computer - Abstract
The optimal follow-up (FU) strategy for patients treated for localised renal cell carcinoma (RCC) remains unclear. Using the RECUR database, we studied imaging intensity utilised in contemporary FU to evaluate its association with outcome after detection of disease recurrence. Consecutive patients with nonmetastatic RCC (n = 1612) treated with curative intent at 12 institutes across eight European countries between 2006 and 2011 were included. Recurrence occurred in 336 patients. Cross-sectional (computed tomography, magnetic resonance imaging) and conventional (chest X-ray, ultrasound) methods were used in 47% and 53%, respectively. More intensive FU imaging (more than twofold) than recommended by the European Association of Urology (EAU) was not associated with improved overall survival (OS) after recurrence. Overall, per patient treated for recurrence remaining alive with no evidence of disease, the number of FU images needed was 542, and 697 for high-risk patients. The study results suggest that use of more imaging during FU than that recommended in the 2017 EAU guidelines is unlikely to improve OS after recurrence. Prospective studies are needed to design optimal FU strategies for the future. Patient summary: After curative treatment for localised kidney cancer, follow-up is necessary to detect any recurrence. This study illustrates that increasing the imaging frequency during follow-up, even to double the number of follow-up imaging procedures recommended by the European Association of Urology guidelines, does not translate into improved survival for those with recurrence. After curative treatment for localised kidney cancer, a more intensive follow-up regimen than that recommended in the 2017 European Association of Urology guidelines did not improve overall survival among those experiencing recurrence, irrespective of the risk of recurrence. This suggests that an increase in follow-up imaging frequency is not cost-efficient. Prospective studies to identify more optimal follow-up strategies are needed.
- Published
- 2019
- Full Text
- View/download PDF