Search

Chickens of the Obese strain (OS) are hereditarily affected with spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis that resembles Hashimoto's thyroiditis of humans in clinical, histopathological, serological, and endocrinological aspects. In this review, the natural history of the OS, reflecting the development and maintenance of the stock and its improvement of productivity over many years at Cornell University, is summarized. To underline the value and usefulness of this animal model, the concept of the multifactorial pathogenesis of autoimmune diseases, which was mainly established at the University of Innsbruck, Austria, is briefly outlined. This detailed analysis on the natural history of the OS was only made feasible by the availability of four decades of records on this chicken line at Cornell University. The report starts with the initial occurrence of a few pullets within the Cornell C-strain (CS) flock that showed obesity, long and silky feathers, and small body size, which, therefore, caused these birds to look notably different than the other CS birds. Experimental findings indicated an autoimmune basis for these characteristics, and the objectives of matings were initially focused on increasing the number of obese individuals for studies on the etiopathology and the mode of inheritance. In subsequent years, matings were directed toward increasing the penetrance and severity of the obese trait in the population. In recent years, the reproductive capability of the obese stock was improved by mating only the best breeders of the population in terms of body weight, egg weight, egg production, fertility, hatchability, and the expression of the obese phenotype. Housing conditions for OS chickens at Cornell and the qualification standards and selection procedures for breeders are described in detail, and results of blood typings are shown. A specific recent finding in OS hens is the high incidence of residues of the right Mullerian duct with cyst formation.

The involvement of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells in pathogenesis of spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT) in obese strain (OS) chickens has not been studied in depth until now. We depleted CD4+ or CD8+ T cells in OS chickens by treatment with murine monoclonal anti-CD4 or anti-CD8 antibodies at 3 day intervals beginning at hatching. The birds were killed at 19-25 days of age. Treatment with anti-CD4 antibody completely prevented SAT development, while treatment with anti-CD8 antibody partially inhibited SAT. These results show the critical role of CD4+ T cells in the development of SAT in OS chickens, and indicate that CD8+ T cells are also involved in SAT pathogenesis.

Chickens of the Obese strain (OS) are known to develop spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT) in the first 2-3 weeks post-hatching, but onset and severity of SAT for this period among sublines of OS chickens has not yet been analysed in detail. In the present paper, we described the kinetics of SAT in age-matched OSB13B13C, OSB5B5C, OSB15B15INN and OSB5B5INN chicken sublines. The results revealed no thyroid infiltration in OS fetuses at 20th ED of the analysed sublines. Mononuclear cell infiltration of thyroid was first noted in 2-4-day-old chickens, followed by aggravation of thyroiditis in 4-week-old OSB13B13C and OSB15B15INN chickens and in 5-week-old OSB5B5C birds. Interestingly, two subpopulations of OSB5B5INN chickens were found with different kinetics of SAT development: one with degree of SAT lower than 40%, was designated "low responders" and the other, with similar degrees of SAT as the other three sublines, was characterized as "high responders". Our results allow an age-dependent prediction of SAT development among OS chickens and the rational design of animal experiments, particularly for assessing the relevance of therapeutic interventions.

Untreated control OS chickens develop spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT). In contrast, OS chickens treated with a monoclonal anti-CD4 antibody failed to develop SAT. The preventive effect of anti-CD4 antibody on SAT was associated with the marked depletion of CD4+ T-cells by anti-CD4 treatment. These results indicate that CD4+ T-cells play a crucial role in SAT of OS chickens.

We studied T cell receptor variable beta (TCR V beta) gene usage by autoreactive T cells in spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT) of obese strain (OS) chickens. Chicken alpha beta T cells may express either V beta 1 or V beta 2 genes, the products of which can be recognized by TCR2 and TCR3 monoclonal antibodies, respectively. Selective depletion of V beta 1+ or V beta 2+ T cells in OS chickens was accomplished by repeated injections of TCR2 or TCR3 antibodies into embryonic and 1-3-week-old chickens. The birds were killed at 20 days of age and their spleens and thyroid glands evaluated by immunohistochemistry. We found that V beta 1+ T cells preferentially infiltrated OS chicken thyroid glands. Antibody treatments resulted in a 41% reduction in frequency of V beta 1+, and a 87% reduction of the frequency of V beta 2+ cells in the circulation, and in a profound decrease of the respective T cells in spleens and thyroid glands. Selective suppression of V beta 1+ T cells partially inhibited SAT development in that thyroid-infiltrating cells and destruction of thyroid follicles were reduced by more than 50%. Thyroglobulin autoantibody serum levels were also reduced in V beta 1+ T cell-depleted OS chickens, whereas selective depletion of V beta 2+ T cells did not inhibit SAT development. These findings indicate preferential TCR V beta 1 gene usage by autoreactive T cells in SAT of OS chickens.

Considerable controversy exists concerning the role of aberrant MHC-class II antigen expression in the pathogenesis of organ-specific auto-immune disease. Since Obese strain (OS) chickens are afflicted with a spontaneously occurring autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT), we have readdressed this pivotal question by investigating the chronical appearance of MHC-class II antigens on thyroid epithelial cells (TEC) of OS and normal healthy CB chickens before onset of overt clinical symptoms in the former. Among the candidates as potent inducers of aberrant MHC-class II antigen expression, interest in our studies focussed on the potential role of viruses in the development of SAT. Since aberrant MHC-class II antigen expression could prove to be an epiphenomenon of virally afflicted TEC, we determined 2,5-oligoadenylate synthetase and 2,5-oligoadenylatepolymer cytosol levels in both chicken lines. Our results indicate that the presence of infiltrating lymphocytes does not necessarily represent a prerequisite for the aberrant expression of MHC-class II antigens but coincides in most cases. However, the phenomenon seems to play a perpetuating rather than a causative role. Moreover, in support of a possible viral involvement, elevated levels of the 2,5-oligoadenylate synthetase and 2,5-oligomers could be demonstrated in TEC cytosol of OS chickens.

Autoimmune diseases have a multifactorial pathogenesis including essential genetic and nonessential modulatory factors. Among the essential factors, not only should genes coding for an abnormal reactivity of the immune system be considered, but we have, in addition, provided experimental evidence for the existence of genes responsible for a susceptibility of the target organ/structure for the autoimmune attack. Only when both sets of essential genes are present does an autoimmune disease develop at all. The modulatory factors then determine the final outcome in each case. The present contribution discusses the immunomodulating role of glucocorticoid and sex steroids focussing on the Obese Strain (OS) of chickens, a model for Hashimoto thyroiditis.

F1-hybrids of Obese strain (OS) chickens, afflicted with spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT), and normal, inbred CB chickens, do not develop severe thyroiditis. About 50% of these crosses show circulating autoantibodies to thyroglobulin (TgAAb), but the thyroid glands are only slightly infiltrated, suggesting that the target organ is not susceptible to autoimmune attack. In the present study we show that despite this mild infiltration TgAAb are only synthesized by lymphoid cells within the thyroid gland. Furthermore, we demonstrate that immunization with chicken thyroglobulin (Tg) in complete Freund's adjuvant causes severe experimental autoimmune thyroiditis (EAT) in F1(OSxCB) hybrids.

Treatment of obese strain chickens, either in ovo or after hatching, with testosterone or various testosterone-derived steroid analogs having no or only weak endocrine activities causes significant protection from spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis occurring in these birds. This effect is not correlated with the endocrinological properties of these steroids. This observation and similar results in other models for autoimmunity may present a basis for a more selective therapy in human autoimmune diseases in that hormonal side effects no longer preclude this approach.

We have shown in earlier studies, that the development of spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT) in chickens of the Obese strain (OS) depends on the presence of both, two dominant genes coding for an altered immune regulation and one recessive gene responsible for the susceptibility of the target organ for the autoimmune attack. The product(s) of the latter is (are) still not known. The present study was aimed at identifying possible candidates of cellular components of the thyroid gland of OS chicken and its SAT susceptible parental Cornell C-strain (CS) by high resolution 2-dimensional (2D) gel electrophoresis. For this purpose organ cultures of the thyroid, bursa, thymus and liver were established and the synthesized polypeptides were labelled by 35S-methionine. OS and CS organs were compared with those of healthy normal White Leghorn (NWL) controls. The autoradiographs of the 2D-gels obtained from individual samples after various labelling periods were subjected to comparative analysis. We have found both quantitative and qualitative differences of polypeptide spots between OS/CS and NWL organ samples, some of them specific for the thyroid gland. Although one has to be aware that in this multidimensional analytical approach numerous, still elusive pattern differences are revealed, the thyroid specific phenomena will be further scrutinized.

We developed a new method for demonstration and enumeration of antigen-binding cells, the principle and application of this method is demonstrated using peripheral blood lymphoid cells from Hashimoto patients, non-Hashimoto, non Graves' disease goiter patients and in patients without thyroid disease. A significantly higher number of thyroglobulin-binding cells was observed in the peripheral blood of Hashimoto patients as compared to members of the two other groups. The results of the FICA-tests were compared to conventional serological data of the individual patients.

Basal plasma levels of corticosterone and corticosteroid-binding globulin (CBG) have been investigated in Obese strain (OS) chickens afflicted with spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT). Corticosterone was determined radioimmunologically, and CBG by using a highly sensitive radioligand saturation assay. OS chickens displayed total corticosterone levels not different from healthy normal White Leghorn (NWL) chickens. CBG, however, was found to be twice as high in OS chickens as compared with their healthy counterparts, irrespective of sex or age. This quantitative difference in the CBG level is not compensated for by either altered affinity or specificity of the molecule. Furthermore, no differences were found in the response of OS and NWL lymphocytes to the suppressive effect of glucocorticoids in vitro. We therefore assume that OS animals are deficient in free, hormonally active corticosterone. An additional indication for such a diminished glucocorticoid tonus was that in vivo treatment of OS chickens with glucocorticoid hormones, thus increasing the free and active hormone fraction, normalizes the T cell hyperreactivity and significantly reduces thyroid infiltration. Possible pathophysiological implications of a diminished glucocorticoid tonus for spontaneous autoimmunity, as well as possible explanations for the beneficial effects of glucocorticoid treatment on the development of SAT, are discussed.

We have recently reported a two-fold defect in glucocorticoid mediated immunoregulation in the Obese strain (OS) of chickens with spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT): (i) a decreased basal corticosterone (CN) tonus due to an elevation of plasma corticosteroid-binding globulin (CBG) and (ii) an impaired CN rise in response to antigenic stimuli as well as lymphokines produced after mitogenic stimulation. The aim of the present study was to investigate the pathophysiological relevance of testosterone for the development of SAT. Compared to healthy normal White Leghorn chickens (NWL) the basal sex hormone tonus as well as androgen receptors of bursal tissue are not altered in the OS. Administration of sheep red blood cells (SRBC) or lymphokine containing conditioned media not only increased CN plasma levels but concomitantly modulated testosterone serum concentrations, although in an inverse direction and without significant difference between OS and healthy control chickens. These results suggest that, in contrast to the glucocorticoid system, androgen tonus as well as its modulation by immune signals are normal in the OS. The mode of action by which androgens exert their known beneficial effect on the development of SAT was also studied. According to our findings the capacity of testosterone to prevent SAT when administered during the posthatching period can be attributed to direct effects on bursal epithelial cells as well as indirect mechanisms, namely a fall in CBG levels leading to normalization of the CN tonus.

Immunologists working in the field of autoimmunity tend to concentrate all their efforts on the elucidation of possible malfunctions of the immune system, particularly pathologic changes of immune regulation. Also in the OS model various groups of investigators emphasized this approach, although it was already clear early in the history of this model that SAT has a multigenic background. The fact that this disease cannot be transferred into normal, histocompatible animals without an appropriate non-MHC linked genetic background was a strong indication that detailed studies of thyroid-associated factors may be warranted for the elucidation of the pathogenesis of this disease and perhaps also its human counterpart, Hashimoto thyroiditis. Since several reviews on the immunologic aspects in the OS model have been published in recent years we have in this communication attempted to discuss the - mostly still rudimentary - findings concerning the target organ itself, including morphological changes before the beginning of infiltration, the analysis of Tg, the altered thyroid function before onset of SAT, the results of cross-breeding studies of OS and inbred normal chickens in respect to the susceptibility of the offspring for the transfer of SAT, the possible role of a virus infection and the aberrant expression of MHC class II antigens on TEC. Cross-breeding studies revealed that most probably a single gene is responsible for the primary altered thyroid function and at least 3 genes code for the susceptibility of the OS thyroid gland to the autoimmune attack. It is not yet clear for which of the above-mentioned observations each of these genes is responsible and what is/are the initial triggering mechanism(s). Ongoing studies in our laboratory concentrate on this question, specifically the potential role of endogenous viruses in this process.

The enhanced T cell reactivity (ConA hyperresponsiveness and IL 2 hypersecretion) of spleen lymphocytes of Obese strain (OS) chickens with spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis has recently been shown to be due to a defect in macrophage-derived non-specific suppressor factors that regulate IL 2 secretion and IL 2-promoted T lymphoblast proliferation in normal healthy animals. In the present study, we present several lines of evidence that the increased T cell response of peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) of OS chickens is due to mechanisms entirely different from the described dysregulation of splenic T cells: 1) In contrast to the splenic macrophages, peripheral blood monocytes of OS animals are not deficient in the production of IL 2 antagonistic activity (IAA); 2) therefore, cocultivation of PBL from OS and Normal White Leghorn (NWL) chickens in communicating culture chambers did not abrogate the difference in Con A response as previously observed with spleen lymphocytes. 3) Immunofluorescence with a monoclonal antibody (INN CH 16) against the chicken IL 2 receptor revealed enhanced numbers of mitogen activatable T cells in OS PBL but not OS spleen lymphocytes. 4) After prolonged Con A stimulation of PBL, OS and NWL lymphoblasts did not differ from each other in functional aspects. In contrast to this, Con A lymphoblasts from OS spleens exhibited enhanced staining with INN CH 16 in parallel with an increased proliferative response to IL 2. Thus, the primary T cell dysfunction involved in the development of autoimmune disease in OS chickens is the result of at least two separate regulatory defects.

The review presents a concept for the pathogenesis of spontaneous, organ-specific autoimmune diseases that take into account an altered immune regulation, modulating hormonal influences and a genetically determined primary susceptibility of the target organ for the autoimmune attack. The concept is exemplified by means of the Obese strain (OS) chicken model which develops a spontaneous hereditary autoimmune thyroiditis. In respect to the the altered function of the immune system both, MHC associated (Ir) and non-MHC associated genes are involved. The MHC, i.e. a certain haplotype, only plays a modulatory role in determining the frequency and severity of spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis, while the presence of certain non-MHC associated genes is a absolute prerequisite for the emergence of the disease. The latter is also true for the genetically determined target organ susceptibility, while hormonal factors, notably sex-steroids and glucocorticoids, again only have a facultative, modulatory effect. Only if an appropriate genetic constellation concerning the non-MHC encoded aberrant immunological function and genes coding for the susceptibility of the thyroid gland for the autoimmune process is present, severe autoimmune thyroids develops.

Development of organ-specific autoimmune diseases depends on both an abnormal immune regulation and a genetically determined primary susceptibility of the target organ to the autoimmune attack. In addition to the essential genetically determined prerequisites there are also facultative, modulating factors that influence the outcome of an autoimmune disease. This concept is exemplified in the Obese strain (OS) chicken model which develops a spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis closely resembling human Hashimoto disease. Three modulating factors are specifically addressed, viz. (a) the lower threshold of OS thyroid epithelial cells for the gamma-interferon-induced MHC class II antigen expression as compared to normal controls, (b) the decreased glucocorticoid tonus of the OS and (c) the presence of a new endogenous virus (ev 22) locus in the OS that has so far not been found in any normal strain and which seems to influence the glucocorticoid-mediated immunoregulatory process.

Obese strain (OS) chickens afflicted with spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT) display several signs of a general immune dysbalance, some of which may be related to altered endocrine mechanisms such as the glucocorticoid tonus. The latter is the combined result of corticosterone (CN) production, metabolism as well as excretion, and the binding of CN to corticosteroid binding globulin (CBG) and glucocorticoid receptors (GR). The present study deals with the comparative investigation of these parameters in OS and normal White Leghorn (NWL) chickens. The results obtained with radioimmunoassay for CN and radioligand saturation assays for plasma CBG as well as GR in the thymus were as follows: (1) both OS and NWL have equal total CN levels; (2) however, OS chickens exhibit elevated CBG levels, whereas the physicochemical parameters (equilibrium affinity, specificity spectrum) of CBG were equal in OS and NWL; (3) the GR capacities and affinities were equal in both OS and NWL throughout development until thymic involution. Similarly, the specificity, affinity, and sedimentation behaviour were equal in OS and NWL. (4) Furthermore, no differences were found in the response of OS and NWL splenocytes to the suppressive effect of glucocorticoids in vitro, also excluding postreceptor alterations at the cellular level in the OS. From these findings we conclude that the increased CBG levels, which are not compensated for by either increased CN plasma levels or by increased receptor capacities or affinities in lymphatic organs, represent a diminished glucocorticoid tonus in OS chickens. This may have immunoregulatory consequences which, in turn, may contribute to the development of SAT.

To determine the number and function of genes which are responsible for spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT) in the obese strain (OS) of chickens we crossed birds of this strain (B15/B15) with those of the inbred CB line (B12/B12). The progeny was analyzed for autoantibodies to thyroglobulin (TgAAb) and for histopathological changes in the thyroid glands. In F1 (OS X CB) hybrids only those animals which derived from CB mothers had circulating TgAAb, the progeny from the reverse combination female OS X male CB was negative. Since the disease is not inherited by OS males only, we conclude that maternal TgAAb, which are transferred from the egg yolk to the embryo, might prevent the immune system of the F1 chickens from TgAAb formation via blocking or eliminating the respective antigens. Those F1 hybrids which have high TgAAb levels in the serum show only little or no thyroiditis. Together with other observations, these data lead to the conclusion that the thyroid gland of the F1 hybrids is not susceptible to TgAAb. This supports previous findings that a genetically determined thyroid abnormality is a prerequisite for the full development of SAT. The low degree of SAT in backcross (F1 X OS) animals and F2 hybrids suggests that several genes are involved in the disease. MHC typing of these generations revealed that the B haplotype affects the time of SAT onset.

Chickens of the Obese strain (OS) develop a hereditary spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT) which closely resembles human Hashimoto's disease. Analysis of the endogenous viruses harboured by these animals revealed a new endogenous virus (ev22) detected as a 5.5 kb Sac I fragment. Crossbreeding experiments showed that ev22 is vertically transmitted as an autosomal trait not associated with major histocompatibility (MHC) alleles. Preliminary experiments indicate that ev22 does not necessarily cause SAT, however, it may have a modulatory role in the development of the disease.

Aberrant expression of HLA-DR antigens on epithelial cells is seen in various organ-specific autoimmune disorders including Hashimoto thyroiditis (HT). Expression of HLA-DQ has so far not been demonstrated on these cells. We report here that thyroid epithelial cells (TEC) in HT, in addition to the known aberrant expression of HLA-DR, coexpress HLA-DQ antigens. Furthermore we provide evidence that class II antigens are synthesized by TEC themselves by demonstration of intracellular HLA-DR gamma-chain. These findings support the theory that TEC may be able to present (auto)antigens in vivo thus perhaps contributing to the perpetuation of thyroid destruction. As expression of class II antigens on TEC was never observed in non- or weakly infiltrated areas, we propose that infiltration by T cells is necessary to induce this aberrant expression of class II antigens.

Antigenic challenge as well as injection of lymphokine-containing media lead to a transient increase of serum glucocorticoids, a phenomenon that has been implicated in the regulation of the specificity of immune responses. In the present study we examined the dialogue between the immune and the neuroendocrine systems in Obese strain (OS) chickens, an animal model for human Hashimoto thyroiditis. The following results were obtained: A) OS and normal White Leghorn (NWL) chickens, 5-mo-old, were immunized with sheep red blood cells followed by daily monitoring of corticosterone (CN) serum levels. Whereas in NWL animals CN serum levels markedly increase 3 to 4 days after immunization, OS animals did not respond with CN elevation. B) A single i.v. injection of conditioned medium (CM) from concanavalin A-stimulated spleen cells also led to a transient, dose-dependent peak in plasma CN (maximum after 30 min). This CN response to a given CM preparation was significantly lower in OS than in NWL animals. C) CM, whether obtained from OS or NWL splenocytes, were equally effective to stimulate CN production. D) A single i.v. injection of CM leads--concomitantly to the CN peak--to a decrease of the concanavalin A-mediated proliferative response of peripheral blood lymphocytes in both OS and NWL chickens. This suppression, however, was significantly more pronounced in NWL chickens. In summary, these data suggest a disturbance of the immune-neuroendocrine communication in OS chickens with spontaneous thyroid autoimmunity. The possible implications for the generation of "forbidden" autoimmune responses are discussed.

In contrast to systemic autoimmunity, spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis of Obese strain (OS) chickens is associated with a marked T cell hyperreactivity in vitro, i.e. an increased proliferation and interleukin 2 (IL 2) secretion in response to Concanavalin A (ConA). In the present study we report an enhanced capacity of OS peripheral lymphoid cells (splenocytes and peripheral blood lymphocytes, PBL) to adsorb fluorescein isothiocyante (FITC) labelled ConA, but not phytohemagglutinin (PHA). However, the elevated ConA binding cannot be a prerequisite for in vitro ConA hyperreactivity as OS thymocytes are normal with respect to ConA binding but nonetheless exhibit elevated responses to this mitogen. Moreover, ConA binding does not correlate with the frequency of cells able to express IL 2 receptors upon short term ConA stimulation. The percentage of ConA activatable cells was found to be increased in OS- PBL as compared to normal control PBL, but was unaltered in OS splenocytes. This finding points to a further mechanism of T cell hyperreactivity in OS chicks in addition to the previously reported defects in nonspecific immunosuppression. Finally, enumeration of cells in the S phase revealed that enhanced proliferation of OS T lymphocytes was not restricted to the in vitro response to ConA and phytohemagglutinin (PHA) but also occurs in vivo.

We have previously shown that normal chicken serum (NCS) is able to interfere with the IL 2 promoted incorporation of DNA precursors into T lymphoblasts and that serum derived from autoimmunity prone Obese strain (OS) chickens is deficient in this respect. This "defect in non-specific suppression" has been speculated to be one of the causes for T cell hyperreactivity in the OS. In this study we present several lines of evidence that the suppressive effect of normal chicken serum (NCS) on 5-(125Iodo)-2-deoxyuridine (125IUdR) uptake into chicken T blasts is a competition artefact due to cold thymidine (TdR) present in NCS. Inhibition of 125IUdR required the continuous presence of NCS and suppression of 3H-TdR incorporation could be competed for by increasing the dose of the radiolabel. Molecular sieve chromatography followed by reversed phase high performance liquid chromotagraphy revealed the "inhibitory" activity to co-elute with TdR. Moreover, NCS did not suppress protein synthesis by chicken T cells growing with IL 2 and did not affect oxidative metabolism, cell viability, expression of IL 2 receptors, or percentages of cells in the S phase of the cell cycle. In accordance with these data, OS-sera suprisingly contain less TdR than those from normal controls. Experiments involving crosses of the OS with the normal inbred CB strain, revealed that the subnormal serum TdR level of the OS is an autosomally dominant trait which, however, segregates from T cell hyperreactivity. These findings falsify our previous hypothesis that a defect in specific IL 2 antagonists might be involved in T cell hyperfunction of the OS and indicate that NCS is devoid of factors which neutralize IL 2 function.

The female sex develops autoimmune disease far more often than the male. This is claimed to be due to differences in peripheral sex steroid levels. We have examined in the bursa of Fabricius of Obese strain (OS) chickens, which spontaneously develop autoimmune thyroiditis, as well as in their healthy counterparts androgen(AR)-, estrogen(ER)-, progestin(PR)- and glucocorticoid(GR)-receptors in an attempt to elucidate possible further pathomechanisms, namely at the target site of steroid hormones. The characterization (affinity, specificity, association- and dissociation-rate, sedimentation behaviour) of all four types of receptors revealed no difference between sex or strain. Furthermore, the ontogeny study of the receptor capacity and affinity from the 7th embryonic day (i.e. before lymphocyte settlement) until bursa involution, again showed no difference between OS and healthy chickens of either sex. Thus, it can be concluded that the principal sex dependency of the susceptibility to autoimmune disease results predominantly from differences in sex steroid levels per se, although alterations in mechanisms beyond the cytosolic receptor level can presently not be excluded.

A variety of immunological, endocrinological, and virological abnormalities have been implicated in the etiopathogenesis of spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT) of Obese strain (OS) chickens, e.g., a general T cell hyperreactivity, an increased uptake of iodine into the thyroid gland, a diminution of the glucocorticoid tonus, and an OS-specific endogenous virus. In crosses of the close-bred OS B15/B15 subline with the inbred normal CB B12/B12 strain we have studied the mode of inheritance of these aberrations and their putative association with SAT. The results indicate that none of these OS-specific characteristics alone is an absolute prerequisite for the development of thyroid infiltration, which appears to be governed by one autosomal recessive gene.

Thyroglobulin-binding lymphoid cells were identified in the spleen of Obese strain (DS) chickens by their capacity to form rosettes with thyroglobulin-coated chicken red blood cells. The nature of these cells was studied in inhibition experiments using turkey anti-chicken bursa or thymus cell sera and rabbit antisera specific for chicken Ig, gamma, mu, alpha, Fabgamma or Fcgamma. Spleen cells actively synthesizing surface receptors for thyroglobulin were identified as B cells and the receptors found to be complete IgM molecules. Normal T cells became thyroglobulin-rosette-forming cells via passive adsorption of thyroglobulin antibodies, a phenomenon which could be inhibited competitively by the addition of normal chicken serum to the incubation medium. Thyroglobulin antibodies passively adsorbed onto the surface of normal T cells also belong to the IgM class as verified both by inhibition experiments and studies employing IgM and IgG fractions of a high titered OS serum for the preincubation of the cell suspensions. Only preincubation with the IgM fraction of the anti-thyroglobulin antibodies resulted in the formation of significant numbers of passive rosette-forming cells.

The Obese strain (OS) of chickens, which is afflicted with Hashimoto-like spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis (SAT), displays elevated T cell proliferation, interleukin (IL)2 production and IL2 receptor expression upon mitogen stimulation, and defects in the neuroendocrine control of the immune system including elevated corticosteroid-binding globulin (CBG) and a deficient increase of serum corticosterone (CN) upon cytokine injection. Recently this strain has further been shown to harbor retrovirus-related sequences (endogenous virus no. 22, ev22) absent in healthy control strains. To determine the number of genes responsible for SAT-associated immunodysregulation and to unravel possible ev22 associations, we analyzed the above immune and endocrine parameters in F1 hybrids and backcrosses of the autoimmune OS B15B15 with healthy inbred CB B12B12 chickens. OS-like T cell hyperproliferation and IL2 hypersecretion in response to both concanavalin A and phytohemagglutinin were transmitted as autosomal dominant traits and co-segregated in backcross animals. In vivo hyporesponse of the OS to the corticosterone-inducing effect of cytokine preparations was inherited dominantly and the elevated CBG serum levels recessively. None of these traits appeared to be major histocompatibility complex (MHC) linked. However, while T cell abnormalities and elevated CBG serum levels were not associated with the autosomal ev22 locus, in vivo hyporesponsiveness to glucocortocoid-inducing cytokines co-segregated with this OS-specific provirus. These results add to the concept of SAT as a polyetiological and plurigenetic disease and do not support our previous hypothesis that T cell hyperreactivity and immunoendocrine dysfunction might be functionally related.

Surgical specimens from thyroid glands from seven patients with Hashimoto thyroiditis and two patients with non-autoimmune colloid goiter were analyzed by immunohistologic techniques (direct and indirect immunofluorescence and immunoperoxidase tests) using polyclonal antisera against total immunoglobulin, Ig classes (IgM, IgD, IgG, and IgA), and complement component C3 and monoclonal antibodies specific for B cells, T cell subpopulation, macrophages, natural killer cells, granulocytes, and HLA-DR antigen. Complement-fixing immune complexes (IgG+, C3+) were noted predominantly in areas with only slight destruction and only moderate lymphoid infiltration of thyroid follicles. In areas with intense lymphoid infiltration of thyroid follicles, where many well-developed germinal centers and significant perivascular lymphoid infiltration were seen, immune complexes were scarce. In these latter areas T helper cells (OKT4+, Leu3a+), were more abundant than T cytotoxic/suppressor cells (OKT8+), macrophages (OKM1+), and plasma cells (IgG+); only a few B lymphocytes (smIgM+, smIgD+), granulocytes (ViMD5+), and natural killer cells (VEP13+, Leu7+) were noted in the interstitium between thyroid follicles, intruding between thyroid follicular epithelial cells and merging into the thyroid follicular lumen. Many activated T cells (OKT10+, HLA-DR+) were present in these areas of advanced destruction. HLA-DR antigen expression was seen on macrophages, tissue reticulum cells, vascular endothelial cells, lymphoid cells, and, most interestingly, on thyroid epithelial cells. Normal thyroid epithelial cells did not express HLA-DR. Only a few epithelial cells in the vicinity of lymphoid infiltrations were HLA-DR+ in early stages of Hashimoto thyroiditis, and the number of HLA-DR+ epithelial cells was significantly increased in advanced stages of the disease. In our present report the potential role of HLA-DR+ thyroid epithelial cells for the in situ stimulation of the immune system within the thyroid gland of patients with Hashimoto thyroiditis is discussed, and it is hypothesized that HLA-DR+ thyroid epithelial cells may be an important factor for the progression and self-perpetuation of the disease, which is probably initiated by humoral components of the immune system but further propagated by cellular immunopathologic mechanisms.

Surgical specimens from patients with Hashimoto thyroiditis (HT) or colloid goiter (CG) were analyzed using an immunofluorescence double staining technique to characterize the infiltrating mononuclear cells (MNC) and to determine the possible expression of HLA-DR antigens by these cells. In HT the majority of infiltrating MNC were T cells. In the interstitium T cells with helper/inducer phenotype (Leu 3a+) were more abundant than those with suppressor/cytotoxic phenotype (OKT8+) and approximately 10-25% of all T cells expressed HLA-DR. Among the cells in peripolesis [i.e., protruding between thyroid epithelial cells (TEC)] OKT8+ cells were observed more frequently than Leu 3a+ cells, expression of DR antigens being 7 and 12%, respectively. The occurrence of Leu 3a+ cells in peripolesis is in marked contrast to the findings in colloid goiter where the intraepithelial population of MNC is almost exclusively composed of OKT8+ cells. The various ways in which the peripoletic Leu 3a+ cells could contribute to the special pathogenesis of HT are discussed.

The disturbed homeostasis of the immune system in Obese strain (OS) chickens with spontaneous autoimmune thyroiditis consists in a general T cell hyperreactivity (concanavalin A hyperresponsiveness, interleukin 2 (IL 2) hypersecretion), particularly expressed by those lymphocytes which infiltrate the diseased thyroid gland. This abnormality has been attributed to a defective regulation of both IL 2 production and IL 2 function by low m.w. factors, which are present in serum and splenocyte culture supernatants of normal chickens, but deficient in the OS. In the present study we identified the cellular origin of IL 2 antagonistic activity as a nonlymphoid, adherent cell. Suppressor factor production in vitro was confined to the plastic adherent fraction of spleen cells and preincubation of splenocytes with nylon wool, silica particles, or carbonyl iron significantly reduced the nonspecific suppressive activity of the culture supernatant. Kinetic studies revealed the defect in nonspecific suppression to entail prolonged IL 2 production by concanavalin A-activated OS spleen cells. In vivo treatment of normal White Leghorn chickens with silica led to a decrease in suppressive serum activity down to the OS level, whereas neither neonatal thymectomy nor bursectomy had any effect. The defective suppressor factor production in autoimmune chickens appeared to be due to a functional, but not numeric defect of macrophages as revealed by phenol red staining. The possibility that this aberration in adherent cell function might be a secondary phenomenon to the recently described reduced corticosterone tonus in OS chickens was excluded by in vivo substitution with exogenous glucocorticoids which did not normalize the suppressor defect in serum or in conditioned medium. Finally, we present evidence that T lymphoblasts from OS animals are less susceptible to IL 2 antagonistic regulation than normal cells, which possibly further contributes to the T cell hyperfunction of this autoimmune strain.