Search

Background: The presence of defects at stress-redistribution thallium-201 scintigraphy is related to a higher risk of cardiac events. However, the prognostic value of defects that become reversible after reinjection is not known. In this study we evaluated the prognostic contribution of stress-redistribution-reinjection with special regard to 3-hour fixed defects that become reversible after reinjection., Methods and Results: We studied 122 patients with chronic myocardial infarction (>2 months) and suspected or known residual ischemia, with stress-redistribution-reinjection planar scintigraphy. Thallium scans were analyzed by three observers (three segments per view, 5-point score) and classified as normal, fixed, and reversible. The lung/heart ratio was also calculated. At a median follow-up of 47 months, 10 patients had hard events (four deaths and six myocardial infarctions) (group I), 12 patients had unstable angina (group II), 12 patients underwent planned coronary artery bypass grafting or percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (group III), and 86 patients had no events (group IV). The presence of fixed defects that became reversible after reinjection did not identify patients at higher risk. The number of reversible defects at 3 hours was significantly higher only in patients who underwent revascularization. Unstable angina was not predicted by any scintigraphic pattern. The variables that were statistically related to hard events by univariate analysis were increased lung uptake, reversible cavity dilation, and the number of fixed defects that remained fixed after reinjection. By Cox multivariate analysis, the strongest predictor of hard events was the presence of more than three fixed defects that remained fixed after reinjection as a marker of irreversible myocardial damage., Conclusions: (201)Tl reinjection is a useful approach for not only detecting viable myocardium but also risk stratification in patients with chronic myocardial infarction.

Unlabelled: To establish the real nature of 201Tl defects in the assessment of myocardial viability (e.g., fixed versus reversible), 201Tl reinjection was evaluated in a multicenter trial involving 402 consecutive patients with ischemic heart disease and exercise 201Tl defects., Methods: Twelve hospitals, using the same type of gamma camera and computer software, adopted one of the two most widely used reinjection protocols. In 230 patients (Group A), reinjection was performed immediately after stress-redistribution planar imaging; in 172 patients (Group B), reinjection was performed on a separate day and followed by rest-redistribution imaging. The images were interpreted by three blinded observers in a core laboratory on a five-point qualitative scale; the reproducibility in visual scoring was excellent., Results: Groups A and B had a similar prevalence of myocardial segments with abnormal uptake at stress (39%, 40%), as well as with reversible (16%, 17%), partially reversible (21%, 19%) and irreversible (63%, 64%) defects at redistribution. After reinjection, 201Tl uptake improved in 27% and 36% of both partially reversible and irreversible defects in Groups A and B. No differences were found when comparing early and delayed reinjection imaging in Group B., Conclusion: This study confirms the validity of 201Tl reinjection in a large, unselected population, but the discordance with stress/redistribution is less than has been previously reported for both 201Tl reinjection protocols, the prevalence of improved segments after reinjection was higher with the separate day approach.

Nine medical centers, equipped with the same gamma camera and computer software, participated in this multicenter study on thallium-201 reinjection imaging. Preliminary findings for the first 143 patients with ischemic heart disease and perfusion defects at stress imaging are reported. Eighty-eight patients were reinjected at rest after conventional stress-redistribution imaging. Another 55 patients were reinjected at rest on a separate day. After segmental comparison of conventional redistribution versus stress imaging, differences > 1 in the segmental scores on a reduced 3 point scale identified 58 patients with irreversible or mainly irreversible defects (dominant scar pattern) and 85 patients with reversible or mainly reversible defects (dominant ischemic pattern). When reinjection was compared to stress images, 24 patients out of 58 with a dominant scar pattern at the conventional analysis were then assigned to the group with a dominant ischemic pattern. No clinical variables or exercise stress data were found to be significantly different in this patient subgroup. Only 4 out of 85 patients with a dominant ischemic pattern were reassigned to a dominant scar pattern after reinjection scoring. These preliminary results of the SIRT study confirm the consistent problem of scar overestimation by conventional stress-redistribution imaging and the clinical value of the thallium-201 reinjection procedure for differentiating viable from necrotic myocardium.

Fixed defects on thallium-201 myocardial scintigraphy which have been traditionally interpreted as myocardial scar, may in fact be viable myocardium. This has been shown to be the case on 24 hour delayed imaging, positron emission tomography and repeat thallium imaging after coronary angioplasty or bypass surgery. We studied 25 suspected post myocardial infarction ischemia patients who had one or more fixed defects on exercise thallium scintigraphy. Immediately after the conventional delayed images, a second TI-201 injection of 1 mCi (re-injection) was given, followed by an additional set of images. After re-injection, 41% of fixed defects on the conventional delayed images showed increased thallium uptake as evidence of viable myocardium, and 46% of partially reversible defects on the conventional delayed images showed a concordant but increased uptake. Re-injection provided the only evidence for ischemia in 4 patients (16%) and documented ischemia in a new vascular territory in 3 patients (12%). Thus, we conclude that thallium re-injection is an improved technique for assessing myocardial viability in patients after myocardial infarction.