Search

Many cancers both evoke and subvert endogenous anti-tumor immunity. However, immunosuppression can be therapeutically reversed in subsets of cancer patients by treatments such as checkpoint inhibitors or Toll-like receptor agonists (TLRa). Moreover, chemotherapy can leukodeplete immunosuppressive host elements, including myeloid-derived suppressor cells (MDSCs) and regulatory T-cells (Tregs). We hypothesized that chemotherapy-induced leukodepletion could be immunopotentiated by co-administering TLRa to emulate a life-threatening infection. Combining CpG (ODN 1826) or CpG+poly(I:C) with cyclophosphamide (CY) resulted in uniquely well-tolerated therapeutic synergy, permanently eradicating advanced mouse tumors including 4T1 (breast), Panc02 (pancreas) and CT26 (colorectal). Definitive treatment required endogenous CD8+ and CD4+ IFNγ-producing T-cells. Tumor-specific IFNγ-producing T-cells persisted during CY-induced leukopenia, whereas Tregs were progressively eliminated, especially intratumorally. Spleen-associated MDSCs were cyclically depleted by CY+TLRa treatment, with residual monocytic MDSCs requiring only continued exposure to CpG or CpG+IFNγ to effectively attack malignant cells while sparing non-transformed cells. Such tumor destruction occurred despite upregulated tumor expression of Programmed Death Ligand-1, but could be blocked by clodronate-loaded liposomes to deplete phagocytic cells or by nitric oxide synthase inhibitors. CY+TLRa also induced tumoricidal myeloid cells in naive mice, indicating that CY+TLRa's immunomodulatory impacts occurred in the complete absence of tumor-bearing, and that tumor-induced MDSCs were not an essential source of tumoricidal myeloid precursors. Repetitive CY+TLRa can therefore modulate endogenous immunity to eradicate advanced tumors without vaccinations or adoptive T-cell therapy. Human blood monocytes could be rendered similarly tumoricidal during in vitro activation with TLRa+IFNγ, underscoring the potential therapeutic relevance of these mouse tumor studies to cancer patients., Competing Interests: The authors have no financial conflicts of interest.

Previously we demonstrated that human glioblastoma cell lines induce apoptosis in peripheral blood T cells through partial involvement of secreted gangliosides. Here we show that GBM-derived gangliosides induce apoptosis through involvement of the TNF receptor and activation of the caspase cascade. Culturing T lymphocytes with GBM cell line derived gangliosides (10-20 μg/ml) demonstrated increased ROS production as early as 18 hrs as indicated by increased uptake of the dye H2DCFDA while western blotting demonstrated mitochondrial damage as evident by cleavage of Bid to t-Bid and by the release of cytochrome-c into the cytosol. Within 48-72 hrs apoptosis was evident by nuclear blebbing, trypan blue positivity and annexinV/7AAD staining. GBM-ganglioside induced activation of the effector caspase-3 along with both initiator caspases (-9 and -8) in T cells while both the caspase-8 and -9 inhibitors were equally effective in blocking apoptosis (60% protection) confirming the role of caspases in the apoptotic process. Ganglioside-induced T cell apoptosis did not involve production of TNF-α since anti-human TNFα antibody was unable to protect T cells from nuclear blebbing and subsequent cell death. However, confocal microscopy demonstrated co-localization of GM2 ganglioside with the TNF receptor and co-immunoprecipitation experiments showed recruitment of death domains FADD and TRADD with the TNF receptor post ganglioside treatment, suggesting direct interaction of gangliosides with the TNF receptor. Further confirmation of the interaction between GM2 and TNFR1 was obtained from confocal microscopy data with wild type and TNFR1 KO (TALEN mediated) Jurkat cells, which clearly demonstrated co-localization of GM2 and TNFR1 in the wild type cells but not in the TNFR1 KO clones. Thus, GBM-ganglioside can mediate T cell apoptosis by interacting with the TNF receptor followed by activation of both the extrinsic and the intrinsic pathway of caspases.

Sunitinib, a protein tyrosine kinase inhibitor is the frontline therapy for renal and gastrointestinal cancers. We hypothesized that by virtue of its well documented tumor apoptosis and immune adjuvant properties, combination of Sunitinib with anti-tumor immunotherapeutics will provide synergistic inhibition of tumor growth. Our study was designed to evaluate the impact of Sunitinib on immunotherapy mediated anti-tumor immune responses and evaluate its efficacy as a combinatorial therapy with tumor targeted immunotherapeutic vaccination. Mice immunized with recombinant α-lactalbumin, a lactation protein expressed on majority of breast tumors were treated with 1 mg of Sunitinib for seven consecutive days beginning (1) concurrently, on the day of α-lactalbumin immunization or (2) sequentially, on day 9 after immunization. Ten-day lymph nodes or 21 day spleens were tested by ELISPOT assays and flow cytometry to evaluate responsiveness to α-lactalbumin immunization in presence of Sunitinib and distribution of cells involved in T cell antigen priming and proliferation in different lymphoid compartments. In addition, therapeutic efficacy of the α-lactalbumin/ Sunitinib combination was evaluated by monitoring tumor growth in the 4T1 transplanted tumor model. Our studies reveal that concurrent administration of Sunitinib with active vaccination against a targeted tumor antigen inhibits priming to the immunogen due to a drastic decrease in CD11b+CD11c+ antigen presenting cells, leading to failure of vaccination. However, sequential delivery of Sunitinib timed to avoid the priming phase of vaccination results in the desired vaccination mediated boost in immune responses., (© 2013 UICC.)

The receptor tyrosine kinase inhibitor, sunitinib, is astonishingly effective in its capacity to reduce MDSCs in peripheral tissues such as blood (human) and spleen (mouse), restoring responsiveness of bystander T lymphocytes to TcR stimulation. Sunitinib blocks proliferation of undifferentiated MDSCs and decreases survival of more differentiated neutrophilic MDSC (n-MDSC) progeny. Ironically, sunitinib's profound effects are observed even in a total absence of detectable anti-tumor therapeutic response. This is best explained by the presence of disparate MDSC-conditioning stimuli within individual body compartments, allowing sensitivity and resistance to sunitinib to coexist within the same mouse or patient. The presence or absence of GM-CSF is likely the major determinant in each compartment, given that GM-CSF's capacity to preempt STAT3-dependent with dominant STAT5-dependent hematopoietic programming confers sunitinib resistance and redirects differentiation from the n-MDSC lineage to the more versatile monocytoid (m-MDSC) lineage. The clinical sunitinib experience underscores that strategies for MDSC and Treg depletions must be mindful of disparities among body compartments to avoid sanctuary effects. Ironically, m-MDSCs manifesting resistance to sunitinib also have the greatest potential to differentiate into tumoricidal accessory cells, by virtue of their capacity to respond to T cell-secreted IFN-γ or to TLR agonists with nitric oxide and peroxynitrate production.

Increased expression of gangliosides by different tumor types including renal cell carcinoma (RCC) is thought to contribute to the immune suppression observed in cancer patients. In this study, we report an increase in apoptotic T cells from RCC patients compared with T cells from normal donors that coincided with the detection of T cells staining positive for GM2 and that the apoptosis was predominantly observed in the GM2(+) but not the GM2(-) T cell population. Ganglioside shedding from tumor rather than endogenous production accounts for GM2(+) T cells since there was no detectable level of mRNA for GM2 synthase in RCC patient T cells and in T cells from normal healthy donors after incubation with either purified GM2 or supernatant from RCC cell lines despite their staining positive for GM2. Moreover, reactive oxygen species as well as activated caspase 3, 8, and 9 were predominantly elevated in GM2(+) but not GM2(-) T cells. Similarly, increased staining for GD2 and GD3 but not GD1a was detected with patient T cells with elevated levels of apoptosis in the GD2(+) and GD3(+) cells. These findings suggest that GM2, GD2, and GD3 play a significant role in immune dysfunction observed in RCC patient T cells.

We previously elucidated an important role for gangliosides in renal cell carcinoma-mediated T lymphocyte apoptosis, although the mechanism by which they mediated lymphocyte death remained unclear. Here, we show that when added in purified form, GD3 is internalized by activated T cells, initiating a series of proapoptotic events, including the induction of reactive oxygen species (ROS), an enhancement of p53 and Bax accumulation, an increase in mitochondrial permeability, cytochrome c release, and the activation of caspase-9. GD3-induced apoptosis of activated T cells was dose dependent and inhibitable by pretreating the lymphocytes with N-acetylcysteine, cyclosporin A, or bongkrekic acid, emphasizing the essential role of ROS and mitochondrial permeability to the process. Ganglioside-induced T-cell killing was associated with the caspase-dependent degradation of nuclear factor-kappaB-inducible, antiapoptotic proteins, including RelA; this suggests that their loss is initiated only after the cascade is activated and that their disappearance amplifies but not triggers GD3 susceptibility. Resting T cells did not internalize appreciable levels of GD3 and did not undergo any of the proapoptotic changes that characterize activated T lymphocytes exposed to the ganglioside. RelA overexpression endows Jurkat cells with resistance to GD3-mediated apoptosis, verifying the role of the intact transcription factor in mediating protection from the ganglioside.

Tumors can promote their own progressive growth by inducing T cell apoptosis. Though previous studies suggested that tumor-mediated T cell killing is receptor dependent, we recently showed that tumor gangliosides also participate, a notion consistent with reports indicating that, in some cell types, gangliosides can activate the intrinsic apoptotic pathway by stimulating reactive oxygen species production, cytochrome c release, and caspase-9 activation. In this study, we used normal peripheral blood T cells, as well as caspase-8-, caspase-9-, and Fas-associated death domain protein-deficient Jurkat cells, to assess whether the death ligands and gangliosides overexpressed by the renal cell carcinoma (RCC) cell line SK-RC-45 can independently stimulate T cell apoptosis as a mechanism of immune escape. Anti-FasL Abs and the glycosylceramide synthase inhibitor 1-phenyl-2-hexadecanoylamino-3-pyrrolidino-1-propanol (PPPP) each partially inhibited the ability of SK-RC-45 to kill cocultured activated T cells; together, as purified molecules, RCC gangliosides and rFasL induced a more extensive mitochondrial permeability transition and greater levels of apoptosis than either agent alone, equivalent to that induced by the FasL- and ganglioside-expressing RCC line itself. rFasL-mediated apoptosis was completely inhibited in caspase-8- and Fas-associated death domain protein-negative Jurkat cells, though apoptosis induced by purified gangliosides remained intact, findings that correlate with the observed partial inhibition of SK-RC-45-induced apoptosis in the Jurkat lines with defective death receptor signaling. Western blot analysis performed on lysates made from wild-type and mutant Jurkat cells cocultured with SK-RC-45 revealed caspase activation patterns and other biochemical correlates which additionally supported the concept that tumor-associated gangliosides and FasL independently activate the caspase cascade in T cells through the intrinsic and extrinsic pathways, respectively.

The ability to induce T-cell apoptosis is one mechanism by which tumors evade the immune system, although the molecules involved remain controversial. We found that renal cell carcinoma (RCC)-induced T-cell apoptosis was inhibited by >50% when cocultures were performed with ganglioside-depleted tumor cells, caspase-8-negative lymphocytes, or anti-tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNFalpha) antibodies, suggesting that tumor gangliosides synergize with signals delivered through TNFalpha death receptors to mediate T-cell killing. The synergy between tumor-derived TNFalpha and the RCC-overexpressed ganglioside GM1 for killing resting T cells is corroborated by studies using purified GM1 and rTNF alpha, which indicate that a 48-hour pretreatment with the ganglioside optimally sensitizes the lymphocytes to a TNFalpha-induced apoptotic death. However, activated T cells, which synthesize TNFalpha themselves, can be killed by exogenous GM1 alone. RelA-overexpressing lymphocytes are protected from GM1 plus TNFalpha-mediated apoptosis, a finding consistent with our previous studies indicating that gangliosides inhibit nuclear factor-kappaB activation. These results are clinically relevant because, similar to T-cells cocultured with GM1-overexpressing RCC lines, T cells isolated from the peripheral blood of patients with metastatic RCC are also heavily coated with that tumor-shed ganglioside. This population of patient cells, unlike T cells isolated from normal donors, is highly susceptible to apoptosis induced by rTNF alpha or by metastatic patient sera, which contain elevated levels of the cytokine. This report thus extends our previous studies by demonstrating that tumor-derived TNFalpha enhances RCC apoptogenicity not only by inducing ganglioside synthesis but also by initiating receptor-dependent apoptosis in T cells in which the nuclear factor-kappaB activation pathway has been inhibited by GM1.

Cancer patients often exhibit loss of proper cell-mediated immunity and reduced effector T-cell population in the circulation. Thymus is a major site of T-cell maturation, and tumors induce thymic atrophy to evade cellular immune response. Here, we report severe thymic hypocellularity along with decreased thymic integrity in tumor bearer. In an effort to delineate the mechanisms behind such thymic atrophy, we observed that tumor-induced oxidative stress played a critical role, as it perturbed nuclear factor-kappaB (NF-kappaB) activity. Tumor-induced oxidative stress increased cytosolic IkappaBalpha retention and inhibited NF-kappaB nuclear translocation in thymic T cells. These NF-kappaB-perturbed cells became vulnerable to tumor-secreted tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha (TNF-alpha)-mediated apoptosis through the activation of TNF receptor-associated protein death domain-associated Fas-associated protein death domain and caspase-8. Interestingly, TNF-alpha-depleted tumor supernatants, either by antibody neutralization or by TNF-alpha-small interfering RNA transfection of tumor cells, were unable to kill T cell effectively. When T cells were overexpressed with NF-kappaB, the cells became resistant to tumor-induced apoptosis. In contrast, when degradation-defective IkappaBalpha (IkappaBalpha super-repressor) was introduced into T cells, the cells became more vulnerable, indicating that inhibition of NF-kappaB is the reason behind such tumor/TNF-alpha-mediated apoptosis. Curcumin could prevent tumor-induced thymic atrophy by restoring the activity of NF-kappaB. Further investigations suggest that neutralization of tumor-induced oxidative stress and restoration of NF-kappaB activity along with the reeducation of the TNF-alpha signaling pathway can be the mechanism behind curcumin-mediated thymic protection. Thus, our results suggest that unlike many other anticancer agents, curcumin is not only devoid of immunosuppressive effects but also acts as immunorestorer in tumor-bearing host.

Here we report that glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) mediates immunosuppression by promoting T-cell death via tumor-associated CD70 and gangliosides that act through receptor-dependent and receptor-independent pathways, respectively. GBM lines cocultured with T cells induced lymphocyte death. The GBM lines were characterized for their expression of CD70, Fas ligand (FasL), and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha), and the possible participation of those molecules in T-cell killing was assessed by doing GBM/T cell cocultures in the presence of anti-CD70 antibodies, Fas fusion proteins, or anti-TNF-alpha antibodies. CD70 but not TNF-alpha or FasL is responsible for initiating T-cell death via the receptor-dependent pathway. Of the four GBM cell lines that induced T-cell death, three highly expressed CD70. Two nonapoptogenic GBM lines (CCF3 and U138), on the other hand, had only minimally detectable CD70 expression. Blocking experiments with the anti-CD70 antibody confirmed that elevated CD70 levels were involved in the apoptogenicity of the three GBM lines expressing that molecule. Gangliosides were found to participate in the induction of T-cell apoptosis, because the glucosylceramide synthase inhibitor (PPPP) significantly reduced the abilities of all four apoptogenic lines to kill the lymphocytes. High-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) and mass spectroscopy revealed that GM2, GM2-like gangliosides, and GD1a were synthesized in abundance by all four apoptogenic GBM lines but not by the two GBMs lacking activity. Furthermore, gangliosides isolated from GBM lines as well as HPLC fractions containing GM2 and GD1a were directly apoptogenic for T cells. Our results indicate that CD70 and gangliosides are both products synthesized by GBMs that may be key mediators of T-cell apoptosis and likely contribute to the T-cell dysfunction observed within the tumor microenvironment.

It is now understood that the genetic plasticity of cancer cells can lead to alterations that confer selective growth advantages to the tumor, some of which play a role in immune escape. A number of mutations veiling tumor cells from host immune defenses have been well characterized but more recent studies suggest that a variety of tumors can also express products that are actually toxic for the immune effectors. A component of this tumor-induced T-cell death has been attributed to receptor-mediated apoptosis. Some tumors, however, synthesize soluble factors that mediate similar effects. In this regard, we previously showed that supernatants from explanted renal cell carcinoma (RCC) tumors sensitized normal T cells to activation induced cell death, and the responsible products had the features of gangliosides. We have also shown that renal tumor lines, including SK-RC-45, induce apoptosis of both Jurkat cells and normal T lymphocytes. Here, we used the ganglioside synthesis inhibitor PPPP to define the role of gangliosides in RCC cell line (SK-RC-45)-mediated T cell and Jurkat cell apoptosis and to elucidate the proapoptotic molecular events by which the glycosphingolipids produce their effects. The ganglioside-synthesizing SK-RC-45 line stimulated the TUNEL (terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated nick end labeling) positivity of cocultured T cells by a mechanism that involved decreasing lymphocyte expression levels of Bcl-2 and Bcl-(XL), inducing cytochrome c release from their mitochondria and activating caspases 9 and 3. These proapoptotic events were partially or completely abrogated when tumor cells were pretreated with PPPP for 5 days before the SK-RC-45/T lymphocyte coincubation, a regimen that reduced tumor-associated ganglioside levels by 70-80%. Our results suggest that gangliosides may be key mediators of RCC-induced T-cell apoptosis and imply that they contribute to the T-cell dysfunction in the tumor microenvironment.

Alterations in intracellular Zn(2+) concentrations are believed to play a crucial role in modulating apoptosis. The observation that Zn(2+) deficiency can induce cell death both in vivo and in vitro has been attributed to the fact that exchange of Zn(2+) for Ca(2+) and Mg(2+) within the nuclei may directly activate endogenous endonucleases therefore inducing DNA fragmentation independent of cytoplasmic factors. Here we show that the membrane-permeable zinc chelator, N,N',N'-tetrakis(2-pyridylmethyl) ethylenediamine (TPEN) induces translocation of cytochrome c from the mitochondrial intramembranous space into the cytosol in human peripheral blood T lymphocytes (PBL) with subsequent activation of caspases-3, -8, and -9. Pretreatment of T lymphocytes with caspase inhibitors Z-VAD.fmk or DEVD.fmk prevented DNA fragmentation in response to TPEN indicating that apoptosis triggered by zinc deficiency is entirely dependent on activation of caspase family members. The release of cytochrome c and activation of downstream caspases precedes changes in the mitochondrial transmembrane potential (Delta Psim). Therefore, cytoplasmic and mitochondrial events are critical to this process.

Nuclear factor kappaB (NFkappaB) regulates the expression of various genes essential for cell survival. Here we demonstrate that suppression of NFkappaB nuclear import with SN50 peptide carrying the nuclear localization sequence (NLS) of the NFkappaB p50 subunit induces apoptosis in human peripheral blood T lymphocytes (T-PBL), which can be blocked with the pan-caspase inhibitor Z-VAD.fmk. However, even when caspase function is blocked, the addition of SN50 induces irreversible cell loss due to the reduction in the mitochondrial transmembrane potential (DeltaPsim) followed by disruption of the cell membrane, hallmarks of necrosis. These observations demonstrate that although inhibition of NFkappaB nuclear translocation by SN50 peptide can induce caspase-dependent apoptosis in T-PBL, cell death may still proceed in the absence of functional caspase activity. The availability of downstream caspases appears to determine the mode of cell death in NFkappaB defective cells., (Copyright 2001 Academic Press.)

The T cells of many cancer patients are naturally sensitized to tumor-associated antigens (Ag), or they can readily be sensitized with vaccine maneuvers. In melanoma patients, the adoptive transfer of such T cells can often be causally linked to the objective regression of established tumors. So far, few patients have shown sustained clinical benefit from such therapy, but preclinical mouse studies have now clearly delineated the hurdles that must be overcome to render T-cell-based antitumor therapy effective. Contrary to earlier expectations, it is now established that remarkably potent CD4+ and CD8+ pre-effector T cells are naturally sensitized even in mice bearing progressive, weakly immunogenic tumors. However, such T cells often display signal transduction impairments as a consequence of the tumor environment, which limit their acquisition of optimal effector function. Extracorporealization and culture of these tumor-sensitized T cells with appropriate activation stimuli not only restores normal signal transduction, but also confers resolute effector activity that can often sustain tumor rejection upon reinfusion. In mouse studies, the L-selectin(low) fraction of T cells in tumor-draining lymph nodes (TDLN) constitutes the potent pre-effector population and comprises both CD4+ and helper-independent CD8+ T cells. Appropriate in vitro activation confers an apparently unrestricted trafficking capacity to this fraction, and even the ability to proliferate within the tumor bed, leading to unprecedented tumor rejection at anatomic sites (e.g., subcutaneous and intracranial) that were historically refractory to such treatment. Such results underscore the surprising capacity of appropriately activated effector T cells to withstand the immunosuppressive, tolerogenic, and apoptotic influences of the typical tumor environment. Given the increasingly appreciated and critical communications between T cells and host Ag-presenting cells (APC), which cross-present tumor Ag, it is likely that dendritic cell-based vaccine maneuvers that promote sensitization of T1-committed L-selectin(low) antitumor T cells will play an increasingly important role in adoptive therapy strategies.

Activation of the transcription factor nuclear factor-kappaB (NFkappaB) is impaired in T cells from patients with renal cell carcinomas (RCCs). In circulating T cells from a subset of patients with RCCs, the suppression of NFkappaB binding activity is downstream from the stimulus-induced degradation of the cytoplasmic factor IkappaBalpha. Tumor-derived soluble products from cultured RCC explants inhibit NFkappaB activity in T cells from healthy volunteers, despite a normal level of stimulus-induced IkappaBalpha degradation in these cells. The inhibitory agent has several features characteristic of a ganglioside, including sensitivity to neuraminidase but not protease treatment; hydrophobicity; and molecular weight less than 3 kDa. Indeed, we detected gangliosides in supernatants from RCC explants and not from adjacent normal kidney tissue. Gangliosides prepared from RCC supernatants, as well as the purified bovine gangliosides G(m1) and G(d1a), suppressed NFkappaB binding activity in T cells and reduced expression of the cytokines IL-2 and IFN-gamma. Taken together, our findings suggest that tumor-derived gangliosides may blunt antitumor immune responses in patients with RCCs.

Interleukin-12 (IL-12) is a heterodimeric cytokine that enhances the cytolytic activity, proliferation, and interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) production by T lymphocytes and natural killer cells, and has significant antitumor activity in a variety of murine tumor models. The induction of interferon (IFN)-gamma by IL-12 in tumor-bearing mice plays an important role in its antitumor activity. We therefore examined the effects of IL-12 on IFN-gamma production by T cells derived from patients with renal cell carcinoma (RCC), including freshly isolated tumor infiltrating lymphocytes (T-TIL), matched peripheral blood T cells (T-PBL), and RCC-specific TIL lines. IL-12 alone induced IFN-gamma secretion by T cells from normal individuals and appeared to act synergistically with either IL-2 or anti-CD3 antibody. In contrast, it failed to stimulate significant IFN-gamma secretion by T-PBL and T-TIL from RCC patients. This unresponsive state in T-PBL appeared selective because IFN-gamma was produced when cells were stimulated with either phytohemagglutinin or anti-CD3 antibody. Moreover, costimulation through the T-cell receptor (TCR)/CD3 complex or with IL-2 made T-PBL from RCC patients responsive to IL-12, possibly secondary to the upregulation of IL-12R (beta chain). A selective loss of IL-12-dependent production of IFN-gamma was also consistently observed in two of three established RCC-specific TIL lines. Although these cell lines did not respond to any concentration of IL-12, they did produce IFN-gamma after ligation of the TCR/CD3 or stimulation with IL-2, IL-12 also acted either syngeristically or additively with IL-2, anti-CD3 antibody, or autologous tumor cells to induce IFN-gamma production. The observed decreases in IFN-gamma production in response to IL-12 may have a negative effect on the development of T-cell immunity. The clinical importance of these findings during in vivo administration of IL-12 remains to be determined.

Studies have demonstrated abnormalities of the CD3/T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) and pathways of signal transduction in T lymphocytes from animals and patients with advanced malignancy. Diminished expression of TCRzeta and p56(lck) that are associated with the TCR and reduced nuclear localization of RelA containing nuclear factor kappaB (NFkappaB) complexes have been noted. These defects have been described in T cells from patients with malignant melanoma, renal cell carcinoma (RCC), ovarian cancer, and colorectal cancer. Preliminary observations also indicate possible correlation with clinical variables such as stage in selected instances. To further characterize altered expression of TCRzeta, p56(lck), and impaired activation of NFkappaB, T lymphocytes were obtained from 65 patients with RCC, the majority of whom were receiving combination cytokine therapy [interleukin (IL)-2, IFN alpha-containing regimens] and 37 control individuals. In 29 of these patients, levels of TCRzeta and p56(lck) were determined by Western blots of T-cell lysates and semiquantitated using densitometry. Relative levels were then correlated with a series of clinical variables including response to therapy, performance status, survival, disease sites, age, and others. In another group of 28 patients (three individuals from the first group), the frequency of abnormal NFkappaB activation was studied using electrophoretic mobility shift assays after activation of T cells with phorbol myristate acetate/ionomycin or anti-CD3 monoclonal antibody. Changes in these signaling molecules during cytokine treatment were also investigated. TCRzeta and p56(lck) were detected in the peripheral blood T cells in 27 of 29 patients, and overall, reduced levels were noted visually in 12 of 29 (41%) and 13 of 29 (45%) individuals, respectively. When levels were semiquantitated using densitometry, significant decreases of TCRzeta (P = 0.029) and p56(lck) (P = 0.029) but not CD3epsilon (P = 0.131), compared with control levels, were found. In patients treated with IL-2/IFN alpha-based therapy, relative levels of TCRzeta increased significantly (P = 0.002) on day 15 of cycle one compared with the baseline. Correlations of TCRzeta or p56(lck) levels with response or disease variables, except for lower TCRzeta levels (P < 0.001) in the presence of bone metastases, were not found. Abnormal NFkappaB activation after stimulation with phorbol myristate acetate/ionomycin and/or anti-CD3 monoclonal antibody was found in 59% of patients (17 of 28) and was not accounted for by the advanced age of the study cohort. Activation of NFkappaB in peripheral blood T cells was inducible during cytokine therapy in four of six individuals who displayed impaired NFkappaB activity prior to therapy. Moreover, impaired activation of NFkappaB does not appear linked to a reduction of TCRzeta expression, because in five patients, normal TCRzeta levels were present although kappaB binding was not inducible. In the majority of patients with advanced RCC, peripheral blood T cells express TCRzeta and p56(lck), and in a subset, reduced levels of these TCRzeta associated molecules are seen that may increase during cytokine-based therapy. Abnormal activation of NFkappaB is also present in >50% of patients and may also revert to normal during IL-2/IFN alpha-based treatment. This alteration in NFkappaB activation occurred in the presence of normal expression of TCRzeta-associated signaling elements. The clinical significance of these findings remains unclear.

Granzyme B is a protein thought to play a pivotal role in the cytolytic functions of T cells. In view of this, the inducibility of this gene in freshly isolated T cells (T-TILs) infiltrating human renal cell carcinoma (RCC) in vitro was examined by using the reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). A reduction in granzyme B messenger RNA (mRNA) expression in stimulated T-TILs from five of nine patients with RCC compared with autologous peripheral blood T cells was noted. The reduced expression was observed after multiple stimuli including anti-CD3 antibody, interleukin-2 (IL-2), and phytohemagglutinin (PHA). Because CD8+ T cells represent the predominant cytotoxic population, the ability of this cell population to express granzyme B mRNA after stimulation also was examined. When compared with CD8+ peripheral blood lymphocytes (T-PBLs) from patients with RCC and normal donors, the induction of granzyme B mRNA was reduced in CD8+ T-TILs. CD8+ T-TILs also had lower non-major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted cytotoxic activity than did CD8+ T-PBLs against both Daudi cells and allogeneic RCC cell lines. These results show that in a subset of patients with RCC, depressed lytic activity of CD8+ TILs compared with CD8+ PBLs is present. Reduced granzyme B mRNA expression also was noted in selected patients.

T-cell responses have been reported to be impaired in cancer patients, and lymphocytes infiltrating human tumors (T-TIL) appear to be more affected than those in the peripheral blood. T-TIL display a poor proliferative response when compared to peripheral blood T (T-PBL) cells that show a strong response to all stimuli. Here we report that T-TIL from patients with renal cell carcinoma (RCC) also have a defect in transferrin receptor (TfR) expression that is not present in T-PBL cells. Immunocytometry studies (dual staining for CD3 epsilon and TfR) demonstrated that autologous T cells from the peripheral blood but not from the tumor expressed TfR following stimulation with IL2, anti-CD3 or PHA. Expression of TfR correlated with the capacity of T cells from the blood and tumor to proliferate. Gene expression studies using reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) demonstrated that TfR mRNA levels in T-TIL were undetectable or low relative to T-PBL following stimulation. The failure to detect TfR mRNA in T-TIL after stimulation was not due to a shift in kinetics of mRNA accumulation since TfR mRNA was not detectable at any of the times tested (4, 12, 24 and 36 hr). The defect in TfR gene expression is selective since IL2R alpha gene expression was induced in T-TIL. Because IL2 binding to its receptor results in TfR expression, the defect in TfR induction in T-TIL appears to be distal to IL2R alpha expression. Our studies illustrate another alteration in T-TIL that is not observed in T cells from the peripheral blood. The absence of TfR gene expression may contribute to the poor proliferative response of T cells from the tumor.

Previously we showed that IL2 expanded tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs) from renal cell carcinoma mediated non-major histocompatibility complex-restricted cytotoxicity. Phenotypic analysis showed that cultured TILs were composed mostly of T-lymphocytes with varying numbers of CD4+, CD8+, and CD56+ (Leu19+) populations. Here we compared the cytolytic activity of the two predominant TIL subsets, CD3+CD4+ and CD3+CD8+, to that of the CD56+ populations. Using magnetic beads coated with antibodies to either CD4 or CD8, CD3+CD4+, and CD3+CD8+ TILs were isolated in a highly enriched form (greater than 92%) and could be expanded for over 40 days in vitro with 1000 units/ml IL2. In a 4-h 51Cr release assay the CD4+ and CD8+ TILs showed minimal lytic activity, whereas unseparated cells exhibited significant levels of non-major histocompatibility complex-restricted cytotoxicity. The lytic activity seen in the 4-h assay with unseparated TILs appeared to be related to the presence of CD56+ populations. With one exception none of the purified CD4+ or CD8+ TILs expressed any significant levels of CD56, while the unseparated TILs contained varying numbers of CD3+CD56+ and CD3-CD56+ populations. Cell-sorting experiments verified that the CD56+ populations were responsible for most of the lytic activity in 4 h even though CD3+CD56- cells represented the predominant cell type. Although CD3+CD56- TILs were minimally lytic in 4 h, we show here that both CD3+CD4+ and CD3+CD8+ subsets displayed substantial cytotoxicity in long-term assays. In the 18-h 51Cr release assay 5 of 6 CD4+ and 2 of 3 CD8+ TILs were lytic for the autologous tumor. In two cases, restimulation with the autologous tumor induced augmented cytolytic activity of TIL subsets and in one case induced lytic activity in 4 h. The cytotoxic activity of TIL subsets was further examined using a 72-h assay in which TILs were cocultured with a confluent layer of tumor cells. The degree of cytotoxicity was quantitated by measuring the amount of crystal violet dye that was incorporated by tumor cells which remained after the incubation period. CD4+ and CD8+ TILs typically caused greater than a 50% reduction of tumor cells in 3 days and the level of reduction was increased when IL2 was added to the cultures. All the CD4+ and CD8+ subset preparations were cytotoxic in the 3-day assay even though some were not lytic for certain targets in the 18-h 51Cr release assay.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

To better understand the modulatory effects of interleukin-2 (IL-2) on lymphocyte proliferation, we examined the clonality of the in vitro T-cell response by Southern blot hybridization. Tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs) grown in the presence of IL-2 for 15-26 days had detectable T-cell receptor beta-chain gene rearrangements, which indicated oligoclonal enhancement in culture in four of nine TIL samples. In contrast, none of 11 uncultured TIL samples had detectable gene rearrangements. Lack of detection in at least three of the five negative, cultured TIL samples could be explained by increased numbers of natural killer cells. We hypothesize that the oligoclonal expansion noted results from the enhanced response of immune-primed T cells to IL-2.

This study examines the antigen that stimulate production or release of a soluble helper factor(s) involved in development of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). Antigens associated with the Mls locus, I and K/D regions of the MHC were all capable of stimulating responder cells in MLC to produce helper factor. These supernatant fluids were all capable of providing "help" for the generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes in MLC in which spleen cells are stimulated by allogeneic heat-treated thymocytes or splenocytes. Previous reports from our laboratory as well as others have shown that heat-treated cells do not stimulate a cytotoxic response. Heat-treatment of Mls, I, and H-2K/H-2D region incompatible stimulatory cells in MLC eliminated their ability to induce responder cells to produce helper factor, suggesting this is the mechanism whereby heat-treatment reduces the ability of cells to stimulate cell-mediated lympholysis (CML). The inability of supernatant fluids, from MLCs in which heat-treated cells were the stimulators, to assist in the generation of cytotoxic T cells did not appear to be the result of any suppressive factor induced by such treatment. Further, the antigens that stimulate pre-killer cells appear functionally distinct from those heat labile antigens (Mls, I, H-2K/H-2D associated) that stimulate helper factor production since heat-treated allogeneic cells served as stimulators of cytotoxicity provided helper activity was added to the MLC.

During previous studies on the regulation of cloned T lymphocyte function, we observed that murine cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones progressively lose the ability to lyse appropriate target cells during prolonged (24 to 48 hr) incubation with the tumor promoter phorbol myristic acetate (PMA). We further observed that the cytolytic function of PMA-treated CTL clones can be restored by incubation with secondary MLC supernatant (2 degrees MLC SN), a potent source of cytokines. We now report our observations on the nature of the cytokine(s) responsible for recovery of CTL activity. Like 2 degrees MLC SN, the lectin-induced SN from a cloned helper T cell and the lectin-induced SN from a T cell hybridoma can restore cytolytic activity to cloned CTL treated with PMA. In contrast, supernatants from L929 cells, WEHI-3 cells, and P388D1 cells fail to restore cytolytic activity to similarly treated cloned CTL. These data suggest that IL 2 and/or gamma-IFN, but not CSF-1, CSF-GM, IL 3, or IL 1, can influence expression of cytolysis by cloned CTL. Furthermore, highly purified IL 2 can restore cytolytic activity, even when cytosine arabinoside is present to inhibit clonal expansion. Our studies indicate that cytolysis is a reversible function of cloned CTL, and that cytolysis may not necessarily represent an end-stage feature of CTL maturation. Our studies further show that IL 2 is both necessary and sufficient for resumption of cytolytic function by "deactivated" CTL. As such, these observations suggest that IL 2 can regulate not only T cell proliferation but also the expression of cytolysis by some cytolytic T cell populations.

We investigate the production and biological activity of soluble helper factors produced by peritoneal T cells and macrophage derived from mice primed in vivo with Listeria monocytogenes. Supernatant fluids from co-cultures of these immune T cells and activated macrophages contained Interleukin 1 (IL 1) and Interleukin 2 (IL 2), and had the ability to assist the generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) from a population of nylon wool nonadherent spleen cells sensitized to allogeneic heat-treated thymocytes. The ability to assist CTL development involved T cell and macrophage factors in addition to IL 1 and IL 2. Immune T cells cultured alone produced a factor, devoid of significant IL 2 activity, that assisted CTL development only if adherent cells were present in the responding population. Activated macrophage produced a 38,000 dalton component, distinct from IL 1 on the basis of m.w., that assisted the development of CTL from nylon wool nonadherent splenic cells. Supernatants fluids from co-cultures of immune T cells and allogeneic, nonactivated macrophage contained a CTL helper factor but did not contain IL 1 or IL 2 activities. In contrast, supernatant fluids from co-cultures of immune T cells and syngeneic, nonactivated macrophage contained all 3 activities. This suggests a genetic restriction for the production of IL 1 and IL 2 that does not restrict the production of a CTL helper factor. These results demonstrate that T cell- and macrophage-derived helper factors distinct from IL 1 and IL 2 participate in the development of CTL.