1. Validating the diagnostic accuracy of medical certification: a population-level comparison between verbal autopsy and Saudi medical records causes of death of deceased with type 2 diabetes
- Author
-
Faleh Alyazidi, Deler Shakely, Fawaz R. Alyazidi, Max Petzold, and Laith Hussain-Alkhateeb
- Subjects
causes of death ,medical certification ,health system ,verbal autopsy ,saudi arabia ,mortality statistics ,health policy ,Public aspects of medicine ,RA1-1270 - Abstract
Background In contexts where certifying causes of death (COD) is inadequate – either in industrialized or non-industrialized countries – verbal autopsy (VA) serves as a practical method for determining probable COD, helping to address gaps in vital data. Objective This study aimed to validate the diagnostic accuracy of medical certifications at a population level by comparing COD obtained from medical records against those derived from VA in Saudi Arabia. Method Death records from 2018 to 2021 were collected from a type 2 diabetes mellitus register at a major specialist hospital in Makkah. Three hundred and two VA interviews were completed with deceased patients’ relatives, and the probable COD was determined using InterVA-5 software. Lin’s concordance correlation coefficient was applied to examine similarities of the cause-specific mortality fractions (CSMFs) based on International Classification of Diseases chapters from both verbal autopsy causes of death (VACOD) and the physician review causes of death (PRCOD). Results Overall, the findings demonstrated a moderate level of concordance of COD at the population between VACOD and PRCOD. However, the CSMFs for various COD categories derived from both sources showed a broad spectrum of absolute differences, with the largest disparities observed among the most prevalent COD categories. Conclusion PRCOD was found to overestimate population-level endocrine/metabolic and respiratory disease COD while underestimating circulatory disease, demonstrating medical certification challenges. Conversely, affirming previous literature on prevalent COD in Saudi Arabia, VA appears to deliver a plausible assessment, further strengthening its potential to integrate within the Saudi health system towards an augmented medical certification process.
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF