1. Normal Tissue Injury Induced by Photon and Proton Therapies: Gaps and Opportunities
- Author
-
C. Norman Coleman, Chandan Guha, Justyna Miszczyk, Pataje G. S. Prasanna, K. Rawojć, and Jeffrey C. Buchsbaum
- Subjects
Male ,Organs at Risk ,Oncology ,Cancer Research ,Lung Neoplasms ,Esophageal Neoplasms ,medicine.medical_treatment ,030218 nuclear medicine & medical imaging ,law.invention ,Central Nervous System Neoplasms ,0302 clinical medicine ,Randomized controlled trial ,law ,Carcinoma, Non-Small-Cell Lung ,Neoplasms ,Proton Therapy ,Prospective Studies ,Lung ,Gastrointestinal Neoplasms ,Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic ,Radiation ,Brain Neoplasms ,Heart ,Radiotherapy Dosage ,Esophageal cancer ,Progression-Free Survival ,Head and Neck Neoplasms ,030220 oncology & carcinogenesis ,Female ,medicine.medical_specialty ,Breast Neoplasms ,Radiosurgery ,Article ,03 medical and health sciences ,Clinical Trials, Phase II as Topic ,Internal medicine ,medicine ,Humans ,Radiology, Nuclear Medicine and imaging ,Progression-free survival ,Adverse effect ,Proton therapy ,Photons ,business.industry ,Prostatic Neoplasms ,Radiobiology ,Cancer ,medicine.disease ,Clinical trial ,Radiation therapy ,Quality of Life ,business - Abstract
Despite technological advances in radiotherapy and cancer treatment, patients still experience adverse effects. Proton therapy has emerged as a valuable radiotherapy modality, which can improve treatment outcomes. As normal tissue injury is an important determinant of the outcome, for this review, we analyzed two databases, (i) clinical trials registered in ClinicalTrials.gov and (ii) the literature on proton therapy in PubMed, which shows a steady increase in the number of publications. Most studies in proton therapy registered in the ClinicalTrials.gov with results available are nonrandomized early phase studies, with a relatively small number of patients enrolled. From the larger database of nonrandomized trials, we listed adverse events in specific organ/sites among cancer patients treated with photons and protons to identify critical issues. Present data demonstrate dosimetric advantages of proton therapy with favorable toxicity profiles and forms the basis for comparative randomized prospective trials. Comparative analysis of recently completed three randomized trials for normal tissue toxicities suggest the following: (i) for early stage non-small-cell lung cancer, no meaningful comparison could be made between stereotactic body radiotherapy and stereotactic body proton therapy due to low accrual (NCT01511081), (ii) for locally advanced non-small-cell lung cancer, comparison of intensity-modulated radiotherapy with passive scattering proton therapy (now largely replaced by "spot-scanned" intensity-modulated proton therapy), proton therapy did not provide any benefit in normal tissue toxicity or locoregional failure over photon therapy, and (iii) for locally advanced esophageal cancer proton beam therapy provided a lower total toxicity burden; although it did not improve progression free survival and quality-of-life (NCT01512589). The purpose of this review is to inform the limitations of current trials looking at protons and photons, considering advances in technology, physics, and biology are a continuum and advocate for future trials geared towards accurate precision radiation therapy that needs to be viewed as an iterative process in a defined path towards delivering optimal radiation treatment. A foundational understanding of the radiobiological differences between protons and photons in tumor and normal tissue responses is fundamental to, and necessary for, determining the suitability of a given type of biologically optimized radiation therapy to a patient or a cohort.
- Published
- 2021