Search

NMR-spectroscopy has certain unique advantages for recording unfolding transitions of proteins compared e.g. to optical methods. It enables per-residue monitoring and separate detection of the folded and unfolded state as well as possible equilibrium intermediates. This allows a detailed view on the state and cooperativity of folding of the protein of interest and the correct interpretation of subsequent experiments. Here we summarize in detail practical and theoretical aspects of such experiments. Certain pitfalls can be avoided, and meaningful simplification can be made during the analysis. Especially a good understanding of the NMR exchange regime and relaxation properties of the system of interest is beneficial. We show by a global analysis of signals of the folded and unfolded state of GB1 how accurate values of unfolding can be extracted and what limits different NMR detection and unfolding methods. E.g. commonly used exchangeable amides can lead to a systematic under determination of the thermodynamic protein stability. We give several perspectives of how to deal with more complex proteins and how the knowledge about protein stability at residue resolution helps to understand protein properties under crowding conditions, during phase separation and under high pressure., (© 2022. The Author(s).)

Ankyrin repeat proteins are found in all three kingdoms of life. Fundamentally, these proteins are involved in protein-protein interaction in order to activate or suppress biological processes. The basic architecture of these proteins comprises repeating modules forming elongated structures. Due to the lack of long-range interactions, a graded stability among the repeats is the generic properties of this protein family determining both protein folding and biological function. Protein folding intermediates were frequently found to be key for the biological functions of repeat proteins. In this review, we discuss most recent findings addressing this close relation for ankyrin repeat proteins including DARPins, Notch receptor ankyrin repeat domain, IκBα inhibitor of NFκB, and CDK inhibitor p19 INK4d . The role of local folding and unfolding and gradual stability of individual repeats will be discussed during protein folding, protein-protein interactions, and post-translational modifications. The conformational changes of these repeats function as molecular switches for biological regulation, a versatile property for modern drug discovery.

Background: During protein-folding reactions toward the native structure, short-lived intermediate states can be populated. Such intermediates expose hydrophobic patches and can self-associate leading to non-productive protein misfolding. A major focus of current research is the characterization of short-lived intermediates and how molecular chaperones enable productive folding. Real-time NMR spectroscopy, together with the development of advanced methods, is reviewed here and the potential these methods have to characterize intermediate states as well as interactions with molecular chaperone proteins at single-residue resolution is highlighted., Scope of Review: Various chaperone interactions can guide the protein-folding reaction and thus are important for protein structure formation, stability, and activity of their substrates. Chaperone-assisted protein folding, characterization of intermediates, and their molecular interactions using real-time NMR spectroscopy will be discussed. Additionally, recent advances in NMR methods employed for characterization of high-energy intermediates will be discussed., Major Conclusions: Real-time NMR combines high resolution with kinetic information of protein reactions, which can be employed not only for protein-folding studies and the characterization of folding intermediates but also to investigate the molecular mechanisms of assisted protein folding., General Significance: Real-time NMR spectroscopy remains an effective tool to reveal structural details about the interaction between chaperones and transient intermediates. Methodologically, it provides in-depth understanding of how kinetic intermediates and their thermodynamics contribute to the protein-folding reaction. This review summarizes the most recent advances in this field. This article is part of a Special Issue titled Proline-directed Foldases: Cell Signaling Catalysts and Drug Targets., (Copyright © 2014 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.)

The human AmphyphisinII/Bin1 N-BAR domain belongs to the BAR domain superfamily, whose members sense and generate membrane curvatures. The N-BAR domain is a 57 kDa homodimeric protein comprising a six helix bundle. Here we report the protein folding mechanism of this protein as a representative of this protein superfamily. The concentration dependent thermodynamic stability was studied by urea equilibrium transition curves followed by fluorescence and far-UV CD spectroscopy. Kinetic unfolding and refolding experiments, including rapid double and triple mixing techniques, allowed to unravel the complex folding behavior of N-BAR. The equilibrium unfolding transition curve can be described by a two-state process, while the folding kinetics show four refolding phases, an additional burst reaction and two unfolding phases. All fast refolding phases show a rollover in the chevron plot but only one of these phases depends on the protein concentration reporting the dimerization step. Secondary structure formation occurs during the three fast refolding phases. The slowest phase can be assigned to a proline isomerization. All kinetic experiments were also followed by fluorescence anisotropy detection to verify the assignment of the dimerization step to the respective folding phase. Based on these experiments we propose for N-BAR two parallel folding pathways towards the homodimeric native state depending on the proline conformation in the unfolded state.

In the N2 domain of the gene-3-protein of phage fd, two consecutive beta-strands are connected by a mobile loop of seven residues (157-163). The stability of this loop is low, and the Asp160-Pro161 bond at its tip shows conformational heterogeneity with 90% being in the cis and 10% in the trans form. The refolding kinetics of N2 are complex because the molecules with cis or trans isomers at Pro161 both fold to native-like conformations, albeit with different rates. We employed consensus design to shorten the seven-residue irregular loop around Pro161 to a four-residue type I' turn without a proline. This increased the conformational stability of N2 by almost 10 kJ mol(-1) and abolished the complexity of the folding kinetics. Turn sequences obtained from in vitro selections for increased stability strongly resembled those derived from the consensus design. Two other type I' turns of N2 could also be stabilized by consensus design. For all three turns, the gain in stability originates from an increase in the rate of refolding. The turns form native-like structures early during refolding and thus stabilize the folding transition state. The crystal structure of the variant with all three stabilized turns confirms that the 157-163 loop was in fact shortened to a type I' turn and that the other turns maintained their type I' conformation after sequence optimization., (Copyright (c) 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.)

A promising approach to unravel the relationship between sequence information, tertiary structure, and folding mechanism of proteins is the analysis of the folding behavior of proteins with low sequence identity but comparable tertiary structures. Ribonuclease A (RNase A) and its homologues, forming the RNase A superfamily, provide an excellent model system for respective studies. RNase A has been used extensively as a model protein for folding studies. However, little is known about the folding of homologous RNases. Here, we analyze the folding pathway of onconase, a homologous protein from the Northern leopard frog with great potential as a tumor therapeutic, by high-resolution techniques. Although onconase and RNase A significantly differ in the primary structure (28% sequence identity) and in thermodynamic stability (DeltaDeltaG = 20 kJ mol(-1)), both enzymes possess very similar tertiary structures. The present folding studies on onconase by rapid mixing techniques in combination with fluorescence and NMR spectroscopy allow the structural assignment of the three kinetic phases observed in stopped-flow fluorescence spectroscopy. After a slow peptidyl-prolyl cis-to-trans isomerization reaction in the unfolded state, ONC folds via an on-pathway intermediate to the native state. By quenched-flow hydrogen/deuterium exchange experiments coupled with 2D NMR spectroscopy, 31 amino acid residues were identified to be involved in the structure formation of the intermediate. Twelve of these residues are identical in the RNase A sequence, which is a significantly higher percentage (39%) than the overall 28% sequence identity. Moreover, the structure of this intermediate closely resembles two of the intermediates that occur early during the refolding of RNase A. Obviously, in spite of considerable differences in their amino acid sequence the initial folding events of both proteins are comparable, guided by a limited number of conserved residues.

Repeat proteins are widespread in nature, with many of them functioning as binding molecules in protein-protein recognition. Their simple structural architecture is used in biotechnology for generating proteins with high affinities to target proteins. Recent folding studies of ankyrin repeat (AR) proteins revealed a new mechanism of protein folding. The formation of an intermediate state is rate limiting in the folding reaction, suggesting a scaffold function of this transient state for intrinsically less stable ARs. To investigate a possible common mechanism of AR folding, we studied the structure and folding of a new thermophilic AR protein (tANK) identified in the archaeon Thermoplasma volcanium. The x-ray structure of the evolutionary much older tANK revealed high homology to the human CDK inhibitor p19(INK4d), whose sequence was used for homology search. As for p19(INK4d), equilibrium and kinetic folding analyses classify tANK to the family of sequential three-state folding proteins, with an unusual fast equilibrium between native and intermediate state. Under equilibrium conditions, the intermediate can be populated to >90%, allowing characterization on a residue-by-residue level using NMR spectroscopy. These data clearly show that the three C-terminal ARs are natively folded in the intermediate state, whereas native cross-peaks for the rest of the molecule are missing. Therefore, the formation of a stable folding unit consisting of three ARs is the necessary rate-limiting step before AR 1 and 2 can assemble to form the native state.

The p19(INK4d) protein consists of five ankyrin repeats (ANK) and controls the human cell cycle by inhibiting the cyclin D-dependent kinases (CDK) 4 and 6. We investigated the folding of p19(INK4d) by urea-induced unfolding transitions, kinetic analyses of unfolding and refolding, including double-mixing experiments and a special assay for folding intermediates. Folding is a sequential two-step reaction via a hyperfluorescent on-pathway intermediate. This intermediate is present under all conditions, during unfolding, refolding and at equilibrium. The folding mechanism was confirmed by a quantitative global fit of a consistent set of equilibrium and kinetic data revealing the thermodynamics and intrinsic folding rates of the different states. Surprisingly, the N<-->I transition is much faster compared to the I<-->U transition. The urea-dependence of the intrinsic folding rates causes population of the intermediate at equilibrium close to the transition midpoint. NMR detected hydrogen/deuterium exchange and the analysis of truncated variants showed that the C-terminal repeats ANK3-5 are already folded in the on-pathway intermediate, whereas the N-terminal repeats 1 and 2 are not folded. We suggest that during refolding, repeats ANK3-ANK5 first form the scaffold for the subsequent assembly of repeats ANK1 and ANK2. The binding function of p19(INK4d) resides in the latter repeats. We propose that the graded stability and the facile unfolding of repeats 1 and 2 is a prerequisite for the down-regulation of the inhibitory activity of p19(INK4d) during the cell-cycle.

Cold and heat denaturation of the double mutant Arg 3-->Glu/Leu 66-->Glu of cold shock protein Csp of Bacillus caldolyticus was monitored using 1D (1)H NMR spectroscopy in the temperature range from -12 degrees C in supercooled water up to +70 degrees C. The fraction of unfolded protein, f (u), was determined as a function of the temperature. The data characterizing the unfolding transitions could be consistently interpreted in the framework of two-state models: cold and heat denaturation temperatures were determined to be -11 degrees C and 39 degrees C, respectively. A joint fit to both cold and heat transition data enabled the accurate spectroscopic determination of the heat capacity difference between native and denatured state, DeltaC(p) of unfolding. The approach described in this letter, or a variant thereof, is generally applicable and promises to be of value for routine studies of protein folding.

Nerve growth factor (NGF), a member of the neurotrophin family, is an all-beta-sheet protein with a characteristic structure motif, the cystine knot. Unfolding of NGF in 6 M GdnHCl has been described previously to involve an initial partial loss of structure and a subsequent very slow conversion to a second, completely unfolded state. This latter conversion was postulated to represent a back-threading of the disulfide bond that passes through the cystine knot (loop threading hypothesis). Here, this hypothesis was questioned with the pro form of the protein (proNGF). In proNGF, the mature part is preceded by the 103-amino acid pro-peptide. Consequently, loop threading of the N-terminally extended protein should be significantly delayed. However, unfolding kinetics of proNGF monitored by RP-HPLC, intrinsic fluorescence, and NMR spectroscopy were comparable to those of mature NGF. Time-resolved (1)H-(15)N HSQC spectra revealed a slow time-dependent loss of residual structure of which the kinetics correlated well with the transition observed by RP-HPLC. Refolding from the completely unfolded state led to a partial recovery of natively folded proNGF. In summary, the sequential unfolding of proNGF only marginally differed from that of mature NGF. Therefore, it is very unlikely that a loop threading mechanism is the cause of the slow unfolding step.

The cold shock protein CspB adopts its native and functional tertiary structure on the millisecond time scale. We employed transverse relaxation NMR methods, which allow a quantitative measurement of the cooperativity of this fast folding reaction on a residue basis. Thereby, chemical exchange contributions to the transverse relaxation rate (R(2)) were observed for every residue of CspB verifying the potential of this method to identify not only local dynamics but also to characterize global events. Toward this end, the homogeneity of the transition state of folding was probed by comparing Chevron plots (i.e., dependence of the apparent folding rate on the denaturant concentration) determined by stopped-flow fluorescence with Chevron plots of six residues acquired by R(2) dispersion experiments. The coinciding results obtained for probes at different locations in the three-dimensional structure of CspB indicate the ability and significance of transverse relaxation NMR to determine Chevron plots on a residue-by-residue basis providing detailed insights on the nature of the transition state of folding.

Proteins are involved in virtually every biological process and in order to function, it is necessary for these polypeptide chains to fold into the unique, native conformation. This folding process can take place rapidly. NMR line shape analyses and transverse relaxation measurements allow protein folding studies on a microsecond-to-millisecond time scale. Together with an overview of current achievements within this field, we present millisecond protein folding studies by NMR of the cold shock protein CspB from Bacillus subtilis.

Real-time NMR spectroscopy developed to a generally applicable method to follow protein folding reactions. It combines the access to high resolution data with kinetic experiments allowing very detailed insights into the development of the protein structure during different steps of folding. The present review concentrates mainly on the progress of real-time NMR during the last 5 years. Starting from simple 1D experiments, mainly changes of the chemical shifts and line widths of the resonances have been used to analyze the different states populated during the folding reactions. Today, we have a broad spectrum of 1D, 2D, and even 3D NMR methods focusing on different characteristics of the folding polypeptide chains. More than 20 proteins have been investigated so far by these time-resolved experiments and the main results and conclusions are discussed in this report. Real-time NMR provides comprehensive contributions for joining experiment and theory within the 'new view' of protein folding.

ORF56 is a plasmid-encoded protein from Sulfolobus islandicus, which probably controls the copy number of the pRN1 plasmid by binding to its own promotor. The protein showed an extremely high stability in denaturant, heat, and pH-induced unfolding transitions, which can be well described by a two-state reaction between native dimers and unfolded monomers. The homodimeric character of native ORF56 was confirmed by analytical ultracentrifugation. Far-UV circular dichroism and fluorescence spectroscopy gave superimposable denaturant-induced unfolding transitions and the midpoints of both heat as well as denaturant-induced unfolding depend on the protein concentration supporting the two-state model. This model was confirmed by GdmSCN-induced unfolding monitored by heteronuclear 2D NMR spectroscopy. Chemical denaturation was accomplished by GdmCl and GdmSCN, revealing a Gibbs free energy of stabilization of -85.1 kJ/mol at 25 degrees C. Thermal unfolding was possible only above 1 M GdmCl, which shifted the melting temperature (t(m)) below the boiling point of water. Linear extrapolation of t(m) to 0 M GdmCl yielded a t(m) of 107.5 degrees C (5 microM monomer concentration). Additionally, ORF56 remains natively structured over a remarkable pH range from pH 2 to pH 12. Folding kinetics were followed by far-UV CD and fluorescence after either stopped-flow or manual mixing. All kinetic traces showed only a single phase and the two probes revealed coincident folding rates (k(f), k(u)), indicating the absence of intermediates. Apparent first-order refolding rates depend linearly on the protein concentration, whereas the unfolding rates do not. Both lnk(f) and lnk(u) depend linearly on the GdmCl concentration. Together, folding and association of homodimeric ORF56 are concurrent events. In the absence of denaturant ORF56 refolds fast (7.0 x 10(7)M(-1)s(-1)) and unfolds extremely slowly (5.7 year(-1)). Therefore, high stability is coupled to a slow unfolding rate, which is often observed for proteins of extremophilic organisms.

P19(INK4d) is a tumor suppressing protein and belongs to a family of cyclin D-dependent kinase inhibitors of CDK4 and CDK6, which play a key role in human cell cycle control. P19 comprises ten alpha-helices arranged sequentially in five ankyrin repeats forming an elongated structure. This rather simple topology, combined with its physiological function, makes p19 an interesting model protein for folding studies. Urea-induced unfolding transitions monitored by far-UV CD and phenylalanine fluorescence coincide and suggest a two-state mechanism for equilibrium unfolding. Unfolding of p19 followed by 2D (1)H-(15)N HSQC spectra revealed a third species at moderate urea concentrations with a maximum population of about 30 % near 3.2 M urea. It shows poor chemical shift dispersion, but cross-peaks emerge for some residues that are distinct from the native or unfolded state. This equilibrium intermediate either arises only at high protein concentrations (as in the NMR experiment) or has similar optical properties to the unfolded state. Stopped-flow far-UV CD experiments at various urea concentrations revealed that alpha-helical structure is formed in three phases, of which only the fastest phase (10 s(-1)) depends upon the urea concentration. The kinetic of the slowest phase (0.017 s(-1)) can be resolved by 1D real-time NMR and accelerated by cyclophilin. It is limited in rate by prolyl isomerization, and native-like ordered structure cannot form prior to this isomerization. The two fast phases lead to 83 % native protein within the dead time of the NMR experiment. In contrast to p16(INK4a), which exhibits only a marginal stability and high unfolding rates, p19 shows the expected stability for a protein of this size with a clear kinetic barrier between the unfolded and folded state. Therefore, p19 might complement the function of less stable INK4 inhibitors in cell cycle control under unfavorable conditions., (Copyright 2002 Academic Press.)

The refolding reaction of S54G/P55N ribonuclease T1 is a two-step process, where fast formation of a partly folded intermediate is followed by the slow reaction to the native state, limited by a trans --> cis isomerization of Pro39. The hydrodynamic radius of this kinetic folding intermediate was determined by real-time diffusion NMR spectroscopy. Its folding to the native state was monitored by a series of 128 very fast 2D (15)N-HMQC spectra, to observe the kinetics of 66 individual backbone amide probes. We find that the intermediate is as compact as the native protein with many native chemical shifts. All 66 analyzed amide probes follow the rate-limiting prolyl isomerization, which indicates that this cooperative refolding reaction is fully synchronized. The stability of the folding intermediate was determined from the protection factors of 45 amide protons derived from a competition between refolding and H/D exchange. The intermediate has already gained 40% of the Gibbs free energy of refolding with many protected amides in not-yet-native regions.

The refolding of bovine alpha-lactalbumin (BLA) from its chemically denatured state in 6 M GuHCl has been investigated by a variety of complementary biophysical approaches. CD experiments indicate that the species formed in the early stages of refolding of the apo-protein have at least 85 % of the alpha-helical content of the native state, and kinetic NMR experiments show that they possess near-native compactness. Hydrogen exchange measurements using mass spectrometry and NMR indicate that persistent structure in these transient species is located predominantly in the alpha-domain of the native protein and is similar to that present in the partially folded A-state formed by the protein at low pH. The extent of the exchange protection is, however, small, and there is no evidence for the existence of well-defined discrete kinetic intermediates of the type populated in the refolding of the structurally homologous c-type lysozymes. Rather, both mass spectrometric and NMR data indicate that the rate-determining transition from the compact partially structured (molten globule) species to the native state is highly cooperative. The data show that folding in the presence of Ca2+ is similar to that in its absence, although the rate is increased by more than two orders of magnitude. Sequential mixing experiments monitored by fluorescence spectroscopy indicate that this slower folding is not the result of the accumulation of kinetically trapped species. Rather, the data are consistent with a model in which binding of Ca2+ stabilizes native-like contacts in the partially folded species and reduces the barriers for the conversion of the protein to its native state. Taken together the results indicate that folding of BLA, in the presence of its four disulphide bonds, corresponds to one of the limiting cases of protein folding in which rapid collapse to a globule with a native-like fold is followed by a search for native-like side-chain contacts that enable efficient conversion to the close packed native structure., (Copyright 1999 Academic Press.)

The rate-limiting step during the refolding of S54G/P55N ribonuclease T1 is determined by the slow trans-->cis prolyl isomerisation of Pro39. We investigated the refolding of this variant by one-dimensional (1D) and two-dimensional (2D) real-time NMR spectroscopy, initiated by a tenfold dilution from 6 M guanidine hydrochloride at 10 degreesC. Two intermediates could be resolved with the 1D approach. The minor intermediate, which is only present early during refolding, is largely unfolded. The major intermediate, with an incorrect trans Pro39 peptide bond, is highly structured with 33 amide protons showing native chemical shifts and native NOE patterns. They could be assigned in a real-time 2D-NOESY (nuclear Overhauser enhancement spectroscopy) by using a new assignment strategy to generate positive and negative signal intensities for native and non-native NOE cross-peaks, respectively. Surprisingly, amide protons with non-native environments are located not only close to Tyr38-Pro39, but are spread throughout the entire protein, including the C-terminal part of the alpha-helix, beta-strands 3 and 4 and several loop regions. Native secondary and tertiary structure was found for the major intermediate in the N-terminal beta-strands 1 and 2 and the C terminus (connected by the disulfide bonds), the N-terminal part of the alpha-helix, and the loops between beta-strands 4/5 and 5/6. Implications of these native and non-native structure elements of the intermediate for the refolding of S54G/P55N ribonuclease T1 and for cis/trans isomerizations are discussed., (Copyright 1999 Academic Press.)

Protein folding can be described in terms of the development of specific contacts between residues as a highly disordered polypeptide chain converts into the native state. Here we describe an NMR based strategy designed to detect such contacts by observation of nuclear Overhauser effects (NOEs). Experiments with alpha-lactalbumin reveal the existence of extensive NOEs between aromatic and aliphatic protons in the archetypal molten globule formed by this protein at low pH. Analysis of their time development provides direct evidence for near-native compactness of this state. Through a rapid refolding procedure the NOE intensity can be transferred efficiently into the resolved and assigned spectrum of the native state. This demonstrates the viability of using this approach to map out time-averaged interactions between residues in a partially folded protein.

The cold-shock protein CspB (from Bacillus subtilis), a very small protein of 67 residues, folds extremely fast in a reversible N &lrharr; U two-state reaction. Both unfolding and refolding are strongly decelerated when the viscosity of the solvent is increased by adding ethylene glycol or sucrose. The folding of CspB thus seems to follow Kramers' model for reactions in which the reactants must diffuse together. It indicates that the compaction of the protein chain occurs in the rate-limiting step of folding. Chain diffusion to a productively collapsed form and the crossing of a high energy barrier are thus tightly coupled in this folding reaction, and the measured reaction rate depends on both the diffusion of the protein chain in the solvent and the magnitude of the activation energy. We suggest that in protein folding an energetic barrier is essential to separate the native from the unfolded conformations of a protein. This barrier protects the ordered structure of a native protein against continuous unfolding by diffusive chain motions and leads to apparent two-state behavior.

An approach is described to monitor directly at the level of individual residues the formation of structure during protein folding. A two-dimensional heteronuclear nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectrum was recorded after the rapid initiation of the refolding of a protein labeled with nitrogen-15. The intensities and line shapes of the cross peaks in the spectrum reflected the kinetic time course of the folding events that occurred during the spectral accumulation. The method was used to demonstrate the cooperative nature of the acquisition of the native main chain fold of apo bovine alpha-lactalbumin. The general approach, however, should be applicable to the investigation of a wide range of chemical reactions.

The refolding of apo bovine alpha-lactalbumin has been monitored in real time by NMR spectroscopy following rapid in situ dilution of a chemically denatured state. By examining individual resonances in the time-resolved NMR spectra, the native state has been shown to emerge in a cooperative manner from an intermediate formed in the dead-time of the experiments. The kinetics of folding to the native state are closely similar to those observed by stopped-flow fluorescence and near-UV circular dichroism. The NMR spectrum of the transient intermediate resembles closely that of the well characterized stable molten globule state formed at low pH. The results suggest that NMR can play a key role in describing at an atomic level the structural transitions occurring during protein folding.