Search

We propose a semiconductor-superconductor hybrid device for realizing topological superconductivity and Majorana zero modes consisting of a planar Josephson junction structure with periodically modulated junction width. By performing a numerical analysis of the effective model describing the low-energy physics of the hybrid structure, we demonstrate that the modulation of the junction width results in a substantial enhancement of the topological gap and, consequently, of the robustness of the topological superconducting phase and associated Majorana zero modes. This enhancement is due to the formation of minibands with strongly renormalized effective parameters, including stronger spin-orbit coupling, generated by the effective periodic potential induced by the modulated structure. In addition to a larger topological gap, the proposed device supports a topological superconducting phase that covers a significant fraction of the parameter space, including the low Zeeman field regime, in the absence of a superconducting phase difference across the junction. Furthermore, the optimal regime for operating the device can be conveniently accessed by tuning the potential in the junction region using, for example, a top gate., 17 pages, 17 figures

The recent experimental observations of decaying energy oscillations with increasing magnetic field in semiconductor-superconductor Majorana nanowires is in contrast with the theoretical expectations based on the presence of Majorana zero modes localized at the ends of the system. These observations have been recently theoretically justified by considering a position-dependent spin-orbit coupling that can emerge due to a tunnel gate. Here, we show that the window in parameter space where this phenomenology occurs is vanishingly small when compared to the parameter region where Majorana oscillations should increase in amplitude with the applied magnetic field. Further, including a position-dependent effective potential that is also induced due to a tunnel gate practically removes this small window. Using extensive numerical calculations, we show that, as expected, increasing amplitude oscillations of the hybridization energy represent a generic property of topological Majorana zero modes, while decreasing amplitude oscillations are a generic property of low-energy trivial Andreev bound states, recently called partially separated Andreev bound states. By averaging over several realistic parameter configurations, we identify robust features of the hybridization energy that can be observed in a typical differential conductance experiment without fine-tuning the control parameters.

We study one dimensional (1D) and quasi-1D periodic structures as possible platforms for the emergence of Majorana bound states with enhanced robustness against disorder and system inhomogeneity. First, using a simple 1D model, we analytically derive the effective parameters characterizing the minibands generated by the periodic potential. We show that, for strong enough periodic potentials, the higher energy minibands hosting Majorana bound states have significant advantages compared to their counterparts in uniform systems, including increased topological gaps, enhanced robustness against disorder, and enlarged parameter space regions consistent with the presence of topological superconductivity. We identify the problem of engineering a strong enough periodic potential as a key roadblock to realizing efficient periodic 1D structures. To address this challenge, we propose an efficient implementation of the periodic potential based on quasi-1D channels realized in 2D semiconductor heterostructures proximity coupled to superconductor strips of periodically modulated width. Our numerical study of the modulated channel device shows excellent agreement with the simple 1D model, reveals a topological phase diagram that is quite insensitive to the details of the confining potential associated with screening by the superconductor, and demonstrates that engineering patterned 2D structures represents a powerful and versatile approach to realizing robust Majorana bound states., 18 pages, 16 figures

Subband occupancy (i.e. the number of occupied subbands or energy levels in the semiconductor) is a key physical parameter characterizing the topological properties of superconductor-semiconductor hybrid systems in the context of the search for non-Abelian Majorana zero modes. We theoretically study the subband occupation of semiconductor nanowire devices as function of the applied gate potential, the semiconductor-superconductor (SM-SC) work function difference, and the surface charge density by solving self-consistently the Schr\"{o}dinger-Poisson equations for the conduction electrons of the semiconductor nanowire. Realistic surface charge densities, which are responsible for band bending, are shown to significantly increase the number of occupied subbands, making it difficult or impossible to reach a regime where only a few subbands are occupied. We also show that the energy separation between subbands is significantly reduced in the regime of many occupied subbands, with highly detrimental consequences for the realization and observation of robust Majorana zero modes. As a consequence, the requirements for the realization of robust topological superconductivity and Majorana zero modes should include a low value of the chemical potential, consistent with the occupation of only a few subbands. Finally, we show that the local density of states on the exposed nanowire facets provides a powerful tool for identifying a regime with many occupied subbands and is capable of providing additional critical information regarding the feasibility of Majorana physics in semiconductor-superconductor devices. In our work, we address both InAs/Al and InSb/Al superconductor-nanowire hybrid systems of current experimental interest., Comment: 11 pages, 8 figures

Evidence for propagating Majorana quasiparticles is found in a topological superconductor

We discuss the feasibility of measurement-based braiding in semiconductor-superconductor (SM-SC) heterostructures in the so-called quasi-Majorana regime $-$ the topologically-trivial regime due to partially-separated Andreev bound states (ps-ABSs). These low energy ABSs consist of component Majorana bound states (quasi-Majorana modes) that are spatially separated by a length scale smaller than the length of the system, in contrast with the Majorana zero modes (MZMs), which are separated by the length of the wire. In the quasi-Majorana regime, the ZBCPs appear to be robust to various perturbations as long as the energy splitting of the ps-ABS is less than the typical width $\e_w$ of the low-energy conductance peaks $\e_w$. However, the feasibility of measurement-based braiding depends on a different energy scale $\e_m$. In this paper we show that it is possible to prepare the SM-SC system in the quasi-Majorana regime with energy splittings below the $\e_m$ threshold, so that measurement-based braiding is possible in principle. Starting with ps-ABSs with energy below $\e_m$, we identify the maximum amplitudes of different types of perturbations that are consistent with perturbation-induced energy splittings not exceeding the $\e_m$ limit. We argue that measurements generating perturbations larger than the threshold amplitudes appropriate for $\e_m$ cannot realize measurement-based braiding in SM-SC heterostructures in the quasi-Majorana regime. We find that, if possible at all, quantum computation using measurement-based braiding in the quasi-Majorana regime would be plagued with errors introduced by the measurement processes themselves, while such errors are significantly less likely in a scheme involving topological MZMs., Comment: 18 pages, 17 figures

We solve analytically the problem of a finite-length Kitaev chain coupled to a quantum dot (QD) which extends the standard Kitaev chain problem to the quantum dot-semiconductor-superconductor (QD-SM-SC) nanowire heterostructure currently under intense investigation for possible occurrence of Majorana zero modes (MZMs). As a first step we obtain the analytical solution of the finite-length Kitaev chain without the quantum dot which to the best of our knowledge has also not appeared before. Our full solution of the Kitaev chain coupled to a quantum dot reveals the emergence of a robust near-zero-energy Andreev bound state (ABSs) localized in the quantum dot region as the generic lowest energy solution in the topologically trivial phase. By contrast in the Kitaev chain without the quantum dot such a solution does not exist. The robustness of the ABS in the topologically trivial phase is due to a partial spatial decoupling of the component Majorana bound states (MBSs) over the length of the dot potential. As a result the signatures of the ABS in measurements that couple locally to the quantum dot e.g. tunneling measurements are identical to the signatures of topologically protected MZMs which arise only in the topological superconducting (TS) phase of the Kitaev chain.

Recent tunneling conductance measurements of Majorana nanowires show a strong variation in the magnetic field dependence of the superconducting gap among different devices. Here, we theoretically study the magnetic field dependence of the gap closing feature and establish that the degree of convexity (or concavity) of the gap closing as a function of Zeeman field can provide critical constraints on the underlying microscopic parameters of the semiconductor-superconductor hybrid system model. Specifically, we show that the gap closing feature is entirely concave only for strong spin-orbit coupling strength relative to the chemical potential. Additionally, the non-linearity (i.e. concavity or convexity) of the gap closing as a function of magnetic field complicates the simple assignment of a constant effective $ g $-factor to the states in the Majorana nanowire. We develop a procedure to estimate the effective $ g $-factor from recent experimental data that accounts for the non-linear gap closing resulting from the interplay between chemical potential and spin-orbit coupling. Thus, measurements of the magnetic field dependence of the gap closure on the trivial side of the topological quantum phase transition can provide useful information on parameters that are critical to the theoretical modeling of Majorana nanowires., Comment: 12 pages, 5 figures

Higher order topological superconductors hosting Majorana-Kramers pairs (MKPs) as corner modes have recently been proposed in a two-dimensional (2D) quantum spin Hall insulator (QSHI) proximity-coupled to unconventional cuprate or iron-based superconductors. Here, we show that such MKPs can be realized using a conventional s-wave superfluid with a soliton in cold atom systems governed by the Hubbard-Hofstadter model. The MKPs emerge in the presence of interaction at the "corners" defined by the intersections of line solitons and the one-dimensional edges of the system. Our scheme is based on the recently realized cold atom Hubbard-Hofstadter lattice and will pave the way for observing Majorana corner modes and possible higher order topological superfluidity with conventional s-wave superfluids/superconductors., Comment: 5+ pages and 4 figures; Version accepted for publication in PRL

Recent tunneling conductance measurements on semiconductor-superconductor nanowires find zero-bias peaks to be ubiquitous across wide ranges of chemical potential and Zeeman energy. Motivated by this, we demonstrate that topologically-trivial Andreev abound states (ABSs) pinned near zero energy are produced rather generically in inhomogeneous systems with multi-band occupancy in the presence of inter-band coupling. We first investigate the inter-band coupling mechanism responsible for the pinning within a multi-band 1D toy model, then we confirm the findings using a 3D Schr\"{o}dinger-Poisson approach that incorporates the geometric and electrostatic details of the actual device. Our analysis shows that level-repulsion generated by inter-band coupling can lead to a rather spectacular pinning of the lowest-energy mode near zero energy in systems (or regions) characterized by very-short length scales ($\sim100~$nm).We show that level repulsion between the lowest energy levels can mimic the gap opening feature (simultaneous with the emergence of a near-zero energy mode) predicted to occur in Majorana hybrid systems. We also demonstrate that nearly-zero bias differential conductance features exhibiting particle-hole asymmetry are due to the presence of (topologically-trivial) ABSs pinned near zero-energy by level repulsion, not to Majorana zero modes, quasi-Majoranas, or any other low-energy mode that involves (partially) separated Majorana bound states. Our findings demonstrate the importance of understanding in detail multi-band physics and electrostatic effects in the context of the ongoing search for Majorana modes in semiconductor-superconductor heterostructures., Comment: 16 pages, 14 figures

In a recent high-quality experimental work on normal metal--superconducting nanowire junctions arXiv:1807.01940 (2018), strong anisotropic suppression of induced superconductivity has been observed in tunnel conductance measurements in the presence of applied magnetic field with variable orientation. Following this finding, we investigate theoretically the dependence of tunnel conductance on the direction of the Zeeman field in order to understand the operational mechanisms and to extract effective system parameters. Second, motivated by a generic discrepancy between experiment and theory, i.e., many in-gap and above-gap conductance features predicted by theory are barely observed in experiments, we study several mechanisms possibly responsible for the suppression of the theoretically predicted conductance features (e.g., length of the nanowire, self-energy effect due to the proximity effect, finite temperature, finite dissipation, and multiband effect). One essential finding in the current work is that only by a combined understanding of both suppression mechanisms can we extract effective system parameters from the experimental data (e.g., the effective nanowire-superconductor coupling, the effective Land\'e $g$ factor, and the chemical potential of the semiconducting nanowire). In addition, we consider topologically trivial Andreev bound states in hybrid nanowires in the presence of potential inhomogeneities, such as external quantum dots or potential inhomogeneities inside the nanowire. We compare the anisotropic, field-dependent features induced by these nontopological Andreev bound states with the corresponding features produced by topological Majorana zero modes in pristine nanostructures, so that we can provide guidance to differentiate between the topologically trivial and nontrivial cases., Comment: 19 pages, 15 figures

We perform tunneling measurements on indium antimonide nanowire/superconductor hybrid devices fabricated for the studies of Majorana bound states. At finite magnetic field, resonances that strongly resemble Majorana bound states, including zero-bias pinning, become common to the point of ubiquity. Since Majorana bound states are predicted in only a limited parameter range in nanowire devices, we seek an alternative explanation for the observed zero-bias peaks. With the help of a self-consistent Poission-Schr\"odinger multiband model developed in parallel, we identify several families of trivial subgap states which overlap and interact, giving rise to a crowded spectrum near zero energy and zero-bias conductance peaks in experiments. These findings advance the search for Majorana bound states through improved understanding of broader phenomena found in superconductor-semiconductor systems., Comment: 14 pages, 4 figures in main text and 8 figures in supplemental materials. All raw data can be found under directory \anc

We study the electronic structure of full-shell superconductor-semiconductor nanowires, which have recently been proposed for creating Majorana zero modes, using an eight-band $\vec{k} \cdot \vec{p}$ model within a fully self-consistent Schr\"{o}dinger-Poisson scheme. We find that the spin-orbit coupling induced by the intrinsic radial electric field is generically weak for sub-bands with their minimum near the Fermi energy. Furthermore, we show that the chemical potential windows consistent with the emergence of a topological phase are small and sparse and can only be reached by fine tunning the diameter of the wire. These findings suggest that the parameter space consistent with the realization of a topological phase in full-shell InAs/Al nanowires is, at best, very narrow., Comment: 5 pages, 4 figures + Supplemental Material

We theoretically study a spin-orbit-coupled nanowire proximitized by a superconductor in the presence of an externally applied Zeeman field ("Majorana nanowire") with zero-energy Majorana bound states localized at the two ends of the wire when the Zeeman spin splitting is large enough for the system to enter the topological phase. The specific physics of interest in the current work is the effect of having several tunnel probes attached to the wire along its length. Such tunnel probes should allow, as a matter of principle, one to observe both the predicted bulk superconducting gap closing and opening associated with the topological quantum phase transition as well as the Majorana bound states at the wire ends showing up as zero-bias conductance peaks, depending on which probes are used for the tunneling spectroscopy measurement. Because of the possible invasive nature of the tunnel probes, producing local potential fluctuations in the nanowire, we find the physical situation to be quite complex. In particular, depending on the details of the tunnel barrier operational at the probes, the Majorana nanowire could manifest additional low-energy Andreev bound states which will manifest their own almost-zero-bias peaks, complicating the interpretation of the tunneling data in multiprobe Majorana nanowires. We use two complementary microscopic models to simulate the probes, finding that the tunneling conductance spectrum depends rather sensitively on the details of the tunnel barriers at the probes. We apply our general analysis to simulate a recent multiprobe nanowire experiment commenting on the nature of the quasiparticle gaps likely controlling the experimental observations., 11 pages, 8 figures, published version

We show that partially separated Andreev bound states (ps-ABSs), comprised of pairs of overlapping Majorana bound states (MBSs) emerging in quantum dot-semiconductor-superconductor heterostructures, produce robust zero bias conductance plateaus in end-of-wire charge tunneling experiments. These plateaus remain quantized at $2e^2/h$ over large ranges of experimental control parameters. In light of recent experiments reporting the observation of robust $2e^2/h$-quantized conductance plateaus in local charge tunneling experiments, we perform extensive numerical calculations to explicitly show that such quantized conductance plateaus, which are obtained by varying control parameters such as the tunnel barrier height, the super gate potential, and the applied magnetic field, can arise as a result of the existence of ps-ABSs. Because ps-ABSs can form rather generically in the topologically trivial regime, even in the absence of disorder, our results suggest that the observation of a robust quantized conductance plateau does not represent sufficient evidence to demonstrate the existence of non-Abelian topologically-protected Majorana zero modes localized at the opposite ends of a wire., Comment: 8 pages, 8 figures

We show theoretically that in the generic finite chemical potential situation, the clean superconducting spin-orbit-coupled nanowire has two distinct nontopological regimes as a function of Zeeman splitting (below the topological quantum phase transition): one is characterized by finite-energy in-gap Andreev bound states, while the other has only extended bulk states. The Andreev bound state regime is characterized by strong features in the tunneling spectra creating a "gap closure" signature, but no "gap reopening" signature should be apparent above the topological quantum phase transition, in agreement with most recent experimental observations. The gap closure feature is actually the coming together of the Andreev bound states at high chemical potential rather than a simple trivial gap of extended bulk states closing at the transition. Our theoretical finding establishes the generic intrinsic Andreev bound states on the trivial side of the topological quantum phase transition as the main contributors to the tunneling conductance spectra, providing a generic interpretation of existing experiments in clean Majorana nanowires. Our work also explains why experimental tunnel conductance spectra generically have gap closing features below the topological quantum phase transition, but no gap opening features above it., 28 pages, 29 figures, accepted version

We propose a method for solving the Schrodinger-Poisson problem that can be efficiently implemented in realistic 3D tight-binding models of semiconductor-based Majorana devices. The method is based on two key ideas: i) For a given geometry, the Poisson problem is only solved once (for each local orbital) and the results are stored as an interaction tensor; using this Green's function scheme, the Poisson component of the iteration procedure is reduced to a few simple summations. ii) The 3D problem is mapped into an effective multi-orbital 1D problem with molecular orbitals calculated self-consistently as the transverse modes of an infinite wire with the same electrostatic potential as the local electrostatic potential of the finite 3D device. To demonstrate the capabilities of our approach, we calculate the response of the system to an external magnetic field, the dependence of the effective chemical potential on the work function difference, and the dependence of the effective semiconductor-superconductor coupling on the applied gate potential. We find that different low-energy bands are characterized by similar effective couplings, which results in induced gap features characterized by a single energy scale. We also find that electrostatic effects are responsible for a partial suppression of the Majorana energy splitting oscillations. Finally, we show that a position-dependent work function difference can produce a non-homogeneous effective potential that is not affected by the screening due to the superconductor and is only partially suppressed by the charge inside the wire. In turn, this potential can induce trivial low-energy states that mimic the phenomenology of Majorana zero modes. Thus, any position-dependent work function difference (even at the 1% level) along the nanowire must be avoided through carefully engineered semiconductor-superconductor interfaces., 28 pages, 25 figures

Robust topologically trivial low-energy Andreev bound states (ABSs) induced by position-dependent effective potentials have recently come under renewed focus, in light of a remarkable set of experiments observing robust quantized zero-bias conductance plateaus in semiconductor-superconductor heterostructures. We show that (1) the partial spatial separation of the wave functions of the component Majorana bound states (MBSs) is crucial for the creation and stability of topologically trivial near-zero-energy Andreev bound states, (2) the signs of the spin polarizations of the component MBSs can be either the same or opposite, depending on the profile of the inducing potential, and (3) the spin polarizations do not play a fundamental role in generating vastly different coupling strengths to local probes and/or ensuring the robustness of the near-zero-energy ABS. Consequently, in contrast to recent theoretical claims (Vuik et al., arXiv:1806.02801), we find that a robust, quantized zero-bias conductance plateau of height 2e^2/h measured in the topologically trivial regime necessarily requires partially separated ABSs (ps-ABSs), independent of the relative signs of the spin-polarizations. In addition, we show that (4) well-defined energy splitting oscillations involve MBSs characterized by exponential tails pointing toward each other, and (5) ps-ABSs generated by the tunnel barrier itself produce zero-bias conductance peaks with a characteristic width that increases strongly with the applied magnetic field. Finally, we propose (6) a quantitative scheme for analyzing the stability of Majorana modes based on probability distributions of splitting susceptibilities and show that a ps-ABS mode can be remarkably robust when judged based on its signature in a charge tunneling experiment, but, in essence, is topologically unprotected., Comment: 23 pages, 30 figures

We study the low-energy physics of a one-dimensional array of superconducting quantum dots realized by proximity coupling a semiconductor nanowire to multiple superconducting islands separated by narrow uncovered regions. The effective electrostatic potential inside the quantum dots and the uncovered regions can be controlled using potential gates. By performing detailed numerical calculations based on effective tightbinding models, we find that multiple low-energy sub-gap states consisting of partially overlapping Majorana bound states emerge generically in the vicinity of the uncovered regions. Explicit differential conductance calculations show that a robust zero-bias conductance peak is not inconsistent with the presence of such states localized throughout the system, hence the observation of such a peak does not demonstrate the realization of well-separated Majorana zero modes. However, we find that creating effective potential wells in the uncovered regions traps pairs of nearby partially overlapping Majorana bound states, which become less separated and acquire a finite gap that protects the pair of Majorana zero modes localized at the ends of the system. This behavior persists over a significant parameter range, suggesting that proximitized quantum dot arrays could provide a platform for highly controllable Majorana devices., Comment: 14 pages, 14 figures

We show that a pair of overlapping Majorana bound states (MBSs) forming a partially-separated Andreev bound state (ps-ABS) represents a generic low-energy feature in spin-orbit coupled semiconductor-superconductor (SM-SC) hybrid nanowires in the presence of a Zeeman field. In a finite nanowire the ps-ABS interpolates continuously between the "garden variety" ABS, which consists of two MBSs sitting on top of each other, and the topologically protected Majorana zero modes (MZMs), which are separated by a distance given by the length of the wire. Despite being topologically trivial, ps-ABSs can generate signatures identical to MZMs in local charge tunneling experiments. In particular, the height of the zero bias conductance peak (ZBCP) generated by ps-ABSs has the quantized value, 2e2/h, and it can remain unchanged in an extended range of experimental parameters, such as Zeeman field and the tunnel barrier height. We illustrate the formation of such low-energy robust ps-ABSs in two experimentally relevant situations: a hybrid SM-SC system consisting of a proximitized nanowire coupled to a quantum dot and the SM-SC system in the presence of a spatially varying inhomogeneous potential. We then show that, unlike local measurements, a two-terminal experiment involving charge tunneling at both ends of the wire is capable of distinguishing the non-Abelian MZMs from the generic ps-ABSs. While the MZMs localized at the opposite ends of the wire generate correlated differential conduction spectra, including correlations in energy splittings and critical Zeeman fields associated with the emergence of the ZBCPs, such correlations are absent if the ZBCPs are due to ps-ABSs emerging in the topologically trivial phase. Measuring such correlations is the clearest and most straightforward test of topological MZMs in SM-SC heterostructures that can be done in a currently accessible experimental set-up., Version accepted in Phys. Rev. B; 15 pages, 14 figures; Contains the material presented in arXiv:1611.07058, but has substantial new results for quantum dot-nanowire-SC heterostructures

Topological quantum computation using non-Abelian Majorana zero modes localized in proximitized semiconductor nanowires requires careful electrostatic control of wire-junctions so as to manipulate and braid the zero modes enabling anyonic fault-tolerant gate operations. We theoretically investigate the topological superconducting properties of such elementary wire-junctions, the so-called T junctions, finding that the existence of the junction may nonperturbatively affect the Majorana behavior by introducing spurious non-topological subgap states mimicking zero-modes. We propose a possible solution to this potentially serious problem by showing that junctions made lithographically from two-dimensional (2D) electron gas systems may manifest robust subgap topological properties without any spurious zero modes. We propose a 2D structure that enables multiprobe tunneling experiments providing position-dependent spectroscopy, which can decisively settle outstanding open questions related to the origin of the zero-bias conductance peaks observed experimentally. We also find that junctions with trivial superconductors may result in local perturbations that induce extrinsic low-energy states similar to those associated with wire junctions., Published version, 8 pages, 9 figures

Map to Majorana fermions in nanowires is revealed., Topological superconductivity is an exotic state of matter characterized by spinless p-wave Cooper pairing of electrons and by Majorana zero modes at the edges. The first signature of topological superconductivity is a robust zero-bias peak in tunneling conductance. We perform tunneling experiments on semiconductor nanowires (InSb) coupled to superconductors (NbTiN) and establish the zero-bias peak phase in the space of gate voltage and external magnetic field. Our findings are consistent with calculations for a finite-length topological nanowire and provide means for Majorana manipulation as required for braiding and topological quantum bits.

Motivated by an important recent experiment [Deng et al., Science 354, 1557 (2016)], we theoretically consider the interplay between Andreev bound states(ABSs) and Majorana bound states(MBSs) in quantum dot-nanowire semiconductor systems with proximity-induced superconductivity(SC), spin-orbit coupling and Zeeman splitting. The dot induces ABSs in the SC nanowire which show complex behavior as a function of Zeeman splitting and chemical potential, and the specific question is whether two such ABSs can come together forming a topological MBS. We consider physical situations involving the dot being non-SC, SC, or partially SC. We find that the ABSs indeed tend to coalesce together producing near-zero-energy midgap states as Zeeman splitting and/or chemical potential are increased, but this mostly happens in the non-topological regime although there are situations where the ABSs could come together forming a topological MBS. The two scenarios(two ABSs forming a near-zero-energy non-topological ABS or a zero-energy topological MBS) are difficult to distinguish by tunneling conductance spectroscopy due to essentially the same signatures. Theoretically we distinguish them by knowing the critical Zeeman splitting for the topological quantum phase transition or by calculating the topological visibility. We find that the "sticking together" propensity of ABSs to produce a zero-energy midgap state is generic in class D systems, and by itself says nothing about the topological nature of the underlying SC nanowire. One must use caution in interpreting tunneling conductance measurements where the midgap sticking-together behavior of ABSs cannot be construed as definitive evidence for topological SC with non-Abelian MBSs. We also suggest some experimental techniques for distinguishing between trivial and topological ZBCPs., 32 pages, 29 figures

We consider core-shell nanowires with conductive shell and insulating core and with polygonal cross section. We investigate the implications of this geometry on Majorana states expected in the presence of proximity-induced superconductivity and an external magnetic field. A typical prismatic nanowire has a hexagonal profile, but square and triangular shapes can also be obtained. The low-energy states are localized at the corners of the cross section, i.e., along the prism edges, and are separated by a gap from higher energy states localized on the sides. The corner localization depends on the details of the shell geometry, i.e., thickness, diameter, and sharpness of the corners. We study systematically the low-energy spectrum of prismatic shells using numerical methods and derive the topological phase diagram as a function of magnetic field and chemical potential for triangular, square, and hexagonal geometries. A strong corner localization enhances the stability of Majorana modes to various perturbations, including the orbital effect of the magnetic field, whereas a weaker localization favorizes orbital effects and reduces the critical magnetic field. The prismatic geometry allows the Majorana zero-energy modes to be accompanied by low-energy states, which we call pseudo Majorana, and which converge to real Majoranas in the limit of small shell thickness. We include the Rashba spin-orbit coupling in a phenomenological manner, assuming a radial electric field across the shell., This work was partially financed by Reykjavik University and the Icelandic Research Fund. L.S. was supported by Grant No. FIS2014-52564 (Mineco, Spain). T.D.S. was supported in part by NSF DMR-1414683.

A minimal model for the hybrid superconductor-semiconductor nanowire Majorana platform is developed that fully captures the effects of the low-energy renormalization of the nanowire modes arising from the presence of the parent superconductor. In this model, the parent superconductor is an active component that participates explicitly in the low-energy physics, not just a passive partner that only provides proximity-induced Cooper pairs for the nanowire. This treatment on an equal footing of the superconductor and the semiconductor has become necessary in view of recent experiments, which do not allow a consistent interpretation based just on the bare semiconductor properties. The general theory involves the evaluation of the exact semiconductor Green function that includes a dynamical self-energy correction arising from the tunnel-coupled superconductor. General conditions for the emergence of topological superconductivity are worked out for single-band as well as multi-band nanowires and detailed numerical results are given for both infinite and finite wire cases. The topological quantum phase diagrams are provided numerically and the Majorana bound states are obtained along with their oscillatory energy splitting behaviors due to wavefunction overlap in finite wires. Renormalization effects are shown to be both qualitatively and quantitatively important in modifying the low-energy spectrum of the nanowire. The results of the theory are found to be in good qualitative agreement with Majorana nanowire experiments, leading to the conclusion that the proximity-induced low-energy renormalization of the nanowire modes by the parent superconductor is of fundamental importance in superconductor-semiconductor hybrid structures. Implications of the general theory for obtaining true zero energy topological Majorana modes are pointed out., 19 pages, 16 figures

With the recent achievement of extremely high-quality epitaxial interfaces between InAs nanowires and superconducting Al shells with strong superconductor-semiconductor tunnel coupling, a new regime of proximity-induced superconductivity in semiconductors can be explored where the induced gap may be similar in value to the bulk Al gap (large gap) with negligible subgap conductance (hard gap). We propose several experimentally relevant consequences of this large-gap strong-coupling regime for tunneling experiments, and we comment on the prospects of this regime for topological superconductivity. In particular, we show that the advantages of having a strong spin-orbit coupling and a large spin g-factor in the semiconductor nanowire may both be compromised in this strongly coupled limit, and somewhat weaker interface tunneling may be necessary for achieving optimal proximity superconductivity in the semiconductor nanowire. We derive a minimal, generic theory for the strong-coupling hard-gap regime obtaining good qualitative agreement with the experiment and pointing out future directions for further progress toward Majorana nanowires in hybrid semiconductor-superconductor structures., Comment: 8 pages, 5 figures; published version

Multiple zero-energy Majorana fermions (MFs) with spatially overlapping wave functions can survive only if their splitting is prevented by an underlying symmetry. Here we show that, in quasi-one-dimensional (Q1D) time reversal invariant topological superconductors (class DIII), a realistic model for superconducting lithium molybdenum purple bronze and certain families of organic superconductors, multiple Majorana-Kramers pairs with strongly overlapping wave functions persist at zero energy even in the absence of an easily identifiable symmetry. We find that similar results hold in the case of Q1D semiconductor-superconductor heterostructures (class D) with transverse hopping t_{perp} much smaller than longitudinal hopping t_x. Our results, explained in terms of special properties of the Hamiltonian and wave functions, underscore the importance of hidden accidental symmetries in topological superconductors.

Three-dimensional antiferromagnets with random magnetic anisotropy (RMA) that have been experimentally studied to date have competing two-dimensional and three-dimensional exchange interactions which can obscure the authentic effects of RMA. The magnetic phase diagram of Fe_{x}Ni_{1-x}F_{2} epitaxial thin films with true random single-ion anisotropy was deduced from magnetometry and neutron scattering measurements and analyzed using mean-field theory. Regions with uniaxial, oblique, and easy-plane anisotropies were identified. A RMA-induced glass region was discovered where a Griffiths-like breakdown of long-range spin order occurs.

We investigate the properties of a strongly correlated electron system in the proximity of a Mott insulating phase within the Hubbard model, using a cluster generalization of the dynamical mean field theory. We find that Mottness is intimately connected with the existence in momentum space of a surface of zeros of the single particle Green’s function. The opening of a Mott–Hubbard gap at half filling and the opening of a pseudogap at finite doping are necessary elements for the existence of this surface. At the same time, the Fermi surface may change topology or even disappear. Within this framework, we provide a simple picture for the appearance of Fermi arcs. We identify the strong short-range correlations as the source of these phenomena and we identify the cumulant as the natural irreducible quantity capable of describing this short-range physics. We develop a new version of the cellular dynamical mean field theory based on cumulants that provides the tools for a unified treatment of general lattice Hamiltonians.

Charge currents in thin films of Bi 2 Se 3 are controlled using a two-color scheme that exploits quantum interference of single- and two-photon absorption pathways. Injection and shift currents are observed and linked to surface state excitations.

We develop a theory for the proximity effect in superconductor-semiconductor-normal metal tunneling structures, which have recently been extensively studied experimentally, leading to the observation of transport signatures consistent with the predicted zero-energy Majorana bound states. We show that our model for the semiconductor nanowire having multiple occupied subbands with different transmission probabilities through the barrier reproduces the observed "soft-gap" behavior associated with substantial subgap tunneling conductance. We study the manifestations of the soft gap phenomenon both in the tunneling conductance and in local density of states measurements and discuss the correlations between these two quantities. We emphasize that the proximity effect associated with the hybridization between low-lying states in the multiband semiconductor and the normal metal states in the lead is an intrinsic effect leading to the soft gap problem. In addition to the intrinsic contribution, there may be extrinsic effects, such as, for example, interface disorder, exacerbating the soft gap problem. Our work establishes the generic possibility of an ubiquitous presence of an intrinsic soft gap in the superconductor-semiconductor-normal metal tunneling transport conductance induced by the inverse proximity effect of the normal metal., Comment: published version, 11+ pages, 8 figures

We study the low-energy physics of topological insulator (TI) nanoribbons proximity-coupled to s-wave superconductors (SCs) by explicitly incorporating the proximity effects that emerge at the TI-SC interface. We construct a low-energy effective theory that incorporates the proximity effect through an interface contribution containing both normal and anomalous terms and an energy-renormalization matrix. We show that the strength of the proximity-induced gap is determined by the transparency of the interface and the amplitude of the low-energy TI states at the interface. Consequently, the induced gap is strongly band-dependent and collapses for bands containing states with low amplitude at the interface. We find that states with energies within the bulk TI gap have surface-type character and, in the presence of proximity-induced or applied bias potentials, have most of their weight near either the top or the bottom surface of the nanoribbon. As a result, single interface TI-SC structures are susceptible to experiencing a collapse of the induced gap whenever the chemical potential is far enough from the value corresponding to the bulk TI Dirac point and crosses weakly coupled bands. We also find that changing the chemical potential in single-interface structures using gate potentials may be ineffective, as it does not result in a significant increase of the induced gap. On the other hand, we find that symmetric structures, such as a TI nanowire sandwiched between two superconductors, are capable of realizing the full potential of TI-based structures to harbor robust topological superconducting phases., published version, 15+ pages, 16 figures

We show that the topologically trivial zero bias peak (ZBP) emerging in semiconductor Majorana wires due to soft confinement exhibits correlated splitting oscillations as a function of the applied Zeeman field, similar to the correlated splitting of the Majorana ZBP. Also, we find that the presence of a strong impurity can effectively cut the wire in two and destroy the correlated splitting in both the trivial and the Majorana regimes. We identify a strong nonlocal effect that operates only in the topologically trivial regime and demonstrate that the dependence of the ZBP on the confining gate potential at the opposite end in Majorana wires with two normal metal end-contacts represents a powerful tool for discriminating between topologically trivial and nontrivial ZBPs., Comment: published version, 4+ pages, 4 figures

We report on a strong coupling approach (on-site Coulomb repulsion, U larger than the nearest-neighbour hopping energy |t|) to the Hubbard model. Starting from the Hubbard operators which diagonalize the interaction term, we generate a hierarchy of composite operators from the equations of motion. Using the Hubbard operators as a basis, we are able to compute the associated Green functions including the anomalous Green functions which describe pair formation. We show explicitly that these anomalous Green functions are non-zero in the d_{x^2-y^2} channel; however, the entities that pair up are not single electron-like particles but rather composite excitations (which we call cexons) made out of an electron and a hole on nearest-neighbour sites. Cexons are fermionic in nature as they have spin 1/2 and also have unit charge. Our calculations of the chemical potential reveal that negative compressibility in the 2D Hubbard model and composite excitation pairing are intimately connected, namely, the larger the negative compressibility, the larger the pairing amplitude. Our observation of negative compressibility in the under-doped regime is consistent with phase segregation or stripe formation in the normal state. While pairing ameliorates the negative compresssibility, it does not eliminate it entirely. In addition, we find that the anomalous correlation functions are particle-hole symmetric and exhibit a maximum at a doping level of roughly 10% as measured from half-filling. For U=8|t|, the onset temperature for pair formation is 0.02|t|.

The stability of the Majorana modes in the presence of a repulsive interaction is studied in the standard semiconductor wire - metallic superconductor configuration. The effects of short-range Coulomb interaction, which is incorporated using a purely repulsive $\delta$-function to model the strong screening effect due to the presence of the superconductor, are determined within a Hartree-Fock approximation of the effective Bogoliubov-De Gennes Hamiltonian that describes the low-energy physics of the wire. Through a numerical diagonalization procedure we obtain interaction corrections to the single particle eigenstates and calculate the extended topological phase diagram in terms of the chemical potential and the Zeeman energy. We find that, for a fixed Zeeman energy, the interaction shifts the phase boundaries to a higher chemical potential, whereas for a fixed chemical potential this shift can occur either to lower or to higher Zeeman energies. This effects can be interpreted as a renormalization of the g-factor due to the interaction. The minimum Zeeman energy needed to realize Majorana fermions decreases with increasing the strength of the Coulomb repulsion. Furthermore, we find that in wires with multi-band occupancy this effect can be enhanced by increasing the chemical potential, i. e. by occupying higher energy bands., Comment: 18 pages, 7 figures

After a recent series of rapid and exciting developments, the long search for the Majorana fermion - the elusive quantum entity at the border between particles and antiparticles - has produced the first positive experimental results, but is not over yet. Originally proposed by E. Majorana in the context of particle physics, Majorana fermions have a condensed matter analog in the zero-energy bound states emerging in topological superconductors. A promising route to engineering topological superconductors capable of hosting Majorana zero modes consists of proximity coupling semiconductor thin films or nanowires with strong spin-orbit interaction to conventional s-wave superconductors in the presence of an external Zeeman field. The Majorana zero mode is predicted to emerge above a certain critical Zeeman field as a zero-energy state localized near the order parameter defects, viz., vortices for thin films and wire-ends for the nanowire. These Majorana bound states are expected to manifest non--Abelian quantum statistics, which makes them ideal building blocks for fault--tolerant topological quantum computation. This review provides an update on current status of the search for Majorana fermions in semiconductor nanowires by focusing on the recent developments, in particular the period following the first reports of experimental signatures consistent with the realization of Majorana bound states in semiconductor nanowire--superconductor hybrid structures. We start with a discussion of the fundamental aspects of the subject, followed by considerations on the realistic modeling which is a critical bridge between theoretical predictions based on idealized conditions and the real world, as probed experimentally. The last part is dedicated to a few intriguing issues that were brought to the fore by the recent encouraging experimental advances., Invited topical review paper. Published version, 29 pages, 20 figures

Majorana fermions (MFs) are predicted to occur as zero-energy bound states in semiconductor nanowire-superconductor structures. However, in the presence of disorder or smooth confining potentials, these structures can also host non-topological nearly-zero energy states. Here, we demonstrate that the MFs and the nearly-zero topologically-trivial states have different characteristic signatures in a tunneling conductance measurement, which allows to clearly discriminate between them. We also show that low-energy non-topological states can strongly hybridize with metallic states from the leads, which generates the smooth background that characterizes the soft superconducting gap measured in tunneling experiments and produces an additional decoherence mechanism for the Majorana mode. Our results pave the way for the conclusive identification of MFs in a solid state system and provide directions for minimizing quantum decoherence in Majorana wires.

We theoretically consider the proximity effect in semiconductor-superconductor hybrid nanostructures, which are being extensively studied in the context of the ongoing search for non-Abelian Majorana fermions in solid state systems. Specifically, we consider the dependence on the thickness of the semiconductor in the direction normal to the interface, a physical effect that has been uncritically neglected in all prior work on the subject. Quite surprisingly, we find the completely unanticipated result that increasing the semiconductor thickness leads to a drastic suppression of the induced superconducting gap due to proximity-induced interband coupling. As a result, in the limit of strong semiconductor-superconductor coupling, the proximity-induced gap becomes much smaller than the bulk superconductor gap and depends weakly on the interface transparency., 4 pages, 4 figures

Recent observations of a zero-bias conductance peak in tunneling transport measurements in superconductor-semiconductor nanowire devices provide evidence for the predicted zero-energy Majorana modes, but not the conclusive proof of their existence. We establish that direct observation of a splitting of the zero-bias conductance peak can serve as the smoking gun evidence for the existence of the Majorana mode. We show that the splitting has an oscillatory dependence on the Zeeman field (chemical potential) at fixed chemical potential (Zeeman field). By contrast, when the density is constant rather than the chemical potential---the likely situation in the current experimental setups---the splitting oscillations are generically suppressed. Our theory predicts the conditions under which the splitting oscillations can serve as the smoking gun for the experimental confirmation of the elusive Majorana mode.

We investigate theoretically the low energy physics of semiconductor Majorana wires in the vicinity of a magnetic field-driven topological quantum phase transition (TQPT). The local density of states (LDOS) at the end of the wire, which is directly related to the differential conductance in the limit of point-contact tunneling, is calculated numerically. We find that the dependence of the end-of-wire LDOS on the magnetic field is non-universal and that the signatures associated with the closing of the superconducting gap at the Majorana TQPT are essentially invisible within a significant range of experimentally relevant parameters. Our results provide an explanation for the recent observation of the apparent non-closure of the gap at the Majorana TQPT in semiconductor nanowires., 4+ pages, 5 figures, 5 pages of supplementary material; PRL published version

The excitation gap above the Majorana fermion (MF) modes at the ends of 1D topological superconducting (TS) semiconductor wires scales with the bulk quasiparticle gap E_{qp}. This gap, also called minigap, facilitates experimental detection of the pristine TS state and MFs at experimentally accessible temperatures T << E_{qp}. Here we show that the linear scaling of minigap with E_{qp} can fail in quasi-1D wires with multiple confinement bands when the applied Zeeman field is greater than or equal to about half of the confinement-induced bandgap. TS states in such wires have an approximate chiral symmetry supporting multiple near zero energy modes at each end leading to a minigap which can effectively vanish. We show that the problem of small minigap in such wires can be resolved by forcing the system to break the approximate chirality symmetry externally with a second Zeeman field. Although experimental signatures such as zero bias peak from the wire ends is suppressed by the second Zeeman field above a critical value, such a field is required in some important parameter regimes of quasi-1D wires to isolate the topological physics of end state MFs. We also discuss the crucial difference of our minigap calculations from the previously reported minigap results appropriate for idealized spinless p-wave superconductors and explain why the clustering of fermionic subgap states around the zero energy Majorana end state with increasing chemical potential seen in the latter system does not apply to the experimental TS states in spin-orbit coupled nanowires., Crucial difference of the present results with previously reported results for idealized spinless p-wave wires discussed (see conclusion); new references added; Title changed in response to Editor comment; new version as accepted in PRB

The homogeneous-inhomogeneous transitions of a two-dimensional electron gas in a strong perpendicular magnetic field are studied in the particular case when half of the states in a spin splitted Landau level are occupied. To this end the dielectric susceptibility in the homogeneous states as well as the free energy in the modulated states are calculated. Unless theg factor dos not exceed a certain value the charge-density waves are stable in an interval of finite temperatures.

We study multiband semiconducting nanowires proximity-coupled with an s-wave superconductor and calculate the topological phase diagram as a function of the chemical potential and magnetic field. The non-trivial topological state corresponds to a superconducting phase supporting an odd number of pairs of Majorana modes localized at the ends of the wire, whereas the non-topological state corresponds to a superconducting phase with no Majoranas or with an even number of pairs of Majorana modes. Our key finding is that multiband occupancy not only lifts the stringent constraint of one-dimensionality, but also allows having higher carrier density in the nanowire. Consequently, multiband nanowires are better-suited for stabilizing the topological superconducting phase and for observing the Majorana physics. We present a detailed study of the parameter space for multiband semiconductor nanowires focusing on understanding the key experimental conditions required for the realization and detection of Majorana fermions in solid-state systems. We include various sources of disorder and characterize their effects on the stability of the topological phase. Finally, we calculate the local density of states as well as the differential tunneling conductance as functions of external parameters and predict the experimental signatures that would establish the existence of emergent Majorana zero-energy modes in solid-state systems., Comment: 29 pages, 30 figures

We study the superconducting proximity effect between a conventional semiconductor and a disordered s-wave superconductor. We calculate the effective momentum relaxation rate in the semiconductor due to processes involving electron tunneling into a disordered superconductor and scattering off impurities. The magnitude of the effective disorder scattering rate is important for understanding the stability of the topological (chiral p-wave) superconducting state that emerges in the semiconductor, since disorder scattering has a detrimental effect and can drive the system into a non-topological state. We find that the effective impurity scattering rate involves higher-order tunneling processes and is suppressed due to the destructive quantum interference of quasi-particle and quasi-hole trajectories. We show that, despite the fact that both the proximity-induced gap and the effective impurity scattering rate depend on interface transparency, there is a large parameter regime where the topological superconducting phase is robust against disorder in the superconductor. Thus, we establish that the static disorder in the superconductor does not suppress the proximity induced topological superconductivity in the semiconductor., Comment: 5 pages, 2 figures

Topologically non-trivial superconductivity has been predicted to occur in superconductors with a sizable spin-orbit coupling in the presence of an external Zeeman splitting. Two such systems have been proposed: (a) s-wave superconductor pair potential is proximity induced on a semiconductor, and (b) pair potential naturally arises from an intrinsic s-wave pairing interaction. As is now well known, such systems in the form of a 2D film or 1D nano-wires in a wire-network can be used for topological quantum computation. When the external Zeeman splitting $\Gamma$ crosses a critical value $\Gamma_c$, the system passes from a regular superconducting phase to a non-Abelian topological superconducting phase. In both cases (a) and (b) we consider in this paper the pair potential $\Delta$ is strictly s-wave in both the ordinary and the topological superconducting phases, which are separated by a topological quantum critical point at $\Gamma_c = \sqrt{\Delta^2 + \mu^2}$, where $\mu (>> \Delta)$ is the chemical potential. On the other hand, since $\Gamma_c >> \Delta$, the Zeeman splitting required for the topological phase ($\Gamma > \Gamma_c$) far exceeds the value ($\Gamma \sim \Delta$) above which an s-wave pair potential is expected to vanish (and the system to become non-superconducting) in the absence of spin-orbit coupling. We are thus led to a situation that the topological superconducting phase appears to set in a parameter regime at which the system actually is non-superconducting in the absence of spin-orbit coupling. In this paper we address the question of how a pure s-wave pair potential can survive a strong Zeeman field to give rise to a topological superconducting phase. We show that the spin-orbit coupling is the crucial parameter for the quantum transition into and the robustness of the topologically non-trivial superconducting phase realized for $\Gamma >> \Delta$., Comment: as published in the focus issue on Topological Quantum Computation, New J. Phys. 13 (2011)

We study multiband semiconducting nanowires proximity-coupled with an s-wave superconductor. We show that when odd number of subbands are occupied the system realizes non-trivial topological state supporting Majorana modes localized at the ends. We study the topological quantum phase transition in this system and analytically calculate the phase diagram as a function of the chemical potential and magnetic field. Our key finding is that multiband occupancy not only lifts the stringent constraint of one-dimensionality but also allows to have higher carrier density in the nanowire and as such multisubband nanowires are better-suited for observing the Majorana particle. We study the robustness of the topological phase by including the effects of the short- and long-range disorder. We show that in the limit of strong interband mixing there is an optimal regime in the phase diagram ("sweet spot") where the topological state is to a large extent insensitive to the presence of disorder., 4 pages, 3 figures, expanded version includes new results; accepted for publication in PRL

We construct a theory of charge transport by the surface states of topological insulators in three dimensions. The focus is on the experimentally relevant case when the electron doping is such that the Fermi energy $\epsilon_F$ and transport scattering time $\tau$ satisfy $\epsilon_F \tau/\hbar \gg 1$, but sufficiently low that $\epsilon_F$ lies below the bottom of the conduction band. Our theory is based on the spin density matrix and takes the quantum Liouville equation as its starting point. The scattering term is determined accurately to linear order in the impurity density. We consider scattering by charged impurities and short-range scatterers such as surface roughness. We calculate also the polarization function in topological insulators, emphasizing the differences from graphene. We find that the main contribution to the conductivity is $\propto n_i^{-1}$, where $n_i$ is the impurity density, and will have different carrier density dependencies for different forms of scattering. Two different contributions to this conductivity are traced to the scalar and spin-dependent terms in the Hamiltonian and their relative weight depends on the doping density. Our results contain all contributions to the conductivity to orders zero and one in the impurity density. We discuss also a way to determine the dominant scattering angles by studying the ratio of the transport relaxation time to the Bloch lifetime as a function of the Wigner-Seitz radius $r_s$. We also discuss the effect on the surface states of adding metallic contacts., Comment: 20 pages, 3 figures