Search

The development of genetically modified "whole" tumor cell vaccines for cancer therapy relies on the efficient transduction and expression of genes by vectors. In the present study, we have used a disabled infectious single cycle-herpes simplex virus 2 (DISC-HSV-2) vector constructed to express cytokine or marker genes upon infection. DISC-HSV-2 is able to infect a wide range of tumor cells and efficiently express the beta-galactosidase reporter gene, granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF), or IL-2 genes. Gene expression occurred rapidly after infection of tumor cells, and the level of production of the gene product (beta-galactosidase, GM-CSF, or IL-2) was shown to be both time-and dose-dependent. Vaccination with irradiated DISC-mGM-CSF or DISC-hIL-2-infected murine tumor cells resulted in greatly enhanced immunity to tumor challenge with live parental tumor cells compared with control vaccines. When used therapeutically to treat existing tumors, vaccination with irradiated DISC-mGM-CSF-infected tumor cells significantly reduced the incidence and growth rates of tumors when administered locally adjacent to the tumor site, providing up to 90% protection. The prophylactic and therapeutic efficacy of DISC-mGM-CSF-infected cells was shown initially using a murine renal cell carcinoma model (RENCA), and the results were confirmed in two additional murine tumor models: the M3 melanoma and 302R sarcoma. Therapy with DISC-infected RENCA "whole" cell vaccines failed to reduce the incidence or growth of tumor in congenitally T-cell deficient (Nu+/Nu+) mice or mice depleted of CD4+ and/or CD8+ T-lymphocytes, confirming that both T-helper and T-cytotoxic effector arms of the immune response are required to promote tumor rejection. These preclinical results suggest that this "novel" DISC-HSV vector may prove to be efficacious in developing genetically modified whole-cell vaccines for clinical use.

Monocytes and macrophages have been shown to be cytotoxic towards tumour cells in vitro. However, although tumour-associated monocytes and macrophages are now widely accepted to contribute a relatively high proportion of the cellular infiltrate of experimental and human solid carcinomas, a cytotoxic/cytostatic effector function for these cells in vitro or in vivo has yet to be conclusively demonstrated. In the present study, we show that non-activated peripheral blood monocytes co-cultured with tumour cells across a semi-permeable membrane release soluble factors that modulate the growth of tumour cells in contrasting ways. After Nycoprep 1.068 separation, non-activated peripheral blood monocytes enhanced the in vitro proliferation of HT29 colon adenocarcinoma cells but inhibited T47D breast carcinoma cell replication; peripheral blood lymphocytes were incapable of mediating these effects. In contrast, peripheral blood monocytes activated by interferon gamma caused a pronounced inhibition of both HT29 and T47D cell proliferation.

Hamster embryo cells transformed by Herpesvirus Type 2 (HSV-2) virus (two separate cell lines) and by HSV-1 virus (one cell line) were inoculated into hamsters. The morphological appearance of tumours was studied by both light and electron microscopy, and the results compared to similar studies of tumours induced by SV40 virus. The tumours were also tested for immunogenicity, and for susceptibility to contact suppression with BCG. The results indicated that the tumours induced by inoculation of HSV-transformed cells were distinct from those of other DNA viruses; that the two cell lines transformed by HSV-2 were very similar but distinct from the cell line transformed by HSV-1; that all 3 HSV tumour cell lines were weakly immunogenic, and 2 were susceptible to contact inhibition with BCG. The relevance of the morphological and immunogenic properties of the animal tumour is discussed with relation to the possible importance of the findings to human malignant disease.

Lymph-node cells (LNC) from multiparous pregnant rats were separated on columns prepared from nylon wool, and tested for cytotoxicity against target tumour cells. Reactivity of LNC towards hepatoma D23 and mammary carcinoma AAF57 was demonstrated in cell populations retained on the nylon wool, and not with cells eluted from the column. Although only 25% of the samples of unfractionated LNC were cytotoxic for tumour cells, retained cell fractions were cytotoxic in 11 out of 12 tests (p = less than 0.05). Similarly retained LNC were also cytotoxic for 15-day-old embryo cells but not for normal adult rat fibroblasts. Using multiparous rat serum it was shown that the reactivity of the retained LNC population could be abrogated in eight out of 11 tests (p = less than 0.05). The LNC population recovered from the nylon wool constituted 28 to 35% of the original LNC preparation, and consisted of 60-70% Ig-bearing cells together with a subpopulation of cells responding to soluble PHA. Separation of multiparous LNC on glass beads coated with rat Ig and then rabbit anti-rat Ig (in excess) also demonstrated the retained cell population to be cytotoxic against tumour cells. Approximately 17-20% of the original cell population was recovered from cells retained on the column, and consisted of an enriched Ig-bearing cell population (65-80% Ig-bearing cells) and LNC responsive to PHA. Carbonyl iron treatment of multiparous rat LNC was found to remove detectable cytotoxicity from multiparous rat LNC preparations. The cytotoxicity of multiparous rat LNC retained on nylon wool was also abolished following incubation with carbonyl iron. Definite conclusions as to the nature of the effector cell cannot be drawn from this test, since carbonyl iron treatment was found to remove not only phagocytic cells from LNC preparations but also a proportion of other cell populations including Ig-bearing lymphocytes... In addition to detecting a cytotoxic LNC population reactive towards tumour-associated embryonic antigens (retained fractions from nylon-wool column separation), a subpopulation of multiparous rat LNC was demonstrated in cell fractions eluted from the nylon wool which was shown to suppress the cytotoxicity of the retained multiparous LNC population. The exact nature of this subpopulation of LNC and the mechanism of action is at present not known.

Natural cytotoxicity in the rat was assessed against solid tumors and normal and embryonic rat monolayer culture lines, and the results were compared with rat natural killer activity towards syngeneic, allogeneic, and xenogeneic lymphoma targets. The targets tested showed a very wide range of susceptibility to lysis by peripheral blood and spleen effector cells in both 4- and 18-hr cytotoxicity assays. Cytotoxicity toward the mouse lymphoma, YAC-1, and rat sarcoma LT1 targets was relatively high in a 4-hr assay, compared with that toward the other cell lines used in the study. At 18 hr, increased killing was seen against YAC-1, LT1, SP3 (rat pheochromoblastoma), F2304 (rat embryonic cells), and normal rat kidney cells, while a significant increase in susceptibility with time was not observed with other rat targets: W/Fu-T (sarcoma); ERTh/V-G (sarcoma); R35 (mammary tumor); and W/Fu-P21 (embryo fibroblasts) targets. The cytotoxicity against all of the targets tested was not age restricted and was potentiated by rat interferon. Natural cytotoxic reactivity was seen with effector cells from the blood, spleen, and peritoneal cavity of both W/Fu (euthymic) and Rowett nude (congenitally athymic) rats. Cytotoxic effector cells from the blood were present in the low-density fractions recovered from discontinuous Percoll density gradients and, as shown previously for lymphoma target cells, a strong correlation was observed between the killing of embryonic, normal, and solid tumor targets and the presence of large granular lymphocytes. These results indicate that the naturally cytotoxic rat effector cells for normal fibroblast and bone marrow targets, lymphomas-leukemias, embryonic cell lines, and solid tumor targets are all included in the large granular lymphocyte subpopulation.

The antitumour properties of the drug N-137 were assessed in vivo in two murine T lymphoma models and two naturally metastatic hamster fibrosarcomas of Herpesvirus hominis aetiology. N-137 therapy caused a significant delay in the subcutaneous growth rate of both lymphomas (EL4 and TLX9) and in many cases completely prevented tumour appearance when administered at high doses. The antitumour effect observed in both systems was shown to be dose dependent. In contrast, N-137 therapy failed to influence the growth of two hamster fibrosarcomas (HSV-333-2-26 Met A and Met B lines), and drug administration prior to or following resection of Met B tumours failed to influence the development of natural metastases as measured by monitoring animal survival.

Subcutaneous injection of cortisone acetate administered with or without oral heparin retarded the growth of two HSV-2 induced hamster fibrosarcomas. Histological sections showed no obvious difference between the vasculature of treated and untreated tumours although there were fewer infiltrating lymphocytes in treated tumours. Treatment was, however, found to be ineffective against metastatic development following resection of primary tumours. Natural killer cell activity was found to be greatly reduced in animals receiving heparin and/or cortisone acetate treatment and this may influence the effectiveness of treatment on the metastatic process. We conclude that treatment of tumours with cortisone plus heparin is no different from the response to cortisone used alone.

Inhibition of subcutaneous tumour growth, following treatment with tilorone hydrochloride, was observed with two transplantable methylcholanthrene-induced rat sarcomas (Mc7, Mc4), but similar drug treatment was ineffective against two rat hepatomas induced by dimethylaminoazobenzene (D23, D30). Successful therapy of sarcoma Mc7 and Mc4 subcutaneous growth was not accompanied by the development of specific antitumour immunity, although with hepatoma D30, which grew out following tilorone hydrochloride treatment, specific immunity was demonstrated, indicating that drug treatment does not prevent the initiation of an antitumour response during progressive tumour development. Under defined experimental conditions tilorone hydrochloride also prevented pulmonary metastases from a subcutaneous tumour graft of epithelioma SP1 and mammary carcinoma SP22, as measured by an increased survival or treated rats.

Mice thymectomised at 3-4 weeks of age and subsequently given whole-body irradiation (9 Gy) under cytosine arabinoside cover (TAR mice) provide an alternative model to the athymic nude (nu+/nu+) mouse for studying the biological characteristics of tumour xenografts. In the present study we have evaluated the repopulation events in the bone marrow and spleen following whole body irradiation of TAR mice, and analysed immune competence up to 98 days following irradiation. Repopulation of both bone marrow and spleen was evident in the weeks following whole body irradiation, and an initial increase in the relative proportion of T-lymphocytes present in the spleen was followed by a decrease in the percentage of lymphocytes expressing T-cell markers, which remained below the level observed in control mouse spleen cell preparations. TAR mice exhibited a decreased ability to respond to a non-specific T-cell mitogen and to elicit a T-cell dependent antibody response to influenza viral antigen. Both TAR and control mice possessed macrophages which could be activated to the tumouricidal state, and natural killer activity of TAR mice was enhanced greater than 3-fold above control values. The ability of TAR mice to accept tumour xenografts decreased with the increasing time interval between irradiation and subcutaneous implantation of tumour cells, and (in some instances) spontaneous regression was observed. In addition, a hamster tumour cell line possessing high metastatic potential in its syngeneic host was shown to metastasise to the regional lymph node, lungs, liver, kidneys and spleen of TAR mice from a cell inoculum implanted subcutaneously immediately after irradiation; however, with increasing time between irradiation and inoculation of tumour cells tumour metastasis decreased. The ability of TAR mice to support the growth and metastasis of tumour xenografts would appear to inversely correlate with the increase in natural killer cell activity following irradiation.

A primary subcutaneous tumour of low spontaneous metastatic capacity, produced after inoculation of Herpes-virus hominis type-2-transformed hamster fibroblasts (parent line) and two in vivo derived highly metastatic lung deposits (Met A and Met B) were karyotyped and compared after trypsin G-banding. The parent line was cytogenetically heterogeneous with a modal chromosome number of 74. However, a number of cells were of a higher ploidy level. A large variation in both numerical and structural abnormalities was observed, the chromosome rearrangements were often complex and unstable, but all the cells contained a theme of common marker chromosomes. Met A and Met B were near diploid (mean chromosome numbers 42 and 44 respectively) with a low level of tetraploid cells. They shared many chromosome rearrangements but could be readily distinguished by an additional translocation unique to Met A. Cytogenetic homogeneity within and between metastases suggested that they were of monoclonal origin and had been derived from a karyotypically similar subpopulation within the parent tumour. We were unable to detect such cells in the parent line; thus, their numbers within the parent tumour were likely to be low. Metastasis, therefore, has been highly selective, depending on the particular phenotypic properties of Met A and Met B. All cells of the parent and metastatic lines have homogeneously staining regions (HSR) and abnormalities of chromosomes 15 (C15) which may be important in tumorigenesis. In addition, Met A and Met B cells have a number of chromosome rearrangements [translocations, deletions and a double minute chromosome (DM)] not present in the parent cells. They are retained at a high frequency in the cells of Met A and Met B and thus it seems likely that the metastatic phenotype is associated with one or more of these chromosome aberrations.

The natural killer (NK) cell susceptibility of hamster tumours exhibiting high and low levels of spontaneous metastasis in vivo was investigated. The parent cell line (HSV-2-333-2-26), which was weakly metastatic, and the NK-sensitive target line K562 were both sensitive to hamster natural killer cell activity. In contrast, 2 in vivo cloned sublines, designated met A and met B, exhibited a high level of spontaneous metastasis and were shown to be weakly or non-susceptible to hamster UK reactivity.

Wistar rats were sensitized to rat embryonic tissue by immunization with irradiated (5000 rad) rat embryo cells (2 X 10(6) s.c. + 1 X 10(6) i.p.) derived from embryos aged 14-15 days, or by implantation of irradiated (5000 rad) tissue grafts from these embryos. Three to five immunizations were given at weekly intervals, and the rats were then challenged subcutaneously 7-10 days after the final inoculum with minimal tumour-producing tumour cell doses. Immunization with irradiated rat embryo cells failed to influence the growth and development of tumour cells prepared from hepatoma D23 and D30, sarcoma Mc57, mammary carcinoma AAF57 or cells prepared from spontaneously arising mammary carcinomata Sp4 and Sp15. Using adoptive transfer techniques, lymphoid cells from embryo-sensitized rats, when used in a 3000 : 1 ratio (lymphoid cells : tumour cells), were shown effectively to retard the growth of hepatoma D23 in 3 out of 7 experiments performed. Similar adoptive transfer procedures proved ineffective in preventing the growth of mammary carcinoma AAF57. Using in vitro cytotoxicity tests, lymph node cells and spleen cells from embryo-immunized rats were shown to be cytotoxic for several rat tumour cell targets : hepatoma D23 (7/10 tests), sarcoma Mc7 (8/12 tests), mammary carcinoma AAF57 (2/2 tests) and Sp4 (3/4 tests), and for 14-15-day-old rat embryo cells (5/10 tests). In comparative tests lymphoid cells were relatively non-cytotoxic for 20-day-old rat embryo cells (1/6 tests) or cells prepared from adult rat lung or kidney (1/10 tests). The role of embryonic antigen(s) in tumour rejection is discussed.

Transplant immunity to adenovirus 12-induced tumour cells was demonstrated in CBA mice which had been previously immunized with extracts of homologous tumour cells. Immunization of mice with tumour cell extract together with heat-killed Mycobacterium butyricum gave better transplant immunity to tumour cell challenge than tumour extracts alone. Mice immunized with Mycobacterium butyricum alone prior to challenge with tumour cells, did not show any significant difference in the incidence of tumours from control mice.

Adult CBA mice thymectomized, treated with antilymphocytic globulin (ALG) and inoculated with human leprosy organisms were accidentally infected with polyoma virus and all developed tumours. After cessation of ALG administration, some animals were given spleen cells from syngeneic donors immunized with polyoma virus; none developed tumours. Similar results were obtained in mice deliberately infected with polyoma virus but not with leprosy organisms. Passive transfer of antibody before but not after virus inoculation prevented tumour formation in immunosuppressed recipients. Virus infection in thymectomized, lethally irradiated and bone marrow reconstituted mice resulted in only a very low incidence of tumours. These results emphasize the role of immunological surveillance in preventing polyoma tumour formation under natural conditions.