Search

Antibody microarrays have the potential to revolutionize molecular detection for many applications, but their current use is limited by poor reliability, and efforts to change this have not yielded fruitful results. One difficulty which limits the rational engineering of next-generation devices is that little is known, at the molecular level, about the antibody-antigen binding process near solid surfaces. Atomic-level structural information is scant because typical experimental techniques (X-ray crystallography and NMR) cannot be used to image proteins bound to surfaces. To overcome this limitation, this study uses molecular simulation and an advanced, experimentally validated, coarse-grain, protein-surface model to compare fab-lysozyme binding in bulk solution and when the fab is tethered to hydrophobic and hydrophilic surfaces. The results show that the tether site in the fab, as well as the surface hydrophobicity, significantly impacts the binding process and suggests that the optimal design involves tethering fabs upright on a hydrophilic surface. The results offer an unprecedented, molecular-level picture of the binding process and give hope that the rational design of protein-microarrays is possible.

The structures of protein antigen-antibody (Ag-Ab) interfaces contain information about how Ab recognize Ag as well as how Ag are folded to present surfaces for Ag recognition. As such, the Ab surface holds information about Ag folding that resides with the Ab-Ag interface residues and how they interact. In order to gain insight into the nature of such interactions, a data set comprised of 53 non-redundant 3D structures of Ag-Ab complexes was analyzed. We assessed the physical and biochemical features of the Ag-Ab interfaces and the degree to which favored interactions exist between amino acid residues on the corresponding interface surfaces. Amino acid compositional analysis of the interfaces confirmed the dominance of TYR in the Ab paratope-containing surface (PCS), with almost two fold greater abundance than any other residue. Additionally TYR had a much higher than expected presence in the PCS compared to the surface of the whole antibody (defined as the occurrence propensity), along with aromatics PHE, TRP, and to a lesser degree HIS and ILE. In the Ag epitope-containing surface (ECS), there were slightly increased occurrence propensities of TRP and TYR relative to the whole Ag surface, implying an increased significance over the compositionally most abundant LYS>ASN>GLU>ASP>ARG. This examination encompasses a large, diverse set of unique Ag-Ab crystal structures that help explain the biological range and specificity of Ag-Ab interactions. This analysis may also provide a measure of the significance of individual amino acid residues in phage display analysis of Ag binding., (Copyright © 2012 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.)

Many germ line antibodies have asparagine residues at specific sites to achieve specific antigen recognition. To study the role of asparagine residues in the stabilization of antigen-antibody complexes, we examined the interaction between hen egg white lysozyme (HEL) and the corresponding HyHEL-10 variable domain fragment (Fv). We introduced Ala and Asp substitutions into the Fv side chains of L-Asn-31, L-Asn-32, and L-Asn-92, which interact directly with residues in HEL via hydrogen bonding in the wild-type Fv-HEL complex, and we investigated the interactions between these mutant antibodies and HEL. Isothermal titration calorimetric analysis showed that all the mutations decreased the negative enthalpy change and decreased the association constants of the interaction. Structural analyses showed that the effects of the mutations on the structure of the complex could be compensated for by conformational changes and/or by gains in other interactions. Consequently, the contribution of two hydrogen bonds was minor, and their abolition by mutation resulted in only a slight decrease in the affinity of the antibody for its antigen. By comparison, the other two hydrogen bonds buried at the interfacial area had large enthalpic advantage, despite entropic loss that was perhaps due to stiffening of the interface by the bonds, and were crucial to the strength of the interaction. Deletion of these strong hydrogen bonds could not be compensated for by other structural changes. Our results suggest that asparagine can provide the two functional groups for strong hydrogen bond formation, and their contribution to the antigen-antibody interaction can be attributed to their limited flexibility and accessibility at the complex interface.

Lysozyme was immobilized on a prefabricated carboxylic acid terminated chemical template, forming a tightly packed, one monolayer thick lysozyme pattern. Polyclonal anti-lysozyme antibodies can bind to the immobilized lysozyme pattern. Atomic force microscope (AFM) observation reveals that the antibodies bind to the lysozyme molecules on the pattern edge before they bind to the lysozyme molecules in the pattern interior. Better spatial accessibility and flexibility of the lysozyme molecules on the pattern edge are used to explain the observed antibody binding preference. The topographies of the lysozyme pattern also affect the antibody binding. The antibodies bind to the edge lysozyme from the top if the lysozyme pattern is half-buried in a 10 A deep channel, whereas the antibodies bind to the edge lysozyme from the side if the lysozyme pattern is immobilized on a protruding terrace. The observed "edge effect" suggests that, for the same protein coverage, reducing the protein pattern feature to the nanoscale will improve the overall binding activity of the immobilized protein toward the antibody.

Tyrosine is an important amino acid in protein-protein interaction hot spots. In particular, many Tyr residues are located in the antigen-binding sites of antibodies and endow high affinity and high specificity to these antibodies. To investigate the role of interfacial Tyr residues in protein-protein interactions, we performed crystallographic studies and thermodynamic analyses of the interaction between hen egg lysozyme (HEL) and the anti-HEL antibody HyHEL-10 Fv fragment. HyHEL-10 has six Tyr residues in its antigen-binding site, which were systematically mutated to Phe and Ala using site-directed mutagenesis. The crystal structures revealed several critical roles for these Tyr residues in the interaction between HEL and HyHEL-10 as follows: 1) the aromatic ring of Tyr-50 in the light chain (LTyr-50) was important for the correct ternary structure of variable regions of the immunoglobulin light chain and heavy chain and of HEL; 2) deletion of the hydroxyl group of Tyr-50 in the heavy chain (HTyr-50) resulted in structural changes in the antigen-antibody interface; and 3) the side chains of HTyr-33 and HTyr-53 may help induce fitting of the antibody to the antigen. Hot spot Tyr residues may contribute to the high affinity and high specificity of the antigen-antibody interaction through a diverse set of structural and thermodynamic interactions.

We used atomic force microscopy (AFM) to explore the antigen binding forces of individual Fv fragments of antilysozyme antibodies (Fv). To detect single molecular recognition events, genetically engineered histidine-tagged Fv fragments were coupled onto AFM tips modified with mixed self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) of nitrilotriacetic acid- and tri(ethylene glycol)-terminated alkanethiols while lysozyme (Lyso) was covalently immobilized onto mixed SAMs of carboxyl- and hydroxyl-terminated alkanethiols. The quality of the functionalization procedure was validated using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (surface chemical composition), AFM imaging (surface morphology in aqueous solution), and surface plasmon resonance (SPR, specific binding in aqueous solution). AFM force-distance curves recorded at a loading rate of 5000 pN/s between Fv- and Lyso-modified surfaces yielded a distribution of unbinding forces composed of integer multiples of an elementary force quantum of approximately 50 pN that we attribute to the rupture of a single antibody-antigen pair. Injection of a solution containing free Lyso caused a dramatic reduction of adhesion probability, indicating that the measured 50 pN unbinding forces are due to the specific antibody-antigen interaction. To investigate the dynamics of the interaction, force-distance curves were recorded at various loading rates. Plots of unbinding force vs log(loading rate) revealed two distinct linear regimes with ascending slopes, indicating multiple barriers were present in the energy landscape. The kinetic off-rate constant of dissociation (k(off) approximately = 1 x 10(-3) s(-1)) obtained by extrapolating the data of the low-strength regime to zero force was in the range of the k(off) estimated by SPR.

The structure of the complex between hen egg-white lysozyme and the Fab HyHEL-5 at 2.7 A resolution has previously been reported [Cohen et al. (1996), Acta Cryst. D52, 315-326]. With the availability of recombinant Fab, the X-ray structure of the complex has been re-evaluated at 1.7 A resolution. The refined structure has yielded a detailed picture of the Fab-lysozyme interface, showing the high complementarity of the protein surfaces as well as several water molecules within the interface that complete the good fit. The model of the full complex has improved significantly, yielding an R(work) of 19.5%. With this model, the structural results can be compared with the results of isothermal titration calorimetry. An attempt has been made to estimate the changes in bound waters that accompany complex formation and the difficulties inherent in using the crystal structures to provide the information necessary to make this calculation are discussed.

One nanosecond molecular dynamic (MD) simulation of anti-hen egg white lysozyme (HEL) antibody HyHEL63 (HH63) complexed with HEL reveals rigid and flexible regions of the HH63 binding site. Fifty conformations, extracted from the MD trajectory at regular time intervals were superimposed on HH63-HEL X-ray crystal structure, and the root mean squared deviations (RMSDs) and deviations in Calpha atom positions between the X-ray structure and the MD conformer were measured. Residue positions showing the large deviations in both light chain and heavy chain of the antibody were same in all the MD conformers. The residue positions showing smallest deviations were same for all the conformers in the case of light chain, whereas relatively variable in the heavy chain. Positions of large and small deviations fell in the complementarity determining regions (CDRs), for both heavy and light chains. The larger deviations were in CDR-2 of light and CDR-1 of heavy chain. Smaller deviations were in CDR-3 of light and CDR-2 and CDR-3 of heavy chains. The large and small deviating regions highlight flexible and rigid regions of HH63 binding site and suggest a mosaic binding mechanism, including both "induced fit" and preconfigured "lock-and-key" type of binding. Combined "induced fit" and "lock-and-key" binding would be a better definition for the formation of large complexes, which bury larger surface area on binding, as in the case of antibody-HEL complex. We further show that flexible regions, comprising mostly charged and polar residues, form intermolecular interactions with HEL, whereas rigid regions do not. Electrostatic complementarity between HH63 and HEL also imply optimized binding affinity. Flexible and rigid regions of a high-affinity antibody are selected during the affinity maturation of the antibody and have specific functional significance. The functional importance of local inherently flexible regions is to establish intermolecular contacts or they play a key role in molecular recognition, whereas local rigid regions provide the structural framework.

Three antibodies, HyHEL-8 (HH8), HyHEL-10 (HH10), and HyHEL-26 (HH26) are specific for the same epitope on hen egg white lysozyme (HEL), and share >90% sequence homology. Their affinities vary by several orders of magnitude, and among the three antibodies, HH8 is the most cross-reactive with kinetics of binding that are relatively invariable compared to HH26, which is highly specific and has quite variable kinetics. To investigate structural correlates of these functional variations, the Fv regions of HH8 and HH26 were homology-modeled using the x-ray structure of the well-characterized HH10-HEL complex as template. The binding site of HH26 is most charged, least hydrophobic, and has the greatest number of intramolecular salt bridges, whereas that of HH8 is the least charged, most hydrophobic and has the fewest intramolecular salt bridges. The modeled HH26-HEL structure predicts the recently determined x-ray structure of HH26, (Li et al., 2003, Nat. Struct. Biol. 10:482-488) with a root-mean-square deviation of 1.03 A. It is likely that the binding site of HH26 is rendered rigid by a network of intramolecular salt bridges whereas that of HH8 is flexible due to their absence. HH26 also has the most intermolecular contacts with the antigen whereas HH8 has the least. HH10 has these properties intermediate to HH8 and HH26. The structurally rigid binding site with numerous specific contacts bestows specificity on HH26 whereas the flexible binding site with correspondingly fewer contacts enables HH8 to be cross-reactive. Results suggest that affinity maturation may select for high affinity antibodies with either "lock-and-key" preconfigured binding sites, or "preconfigured flexibility" by modulating combining site flexibility.

The process whereby the immune system generates antibodies of higher affinities during a response to antigen (affinity maturation) is a prototypical example of molecular evolution. Earlier studies have been confined to antibodies specific for small molecules (haptens) rather than for proteins. We compare the structures of four antibodies bound to the same site on hen egg white lysozyme (HEL) at different stages of affinity maturation. These X-ray snapshots reveal that binding is enhanced, not through the formation of additional hydrogen bonds or van der Waals contacts or by an increase in total buried surface, but by burial of increasing amounts of apolar surface at the expense of polar surface, accompanied by improved shape complementarity. The increase in hydrophobic interactions results from highly correlated rearrangements in antibody residues at the interface periphery, adjacent to the central energetic hot spot. This first visualization of the maturation of antibodies to protein provides insights into the evolution of high affinity in other protein-protein interfaces.

This work shows that quantitative multivariate modeling is an emerging possibility for unraveling protein-protein interactions using a combination of designed mutations with sequence and structure information. Using this approach, it is possible to stereochemically determine which residue properties contribute most to the interaction. This is illustrated by results from modeling of the interaction of the wild-type and 17 single and double mutants of a camel antibody specific for lysozyme. Linear multivariate models describing association and dissociation rates as well as affinity were developed. Sequence information in the form of amino acid property scales was combined with 3D structure information (obtained using molecular mechanics calculations) in the form of coordinates of the alpha-carbons and the center of the side chains. The results show that in addition to the amino acid properties of the mutated residues 101 and 105, the dissociation rate is controlled by the side-chain coordinate of residue 105, whereas the association is determined by the coordinates of residues 99, 100, 105 (side chain), 111, and 112. The great difference between the models for association and dissociation rates illustrates that the event of molecular recognition and the property of binding stability rely on different physical processes.

To study the role of hydrogen bonding via interfacial water molecules in protein-protein interactions, we examined the interaction between hen egg white lysozyme (HEL) and its HyHEL-10 variable domain fragment (Fv) antibody. We constructed three antibody mutants (l-Y50F, l-S91A, and l-S93A) and investigated the interactions between the mutant Fvs and HEL. Isothermal titration calorimetry indicated that the mutations significantly decreased the negative enthalpy change (8-25 kJ mol(-1)), despite some offset by a favorable entropy change. X-ray crystallography demonstrated that the complexes had nearly identical structures, including the positions of the interfacial water molecules. Taken together, the isothermal titration calorimetric and x-ray crystallographic results indicate that hydrogen bonding via interfacial water enthalpically contributes to the Fv-HEL interaction despite the partial offset because of entropy loss, suggesting that hydrogen bonding stiffens the antigen-antibody complex.

Antibodies HyHEL8, HyHEL10, and HyHEL26 (HH8, HH10, and HH26, respectively) recognize highly overlapping epitopes on hen egg-white lysozyme (HEL) with similar affinities, but with different specificities. HH8 binding to HEL is least sensitive toward mutations in the epitope and thus is most cross-reactive, HH26 is most sensitive, whereas the sensitivity of HH10 lies in between HH8 and HH26. Here we have investigated intra- and intermolecular interactions in three antibody-protein complexes: theoretical models of HH8-HEL and HH26-HEL complexes, and the x-ray crystal structure of HH10-HEL complex. Our results show that HH8-HEL has the lowest number and HH26-HEL has the highest number of intra- and intermolecular hydrogen bonds. The number of salt bridges is lowest in HH8-HEL and highest in HH26-HEL. The binding site salt bridges in HH8-HEL are not networked, and are weak, whereas, in HH26-HEL, an intramolecular salt-bridge triad at the binding site is networked to an intermolecular triad to form a pentad. The pentad and each salt bridge of this pentad are exceptionally stabilizing. The number of binding-site salt bridges and their strengths are intermediate in HH10-HEL, with an intramolecular triad. Our further calculations show that the electrostatic component contributes the most to binding energy of HH26-HEL, whereas the hydrophobic component contributes the most in the case of HH8-HEL. A "hot-spot" epitope residue Lys-97 forms an intermolecular salt bridge in HH8-HEL, and participates in the intermolecular pentad in the HH26-HEL complex. Mutant modeling and surface plasmon resonance (SPR) studies show that this hot-spot epitope residue contributes significantly more to the binding than an adjacent epitope residue, Lys-96, which does not form a salt bridge in any of the three HH-HEL complexes. Furthermore, the effect of mutating Lys-97 is most severe in HH26-HEL. Lys-96, being a charged residue, also contributes the most in HH26-HEL among the three complexes. The SPR results on these mutants also highlight that the apparent "electrostatic steering" on net on rates actually act at post-collision level stabilization of the complex. The significance of this work is the observed variations in electrostatic interactions among the three complexes. Our work demonstrates that higher electrostatics, both as a number of short-range electrostatic interactions and their contributions, leads to higher binding specificity. Strong salt bridges, their networking, and electrostatically driven binding, limit flexibilities through geometric constrains. In contrast, hydrophobic driven binding and low levels of electrostatic interactions are associated with conformational flexibility and cross-reactivity.

In most of the work dealing with the analysis of protein-protein interfaces, a single X-ray structure is available or selected, and implicitly it is assumed that this structure corresponds to the optimal complex for this pair of proteins. However, we have found a degenerate interface in a high-affinity antibody-antigen complex: the two independent complexes of the camel variable domain antibody fragment cAb-Lys3 and its antigen hen egg white lysozyme present in the asymmetric unit of our crystals show a difference in relative orientation between antibody and antigen, leading to important differences at the protein-protein interface. A third cAb-Lys3-hen lysozyme complex in a different crystal form adopts yet another relative orientation. Our results show that protein-protein interface characteristics can vary significantly between different specimens of the same high-affinity antibody-protein antigen complex. Consideration should be given to this type of observation when trying to establish general protein-protein interface characteristics., (Copyright 2001 Academic Press.)

Antigen-antibody complexes provide useful models for studying the structure and energetics of protein-protein interactions. We report the cloning, bacterial expression, and crystallization of the antigen-binding fragment (Fab) of the anti-hen egg white lysozyme (HEL) antibody HyHEL-63 in both free and antigen-bound forms. The three-dimensional structure of Fab HyHEL-63 complexed with HEL was determined to 2.0 A resolution, while the structure of the unbound antibody was determined in two crystal forms, to 1.8 and 2.1 A resolution. In the complex, 19 HyHEL-63 residues from all six complementarity-determining regions (CDRs) of the antibody contact 21 HEL residues from three discontinuous polypeptide segments of the antigen. The interface also includes 11 bound water molecules, 3 of which are completely buried in the complex. Comparison of the structures of free and bound Fab HyHEL-63 reveals that several of the ordered water molecules in the free antibody-combining site are retained and that additional waters are added upon complex formation. The interface waters serve to increase shape and chemical complementarity by filling cavities between the interacting surfaces and by contributing to the hydrogen bonding network linking the antigen and antibody. Complementarity is further enhanced by small (<3 A) movements in the polypeptide backbones of certain antibody CDR loops, by rearrangements of side chains in the interface, and by a slight shift in the relative orientation of the V(L) and V(H) domains. The combining site residues of complexed Fab HyHEL-63 exhibit reduced temperature factors compared with those of the free Fab, suggesting a loss in conformational entropy upon binding. To probe the relative contribution of individual antigen residues to complex stabilization, single alanine substitutions were introduced in the epitope of HEL recognized by HyHEL-63, and their effects on antibody affinity were measured using surface plasmon resonance. In agreement with the crystal structure, HEL residues at the center of the interface that are buried in the complex contribute most to the binding energetics (DeltaG(mutant) - DeltaG(wild type) > 3.0 kcal/mol), whereas the apparent contributions of solvent-accessible residues at the periphery are much less pronounced (<1.5 kcal/mol). In the latter case, the mutations may be partially compensated by local rearrangements in solvent structure that help preserve shape complementarity and the interface hydrogen bonding network.

Alanine scanning mutagenesis of the HyHEL-10 paratope of the HyHEL-10/HEWL complex demonstrates that the energetically important side chains (hot spots) of both partners are in contact. A plot of deltadeltaG(HyHEL-10&#95;mutant) vs. deltadeltaG(HEWL&#95;mutant) for the five of six interacting side-chain hydrogen bonds is linear (Slope = 1). Only 3 of the 13 residues in the HEWL epitope contribute >4 kcal/mol to the free energy of formation of the complex when replaced by alanine, but 6 of the 12 HyHEL-10 paratope amino acids do. Double mutant cycle analysis of the single crystallographically identified salt bridge, D32H/K97, shows that there is a significant energetic penalty when either partner is replaced with a neutral side-chain amino acid, but the D32(H)N/K97M complex is as stable as the WT. The role of the disproportionately high number of Tyr residues in the CDR was evaluated by comparing the deltadeltaG values of the Tyr --> Phe vs. the corresponding Tyr --> Ala mutations. The nonpolar contacts in the light chain contribute only about one-half of the total deltadeltaG observed for the Tyr --> Ala mutation, while they are significantly more important in the heavy chain. Replacement of the N31L/K96 hydrogen bond with a salt bridge, N31D(L)/K96, destabilizes the complex by 1.4 kcal/mol. The free energy of interaction, deltadeltaG(int), obtained from double mutant cycle analysis showed that deltadeltaG(int) for any complex for which the HEWL residue probed is a major immunodeterminant is very close to the loss of free energy observed for the HyHEL-10 single mutant. Error propagation analysis of double mutant cycles shows that data of atypically high precision are required to use this method meaningfully, except where large deltadeltaG values are analyzed.

The change in free energy of binding of hen egg white lysozyme (HEL) to the antibody HyHel-10 arising from ten point mutations in HEL (D101K, D101G, K96M, K97D, K97G, K97G, R21E, R21K, W62Y, and W63Y) was calculated using a combination of the finite difference Poisson-Boltzmann method for the electrostatic contribution, a solvent accessible surface area term for the non-polar contribution, and rotamer counting for the sidechain entropy contribution. Comparison of experimental and calculated results indicate that because of pKa shifts in some of the mutated residues, primarily those involving Aspartate or Glutamate, proton uptake or release occurs in binding. When this effect was incorporated into the binding free energy calculations, the agreement with experiment improved significantly, and resulted in a mean error of about 1.9 kcal/mole. Thus these calculations predict that there should be a significant pH dependence to the change in binding caused by these mutations. The other major contributions to binding energy changes comes from solvation and charge charge interactions, which tend to oppose each other. Smaller contributions come from nonpolar interactions and sidechain entropy changes. The structures of the HyHel-10-HEL complexes with mutant HEL were obtained by modeling, and the effect of the modeled structure on the calculations was also examined. "Knowledge based" modeling and automatic generation of models using molecular mechanics produced comparable results.

The rate constants, k(on), for the formation of hen (chicken) lysozyme (HEWL). Fab-10 complexes have been determined for wild-type (WT) and epitope-mutated lysozymes by a homogeneous solution method based on the 95% reduced enzymatic activity of the complex. The values fall within a narrow 10-fold range [(0.18 to 1.92) x 10(6) M(-1)s(-l)]. The affinity constants, K(D), cover a broader, 440-fold, range from 0.075 to 33 nM. Values of K(D) as high as 7 microM were obtained for the complexes prepared from some mutations at HEWL positions 96 and 97, but the associated kinetic constants could not be determined. The values of k(on) are negatively correlated with side-chain volume at position 101HEWL, but are essentially independent of this parameter for position 21HEWL substitutions. The multiple mutations made at positions 21HEWL and 101HEWL provide sufficient experimental data on complex formation to evaluate phi values [phi = (deltadeltaGon)/(deltadeltaG(D))] at these two positions to begin to define trajectories for protein-protein association. The data, when interpreted within the concept of a two-step association sequence embracing a metastable encounter complex intermediate, argue that the rate determining step at position 21HEWL (phiavg = 0.2) is encounter complex formation, but the larger phi(avg) value of 0.36 experienced for most position 101HEWL mutations indicates a larger contribution from the post-encounter annealing process at this site for these replacements.

The recent sequencing of many complete genomes, combined with the development of methods that allow rapid structure determination for many proteins, has changed the way in which protein structure determinations can be approached. One-by-one determinations of individual protein structures will soon be augmented by class-directed structure analyses in which a group of proteins is targeted and structures of representative members are determined and used to represent the entire group. Such a shift in approach would be the foundation for a broad protein structure initiative targeting classes of proteins important for biotechnology and for a fundamental understanding of protein function.

The hen (chicken) egg-white lysozyme (HEWL) epitope for the monoclonal antibody HyHEL-10 Fab (Fab-10) was investigated by alanine scan mutagenesis. The association rate constants (k(on)) for the HEWL Fab-10 complexes were obtained from the homogenous solution method described in the preceding paper (Taylor et al., 1998). A new method for determining the dissociation rate constant (k(off)) for the complex, by trapping nascent free antibody with an inactive HEWL mutant is described. The values of k(on) fall within a factor of 2 of the wild-type (WT) HEWL value (1.43+/-0.13 X 10(6)M(-1)s(-1)), while the increases in k(off)more nearly reflect the total change in free energies of the complex (deltadeltaG(D)). The dissociation constants (K(D)) were measured directly in those cases where satisfactory kinetic data could not be obtained. The Y20A, K96A, and K97A HEWL.Fab-10 complexes are destabilized by more than 4 kcal/mol compared to the WT complex. The R21A, L75A, and D101A antibody complexes are moderately destabilized (0.7 < deltadeltaG(D)< or = 1.0 kcal/mol). Additional mutations of the "hotspot" residues (Tyr20, Lys96, Lys97) were constructed to probe, more precisely, the nature of their contributions to complex formation. The results show that the entire hydrocarbon side chains of Tyr20 and Lys97, and only the epsilon-amino group of Lys96, contribute to the stability of the complex. The value of deltadeltaG(D) for the R21A mutant complex is a distinct outlier in the Arg21 replacement series demonstrating the importance of supplementing alanine scan mutagenesis with additional mutations.

We examined temperature dependency of thermodynamic parameters in the interactions between hen egg-white lysozyme (HEL) and anti-HEL antibody, D1.3, and two mutant antibodies. The DeltaH degrees values appeared to decrease biphasically in the temperature range from 10 to 45 degrees C with the apparent inflection point around 30 degrees C. The DeltaG degrees calculated from the KA values showed only small differences because of entropy and enthalpy compensation. It has been argued that large negative values of heat capacity change (DeltaCp degrees), if observed, are mainly derived from hydrophobic interactions. However, the observed DeltaCp degrees values were too high to be ascribed only to hydrophobic interactions. Moreover, addition of methanol did not cause a decrease in the absolute value of DeltaCp degrees.

A new approach for the characterization of conformationally dependent epitope structures in protein antigens is described using differential chemical modification of immune complexes in combination with mass spectrometric peptide mapping analysis. Well-established methods for epitope characterization are frequently not applicable to conformationally dependent epitopes, and direct methods of structure analysis such as X-ray crystallography of immune complexes have been successful only in a few cases. Our approach combines tertiary structure-selective chemical modification of immune complexes with the molecular characterization of reaction products by mass spectrometric peptide mapping. The comparison of the modification pattern of free and antibody-bound antigen provides the identification of residues protected from modification by the antibody. These residues hence are characterized as part of the epitope structure. The well-characterized hen egg white lysozyme and a corresponding monoclonal IgM-type antibody were investigated as a model system. Specific modification reactions for arginine, lysine, and tyrosine residues were performed, and the modification sites in free and antibody-bound antigen were determined by mass spectrometric peptide mapping. The R14 residue and residues K13 and K96 in the antibody-bound lysozyme were found to be protected from modification, comprising a surface of spatially adjacent residues by folding of the native protein. In contrast, other K and R residues as well as Y20 and Y23 showed no significant shielding from modification in the immune complex. These results provided an estimation of the molecular epitope surface area of native lysozyme.

Using phage-display, an anti-turkey egg-white lysozyme single-chain Fv fragment was selected from a naive light chain variable region repertoire in combination with a heavy chain variable region 'mini library' of anti-hen egg-white lysozyme single-domain binders (Ward et al., 1989). Whereas the selected VH domain alone binds somewhat better hen egg-white lysozyme than turkey egg-white lysozyme, but both with comparatively low affinity, the specificity of VH is converted by addition of the VL domain. Thus, the single-chain Fv fragment is more specific for turkey egg-white lysozyme, with markedly increased affinities towards both lysozymes. The complex of single-chain Fv with turkey lysozyme has been crystallized and characterized by preliminary X-ray analysis.

Association between proteins often depends on the pH and ionic strength conditions of the medium in which it takes place. This is especially true in complexation involving titratable residues at the complex interface. Continuum electrostatics methods were used to calculate the pH-dependent energetics of association of hen egg lysozyme with two closely related monoclonal antibodies raised against it and the association of these antibodies against an avian species variant. A detailed analysis of the energetic contributions reveals that even though the hallmark of association in the two complexes is the presence of conserved charged-residue interactions, the environment of these interactions significantly influences the titration behavior and concomitantly the energetics. The contributing factors include minor structural rearrangements, buried interfacial area, dielectric environment of the key titratable residues, and geometry of the residue dispositions. Modeled structures of several mutant complexes were also studied so as to further delineate the contribution of individual factors to the titration behavior.

Fluorescence polarization spectroscopy and isothermal titration calorimetry were used to study the influence of osmolytes on the association of the anti-hen egg lysozyme (HEL) monoclonal antibody HyHEL-5 with bobwhite quail lysozyme (BWQL). BWQL is an avian species variant with an Arg-->Lys mutation in the HyHEL-5 epitope, as well as three other mutations outside the HyHEL-5 structural epitope. This mutation decreases the equilibrium association constant of HyHEL-5 for BWQL by over 1000-fold as compared to HEL. The three-dimensional structure of this complex has been obtained recently. Fluorescein-labeled BWQL, obtained by labeling at pH 7.5 and purified by hydrophobic interaction chromatograpy, bound HyHEL-5 with an equilibrium association constant close to that determined for unlabeled BWQL by isothermal titration calorimetry. Fluorescence titration, stopped-flow kinetics, and isothermal titration calorimetry experiments using various concentrations of the osmolytes glycerol, ethylene glycol, and betaine to perturb binding gave a lower limit of the uptake of approximately 6-12 water molecules upon formation of the HyHEL-5/BWQL complex.

The energetics of association of the murine anti-hen egg lysozyme antibody HyHEL-5 with bobwhite quail lysozyme, California quail lysozyme, and the Arg45-->Lys mutant of hen egg lysozyme was characterized by isothermal titration calorimetry. The association of each lysozyme with HyHEL-5 is enthalpically driven in the temperature range 10 degrees C to 37 degrees C. The calorimetric results indicate that the salt-links between Arg45 and Arg68 of hen egg lysozyme and GluH50 on the HyHEL-5 paratope are energetically important in HyHEL-5/HEL association. In contrast to previous studies, the results suggest that the three characteristic 'quail' mutations affect the energetics of antibody/antigen association, even though they are buried and not in direct contact with the antibody.

The idiotope-antiidiotope complex between the anti-hen egg white lysozyme antibody D1.3 and the anti-D1.3 antibody E5.2 provides a useful model for studying protein-protein interactions. A high-resolution crystal structure of the complex is available [Fields, B. A., Goldbaum, F. A., Ysern, X., Poljak, R.J., & Mariuzza, R. A. (1995) Nature 374, 739-742], and both components are easily produced and manipulated in Escherichia coli. We previously analyzed the relative contributions of individual residues of D1.3 to complex stabilization by site-directed mutagenesis [Dall'Acqua, W., Goldman, E. R., Eisenstein, E., & Mariuzza, R. A. (1996) Biochemistry 35, 9667-9676]. In the current work, we introduced single alanine substitutions in 9 out of 21 positions in the combining site of E5.2 involved in contacts with D1.3 and found that 8 of them play a significant role in ligand binding (delta Gmutant-delta Gwild type > 1.5 kcal/mol). Furthermore, energetically important E5.2 and D1.3 residues tend to be juxtaposed in the crystal structure of the complex. In order to further dissect the energetics of specific interactions in the D1.3-E5.2 interface, double mutant cycles were carried out to measure the coupling of 13 amino acid pairs, 9 of which are in direct contact in the crystal structure. The highest coupling energy (4.3 kcal/mol) was measured for a charged-neutral pair which forms a buried hydrogen bond, while side chains which interact through solvated hydrogen bonds have lower coupling energies (1.3-1.7 kcal/mol), irrespective of whether they involve charged-neutral or neutral-neutral pairs. Interaction energies of similar magnitude (1.3-1.6 kcal/mol) were measured for residues forming only van der Waals contacts. Cycles between distant residues not involved in direct contacts in the crystal structure also showed significant coupling (0.5-1.0 kcal/mol). These weak long-range interactions could be due to rearrangements in solvent or protein structure or to secondary interactions involving other residues.

Using site-directed mutagenesis, X-ray crystallography, and titration calorimetry, we have examined the structural and thermodynamic consequences of removing specific hydrogen bonds in an antigen-antibody interface. Crystal structures of three antibody FvD1.3 mutants, VLTyr50Ser (VLY50S), VHTyr32Ala (VHY32A), and VHTyr101Phe (VHY101F), bound to hen egg white lysozyme (HEL) have been determined at resolutions ranging from 1.85 to 2.10 A. In the wild-type (WT) FvD1.3-HEL complex, the hydroxyl groups of VLTyr50, VHTyr32, and VHTyr101 each form at least one hydrogen bond with the lysozyme antigen. Thermodynamic parameters for antibody-antigen association have been measured using isothermal titration calorimetry, giving equilibrium binding constants Kb (M-1) of 2.6 x 10(7) (VLY50S), 7.0 x 10(7) (VHY32A), and 4.0 x 10(6) (VHY101F). For the WT complex, Kb is 2.7 x 10(8) M-1; thus, the affinities of the mutant Fv fragments for HEL are 10-, 4-, and 70-fold lower than that of the original antibody, respectively. In all three cases entropy compensation results in an affinity loss that would otherwise be larger. Comparison of the three mutant crystal structures with the WT structure demonstrates that the removal of direct antigen-antibody hydrogen bonds results in minimal shifts in the positions of the remaining protein atoms. These observations show that this complex is considerably tolerant, both structurally and thermodynamically, to the truncation of antibody side chains that form hydrogen bonds with the antigen. Alterations in interface solvent structure for two of the mutant complexes (VLY50S and VHY32A) appear to compensate for the unfavorable enthalpy changes when protein-protein interactions are removed. These changes in solvent structure, along with the increased mobility of side chains near the mutation site, probably contribute to the observed entropy compensation. For the VHY101F complex, the nature of the large entropy compensation is not evident from a structural comparison of the WT and mutant complexes. Differences in the local structure and dynamics of the uncomplexed Fv molecules may account for the entropic discrepancy in this case.

The HyHEL-5 antibody has more than a thousandfold lower affinity for bobwhite quail lysozyme (BWQL) than for hen egg-white lysozyme (HEL). Four sequence differences exist between BWQL and HEL, of which only one is involved in the interface with the Fab. The structure of bobwhite quail lysozyme has been determined in the uncomplexed state in two different crystal forms and in the complexed state with HyHEL-5, an antihen egg-white lysozyme Fab. Similar backbone conformations are observed in the three molecules of the two crystal forms of uncomplexed BWQL, although they show considerable variability in side-chain conformation. A relatively mobile segment in uncomplexed BWQL is observed to be part of the HyHEL-5 epitope. No major backbone conformational differences are observed in the lysozyme upon complex formation, but side-chain conformational differences are seen in surface residues that are involved in the interface with the antibody. The hydrogen bonding in the interface between BWQL and HyHEL-5 is similar to that in previously determined lysozyme-HyHEL-5 complexes.

The crystal structure of the Fv fragment of the murine monoclonal anti-lysozyme antibody D1.3, complexed with turkey egg-white lysozyme (TEL), is presented. D1.3 (IgG1, kappa) is a secondary response antibody specific for hen egg-white lysozyme (HEL). TEL and HEL are homologous and differ in amino acid sequence in the antibody-antigen interface only at position 121. The side-chain of HEL residue Gln121 makes a pair of hydrogen bonds to main-chain atoms of the antibody light chain. In the D1.3-TEL structure, TEL residue His121 makes only one hydrogen bond with the light chain as a result of 129 degree and 145 degree change in peptide torsion angles for residues Trp92 and Ser93. Probably as a consequence of this conformational change, the D1.3-TEL association occurs at a much slower rate than the D1.3-HEL association. The D1.3-TEL complex is destabilized with respect to the D1.3-HEL interaction by the loss of two hydrogen bonds, exclusively due to the substitution of histidine for glutamine. While antibodies of secondary responses are indeed highly specific for antigen, this work demonstrates that by undergoing subtle conformational change antibodies can still recognize mutated protein antigens, albeit at a cost to affinity.

The binding of anti-lysozyme monoclonal antibodies, D44.1 or D1.3, to their antigen reduces the rate of exchange for many amide hydrogens in lysozyme. The D44.1 antibody contacts a similar region of lysozyme to the HyHEL-5 antibody, while the D1.3 antibody binds to the side of lysozyme which is opposite to the HyHEL-5 and D44.1 epitopes. We compare the effects of binding these antibodies on amide hydrogen exchange rates in lysozyme. These comparisons suggest that there are regions of lysozyme that fluctuate in a coordinated manner such that the effects of binding can be propagated to regions that are distant from the epitope. The activation enthalpies for hydrogen exchange for 36 of the 126 amide hydrogens in lysozyme and for 25 of 126 lysozyme amide hydrogens in the lysozyme-D1.3 complex are also reported. These data suggest that the reduction in amide hydrogen exchange rates upon antibody binding reflect changes in the dynamics of the antigen. These changes contribute to a reduction in the specific heat capacity upon binding.

Type c lysozymes, and hen egg lysozyme in particular, have been extensively used to study the immune response because of their strong immunogenicity, the availability of many natural variants to study cross-reactivity, and the possibility to correlate these results with the known three-dimensional structure of lysozymes from several species. To date, the structure of six different murine monoclonal anti-lysozyme antibodies has been studied as a complex between the Fab fragment and antigen. In some cases, the structure of the uncomplexed Fab is also available, giving detail at the atomic level of the changes which take place during the formation of the antibody-antigen complex. The bacterially-expressed Fv molecule, the simplest fragment of an immunoglobulin retaining an intact antigen-binding site, has been studied for three of the monoclonal anti-lysozyme antibodies. Recombinant Fv fragments have opened up the possibility of using site-directed mutagenesis to study the effect of amino acid changes at the antibody-antigen interface. The six monoclonal antibodies appear to recognize epitopes which are localised on three different regions of the lysozyme surface.

The solvation of the antibody-antigen Fv D1.3-lysozyme complex is investigated through a study of the conservation of water molecules in crystal structures of the wild-type Fv fragment of antibody D1.3, 5 free lysozyme, the wild-type Fv D1.3-lysozyme complex, 5 Fv D1.3 mutants complexed with lysozyme and the crystal structure of an idiotope (Fv D1.3)-anti-idiotope (Fv E5.2) complex. In all, there are 99 water molecules common to the wild-type and mutant antibody-lysozyme complexes. The antibody-lysozyme interface includes 25 well-ordered solvent molecules, conserved among the wild-type and mutant Fv D1.3-lysozyme complexes, which are bound directly or through other water molecules to both antibody and antigen. In addition to contributing hydrogen bonds to the antibody-antigen interaction the solvent molecules fill many interface cavities. Comparison with x-ray crystal structures of free Fv D1.3 and free lysozyme shows that 20 of these conserved interface waters in the complex were bound to one of the free proteins. Up to 23 additional water molecules are also found in the antibody-antigen interface, however these waters do not bridge antibody and antigen and their temperature factors are much higher than those of the 25 well-ordered waters. Fifteen water molecules are displaced to form the complex, some of which are substituted by hydrophilic protein atoms, and 5 water molecules are added at the antibody- antigen interface with the formation of the complex. While the current crystal models of the D1.3-lysozyme complex do not demonstrate the increase in bound waters found in a physico-chemical study of the interaction at decreased water activities, the 25 well- ordered interface waters contribute a net gain of 10 hydrogen bonds to complex stability.

The titration behavior of the ionizable residues of the HyHEL-5-hen egg lysozyme complex and its individual components has been studied using continuum electrostatic calculations. Several residues of HyHEL-5 had pKa values shifted away from model values for isolated residues by more than three pH units. Shifts away from the model values were smaller for the residues of hen egg lysozyme. A moderate variation in the pKa values of the titratable groups was observed upon increase of the ionic strength from 0 to 100 mM, amounting to 1-2 pH units in most cases. Under physiological conditions, the net charge of HyHEL-5 was opposite that for hen egg lysozyme. Several residues, including those involved in the Arg-Glu salt bridges that have been proposed to be important in antibody-antigen binding, had pKa values that were changed significantly upon binding. The main titration event upon antibody-antigen binding appears to be loss of a proton from residue GluH50 of the Fv molecule. The limitations of our calculation methods and the role they might play in the design of antibodies for use in assays, sensors and separations are discussed.

The three-dimensional structures of the free and antigen-complexed Fabs from the mouse monoclonal anti-hen egg white lysozyme antibody D44.1 have been solved and refined by X-ray crystallographic techniques. The crystals of the free and lysozyme-bound Fabs were grown under identical conditions and their X-ray diffraction data were collected to 2.1 and 2.5 A, respectively. Two molecules of the Fab-lysozyme complex in the asymmetric unit of the crystals show nearly identical conformations and thus confirm the essential structural features of the antigen-antibody interface. Three buried water molecules enhance the surface complementarity at the interface and provide hydrogen bonds to stabilize the complex. Two hydrophobic buried holes are present at the interface which, although large enough to accommodate solvent molecules, are void. The combining site residues of the complexed FabD44.1 exhibit reduced temperature factors compared with those of the free Fab. Furthermore, small perturbations in atomic positions and rearrangements of side-chains at the combining site, and a relative rearrangement of the variable domains of the light (VL) and the heavy (VH) chains, detail a Fab accommodation of the bound lysozyme. The amino acid sequence of the VH domain, as well as the epitope of lysozyme recognized by D44.1 are very close to those previously reported for the monoclonal antibody HyHEL-5. A feature central to the FabD44.1 and FabHyHEL-5 complexes with lysozyme are three salt bridges between VH glutamate residues 35 and 50 and lysozyme arginine residues 45 and 68. The presence of the three salt bridges in the D44.1-lysozyme interface indicates that these bonds are not responsible for the 1000-fold increase in affinity for lysozyme that HyHEL-5 exhibits relative to D44.1.

The crystal structures of pheasant and guinea fowl lysozymes have been determined by X-ray diffraction methods. Guinea fowl lysozyme crystallizes in space group P6(1)22 with cell dimensions a = 89.2 A and c = 61.7 A. The structure was refined to a final crystallographic R-factor of 17.0% for 8,854 observed reflections in the resolution range 6-1.9 A. Crystals of pheasant lysozyme are tetragonal, space group P4(3)2(1)2, with a = 98.9 A, c = 69.3 A and 2 molecules in the asymmetric unit. The final R-factor is 17.8% to 2.1 A resolution. The RMS deviation from ideality is 0.010 A for bond lengths and 2.5 degrees for bond angles in both models. Three amino acid positions beneath the active site are occupied by Thr 40, Ile 55, and Ser 91 in hen, pheasant, and other avian lysozymes, and by Ser 40, Val 55, and Thr 91 in guinea fowl and American quail lysozymes. In spite of their internal location, the structural changes associated with these substitutions are small. The pheasant enzyme has an additional N-terminal glycine residue, probably resulting from an evolutionary shift in the site of cleavage of prelysozyme. In the 3-dimensional structure, this amino acid partially fills a cleft on the surface of the molecule, close to the C alpha atom of Gly 41 and absent in lysozymes from other species (which have a large side-chain residue at position 41: Gln, His, Arg, or Lys). The overall structures are similar to those of other c-type lysozymes, with the largest deviations occurring in surface loops. Comparison of the unliganded and antibody-bound models of pheasant lysozyme suggests that surface complementarity of contacting surfaces in the antigen-antibody complex is the result of local, small rearrangements in the epitope. Structural evidence based upon this and other complexes supports the notion that antigenic variation in c-type lysozymes is primarily the result of amino acid substitutions, not of gross structural changes.

The fundamental event in biological assembly is association of two biological macromolecules. Here we present a successful, accurate ab initio prediction of the binding of uncomplexed lysozyme to the HyHel5 antibody. The prediction combines pseudo Brownian Monte Carlo minimization with a biased-probability global side-chain placement procedure. It was effected in an all-atom representation, with ECEPP/2 potentials complemented with the surface energy, side-chain entropy and electrostatic polarization free energy. The near-native solution found was surprisingly close to the crystallographic structure (root-mean-square deviation of 1.57 A for all backbone atoms of lysozyme) and had a considerably lower energy (by 20 kcal mol-1) than any other solution.

Although antibodies are highly specific, cross-reactions are frequently observed. To understand the molecular basis of this phenomenon, we studied the anti-hen egg lysozyme (HEL) monoclonal antibody (mAb) D11.15, which cross-reacts with several avian lysozymes, in some cases with a higher affinity (heteroclitic binding) than for HEL. We have determined the crystal structure of the Fv fragment of D11.15 complexed with pheasant egg lysozyme (PHL). In addition, we have determined the structure of PHL, Guinea fowl egg lysozyme, and Japanese quail egg lysozyme. Differences in the affinity of D11.15 for the lysozymes appear to result from sequence substitutions in these antigens at the interface with the antibody. More generally, cross-reactivity is seen to require a stereochemically permissive environment for the variant antigen residues at the antibody-antigen interface.

The crystal structure for an antibody-antigen system, that of the anti-hen egg lysozyme monoclonal antibody HyHEL-5 complexed to lysozyme, is used as the starting point for computer simulations of diffusional encounters between the two proteins. The investigation consists of two parts: first, the linearized Poisson-Boltzmann equation is solved to determine the long-range electrostatic forces between antibody and antigen, and then, the relative motion as influenced by these forces is modeled within Brownian motion theory. The effects of various point mutations on the calculated reaction rate are considered. It is found that charged residues close to the binding site exert the greatest influence in steering the proteins into a configuration favorable for their binding, while more distant mutations are qualitatively described by the Smoluchowski model for the mutual diffusion of two uniformly charged spheres. The antibody residues involved in forming salt links with the lysozyme, Glu-H35 and Glu-H50, appear to be particularly important in electrostatic steering, as neutralization of both of them yields reaction rates that are two to three orders of magnitude below those of wild-type rates. The relative rates obtained from the simulations can be tested through kinetic measurements on mutant protein complexes. Kinetically efficient partners can also be designed and constructed through directed mutagenesis.

The complex formed between the Fab fragment of a murine monoclonal antihen egg lysozyme antibody F9.13.7 and the heterologous antigen Guinea-fowl egg lysozyme has been crystallized by the hanging drop technique. The crystals, which diffract X-rays to 3 A resolution, belong to the monoclinic space group P2(1), with a = 83.7 A, b = 195.5 A, c = 50.2 A, beta = 108.5 degrees and have two molecules of the complex in the asymmetric unit. The three-dimensional structure has been determined from a preliminary data set to 4 A using molecular replacement techniques. The lysozyme-Fab complexes are arranged with their long molecular axes approximately parallel to the crystallographic unique axis. Fab F9.13.7 binds an antigenic determinant that partially overlaps the epitope recognized by antilysozyme antibody HyHEL10.

Serologically detected antigenic determinants unique to an antibody or group of antibodies are called idiotopes. The sum of idiotopes of an antibody constitute its idiotype. Idiotypes have been intensively studied following a hypothesis for the self-regulation of the immune system through a network of idiotype-anti-idiotype interactions. Furthermore, as antigen and anti-idiotypes can competitively bind to idiotype-positive, antigen-specific antibodies, anti-idiotypes may carry an 'internal image' of the external antigen. Here we describe the structure of the complex between the monoclonal anti-lysozyme FabD1.3 and the anti-idiotopic FabE225 at 2.5 A resolution. This complex defines a private idiotope consisting of 13 amino-acid residues, mainly from the complementarity-determining regions of D1.3. Seven of these residues make contacts with the antigen, indicating a significant overlap between idiotope and antigen-combining site. Idiotopic mimicry of the external antigen is not achieved at the molecular level in this example.