Search

Bioefficacy of PermaNet was evaluated in both the laboratory and field against Anopheles culicifacies and An. stephensi, major malaria vectors in India. Contact bioassays were carried out after repeated washings and ring net bioassays to determine the median knockdown time of mosquitoes. Three villages were selected for the field trial: in the 1st village PermaNets were distributed, in the 2nd village untreated nets were distributed, and the 3rd village was a control. Entomological data were collected using standard procedures. The PermaNet contact bioassays showed high mortality (>80%) even after 20 washes against both the vector species. The median knockdown time of An. culicifacies and An. stephensi was 392 and 480 sec when exposed to fresh PermaNets and 472 and 986 sec when exposed to PermaNets that had been washed 20 times, respectively. PermaNets showed high efficacy in reducing the person-vector contact as evidenced by reduced person-hour density in the PermaNet village. Long-term field trials are indicated to test the impact of use of PermaNets in controlling malaria.

During recent years, long-lasting insecticide-treated nets (LLINs) have been developed to overcome the problems of low retreatment rates, washing, and erratic dose of the insecticide resulting in the dilution of efficacy of the conventional insecticide-treated mosquito nets. These nets are treated at factory level with insecticide either incorporated into or coated around fibers. Olyset net, a polyethylene net with 2% permethrin incorporated within fibers, is one type of LLIN. Therefore, these nets were evaluated for their wash resistance and bioefficacy against malaria vectors Anopheles culicifacies Giles and Anopheles fluviatilis James (Diptera: Culicidae) and other nontarget species. Cone bioassay tests produced 100% mortality in these two vector species with 3-min exposure. Results of the bioassays on washed nets showed 100% mortality in An. fluviatilis even after 20 washings, whereas in An. culicifacies 100% mortality up to 11 washings and 80% mortality up to 20 washings were observed. Cone bioassay tests also were performed on nontarget mosquito species Culex quinquefasciatus Say; house fly, Musca domestica L.; American cockroach, Periplaneta americana (L.); head louse, Pediculus humanus capitis De Geer; and bed bug, Cimex lectularius L. with 30-min exposure. Except for bed bugs, 100% mortality was observed in these nontarget species after 24-h recovery period. In bed bugs, only 25% mortality was observed. The density of An. culicifacies and An. fluviatilis was significantly reduced in houses with Olyset nets compared with those with untreated nets or no nets. Thus, it may be concluded that Olyset nets are highly effective against malaria vectors and moderately against other nontarget household insects.

Olyset nets are highly effective in killing anopheline mosquitoes within 3 min of exposure, as evidenced in cone bioassay tests. These nets also showed their efficacy on other vector mosquitoes (Aedes aegypti and Cx. quinquefasciatus) at higher exposure periods. The efficacy remained at approximately 90% even after 20 washings at an interval of 24 h against Anopheles culicifacies and Cx. quinquefasciatus. Use of the nets inside the house also resulted in drastic reduction of daytime resting density of mosquitoes because of high repellency, excitorepellency, and killing action of the nets. Pilot studies are indicated to evaluate the impact of use of Olyset nets on vector-borne diseases, particularly malaria, and its cost-effectiveness in comparison to conventional indoor residual spraying.

A longitudinal study was carried out to evaluate the bioefficacy of indoor residual spraying of bendiocarb 80% wettable powder (WP) at 0.2 and 0.4 g/m2 against Anopheles culicifacies, a principle malaria vector, and the impact of bendiocarb use on malaria incidence in selected villages of the Ghaziabad District, Uttar Pradesh, India. The control village was sprayed with malathion at 1 g/m2 in 2001. Two rounds of bendiocarb spraying were carried out in each year from 1999 to 2001. Bendiocarb applications resulted in significant reduction in densities of adult An. culicifacies and other mosquito species in villages when compared to that of the control village (P < 0.05). Bioassay tests revealed that persistence of insecticide against An. culicifacies at 100% mortality was observed for about 10, 8, and 10 wk on mud, cement, and brick wall surfaces, respectively. Epidemiological evaluation revealed that malaria cases were significantly reduced after 1 year of spraying (P < 0.05) and by 2001, no Plasmodium falciparum was recorded in either of the bendiocarb-sprayed villages. The study revealed that indoor residual spraying of bendiocarb 80% WP at 0.2 g/m2 produced effective control of resistant An. culicifacies, provided that >95% human-dwelling room coverage is achieved in both 1st and 2nd rounds of spraying at an interval of 10 wk in areas where malaria is a seasonal problem.

Follow-up studies were carried out from 1989 to 1998 after withdrawal of deltamethrin indoor spraying to evaluate the recovery rate of a population of Anopheles culicifacies resistant to dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDT) and hexachlorocyclohexane (HCH) in selected villages in Uttar Pradesh State, India. The study revealed 82.4-96.5% reduction in adult density of An. culicifacies and 72.7-96% reduction in malaria incidence in the area sprayed with deltamethrin at 20 mg/m2 as compared to a control area sprayed with HCH, for 5 successive years even after withdrawal of deltamethrin spray. The impact was very clear when the annual falciparum incidence was compared with that of the control area. The vector population gradually started recovering after 5 years. However, the slide falciparum rate remained below 4 even after 10 years of withdrawal of spraying. The study revealed that indoor residual spraying of deltamethrin would be cost-effective, at least in areas where malaria is transmitted by An. culicifacies, which is primarily a zoophilic species and associated with malaria epidemics. In view of this, a review of the insecticide policy and strategy of vector control is urgently needed because of the possible risks associated with the presence of nonbiodegradable insecticide in the environment, as well as to minimize the costs of operation and to enhance the useful life of insecticides.

Background & Objectives: Indoor residual spraying of Reldan 40% EC @ 0.5 and 1 g/m2 was done in Tatarpur and Chauna villages, respectively in Dhaulana PHC, Distt. Ghaziabad (U.P.) to evaluate its impact against Anopheles culicifacies and malaria incidence. Results were compared with that of Piyawali village which was taken as control area., Methods: Four rounds of spray were done from 1999--2000 in human dwellings and cattlesheds in experimental villages. Entomological parameters--man hour density, parity rate, sporozoite rate, etc. were monitored using standard procedures. Epidemiological indicators such as SPR, SFR, cases/000, Pf/000 were also calculated. Cone bioassays as per WHO method were also carried out to assess the persistence of the insecticide on different surfaces., Results: Entomological results revealed that spraying of reldan @ 0.5 g/m2 resulted in significant reduction in adult densities of An. culicifacies in sprayed villages over the control village. Spraying also resulted in reduction of percent parous females, reduction in malaria incidence (p < 0.05)., Interpretation & Conclusion: Reldan showed high efficacy @ 0.5 g/m2 in controlling the densities of An. culicifacies and malaria incidence. However, double dosage of reldan @ 1 g/m2 can be used for comprehensive vector control provided > 95% spray coverage is achieved.

Bio-efficacy and operational feasibility of alphacypermethrin treated nets was evaluated in certain villages of District Ghaziabad (U.P.). Results revealed that poly-filament nylon nets treated with alphacypermethrin suspension concentrate (g/l) formulation @ 25 mg/m2 has shown repellent action (26.5 +/- 8.1), excito repellent action (93.7 +/- 8.1) and killing action (100%) against An. culicifacies landed on treated nets. Significant reduction in indoor resting density of An. culicifacies in human dwellings was also observed in treated nets village (p < 0.05). Instant killing action of treated nets did provide complete protection to inhabitants sleeping inside the net from An. culicifacies bites. The persistent use of nets by the inhabitants has also resulted significant reduction in malaria cases (p < 0.05). It was interesting to note that not even a single case of falciparum malaria was observed after distribution of treated nets in spite of the fact that at no point of time cent per cent compliance of net usage was observed during the study period. Bio-assay tests revealed that treated nets can produce up to 70% mortality in An. culicifacies for about 22 weeks and as such only one treatment with insecticide is required in a year in seasonal transmission area to protect from malaria. The study also revealed that treated nets can be stored at room temperature for about 10 months without loosing their efficacy suggesting thereby that malaria outbreaks can be tackled by the nets if adequate treated nets are stored in core problem districts. It was also revealed that An. culicifacies is a late night biter and as such treated nets can be used successfully against this species.

Operational feasibility and bio-efficacy of alphacypermethrin treated curtains was evaluated in slum settlements of Andrews Ganj, New Delhi. Jute curtains treated with alphacypermethrin @ 100 mg/m2 were fixed on windows, doors and eves before on set of transmission and evaluations were carried out for two years. Entomological evaluation revealed that jute curtains treated with alphacypermethrin in Slum-I resulted drastic reduction in daytime indoor resting mosquitoes such as An. stephensi, Ae. aegypti and Cx. quinquefasciatus. Similarly, malaria incidence also reduced in the treated curtain used area when compared to that of in untreated curtain and without curtain areas. Bioassay tests on An. stephensi and Cx. quinquefasciatus showed that alphacypermethrin could produce > 70 per cent mortality up to six months in case of An. stephensi--a principal urban malaria vector and hence two rounds of treatment are sufficient in an year to protect inhabitants from malaria. The study indicates alphacypermethrin treated curtains could curtail malaria transmission in slum settlements and is operationally feasible in small houses and is also cost-effective.

A field trial was conducted in Block F of the Moti Bagh area of New Delhi Municipal Committee to demonstrate composite control of Anopheles stephensi and Aedes aegypti by spraying deltamethrin at 100 mg/m2 on window and door curtains of habitations. Results revealed drastic reduction (87.9-93.7%, P < 0.05) of target species in the experimental area. The impact of deltamethrin-treated curtains was also evident against nontarget species (67.9-85.7%. P < 0.05). Treated curtains provided 100% kill of An. stephensi and Ae. aegypti for 3-4 months, followed by a gradual decline in successive months. Use of deltamethrin-treated curtains resulted in 92.0 reduction in slide positivity rate and 95.4% reduction in malaria cases per thousand population. The cost of deltamethrin treatment was Rs 41.15 (<$1 U.S.) per house per annum. Insecticide-treated mosquito window and door curtains, along with legislative measures, may provide cost-effective concurrent control of mosquitoes and other domestic pests.

A study was carried out in selected villages of District Ghaziabad to evaluate the operational feasibility and efficacy of hessian curtains impregnated with deltamethrin@100 mg/m2 in comparison to indoor residual spraying of HCH@0.2 g/m2. The impregnation was carried out before onset of transmission and observations were continued up to two transmission periods. District Health Authorities have carried out HCH indoor residual spraying (IRS) as per schedule in the control village. Entomological evaluation revealed 87 per cent reduction of An. culicifacies up to six months in comparison to HCH indoor residual spraying. However, the reduction in densities of total mosquitoes was only 61.6 per cent. Follow-up studies revealed that the impact of deltamethrin impregnated curtains was diluted after 6-7 months. The results of bioassay tests revealed 100 per cent mortality up to 6-7 months. Epidemiological evaluation revealed 81.9 per cent reduction in total malaria cases as against 88.5 per cent with P. falciparum cases. Similar reduction was also observed when slide positivity rate (SPR), slide falciparum rate (SfR), cases/000 and Pf/000 were compared to corresponding village. Pilot studies are indicated to evaluate the relative efficacy of impregnated curtains, which is quite cheaper than conventional residual insecticide spraying (IRS).

The efficacy of synthetic pyrethroid-impregnated fabrics was evaluated against Anopheles stephensi, Aedes aegypti, and Culex quinquefasciatus, under laboratory conditions. Results revealed that delta-methrin was significantly superior in comparison to lambdacyhalothrin and cyfluthrin. Results of bioassay tests revealed that deltamethrin was 1.5 and 1.9 times more effective than lambdacyhalothrin and cyfluthrin, respectively, against An. stephensi exposed to cotton fabric treated at 100 g/m2. Deltamethrin was 3.9 and 4.6 times more effective against Ae. aegypti and 3.53 and 4.0 times more effective against Cx. quinquefasciatus. Of cotton, nylon, polyethylene, and jute fabrics, the cotton was the best on the basis of median lethal dose (LD50) and 95% lethal dose (LD90) values and persistence of insecticide.

Residual efficacy of deltamethrin 2.5 wp on various types of surfaces was tested against Anopheles culicifacies under field conditions using WHO standard procedure. Deltamethrin was most effective on the thatched surface and produced 100% mortality of An. culicifacies adults up to 12 weeks, even when exposed at the lowest dose /12.5 mg/m2. It was least effective on brick surface and 100% mortality was observed only for three weeks. The efficacy was observed for 8 and 7 weeks on mud and cement surfaces, respectively. However, at the higher rate of application, i.e. 25 mg/m2, 100% mortality of this species was obtained for 12, 10, 9 and 12 weeks on mud, cement, brick and thatch surfaces, respectively.

A feasibility study to identify mosquitogenic conditions in six study sites in and around Delhi (Bhalaswa lake, Nazafgarh drain, Seelampur lake, Sanjay lake, Okhla barrage and Hindon barrage) using Indian Remote Sensing Satellites was carried out. The water bodies with marshy areas, vegetation and human settlements were considered as environmental variables responsible for mosquitogenic conditions. Multidate IRS 1A and B, LISS-II satellite data were collected and analysed on Vax 11/780 computers. False colour composite (FCC) images were generated and land cover assessed using supervised classification based on ground truth training sets. Ground truth validation of satellite data was done on satellite pass dates. Concurrent monitoring of larval and adult mosquito density was performed by selecting sub-sites in each study site. The results indicate that mosquitogenic conditions can be identified (with limitation of resolution, i.e. 36.5 m) using FCC images and these images can be used as base maps of study sites. Characterization of study sites based on land cover was done from the view point of mosquitogenic conditions. Spatial changes in mosquito density vis-a-vis changes in environmental variables revealed positive correlation with water bodies and vegetation in some study sites.

A field trial in Beel Akbarpur village, Dadri PHC, District Ghaziabad (U.P.) was carried out to test the impact of burning neem oil in kerosene lamp from dusk-to-dawn in living rooms on vector populations and incidence of malaria. Results revealed that burning 1% neem oil in kerosene lamps resulted in the deviation of An. culicifacies from living rooms to cattlesheds. This was also reflected when malaria incidence was compared in experimental and control villages. Cases/000 and Pf/000 were 1.03 and 0.0 in experimental village as against 9.6 and 4.3 in control village. Discontinuation of burning 1% neem oil in kerosene lamp resulted in recurrence of An. culicifacies in living rooms and increase in malaria incidence in experimental village.

Field studies were carried out to determine the relative efficacy of repellant action of vegetable, essential and chemical base oils against vector mosquitoes. Results revealed that essential oils viz. Cymbopogan martinii martinii var. Sofia (palmarosa), Cymbopogan citratus (lemon grass) and Cymbopogan nardus (citronella) oils are as effective as chemical base oil namely mylol. These oils provide almost complete protection against Anopheles culicifacies and other anopheline species. Per cent protection against Culex quinquefasciatus ranged between 95-96%. Camphor (C. camphora) oil also showed repellent action and provided 97.6% protection against An. culicifacies and 80.7% against Cx. quinquefasciatus. Vegetable oils namely mustard (B. compestris) and coconut (C. nucisera) showed repellent action, however the efficacy of these oils was not much pronounced against Cx. quinquefasciatus. Results of statistical analysis revealed significant difference between vegetable and essential oils (p < 0.01) against tested species of mosquitoes. Essential oils were found marginally superior in repellancy than camphor and mylol (p < 0.01) against An. culicifacies and Cx. quinquefasciatus.

Laboratory evaluation revealed that the Spherimos and Vectolex formulations of Bacillus sphaericus produced 97 and 100% larval mortality respectively in Culex quinquefasciatus at a dose as low as 0.008 ml/sq m as against 93 and 97% mortality respectively at 1 ml/sq m in Anopheles stephensi. However, in An. culicifacies similar level of mortality was not observed even at 10 ml/sq m of these formulations. Field evaluation revealed 100% reduction of Cx. quinquefasciatus larvae for 2-3 weeks in pools and wells with single application of Spherimos @ 2 ml/sq m as against 95.4% reduction @ 10 ml/sq m in irrigation channel for one week. Vectolex @ 10 ml/sq m provided 99-100% reduction of Cx. quinquefasciatus larvae up to 9 weeks in wells and 1 week in channels.

A village-scale field trial was carried out to assess the operational feasibility and efficacy of smouldering 250 ppm esbiothrin-impregnated rope in repelling mosquitoes and its impact on transmission of malaria. Entomological monitoring revealed that smoke from smouldering rope resulted in 67.2-97.9% reduction of An. culicifacies densities in human and mixed dwellings. The reduction was obviously due to diversion of An. culicifacies population to cattlesheds where ropes were not burnt. The impact was more pronounced when indoor mosquito landing rate on human bait was compared with that of experimental and control areas. This was also reflected in reduced anthropophilic index and curtailment of malaria transmission in experimental area.

An indigenous and appropriate method of personal protection was developed and tested in rural areas. It consists of an ordinary kerosene lamp made of tin with a regulator to adjust the wick. Different concentrations of esbiothrin, a synthetic pyrethroid, were mixed in kerosene and allowed to burn in living rooms and cattlesheds from dusk to dawn to observe hourly entry of mosquitoes. The tin lamp (100 ml capacity) without chimney provided the most efficient protection from mosquito bites. The protection varied from 84.2 +/- 8.2 to 97.8 +/- 2.8. Maximum protection was observed against An. culicifacies. Esbiothrin kerosene lamp (0.01%) lighted in living room provided 99.7% protection to exposed human baits seated at a distance of 1 m from the lamp. The technique is simple, cost-effective and does not require electricity and can be used both for illumination and repelling mosquitoes in remote and inaccesible areas.

Ropes were impregnated with different dosages of deltamethrin and burnt throughout the night in human dwellings and cattlesheds. Smoke from smouldering ropes treated with various dose levels gradually saturated rooms and prevented the entry of mosquitoes. This method provided very good protection from mosquito bites including the principal vector of malaria, A. culicifacies. Results of ropes impregnated with 80 ppm deltamethrin were more consistent than at the lower dosage. The technique is indigenous, cost-effective, simple and appropriate for rural areas and does not require any special skills in its application.