Search

Development of drug resistance during cancer chemotherapy is one of the major causes of chemotherapeutic failure for the majority of clinical agents. The aim of this study was to investigate the underlying molecular mechanism of resistance developed by the mitotic kinesin Eg5 against the potent second-generation ispinesib analogue SB743921 (1), a phase I/II clinical candidate. Biochemical and biophysical data demonstrate that point mutations in the inhibitor-binding pocket decrease the efficacy of 1 by several 1000-fold. Surprisingly, the structures of wild-type and mutant Eg5 in complex with 1 display no apparent structural changes in the binding configuration of the drug candidate. Furthermore, ITC and modeling approaches reveal that resistance to 1 is not through conventional steric effects at the binding site but through reduced flexibility and changes in energy fluctuation pathways through the protein that influence its function. This is a phenomenon we have called "resistance by allostery".

Kinesins are a family of molecular motors that travel unidirectionally along microtubule tracks to fulfil their many roles in intracellular transport or cell division. Over the past few years kinesins that are involved in mitosis have emerged as potential targets for cancer drug development. Several compounds that inhibit two mitotic kinesins (EG5 (also known as KIF11) and centromere-associated protein E (CENPE)) have entered Phase I and II clinical trials either as monotherapies or in combination with other drugs. Additional mitotic kinesins are currently being validated as drug targets, raising the possibility that the range of kinesin-based drug targets may expand in the future.

The human kinesin Eg5 is a potential drug target for cancer chemotherapy. Eg5 specific inhibitors cause cells to block in mitosis with a characteristic monoastral spindle phenotype. Prolonged metaphase block eventually leads to apoptotic cell death. S-trityl-L-cysteine (STLC) is a tight-binding inhibitor of Eg5 that prevents mitotic progression. It has proven antitumor activity as shown in the NCI 60 tumor cell line screen. It is of considerable interest to define the minimum chemical structure that is essential for Eg5 inhibition and to develop more potent STLC analogues. An initial structure-activity relationship study on a series of STLC analogues reveals the minimal skeleton necessary for Eg5 inhibition as well as indications of how to obtain more potent analogues. The most effective compounds investigated with substitutions at the para-position of one phenyl ring have an estimated K i (app) of 100 nM in vitro and induce mitotic arrest with an EC 50 of 200 nM.

We have designed and synthesized a series of monastrol derivatives, an allosteric inhibitor of Eg5, a motor protein responsible for the formation and maintenance of the bipolar spindle in mitotic cells. Sterically demanding structural modifications have been introduced on the skeleton of the parent drug either via a multicomponent Biginelli reaction or a stepwise modification of monastrol. The ability of these compounds to inhibit Eg5 activity has been investigated using two in vitro steady-state ATPase assays (basal and microtubule-stimulated) as well as a cell-based assay. One compound in the series appeared more potent than monastrol by a fivefold factor. Three other compounds that were unable to inhibit Eg5 ATPase activity in vitro proved potent Eg5 inhibitors in the cell-based assay. The results obtained led to the identification of structure-activity relationships further used to design an affinity matrix that can be used for fast and efficient purification of Eg5 from crude lysate of eukaryotic cells.

The mitotic kinesin Eg5 plays an essential role in establishing the bipolar spindle. Recently, several antimitotic inhibitors have been shown to share a common binding region on Eg5. Considering the importance of Eg5 as a potential drug target for cancer chemotherapy it is essential to understand the molecular mechanism, by which these agents block Eg5 activity, and to determine the "key residues" crucial for inhibition. Eleven residues in the inhibitor binding pocket were mutated and the effects were monitored by kinetic analysis and mass spectrometry. Mutants R119A, D130A, P131A, I136A, V210A, Y211A and L214A abolish the inhibitory effect of monastrol. Results for W127A and R221A are less striking, but inhibitor constants are still considerably modified compared to wild-type Eg5. Only one residue, Leu214, was found to be essential for inhibition by STLC. W127A, D130A, V210A lead to increased K(i)(app) values, but binding of STLC is still tight. R119A, P131A, Y211A and R221A convert STLC into a classical rather than a tight-binding inhibitor with increased inhibitor constants. These results demonstrate that monastrol and STLC interact with different amino acids within the same binding region, suggesting that this site is highly flexible to accommodate different types of inhibitors. The drug specificity is due to multiple interactions not only with loop L5, but also with residues located in helices alpha2 and alpha3. These results suggest that tumour cells might develop resistance to Eg5 inhibitors, by expressing Eg5 point mutants that retain the enzyme activity, but prevent inhibition, a feature that is observed for certain tubulin inhibitors.

Human Eg5, responsible for the formation of the bipolar mitotic spindle, has been identified recently as one of the targets of S-trityl-L-cysteine, a potent tumor growth inhibitor in the NCI 60 tumor cell line screen. Here we show that in cell-based assays S-trityl-L-cysteine does not prevent cell cycle progression at the S or G(2) phases but inhibits both separation of the duplicated centrosomes and bipolar spindle formation, thereby blocking cells specifically in the M phase of the cell cycle with monoastral spindles. Following removal of S-trityl-L-cysteine, mitotically arrested cells exit mitosis normally. In vitro, S-trityl-L-cysteine targets the catalytic domain of Eg5 and inhibits Eg5 basal and microtubule-activated ATPase activity as well as mant-ADP release. S-trityl-L-cysteine is a tight binding inhibitor (estimation of K(i,app) <150 nm at 300 mm NaCl and 600 nm at 25 mm KCl). S-trityl-L-cysteine binds more tightly than monastrol because it has both an approximately 8-fold faster association rate and approximately 4-fold slower release rate (6.1 microM(-1) s(-1) and 3.6 s(-1) for S-trityl-L-cysteine versus 0.78 microM(-1) s(-1) and 15 s(-1) for monastrol). S-trityl-L-cysteine inhibits Eg5-driven microtubule sliding velocity in a reversible fashion with an IC(50) of 500 nm. The S and D-enantiomers of S-tritylcysteine are nearly equally potent, indicating that there is no significant stereospecificity. Among nine different human kinesins tested, S-trityl-L-cysteine is specific for Eg5. The results presented here together with the proven effect on human tumor cell line growth make S-trityl-L-cysteine a very attractive starting point for the development of more potent mitotic inhibitors.

An experimental procedure associating both hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (H/D-MS) and mutagenesis was developed to identify the protein-binding region of small inhibitors targeting the motor domain of the human mitotic kinesin Eg5. All the tested inhibitors decrease the deuterium incorporation rate of the same peptides corresponding to the following secondary structure elements: loop L5/helix alpha2 (region Tyr125-Glu145) and strand beta5/helix alpha3 (region Ile202-Leu227). Replacement of these two regions by the equivalent ones from N. crassa conventional kinesin heavy chain completely abolishes the modification of the deuterium incorporation rate by the inhibitors as well as their effects on the basal ATPase activity. The six tested inhibitors thus share a common binding site on Eg5. The strategy reported here allows the regions of a protein involved in ligand binding to be rapidly pinpointed and can be applied to other proteins and used as a general in vitro screening procedure to identify compounds targeting specific binding regions., (Copyright (c) 2006 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.)

Human Eg5, a mitotic motor of the kinesin superfamily, is involved in the formation and maintenance of the mitotic spindle. The recent discovery of small molecules that inhibit HsEg5 by binding to its catalytic motor domain leading to mitotic arrest has attracted more interest in Eg5 as a potential anticancer drug target. We have used hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry and directed mutagenesis to identify the secondary structure elements that form the binding sites of new Eg5 inhibitors, in particular for S-trityl-l-cysteine, a potent inhibitor of Eg5 activity in vitro and in cell-based assays. The binding of this inhibitor modifies the deuterium incorporation rate of eight peptides that define two areas within the motor domain: Tyr125-Glu145 and Ile202-Leu227. Replacement of the Tyr125-Glu145 region with the equivalent region in the Neurospora crassa conventional kinesin heavy chain prevents the inhibition of the Eg5 ATPase activity by S-trityl-l-cysteine. We show here that S-trityl-l-cysteine and monastrol both bind to the same region on Eg5 by induced fit in a pocket formed by helix alpha3-strand beta5 and loop L5-helix alpha2, and both inhibitors trigger similar local conformational changes within the interaction site. It is likely that S-trityl-l-cysteine and monastrol inhibit HsEg5 by a similar mechanism. The common inhibitor binding region appears to represent a "hot spot" for HsEg5 that could be exploited for further inhibitor screening.

Human Eg5, a member of the kinesin superfamily, plays a key role in mitosis, as it is required for the formation of a bipolar spindle. We describe here the first in vitro microtubule-activated ATPase-based assay for the identification of small-molecule inhibitors of Eg5. We screened preselected libraries obtained from the National Cancer Institute and identified S-trityl-L-cysteine as the most effective Eg5 inhibitor with an IC50 of 1.0 micromol/L for the inhibition of basal ATPase activity and 140 nmol/L for the microtubule-activated ATPase activity. Subsequent cell-based assays revealed that S-trityl-L-cysteine induced mitotic arrest in HeLa cells (IC50, 700 nmol/L) with characteristic monoastral spindles. S-trityl-L-cysteine is 36 times more potent for inducing mitotic arrest than the well-studied inhibitor, monastrol. Gossypol, flexeril, and two phenothiazine analogues were also identified as Eg5 inhibitors, and we found that they all result in monoastral spindles in HeLa cells. It is notable that all the Eg5 inhibitors identified here have been shown previously to inhibit tumor cell line growth in the NCI 60 tumor cell line screen, and we conclude that their antitumor activity may at least in part be explained by their ability to inhibit Eg5 activity.

Abstract: Determining the mechanism of action of drugs and their target specificity in cells remains a major challenge. Here we describe the use of cell lines expressing two point mutations in the allosteric inhibitor binding pocket of the mitotic kinesin Eg5 (D130A, in the loop L5 region and L214A in helix α3), which following transfection, were selected for their ability to proliferate normally in the presence of STLC, a well known Eg5 inhibitor. The cell lines were used to discriminate the mechanism of action of other chemically distinct small molecule inhibitors of Eg5 that differ in their mode of action. The STLC resistant cells were capable of continuous proliferation in the presence of ATP uncompetitive inhibitors, such as K858 and dimethylenastron, but were still sensitive to ATP competitive inhibitors that are thought to bind to a distinct site on Eg5 than the allosteric binding pocket. The STLC resistant cell lines can therefore be used as a filter to distinguish Eg5 loop L5 binding drugs from drugs binding to other pockets without prior structural information. Additionally, the cells can be used to analyze whether inhibitors of Eg5 are specific to this potential drug target or whether they have additional targets in dividing cells. [Copyright &y& Elsevier]

Abstract: The kinesin Eg5 plays an essential role in bipolar spindle formation. A variety of structurally diverse inhibitors of the human kinesin Eg5, including monastrol and STLC, share the same binding pocket on Eg5, composed by helix α2/loop L5, and helix α3 of the Eg5 motor domain. Previous biochemical analysis in the inhibitor binding pocket of Eg5 identified key residues in the inhibitor binding pocket of Eg5 that in the presence of either monastrol or STLC exhibited ATPase activities similar to the untreated wild type Eg5. Here we evaluated the ability of full-length human Eg5 carrying point mutations in the drug binding pocket to confer resistance in HeLa and U2OS cells to either monastrol or STLC, as measured by the formation of bipolar spindles. Both transfected cells expressing wild type Eg5 and untransfected cells were equally sensitive to both inhibitors. Expression of Eg5 single point mutants R119A, D130A, L132A, I136A, L214A and E215A conferred significant resistance to monastrol. Certain mutations inducing monastrol resistance such as R119A, D130A and L214A also conferred significant resistance to STLC. For the first time at a cellular level, the propensity of selected Eg5 point mutants to confer drug resistance confirms the target specificity of monastrol and STLC for Eg5. These data also suggest a possible mechanism by which drug resistance may occur in tumors treated with agents targeting Eg5. [Copyright &y& Elsevier]

Kinesins comprise a superfamily of molecular motors that drive a wide variety of cellular physiologies, from cytoplasmic transport to formation of the bipolar spindle in mitosis. These differing roles are reflected in corresponding polymorphisms in key kinesin structural elements. One of these is a unique loop and stem motif found in all kinesins and referred to as loop 5 (L5). This loop is longest in the mitotic kinesin Eg5 and is the target for a number of small molecule inhibitors, including ispinesib, which is being used in clinical trials in patients with cancer. In this study, we have used x-ray crystallography to identify a new structure of an Eg5-ispinesib complex and have combined this with transient state kinetics to identify a plausible sequence of conformational changes that occur in response to ispinesib binding. Our results demonstrate that ispinesib-induced structural changes in L5 from Eg5 lead to subsequent changes in the conformation of the switch II loop and helix and in the neck linker.Weconclude that L5 in Eg5 simultaneously regulates the structure of both the ATP binding site and the motor's mechanical elements that generate force. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The human kinetochore is a highly complex macromolecular structure that connects chromosomes to spindle microtubules (MTs) in order to facilitate accurate chromosome segregation. Centromere-associated protein E (CENP-E), a member of the kinesin superfamily, is an essential component of the kinetochore, since it is required to stabilize the attachment of chromosomes to spindle MTs, to develop tension across aligned chromosomes, to stabilize spindle poles and to satisfy the mitotic checkpoint. Here we report the 2.5 Å resolution crystal structure of the motor domain and linker region of human CENP-E with MgADP bound in the active site. This structure displays subtle but important differences compared to the structures of human Eg5 and conventional kinesin. Our structure reveals that the CENP-E linker region is in a “docked” position identical to that in the human plus-end directed conventional kinesin. CENP-E has many advantages as a potential anti-mitotic drug target and this crystal structure of human CENP-E will provide a starting point for high throughput virtual screening of potential inhibitors. [Copyright &y& Elsevier]

The microtubule-dependent kinesin-like protein Eg5 from Homo sapiens is involved in the assembly of the mitotic spindle. It shows a three-domain structure with an N-terminal motor domain, a central coiled coil, and a C-terminal tail domain. In vivo HsEg5 is reversibly inhibited by monastrol, a small cell-permeable molecule that causes cells to be arrested in mitosis. Both monomeric and dimeric Eg5 constructs have been examined in order to define the minimal monastrol binding domain on HsEg5. NMR relaxation experiments show that monastrol interacts with all of the Eg5 constructs used in this study. Enzymatic techniques indicate that monastrol partially inhibits Eg5 ATPase activity by binding directly to the motor domain. The binding is noncompetitive with respect to microtubules, indicating that monastrol does not interfere with the formation of the motor-MT complex. The binding is not competitive with respect to ATP. Both enzymology and in vivo assays show that the S enantiomer of monastrol is more active than the R enantiomer and racemic monastrol. Stopped-flow fluorometry indicates that monastrol inhibits ADP release by forming an Eg5-ADP-monastrol ternary complex. Monastrol reversibly inhibits the motility of human Eg5. Monastrol has no inhibitory effect on the following members of the kinesin superfamily: MC5 (Drosophila melanogaster Ncd), HK379 (H. sapiens conventional kinesin), DKH392 (D. melanogaster conventional kinesin), BimC1-428 (Aspergillus nidulans BimC), Klp15 (Caenorhabditis elegans C-terminal motor), or Nkin460GST (Neurospora crassa conventional kinesin). [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]