Search

In this report we examined overlap between superantigen (SAg) and Toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) stimulation of the innate immune system. Before in vivo stimulation we found that mouse splenic DCs expressed unexpectedly low levels of surface TLR4 compared to macrophages. In response to LPS, TLR4 gene expression in fractionated spleen cells was downregulated. By comparison, surface TLR4 staining with the Sa15-21 mAb showed little downregulation, and the anti-TLR4 MTS510 mAb showed decreased staining, suggesting that LPS was bound to TLR4 at the time points examined. Interestingly, SAg stimulation induced decreased TLR4 staining as measured by the MTS510 mAb, even though the TLR4 gene was not downregulated. Nevertheless, LPS potently induced DCs to produce TNF and IL-12, but SAg did not, even though they efficiently activated DCs. Notwithstanding, in vivo stimulation with staphylococcal enterotoxin SAg conditioned the innate immune system to hyper-respond to various pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs). Specifically, pre-priming with SAg enhanced LPS-mediated DC synthesis of TNF and IL-12. Thus, SAgs may exert their pathogenesis on the host by conditioning DCs, in a T cell activation dependent manner to potentiate responses to PAMPs.

After in vivo immunization, Ag-specific T cells disappear from circulation and become sequestered in lymphoid tissue where they encounter Ag presented by dendritic cells. In the same site and just after Ag presentation, they "disappear" a second time and we investigated this process. Using a mouse model of T cell deletion (without Toll-like receptor (TLR) stimulation) vs survival (with TLR stimulation), Ag-specific T cells indeed became undetectable by flow cytometry, however were readily detected by immunohistochemistry. Thus, whether or not the activated T cells were destined to delete or survive, they were difficult to extract from lymphoid tissue and did not disappear but in fact were abundantly present. Nevertheless, profound differences were observed during this time period when tolerizing conditions were compared with immunizing conditions. TLR stimulation induced an increase in CD25 expression, acquisition of surface MHC class II, and abnormally high increases in forward and side scatter of the peptide-specific T cells. Using a modified adoptive transfer approach, we demonstrated by flow cytometry that in the presence of TLR stimulation the Ag-specific T cells were tightly coupled to dendritic cells, explaining the unusual increases in size and granularity. Ultimately, these events induced the specific T cells to differentiate into memory cells. We postulate that this is a stage where T cells are either conditioned to survive or to delete depending upon the activation status of the innate immune system.

To better understand how innate and adaptive immune responses interact with each other, we combined 4-1BB T cell costimulation with specific adjuvants to determine whether these treatments would influence specific T cell expansion and function in vivo. In the presence of 4-1BB ligation and Toll-like receptor 3 (TLR)3 and/or TLR4 triggering, CD8 T cell clonal expansion and survival was augmented profoundly. Specific T cells primed in vivo with TLR ligands responded normally to in vitro recall stimulus, but, surprisingly, copriming with 4-1BB costimulation significantly impaired the recall response even though many more specific effector T cells were rescued in vivo. Here, we demonstrate that the rescued CD8 T cells suppressed CD4 T cell proliferation via a type beta transforming growth factor-dependent mechanism. Thus, 4-1BB and TLR ligands induce survival of specific effector CD8 T cells with suppressive recall potential, which may explain the dual role that 4-1BB activation plays in mediating tumor clearance and prevention of autoimmune disease.