Search

Poisoning by organophosphorus compounds (OP) still poses a major medical challenge. Diagnosis of clinical signs of OP poisoning is still the most important parameter for the initiation of specific treatment. However, in case of unspecific signs and of delayed onset of cholinergic crisis a rapid, reliable and on-site analysis of acetylcholinesterase (AChE) and butyrylcholinesterase (BChE) activity would be of great value. Recently the ChE check mobile, a CE-certified ready to use kit for the determination of whole blood AChE and BChE activities, was developed. Here, we evaluated whole blood AChE and BChE reference values with samples taken from 181 male and 61 female volunteers and analyzed them on-site with the ChE check mobile test kit. The analysis of the data revealed a large inter-individual variability (BChE>AChE), only a small sex difference for AChE but a significant difference for BChE activities. The now available normal range values enable an evaluation of determined AChE and BChE activities in case of suspected exposure to OP nerve agents and pesticides. However, the large inter-individual variability of AChE and BChE activities calls for the determination of pre-exposure values in specific subpopulations in order to enable the diagnosis of low-level OP exposure.

The treatment of nerve agent poisoning is still a major challenge for medical services. The high toxicity of these agents calls for specific methods for self-protection, e.g. wearing full personal protective gear, for as long as contamination cannot be excluded. Patients are at risk due to the fast onset of life threatening cholinergic crisis. Accordingly, therapy has to start as early as possible. As inhibition of acetylcholinesterase is considered to be the main toxic mechanism of nerve agents, treatment is directed towards antagonizing the effects of cholinergic overstimulation. To this end, atropine has to be applied according to the severity of poisoning. In order to achieve a fast and adequate therapeutic effect, it appears rational to start with a bolus dose of 2 mg that should be doubled every 5–10 minutes for as long as there is no clinical benefit. In severe cases, atropine therapy should be maintained by continuous infusion. For reactivation of inhibited acetylcholinesterase, oximes also have to be administered as soon as possible at adequate doses and for as long as sufficient reactivation may be expected. For therapy of convulsions and reduction of neurotoxic effects, benzodiazepines should be administered. In addition, further supportive measures, e.g. artificial ventilation, should be used to improve the clinical situation of the patient.

The repeated misuse of highly toxic organophosphorus compound (OP) based chemical warfare agents in military conflicts and terrorist attacks poses a continuous threat to the military and civilian sector. The toxic symptomatology of OP poisoning is mainly caused by inhibition of acetylcholinesterase (AChE, E.C. 3.1.1.7) resulting in generalized cholinergic crisis due to accumulation of the neurotransmitter acetylcholine (ACh) in synaptic clefts. Beside atropine as competitive antagonist of ACh at muscarinic ACh receptors oximes as reactivators of OP-inhibited AChE are a mainstay of standard antidotal treatment. However, human AChE inhibited by certain OP is rather resistant to oxime-induced reactivation. The development of more effective oxime-based reactivators may fill the gaps. To get more insight into a potential structure–activity relationship between human AChE, OPs and oximes in vitro studies were conducted to investigate interactions of different tabun and sarin analogues with human AChE and the oximes obidoxime and HI 6 by determination of various kinetic constants. Rate constants for the inhibition of human AChE by OPs, spontaneous dealkylation and reactivation as well as reactivation by obidoxime and HI 6 of OP-inhibited human AChE were determined. The recorded kinetic data did not allow a general statement concerning a structure–activity relationship between human AChE, OP and oximes.

Despite extensive research for more than six decades on medical countermeasures against poisoning by organophosphorus compounds (OP) the treatment options are meagre. The presently established acetylcholinesterase (AChE) reactivators (oximes), e.g. obidoxime and pralidoxime, are insufficient against a number of nerve agents and there is ongoing debate on the benefit of oxime treatment in human OP pesticide poisoning. Up to now, the therapeutic efficacy of oximes was mostly evaluated in animal models but substantial species differences prevent direct extrapolation of animal data to humans. Hence, it was considered essential to establish relevant experimental in vitro models for the investigation of oximes as antidotes and to develop computer models for the simulation of oxime efficacy in different scenarios of OP poisoning. Kinetic studies on the various interactions between erythrocyte AChE from various species, structurally different OP and different oximes provided a basis for the initial assessment of the ability of oximes to reactivate inhibited AChE. In the present study, in vitro enzyme-kinetic and pharmacokinetic data from a minipig model of dimethoate poisoning and oxime treatment were used to calculate dynamic changes of AChE activities. It could be shown that there is a close agreement between calculated and in vivo AChE activities. Moreover, computer simulations provided insight into the potential and limitations of oxime treatment. In the end, such data may be a versatile tool for the ongoing discussion of the pros and cons of oxime treatment in human OP pesticide poisoning.

The standard treatment of poisoning by organophosphorus compounds (OP) includes the reversible muscarine receptor antagonist atropine and oximes for the reactivation of OP-inhibited acetylcholinesterase (AChE). There is an ongoing discussion on the benefit of oxime therapy in OP pesticide poisoning, and experimental data indicate a limited efficacy of oximes against various nerve agents. Oxime effectiveness can be quantified in vitro by determination of the reactivity (k(r)) and affinity constants (1/K(D)). These constants can be used to calculate reactivation velocities and oxime concentrations necessary for the reactivation of a desired fraction of inhibited AChE. Model calculations indicate that a k(r) 0.1 min(-1) and K(D) 100 µM are minimal requirements for oxime effectiveness when reactivation is performed in the absence of free OP. In addition, the findings demonstrate that selective increase of either reactivity or affinity of an oxime would be insufficient. Hereby, it has to be taken into account that an increase of affinity to OP-inhibited AChE is generally accompanied by an increased affinity to native AChE and subsequent reduction in oxime tolerance. Hence, future developments of more effective oximes should consider kinetic demands by attempting to achieve a certain level of reactivity and affinity, preferentially towards OP-inhibited AChE.

hBChE [human BChE (butyrylcholinesterase)] naturally scavenges OPs (organophosphates). This bioscavenger is currently in Clinical Phase I for pretreatment of OP intoxication. Phosphylated ChEs (cholinesterases) can undergo a spontaneous time-dependent process called ‘aging’ during which the conjugate is dealkylated, leading to creation of an enzyme that cannot be reactivated. hBChE inhibited by phosphoramidates such as tabun displays a peculiar resistance to oxime-mediated reactivation. We investigated the basis of oxime resistance of phosphoramidyl–BChE conjugates by determining the kinetics of inhibition, reactivation (obidoxime {1,1′-(oxybis-methylene) bis[4-(hydroxyimino) methyl] pyridinium dichloride}, TMB-4 [1,3-trimethylene-bis(4-hydroxyiminomethylpyridinium) dibromide], HLö 7 {1-[[[4-(aminocarbonyl) pyridinio]methoxy]methyl]-2,4-bis-[(hydroxyimino)methyl] pyridinium dimethanesulfonate)}, HI-6 {1-[[[4-(aminocarbonyl) pyridinio] methoxy] methyl]-2-[(hydroxyimino)methyl]pyridinium dichloride monohydrate} and aging, and the crystal structures of hBChE inhibited by different N-monoalkyl and N,N-dialkyl tabun analogues. The refined structures of aged hBChE conjugates show that aging proceeds through O-dealkylation of the P(R) enantiomer of N,N-diethyl and N-propyl analogues, with subsequent formation of a salt bridge preventing reactivation, similarly to a previous observation made on tabun–ChE conjugates. Interestingly, the N-methyl analogue projects its amino group towards the choline-binding pocket, so that aging proceeds through deamination. This orientation results from a preference of hBChE's acyl-binding pocket for larger than 2-atoms linear substituents. The correlation between the inhibitory potency and the N-monoalkyl chain length is related to increasingly optimized interactions with the acyl-binding pocket as shown by the X-ray structures. These kinetics and X-ray data lead to a structure–activity relationship that highlights steric and electronic effects of the amino substituent of phosphoramidate. This study provides the structural basis to design new oximes capable of reactivating phosphoramidyl-hBChE conjugates after intoxication, notably when hBChE is used as pretreatment, or to design BChE-based catalytic bioscavengers.

Previous kinetic studies investigating the interactions between human acetylcholinesterase (AChE), structurally different organophosphorus compounds (OP) and oximes did not reveal a conclusive structure–activity relationship of the different reactions. The only exception was for a homologous series of methylphosphonofluoridates bearing C1–C4 O-n- or O-i-alkyl residues. Hence, it was tempting to investigate the kinetic interactions between different pentylsarin analogues, human AChE and two oximes, obidoxime and HI 6, in order to increase the understanding of structure–activity relationship between highly toxic OP and human AChE. The rate constants for the inhibition of human erythrocyte AChE by four pentylsarin compounds (ki), for the spontaneous dealkylation (aging, ka) and reactivation (ks) of inhibited AChE as well as for the oxime-induced reactivation of inhibited AChE by obidoxime and HI 6 reflected by the dissociation constant (KD) and the reactivity constant (kr) were determined. All pentylsarin analogues had a high inhibitory potency towards AChE. Inhibited AChE was subject to spontaneous reactivation which outweighed aging substantially. Pentylsarin-inhibited AChE could be reactivated by oximes, HI 6 being more potent than obidoxime. The determination of inhibition, reactivation and aging kinetics of pentylsarin analogues with human AChE extends the database on interactions between AChE and methylphosphonofluoridate homologues with C1–C4 n- and i-alkyl residues demonstrating a structure–activity relationship depending on the chain length with certain differences regarding inhibition and post-inhibitory reactions. Unfortunately, no structure–activity relationship could be observed for the oxime-induced reactivation of inhibited AChE. In view of previous results with numerous structurally different organophosphates, organophosphonates and phosphoramidates it has to be concluded that up to now kinetic studies did not provide decisive information for the development of more effective oxime-based reactivators.

The availability of highly toxic organophosphorus (OP) warfare agents (nerve agents) underlines the necessity for an effective medical treatment. Acute OP toxicity is primarily caused by inhibition of acetylcholinesterase (AChE). Reactivators (oximes) of inhibited AChE are a mainstay of treatment, however, the commercially available compounds, obidoxime and pralidoxime, are considered to be rather ineffective against various nerve agents, e.g. soman and cyclosarin. This led to the synthesis and investigation of numerous oximes in the past decades. Reactivation of OP-inhibited AChE is considered to be the most important reaction of oximes. Clinical data from studies with pesticide-poisoned patients support the assumption that the various reactions between AChE, OP and oxime, i.e. inhibition, reactivation and aging, can be investigated in vitro with human AChE. In contrast to animal experiments such in vitro studies with human tissue enable the evaluation of oxime efficacy without being affected by species differences. In the past few years numerous in vitro studies were performed by different groups with a large number of oximes and methods were developed for extrapolating in vitro data to different scenarios of human nerve agent poisoning. The present status in the evaluation of new oximes as antidotes against nerve agent poisoning will be discussed.

Organophosphorus compounds (OP) are in wide spread use as pesticides and highly toxic OP may be used as chemical warfare agents (nerve agents). OP inhibit acetylcholinesterase (AChE), therefore, standard treatment includes AChE reactivators (oximes) in combination with antimuscarinic agents. In the last decades, the efficacy of oximes has been investigated in various animal models, mostly in rodents. However, extrapolating animal data to humans is problematical because of marked differences between rodents and humans concerning the toxicokinetics of nerve agents, the pharmacokinetics of antidotes and the AChE enzyme kinetics. In order to improve the understanding of species differences and to enable a more reliable extrapolation of animal data to humans a study was initiated to investigate the effect of highly toxic nerve agents, i.e. VX, Russian VX (VR) and Chinese VX (CVX), with human and pig erythrocyte AChE. Hereby, the rate constants for the inhibition of AChE by these OP (ki) and for the spontaneous dealkylation (ka) and reactivation (ks) of OP-inhibited AChE as well as for the oxime-induced reactivation of OP-inhibited AChE by the oximes obidoxime, 2-PAM, HI 6, HLö 7 and MMB-4 were determined. Compared to human AChE pig AChE showed a lower sensitivity towards the investigated OP. Furthermore, a slower spontaneous dealkylation and reactivation of pig AChE was recorded. The potency of the investigated oximes was remarkably lower with OP-inhibited pig AChE. These data may contribute to a better understanding of species differences and may provide a kinetic basis for extrapolation of data from pig experiments to humans.

Previous in vitro studies showed marked species differences in the reactivating efficiency of oximes between human and animal acetylcholinesterase (AChE) inhibited by organophosphorus (OP) nerve agents. These findings provoked the present in vitro study which was designed to determine the inhibition, aging, spontaneous and oxime-induced reactivation kinetics of the pesticide paraoxon, serving as a model compound for diethyl-OP, and the oximes obidoxime, pralidoxime, HI 6 and MMB-4 with human, Rhesus monkey, swine, rabbit, rat and guinea pig erythrocyte AChE. Comparable results were obtained with human and monkey AChE. Differences between human, swine, rabbit, rat and guinea pig AChE were determined for the inhibition and reactivation kinetics. A six-fold difference of the inhibitory potency of paraoxon with human and guinea pig AChE was recorded while only moderate differences of the reactivation constants between human and animal AChE were determined. Obidoxime was by far the most effective reactivator with all tested species. Only minor species differences were found for the aging and spontaneous reactivation kinetics. The results of the present study underline the necessity to determine the inhibition, aging and reactivation kinetics in vitro as a basis for the development of meaningful therapeutic animal models, for the proper assessment of in vivo animal data and for the extrapolation of animal data to humans.

Treatment of poisoning by highly toxic organophosphorus compounds (OP, nerve agents) is a continuous challenge. Standard treatment with atropine and a clinically used oxime, obidoxime or pralidoxime is inadequate against various nerve agents. For ethical reasons testing of oxime efficacy has to be performed in animals. Now, it was tempting to investigate the reactivation kinetics of MMB-4, a candidate oxime to replace pralidoxime, with nerve agent-inhibited acetylcholinesterase (AChE) from human and animal origin in order to provide a kinetic basis for the proper assessment of in vivo data. By applying a modified kinetic approach, allowing the use of necessary high MMB-4 concentrations, it was possible to determine the reactivation constants with sarin-, cyclosarin-, VX-, VR- and tabun-inhibited AChE. MMB-4 exhibited a high reactivity and low affinity towards OP-inhibited AChE, except of tabun-inhibited enzyme where MMB-4 had an extremely low reactivity. Species differences between human and animal AChE were low (Cynomolgus) to moderate (swine, guinea pig). Due to the high reactivity of MMB-4 a rapid reactivation of inhibited AChE can be anticipated at adequate oxime concentrations which are substantially higher compared to HI-6. Additional studies are necessary to determine the in vivo toxicity, tolerability and pharmacokinetics of MMB-4 in humans in order to enable a proper assessment of the value of this oxime as an antidote against nerve agent poisoning.

Standard treatment of acute poisoning by organophosphorus compounds (OP) includes administration of an antimuscarinic (e.g. atropine) and of an oxime-based reactivator of OP-inhibited acetylcholinesterase (AChE). A recently introduced dynamically working in vitro model with real-time determination of membrane-bound AChE activity was shown to be a very versatile and promising model to investigate oxime-induced reactivation kinetics of OP-inhibited enzyme. In this assay, human AChE from erythrocytes or muscle tissue was immobilized on a particle filter. This bioreactor was continuously perfused with substrate and chromogen and AChE activity was analyzed on-line in a flow-through detector. The model has been successfully adopted to Rhesus monkey, swine and guinea pig erythrocytes and intercostal muscle AChE. In addition, the basic kinetic constants of inhibition, aging, spontaneous- and oxime-induced-reactivation of erythrocyte AChE from these species were determined with a standard static model. The major findings were, in part substantial species differences in the inhibition (sarin, paraoxon) and reactivation kinetics (obidoxime, HI 6) of erythrocyte AChE, but comparable kinetics of inhibition and reactivation between erythrocyte and muscle AChE. Hence, these data provide further support of the assumption that erythrocyte AChE is an adequate surrogate of muscle (synaptic) AChE and admonish that major species differences have to be considered for the design and evaluation of therapeutic animal models.

The widespread use of organophosphorus compounds (OPs) as pesticides and the frequent misuse of OP nerve agents in military conflicts or terrorist attacks emphasize the high clinical relevance of OP poisoning. The toxic symptomatology is caused by inhibition of acetylcholinesterase (AChE). A mainstay of standard antidotal treatment is atropine for antagonizing effects mediated by over stimulation of muscarinic ACh-receptors and oxime to reactivate OP-inhibited AChE. For therapeutic monitoring of oxime treatment in OP poisoning, measurement of erythrocyte AChE is suitable because erythrocyte AChE is an easily accessible surrogate for synaptic AChE. However, measurement of erythrocyte AChE is not standard practice. In contrast, determination of plasma butyrylcholinesterase (BChE) activity is in routine use for monitoring the benefit of oxime therapy. As oxime efficacy is limited with certain OPs (e.g. dimethoate, tabun, soman) alternative therapeutic approaches, e.g. the application of scavengers (BChE) which may sequester OPs before they reach their physiological target, are under investigation. To assess the eligibility of BChE as laboratory parameter and (pseudo catalytic or stoichiometric) scavenger in OP poisoning we initiated an in vitro study under standardized experimental conditions with the objective of determination of kinetic constants for inhibition, reactivation and aging of plasma BChE. It could be shown that, due to limited efficacy of obidoxime, pralidoxime, HI 6 and MMB4 with OP-inhibited BChE, plasma BChE activity is an inappropriate parameter for therapeutic monitoring of oxime treatment in OP poisoning. Furthermore, oxime-induced reactivation is too slow to accomplish a pseudo catalytic function, so that administered BChE may be merely effective as a stoichiometric scavenger.

Organophosphorus compound-based (OP) chemical warfare agents (nerve agents) represent a continuing threat to military forces and the civilian population. OPs act primarily by inhibiting acetylcholinesterase (AChE), the standard treatment for which includes AChE reactivators (oximes) in combination with antimuscarinic drugs. In the last decades, the efficacy of oximes has been investigated mostly in small animal models. In order to increase the predictive value of animal studies it is desirable to measure numerous physiological and biochemical parameters. This is difficult in small animals. Large animal models fulfil these requirements and swine are increasingly being used in toxicology studies. Swine breeds generally show considerable variability in different characteristics which may be minimised by the use of specially bred minipigs which have a known genetic background and health status. A comparative study was, therefore, initiated to investigate the kinetic properties of the White Landrace pig and Gottingen minipig AChE in respect of inhibition by the pesticide paraoxon; the nerve agents cyclosarin, VX and VR; the reactivation of inhibited AChE by oximes (obidoxime, pralidoxime and HI 6); and the aging and spontaneous reactivation of inhibited AChE. The determination of the respective kinetic constants found similarities between pig and minipig AChE which showed marked differences in comparison with human AChE values. This has to be considered in designing meaningful models for the investigation of oxime efficacy in pig or minipig experiments. The generated data indicate comparable kinetic properties of pig and minipig AChE and may provide a kinetic basis for extrapolation of data from pig studies to humans.

Highly toxic organophosphorus-type (OP) chemical warfare agents (nerve agents) and OP pesticides may be used by terrorists and during military conflicts emphasizing the necessity for the development of effective medical countermeasures. The standard treatment with atropine and acetylcholinesterase (AChE) reactivators (oximes) is considered to be ineffective with certain nerve agents due to low oxime efficacy. Despite research over decades none of the oximes has turned out to be a broad spectrum reactivator to cover the whole range of potential threat agents. The prospective oxime HI 6 is a weak reactivator of tabun- and pesticide-inhibited AChE, while the established oxime obidoxime mainly lacks efficacy with cyclosarin-inhibited enzyme. In order to investigate the feasibility of combining obidoxime and HI 6, human AChE inhibited by sarin, cyclosarin, VX, tabun and paraoxon was reactivated by these oximes either alone or in combination. Two major findings of this study were that a combination of HI 6 and obidoxime did not impair reactivation, compared with HI 6 or obidoxime alone, but broadened the spectrum compared with the individual oximes. By using different oxime concentrations a combination of oxime doses may be suggested which could be an alternative to individual obidoxime or HI 6 autoinjectors.

The high number of fatalities due to poisoning by organophosphorus compound-based (OP) pesticides and the availability of highly toxic OP-type chemical warfare agents (nerve agents) emphasize the necessity for an effective medical treatment. Acute OP toxicity is mainly caused by inhibition of acetylcholinesterase (AChE, EC 3.1.1.7). Reactivators (oximes) of inhibited AChE are a mainstay of treatment. However, human AChE inhibited by certain OP, e.g. the phosphoramidates tabun and fenamiphos, is rather resistant towards reactivation by oximes while AChE inhibited by others, e.g. the phosphoramidate methamidophos is easily reactivated by oximes. To get more insight into a potential structure-activity relationship human AChE was inhibited by 16 different tabun analogues and the time-dependent reactivation by 1mM obidoxime, TMB-4, MMB-4, HI 6 or HLo 7, the reactivation kinetics of obidoxime and the kinetics of aging and spontaneous reactivation were investigated. A clear structure-activity relationship of aging, spontaneous and oxime-induced reactivation kinetics could be determined with AChE inhibited by N-monoalkyl tabun analogues depending on the chain length of the N-alkyl residue. N,N-dialkyl analogues bearing ethyl and n-propyl residues were completely resistant towards reactivation while N,N-di-i-propyl tabun was highly susceptible towards reactivation by oximes. AChE inhibited by phosphonoamidate analogues of tabun, bearing a N,N-dimethyl and N,N-diethyl group, could be reactivated and had comparable reactivation kinetics with obidoxime. These results in conjunction with previous data with organophosphates and organophosphonates emphasizes the necessity for kinetic studies as basis for future work on structural analysis with human AChE and for the development of effective broad-spectrum oximes.

The availability of highly toxic OP-type chemical warfare agents (nerve agents) and the exertion of organophosphorus compounds during military conflicts and terrorist attacks against civilians in the past underlines the necessity of an effective treatment regimen of OP-poisoning. Presently, standard treatment includes administration of an antimuscarinic agent (e.g. atropine) and a reactivator of inhibited AChE (oxime), but is considered to be rather ineffective with certain nerve agents due to low oxime effectiveness of the currently available oximes, obidoxime and pralidoxime. The evaluation of new oximes as antidotes relies on the implementation of animal experiments for ethical reasons and is complicated by a limited extrapolation of animal data to humans. The development of a reliable animal model might accelerate the evaluation of new substances and their approval as antidotes, whereas, the pig as higher mammalian species seems to be promising as model animal. A dynamic in vitro model, which allows the calculation of AChE activities at different scenarios was developed to facilitate the definition of effective oxime concentrations and the optimization of oxime treatment of OP poisoning of humans and may furthermore be helpful by designing animal experiments. The model is based on a combination of enzyme kinetics (inhibition, reactivation, aging) of AChE with OP, toxicokinetics and oxime pharmacokinetics. By considering species-specific kinetic data this dynamic model was used for the calculation of AChE activities in humans and pigs after percutaneous exposure with 5× LD 50 VR (Russian VX) and treatment with HI 6, a promising new reactivator of OP-inhibited AChE. Due to a low affinity of HI 6 with VR-inhibited pig AChE the oxime dose that causes maximal reactivation of VR-inhibited pig AChE is conspicuously higher compared to humans. Therefore, the design of animal experiments in consideration of calculated data based on species-specific kinetic values may lead to a more reliable extrapolation of animal data to humans and may reduce the number of necessary animal experiments.

The rife use of organophosphorus compounds (OP) as pesticides and the exertion of highly toxic OP-type chemical warfare agents (nerve agents) during military conflicts and terrorist attacks in the past emphasize the necessity of the development of effective therapeutic countermeasures. Presently, standard treatment of poisoning by OP includes administration of atropine as an antimuscarinic agent and of oximes, e.g. obidoxime or pralidoxime, as reactivators of OP-inhibited acetylcholinesterase (AChE), but is considered to be rather ineffective with certain nerve agents. The evaluation of new oximes as antidotes is only possible by implementation of animal experiments for ethical reasons and therefore complicated by a limited extrapolation of animal data to humans due to marked species differences. A computer simulation based on combination of AChE kinetic data (inhibition, reactivation, aging) with OP toxicokinetics and oxime pharmacokinetics allows the calculation of AChE activities at different scenarios and may facilitate to define effective oxime concentrations and to optimize oxime dosage in OP poisoning. On the base of species-specific kinetic data this model was used to calculate AChE activities in humans and pigs after percutaneous exposure to 5 × LD50 VX and treatment with HI 6. Due to marked species differences between human and pig AChE the HI 6 dose that is necessary to cause a comparable reactivation of VX-inhibited pig AChE is conspicuously higher. Hence, designing animal experiments with the aid of computer modeling may reduce the number of animal experiments and allow a more reliable extrapolation of animal data to humans.