1. Residents’ Views on the Impact of Robotic Surgery on General Surgery Education
- Author
-
Stacy Ranson, Tyler Bernaiche, Jonathan M. Dort, Youssef M. Khalafallah, Chang Liu, Gordon Hafner, and Devon T. Collins
- Subjects
medicine.medical_specialty ,Design analysis ,Education ,03 medical and health sciences ,0302 clinical medicine ,Robotic Surgical Procedures ,medicine ,Humans ,Robotic surgery ,030212 general & internal medicine ,Curriculum ,Retrospective Studies ,Retrospective review ,Case volume ,business.industry ,Rapid expansion ,General surgery ,Internship and Residency ,Robotics ,Residency program ,Surgical training ,United States ,General Surgery ,030220 oncology & carcinogenesis ,Laparoscopy ,Surgery ,business - Abstract
OBJECTIVE The use of the da Vinci Robot has been fast growing in general surgery in the United States over the past decade. While the financial cost of robot-assisted procedures has been studied, there has been limited research on the educational cost of the robotic approach on general surgery trainees, and their surgical skills. DESIGN Analysis of anonymous educational survey responses collected from residents, in addition to case logs which were used as a retrospective review for the 5 years preceding the survey. SETTING One thousand bed, tertiary care hospital general surgery residency program. PARTICIPANTS Twenty-four enrolled general surgery residents in 2018. RESULTS There has been a rapid expansion in the use of robotics in general surgery. In 2017 the total number of general surgery cases using the da Vinci robot increased 6 fold over that in 2013 (23 cases in 2013, 136 in 2017), while both open and laparoscopic procedures have witnessed about a 33% drop in the case volume during those years. Almost all residents would prefer a residency program which offers the da Vinci robot for care and training (95%), however, 38% of general surgery residents reported that the presence of robotic-assisted surgery had a “detrimental” effect on their surgical training. Senior residents were more likely to report a “detrimental” effect (56% vs 27%). A third of the residents believe that robotic surgery is impeding their ability to learn open and laparoscopic surgical techniques, and only 25% denied a negative impact. Senior residents are more likely to report this negative impact (67% vs 13%). CONCLUSIONS Reforms in residency curricula need to be in place to accommodate the expansion of the use of the robotic platform in general surgery. A subjective survey of the residents suggests that robotic surgery can potentially impede the development of residents’ open and laparoscopic surgical skills.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF