1. The Italian Consensus on minimally invasive simultaneous resections for synchronous liver metastasis and primary colorectal cancer: A Delphi methodology
- Author
-
Antonino Spinelli, Gaya Spolverato, Ugo Elmore, S. Berti, Giorgio Ercolani, Nadia Russolillo, Ugo Boggi, L. Vincenti, Simone Nicosia, Andrea Laurenzi, Paolo De Paolis, Giuseppe Maria Ettorre, Agostino Maria De Rose, Luca Aldrighetti, Giovanni Vennarecci, Pierluigi Marini, Matteo Cescon, Michela Mineccia, Umberto Cillo, Francesco Marchegiani, Aldo Rocca, Francesco Minni, Luciano De Carlis, Alfredo Guglielmi, Paolo Delrio, Salvatore Gruttadauria, Riccardo Rosati, Francesco Izzo, Domenico D'Ugo, Vincenzo Bottino, Maurizio Degiuli, Giulio Belli, Fulvio Calise, Vincenzo Mazzaferro, Luca Viganò, Francesco Corcione, Fabrizio Di Benedetto, Riccardo Pellicci, Marco Filauro, Alessandro Ferrero, Andrea Muratore, Marco Massani, Federica Cipriani, Guido Torzilli, Matteo Cimino, Felice Giuliante, Elio Jovine, Rocca, A, Cipriani, F, Belli, G, Berti, S, Boggi, U, Bottino, V, Cillo, U, Cescon, M, Cimino, M, Corcione, F, De Carlis, L, Degiuli, M, De Paolis, P, De Rose, A, D'Ugo, D, Di Benedetto, F, Elmore, U, Ercolani, G, Ettorre, G, Ferrero, A, Filauro, M, Giuliante, F, Gruttadauria, S, Guglielmi, A, Izzo, F, Jovine, E, Laurenzi, A, Marchegiani, F, Marini, P, Massani, M, Mazzaferro, V, Mineccia, M, Minni, F, Muratore, A, Nicosia, S, Pellicci, R, Rosati, R, Russolillo, N, Spinelli, A, Spolverato, G, Torzilli, G, Vennarecci, G, Vigano, L, Vincenti, L, Delrio, P, Calise, F, Aldrighetti, L, Rocca, Aldo, Cipriani, Federica, Belli, Giulio, Berti, Stefano, Boggi, Ugo, Bottino, Vincenzo, Cillo, Umberto, Cescon, Matteo, Cimino, Matteo, Corcione, Francesco, De Carlis, Luciano, Degiuli, Maurizio, De Paolis, Paolo, De Rose, Agostino Maria, D’Ugo, Domenico, Di Benedetto, Fabrizio, Elmore, Ugo, Ercolani, Giorgio, Ettorre, Giuseppe M., Ferrero, Alessandro, Filauro, Marco, Giuliante, Felice, Gruttadauria, Salvatore, Guglielmi, Alfredo, Izzo, Francesco, Jovine, Elio, Laurenzi, Andrea, Marchegiani, Francesco, Marini, Pierluigi, Massani, Marco, Mazzaferro, Vincenzo, Mineccia, Michela, Minni, Francesco, Muratore, Andrea, Nicosia, Simone, Pellicci, Riccardo, Rosati, Riccardo, Russolillo, Nadia, Spinelli, Antonino, Spolverato, Gaya, Torzilli, Guido, Vennarecci, Giovanni, Viganò, Luca, Vincenti, Leonardo, Delrio, Paolo, Calise, Fulvio, Aldrighetti, Luca, Rocca A., Cipriani F., Belli G., Berti S., Boggi U., Bottino V., Cillo U., Cescon M., Cimino M., Corcione F., De Carlis L., Degiuli M., De Paolis P., De Rose A.M., D'Ugo D., Di Benedetto F., Elmore U., Ercolani G., Ettorre G.M., Ferrero A., Filauro M., Giuliante F., Gruttadauria S., Guglielmi A., Izzo F., Jovine E., Laurenzi A., Marchegiani F., Marini P., Massani M., Mazzaferro V., Mineccia M., Minni F., Muratore A., Nicosia S., Pellicci R., Rosati R., Russolillo N., Spinelli A., Spolverato G., Torzilli G., Vennarecci G., Vigano L., Vincenti L., Delrio P., Calise F., and Aldrighetti L.
- Subjects
Synchronous colorectal liver metastases ,medicine.medical_specialty ,Consensus ,Colorectal cancer ,Delphi method ,Consensu ,Colorectal Neoplasm ,030230 surgery ,law.invention ,Metastasis ,Standard procedure ,03 medical and health sciences ,0302 clinical medicine ,Randomized controlled trial ,law ,Minimally invasive surgery ,medicine ,Hepatectomy ,Humans ,Italy ,Colorectal Neoplasms ,Liver Neoplasms ,computer.programming_language ,business.industry ,General surgery ,medicine.disease ,Chemotherapy regimen ,Surgery ,Systematic review ,030220 oncology & carcinogenesis ,business ,computer ,Delphi ,Synchronous colorectal liver metastase ,Human - Abstract
At the time of diagnosis synchronous colorectal cancer, liver metastases (SCRLM) account for 15–25% of patients. If primary tumour and synchronous liver metastases are resectable, good results may be achieved performing surgical treatment incorporated into the chemotherapy regimen. So far, the possibility of simultaneous minimally invasive (MI) surgery for SCRLM has not been extensively investigated. The Italian surgical community has captured the need and undertaken the effort to establish a National Consensus on this topic. Four main areas of interest have been analysed: patients’ selection, procedures, techniques, and implementations. To establish consensus, an adapted Delphi method was used through as many reiterative rounds were needed. Systematic literature reviews were conducted according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses instructions. The Consensus took place between February 2019 and July 2020. Twenty-six Italian centres participated. Eighteen clinically relevant items were identified. After a total of three Delphi rounds, 30-tree recommendations reached expert consensus establishing the herein presented guidelines. The Italian Consensus on MI surgery for SCRLM indicates possible pathways to optimise the treatment for these patients as consensus papers express a trend that is likely to become shortly a standard procedure for clinical pictures still on debate. As matter of fact, no RCT or relevant case series on simultaneous treatment of SCRLM are available in the literature to suggest guidelines. It remains to be investigated whether the MI technique for the simultaneous treatment of SCRLM maintain the already documented benefit of the two separate surgeries.
- Published
- 2021