Search

One-hundred-sixty-nine lung cancers have occurred to date among 10,040 cigarette smoking men who participated in the New York Lung Cancer Detection Program. Almost 40% of the cases, 65, were still Stage I when their disease was diagnosed; 62 had thoracotomy and resection, and in 57, mediastinal node dissection confirmed that the mediastinum was free of metastases ("true pathologic" Stage I). Fifty-four of the 62 (87%) are still alive at this time, while only 15 of 104 (14%) of those with Stage II and III lung cancers are alive. Only two patients of the 62 in Stage I who were treated by resection died of lung cancer, both with T2 tumors. Two others are alive with metastases, one died postoperatively, and five died of other causes without evidence of lung cancer. The estimated probability of survival for true Stage I lung cancer is over 90% at five years, and close to 40% of all lung cancers can be detected in this favorable stage by present radiologic and cytologic screening techniques.

This is a report of the initial (prevalence) screening for lung cancer in a population of 10.040 cigarette-smoking men 45 yr of age and older, recruited from metropolitan New York. All had posteroanterior and lateral chest roentgenograms, and approximately half the men, randomly chosen, also had sputum cytology (dual screen). Fifty-three confirmed lung cancers were found; 22 (40%) were AJCC Stage I, with 85% survival for 5 yr after resection, whereas only 2 of the remaining men with Stage II to III lung cancer lived longer than 3 yr. In the dual screen group, in which the 2 detection techniques could be compared, 6 Stage I lung cancers were detected by radiology alone, 7 by cytology alone, and only 1 by both techniques. All of the cases detected by cytology alone were squamous carcinomas, whereas two thirds of those detected by radiology alone were adenocarcinoma.

A screening program of 10,040 cigarette-smoking men over 45 years of age was undertaken in an attempt to achieve earlier diagnosis, thereby increasing the cure rate, of oat cell lung cancer. Of the 155 men who were found to have lung cancer, 27 (17%) had confirmed oat cell cancer. Only one case was diagnosed at the first examination. The other 26 cases (called incidence cancer) were diagnosed by subsequent examinations. In 24 of the 26 patients, the tumor was not found until it was advanced (Stage III), and of these patients, only one is alive at 21 months follow-up. Two tumors were diagnosed as oat cell carcinoma at an early stage (Stage I), and both patients are alive with no evidence of disease at seven and 24 months. The screening program used in this study did not succeed in detecting oat cell cancer at an early stage.