Search

The largest aggregation of spawning American horseshoe crabs in the world occurs in Delaware Bay and supports one of the largest concentrations of shorebirds in the western hemisphere where the birds feed on horseshoe crab eggs during migration. Unregulated harvest in the 1990s is associated with the decline of shorebird populations using the bay, but corresponding baseline information on the horseshoe crab egg food supply that supported peak shorebird populations has been lacking.Past and current measurements of horseshoe crab eggs in the bay indicate that abundance in the 1980s was an order of magnitude greater (x̄ = 156,600/m2) than present‐day estimates (2015–2021 x̄ = 10,243/m2). An additional egg prevalence index, which characterizes the timing and magnitude of horseshoe crab egg output, revealed a similar pattern of higher prevalence in the 1980s (0.89, 95% confidence interval 0.81–0.94) compared with the recent 2015–2021 interval (0.52, 95% confidence interval 0.43–0.60).Declines of egg and shorebird abundance occurred shortly after horseshoe crab harvest reached its peak. Red knot aerial survey counts have stabilized at 30% of the baseline population while ruddy turnstone counts are 40% of baseline estimates. Initially these species were evenly distributed between the New Jersey and Delaware coasts but both species have trended toward predominately occupying New Jersey beaches.A lack of recovery of horseshoe crab egg and shorebird abundance suggests that horseshoe crab harvest management has stabilized populations but progress toward population recovery has been limited. Impacts from bycatch, the pharmaceutical industry and other potential population impacts must be better quantified and mitigated, if necessary, to promote the recovery of horseshoe crab populations. Measurements of horseshoe egg prevalence and abundance are essential metrics for tracking the progress toward management goals for improving shorebird habitat quality. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Adaptive management requires that predictive models be explicit and transparent to improve decisions by comparing management actions, directing further research and monitoring, and facilitating learning. The rufa subspecies of red knots ( Calidris canutus rufa), which has recently exhibited steep population declines, relies on horseshoe crab ( Limulus polyphemus) eggs as their primary food source during stopover in Delaware Bay during spring migration. We present a model with two different parameterizations for use in the adaptive management of horseshoe crab harvests in the Delaware Bay that links red knot mass gain, annual survival, and fecundity to horseshoe crab dynamics. The models reflect prevailing hypotheses regarding ecological links between these two species. When reported crab harvest from 1998 to 2008 was applied, projections corresponded to the observed red knot population abundances depending on strengths of the demographic relationship between these species. We compared different simulated horseshoe crab harvest strategies to evaluate whether, given this model, horseshoe crab harvest management can affect red knot conservation and found that restricting harvest can benefit red knot populations. Our model is the first to explicitly and quantitatively link these two species and will be used within an adaptive management framework to manage the Delaware Bay system and learn more about the specific nature of the linkage between the two species. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

1. Millions of shorebirds migrate each year through a small number of highly productive staging areas where they often conflict with fisheries interests. Delaware Bay, USA, is a major shorebird stopover site where, in spring, many thousands of shorebirds undergo rapid mass gain by feeding on the eggs of commercially harvested horseshoe crabs Limulus polyphemus. 2. Environmental factors may cause deviations from the best migration schedule. We used within-year mass gain data from red knot Calidris canutus caught in Delaware Bay between 1998 and 2005 to determine the degree of flexibility individuals have to vary migration speed. 3. Mass gain by birds below 133 g was shown to comprise 15·3% fat (39 kJ g−1), the remainder being lean mass (6 kJ g−1). Above this critical level, fat comprised 83·9% of mass deposition. The rates of energy deposition (kJ d−1) were therefore fundamentally different between the two states but were among the highest ever recorded among vertebrates (5–7 × basic metabolic rate). 4. A total of 36–62% of the variation in observed rates of energy deposition between 1998 and 2002 was explained by a year factor, date and mass at initial capture and interaction terms, such that light-weight birds at the end of May had rates of mass gain or energy deposition two to three times higher than birds of similar mass in mid-May, indicating that birds were attempting to achieve a certain mass by a certain date. In 2003 and 2005, this relationship broke down as a result of lower densities of eggs. 5. Synthesis and application. The maintenance of high densities of crab eggs required for high rates of mass gain in red knot requires severe cuts in, or the complete cessation of, the crab harvest, reduced human and raptor-related disturbance as well as management of beaches to provide sufficient crab-spawning habitat. These findings are widely applicable to other systems where harvesting activities come into conflict with migrating animals and show that certain sections of the population, in this case the long-distance migrants from South America, will be impacted more than short-distance migrants whose physiology may give them access to alternative food resources. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

A decline in red knots (Calidris canutus rufa) has been attributed to horseshoe crab (Limulus polyphemus) egg shortages on the Delaware Bay, an important foraging area for migrating knots. We studied the movements and distribution of 65 radiotagged red knots on Delaware Bay from May to June 2004 and related movements to the distribution and abundance of horseshoe crab eggs and other prey and to other habitat characteristics. The number of horseshoe crab eggs was the most important factor determining the use of Delaware Bay beaches by red knots (logistic regression cumulative Akaike's Information Criterion adjusted for small sample size [AICc} w = 0.99). The knots shifted from emergent marsh and peat-beaches to sandy Delaware Bay beach when crab eggs became abundant, which also suggested the importance of crab eggs. While red knots used sandy beach zones more than expected, given their availability, 44% of red knot low tide locations were in bay and coastal emergent marsh. The abundance of Donax variabilis (AICc w = 0.95) and Mytilus edulis (AICc w = 0.94) spat, both food for red knots, had a relationship with red knot use of sandy beaches. Levels of disturbance and the abundance of laughing gulls (Larus atricilla) also were important factors in red knot sandy beach use, although secondary to prey resources (AICc w < 0.4). These results are consistent with the hypothesis that the abundance of horseshoe crab eggs on sandy beaches is driving movement and distribution of red knots and that there is little alternative food during the migratory stopover in Delaware Bay. Our findings that red knots disproportionately use Delaware Bay sites with abundant eggs and that there is a lack of surplus eggs at areas used and unused by red knots support the continuation of management for sustained yield of horseshoe crabs and other food resources at this stopover. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

A letter to the editor is presented in response to the article “Effects of Horseshoe Crab Harvest in Delaware Bay on Red Knots: Are Harvest Restrictions Working?,” by L.J. Niles et al. in a 2009 issue. A response by Lawrence J. Niles and his colleagues is appended.