Search

This essay is devoted to a relatively minor episode in Edmund Burke’s parliamentary career and political speculation involving the rights of war and international law in the final years of the American War of Independence. The starting point for Burke’s consideration of these questions was the affair of St. Eustatius, that is to say Britain’s conquest in 1781 of the Dutch West-Indian island early in the “fourth Anglo-Dutch War” of 1780-1784. The harsh treatment of the Dutch colony’s cosmopolitan community by the commanding officers of the British Navy and Army provoked a series of reactions in Britain and the colonies. The essay starts by outlining the identity of St. Eustatius with its economic, demographic and social features, its peculiar role in the eighteenth-century West Indies and its emblematic meaning in the historical literature of the Enlightenment as a symbol of the virtues of commerce and of economic liberty. It goes on to analyse the facts of the military conquest in 1781 and the ensuing occupation realized by Admiral George Rodney and Major-General John Vaughan, particularly as this affected the “poor Jews at St. Eustatius” (as Burke himself qualified them in his second speech on 4 December 1781), with the subsequent reactions of the Dutch and especially the British Atlantic world. We then examine Edmund Burke’s reasons for taking up this affair, including the political and ideological motives and the sources of arguments he used in the two parliamentary speeches he made on the topic during 1781, relating this to Burke’s ideas on international relations and imperial government during the 1770s and 1780s. We end by pointing to cultural links between Burke’s positions and a wider political, commercial and civic culture emerging in the British Atlantic world which reflected some of the most typical European Enlightenment values and ideological commitments., Cromohs - Cyber Review of Modern Historiography, Vol 13 (2008)

Guido Abbattista - Rolando Minuti, Premessa Marcel Dorigny, Yves Benot (1920-2005) Guido Abbattista, Africains en exposition (Italie XIXe siècle) entre racialisme, spectacularité et humanitarisme Sophie Audidière, Nature humaine et diversité: la facticité selon Helvétius Yves Benot, Les Sauvages d’Amérique du nord: modèle ou épouvantail? Carminella Biondi, "De la littérature des nègres" de l’abbé Grégoire: un plaidoyer manqué? Andrew Curran, Imaginer l’Afrique au siècle des Lumières Thierry Hoquet, La nouveauté du Nouveau Monde du point de vue de l'histoire naturelle Girolamo Imbruglia, Un impero d'età moderna: la Compagnia di Gesù Renato G. Mazzolini, L’interpretazione simbolica della pigmentazione umana nell’antropologia fisica del primo Ottocento Rolando Minuti, Tolleranza e islam. Aspetti di un dibattito tra Seicento e Settecento Marco Platania, Formes de la liberté: images politiques des Indiens d’Amérique dans la deuxième moitié du XVIIIe siècle Emmanuelle Sibeud, "Comment peut-on etre noir ?" Le parcours d'un intellectuel haïtien a la fin du XIXe siècle Ann Thomson, L'Europe des lumieres et le monde musulman: une alterite ambiguë Larry Wolff, The Adriatic Origins of European Anthropology

Guido Abbattista - Rolando Minuti, Introduction. Ann Thomson, Issues at stake in eighteenth-century racial classification. Annette Meyer, The experience of human diversity and the search for unity. Concepts of mankind in the late Enlightenment. Silvia Sebastiani, Race and national characters in eighteenth-century Scotland: the polygenetic discourses of Kames and Pinkerton. Monika Niewójt, Races humaines et liberté dans la pensée politique de Jan Potocki à la veille de la Révolution. Carminella Biondi, Le problème des gens de couleur aux colonies et en France dans la seconde moitié du XVIIIe siècle.