1. Comparison of 5 Ki-67 antibodies regarding reproducibility and capacity to predict prognosis in breast cancer: does the antibody matter?
- Author
-
Ács B, Kulka J, Kovács KA, Teleki I, Tőkés AM, Meczker Á, Győrffy B, Madaras L, Krenács T, and Szász AM
- Subjects
- Adult, Aged, Aged, 80 and over, Antibody Specificity, Breast Neoplasms immunology, Breast Neoplasms pathology, Breast Neoplasms therapy, Disease-Free Survival, Female, Fluorescent Antibody Technique, Humans, Ki-67 Antigen immunology, Lymphatic Metastasis, Middle Aged, Multivariate Analysis, Observer Variation, Predictive Value of Tests, Reproducibility of Results, Retrospective Studies, Risk Assessment, Risk Factors, Time Factors, Antibodies immunology, Breast Neoplasms chemistry, Cell Proliferation, Immunohistochemistry methods, Ki-67 Antigen analysis
- Abstract
Although several antibodies are available for immunohistochemical detection of Ki-67, even the most commonly used MIB-1 has not been validated yet. Our aim was to compare 5 commercially available antibodies for detection of Ki-67 in terms of agreement and their ability in predicting prognosis of breast cancer. Tissue microarrays were constructed from 378 breast cancer patients' representative formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tumor blocks. Five antibodies were used to detect Ki-67 expression: MIB-1 using chromogenic detection and immunofluorescent-labeled MIB-1, SP-6, 30-9, poly, and B56. Semiquantitative assessment was performed by 2 pathologists independently on digitized slides. To compare the 5 antibodies, intraclass correlation and concordance correlation coefficient were used. All the antibodies but immunofluorescent-labeled MIB-1 (at 20% and 30% thresholds, P=.993 and P=.342, respectively) and B56 (at 30% threshold, P=.288) separated high- and low-risk patient groups. However, there were a significant difference (P values for all comparisons≤.005) and a moderate concordance (intraclass correlation, 0.645) between their Ki-67 labeling index scores. The highest concordance was found between MIB-1 and poly (concordance correlation coefficient=0.785) antibodies. None of the antibodies except Ki-67 labeling index as detected by poly (P=.031) at 20% threshold and lymph node status (P<.001) were significantly linked to disease-free survival in multivariate analysis. At 30% threshold, this was reduced to lymph node status (P<.001) alone. Our results showed that there are considerable differences between the different Ki-67 antibodies in their capacity to detect proliferating tumor cells and to separate low- and high-risk breast cancer patient groups., (Copyright © 2017 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.)
- Published
- 2017
- Full Text
- View/download PDF