Search

A large number of catalysts for hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) that are related (structurally and/or functionally) to the active site of [FeFe]-hydrogenases (H-cluster) has been proposed in the past few decades. Very recently, a novel recipe for HER catalysts has been added to the list. This consists in the combination of a diiron core, a ligand that can act as an intramolecular weak base to support protonation (both features that are common to the H-cluster), and a peculiar carbyne ligand that bridges the two metal centers. For instance, complex [Fe2{μ-CNMe2}(μ-CO)(CO)(CN)Cp2] (4) proved to be catalytically active towards HER. The novelty related to this family of biomimicry is not only structural, but also mechanistic. Indeed, an unprecedented (in the context of hydrogenase mimicry) ligand-based mechanism of HER, which avoids protonation at metal, has been dissected by DFT. In order to increase catalytic activity of this “non dithiolate based” system, a systematic search of ligand modification is therefore desirable. In this regard, herein we present results of replacing CN− (the proton shuttle in 4) by other ligands such as CNCH2Ph (5), PPh3 (6) or azide (7). The redox behavior of these compounds has been tested, in the absence and presence of a proton source. CV experiments combined with DFT calculations have revealed and rationalized critical points entailed by modifications of stereo-electronic features of 4. However, understanding the key factors underlying the absence of catalytic activity of these new compounds can be beneficial for the design of future improved biomimicry related to HER. As an example, properly tailored hydrocarbyl complexes replacing dithiolates at the Fe2 core might allow recovering the fruitful electronic properties of cyanides, when coordinated to metal centers.

This perspective aims at illustrating a computational viewpoint on some specific issues concerning structure–activity relationships related to [FeFe]-hydrogenase ([FeFe]-H2ase) biomimicry. Most of the research outlined herein has been addressed by means of density functional theory (DFT) based tools, in some cases in conjunction with experimental techniques. The number of computational, experimental and mixed approach studies on the “hydrogenase models” topic is extraordinarily high. Accordingly, several comprehensive reviews have been published over the last twenty years. Moreover, the number of iron compounds of increasing nuclearity that have been considered as “biomimetic models” of [FeFe]-H2ase has grown exponentially over time. Additionally, the issues regarding some mismatches existing between the natural system and related synthetic analogues, are quite variegated. As a consequence of the countless examples that could be considered as related to “hydrogenase mimicry”, the intent of the present contribution is to provide an account of a limited number of recent study cases, in which DFT has been employed to elucidate redox properties, reactivity issues of selected examples of diiron biomimicry. Herein the treated topics have been explicitly chosen to show how DFT has allowed us to rationalize and complement experimental observations, with a special focus on electrocatalysis aspects. Finally, the specific purpose of this perspective is to show how mutually intertwined are the various issues concerning a fascinating branch of biomimetic research.

The electron rich Fe2(pdt)(RNC)6 1 (pdt=CH2(CH2S−)2) has been used as starting point for a DFT multi-functional study to assess the feasibility of designing a stable inverted (or rotated) disposition of the two FeL3 pyramidal moieties in the dimetallic core, a key feature of [FeFe]-hydrogenase cofactor. The choice of 1 was motivated by the presence of a rotated form in solution, slightly less stable than the unrotated stereoisomer. Aimed to find an upgraded version of 1, featuring the rotated isomer as ground state, various combinations of factors have been tested, for their effect on the relative stability of rotated vs unrotated isomers. The general result is that combining coordination asymmetry, electron donor presence and isocyanides R substituents able to establish intramolecular interactions is effective in stabilizing the rotated isomer. Our DFT study may inspire the design of synthetic biomimetics, with improved resemblance to the natural system.

Hydrogenases are enzymes that catalyze the oxidation and production of molecular hydrogen. For about fifteen years, there have been many reports about the successful connection of these enzymes to photosensitizers with the aim of designing H2 photoproduction systems, but relatively little attention has been paid to whether and why illumination may affect the catalytic properties of the enzyme. In all hydrogenases, hydrogen activation occurs at an inorganic active site that includes at least one Fe-carbonyl motif, which may make it sensitive to irradiation. Here we review the evidence that hydrogenases are indeed photosensitive. We focus mainly on the so-called FeFe hydrogenases; their active site, called the H-cluster, consists of a [4Fe4S] cluster that is bound by a cysteine sulfur to a diiron site. The iron atoms of the binuclear cluster are coordinated by carbonyl and cyanide ligands and an azadithiolate group. We describe the effects of UV-visible light irradiation on the enzyme under cryogenic or turnover conditions and the photoreactivity of model complexes that mimic the diiron site. We emphasize the dependence of the photochemical processes on wavelength, and warn about FeFe hydrogenase photoinhibition, which should probably be considered when attempts are made to use FeFe hydrogenases for the artificial photosynthesis of solar fuels. We also underline the relevance of studies of synthetic mimics of the H-cluster for understanding at atomistic level the photochemical processes observed in the enzyme.

International audience; The synthesis, characterization, and protonation of [Fe2(CO)6{(μ-SCH2)2(Et)P═O}] (1) using the moderately strong acid CF3CO2H (pKaMeCN = 12.7) are reported. Digital simulations of the cyclic voltammetry of 1 in the presence of CF3CO2H and DFT calculations have allowed us to obtain a detailed mechanistic picture of the processes underlying the catalytic hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) that 1 can mediate. Moreover, DFT has shed light on the role of the P═O functionality in the whole catalytic cycle of proton reduction. The reductive behavior of 1 features a double electron transfer with potential inversion, which is associated with deep structural rearrangement of the catalyst. The double reduction appears also functional to the intramolecular proton transfer from the P═O group to the diiron core, a crucial process for the H+/H– heterocoupling yielding H2. The key intermediate for the H2 formation and release is predicted to be a 3H+/3e– species, in which P═O is perfectly poised to shuttle protons from solution to the Fe–H–Fe moiety. Therefore, the R-P═O bridgehead installed in a dithiolato linker of a diiron core proves a valid and versatile alternative to the natural nitrogen-based Fe2 strap.

FeIFeI Fe2(S2C3H6)(CO)6(µ-CO) (1a–CO) and its FeIFeII cationic species (2a+–CO) are the simplest model of the CO-inhibited [FeFe] hydrogenase active site, which is known to undergo CO photolysis within a temperature-dependent process whose products and mechanism are still a matter of debate. Using density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) computations, the ground state and low-lying excited-state potential energy surfaces (PESs) of 1a–CO and 2a+–CO have been explored aimed at elucidating the dynamics of the CO photolysis yielding Fe2(S2C3H6)(CO)6 (1a) and [Fe2(S2C3H6)(CO)6]+ (2a+), two simple models of the catalytic site of the enzyme. Two main results came out from these investigations. First, a–CO and 2a+–CO are both bound with respect to any CO dissociation with the lowest free energy barriers around 10 kcal mol−1, suggesting that at least 2a+–CO may be synthesized. Second, focusing on the cationic form, we found at least two clear excited-state channels along the PESs of 2a+–CO that are unbound with respect to equatorial CO dissociation.

International audience; The so-called FeFe hydrogenases catalyze H2 production and oxidation at a dinuclear inorganic active site. Some of them can be natively purified in an overoxidized, O2-resistant “Hinact” state, recently identified by Rodríguez-Maciá et al. as the product of the reaction of the enzyme with sulfide [Rodríguez-Maciá, P.; J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2018, 140, 9346]. We used a combination of direct electrochemistry experiments with the FeFe hydrogenase from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, site-directed mutagenesis, molecular dynamics and density functional theory (DFT) calculations to describe the mechanism of inhibition: the diffusion of the inhibitor in the enzyme and its subsequent reaction at the active site H-cluster. We conclude that hydrogen sulfide (H2S) inhibits the enzyme noncompetitively, in a first step by replacing a conserved water molecule that is involved in proton transfer, and then binding to the active site as a hydrosulfide ligand (HS–). DFT calculations with the PBE0-D3 functional successfully describe the redox state of the cubane fragment of the H-cluster in the resulting “Htrans” state. Our experimental and theoretical results are consistent with the reactivation involving the reduction of the H-cluster in the Htrans state, followed by the potentiometric or catalytic reoxidation of the enzyme. This mechanism reconciles all experimental observations, and we suggest that it is common to all FeFe hydrogenases. In addition, we observe that the hydrogenases from Megasphaera elsdenii, Clostridium acetobutylicum (CaI), and Clostridium pasteurianum (CpI) are also inhibited by sulfide, but with very slow kinetics. Although sulfide inhibition is fully reversible, we observed an irreversible inactivation by polysulfide contaminants, which should be avoided if the hydrogenase is exposed to sulfide to prepare samples that are protected from air, e.g., for transport or storage.*

A few bio-inorganic systems have been studied by means of modern quantum chemistry (QM) methods, such as the Density Functional Theory (DFT) in connection with a large set of basis functions. At this level, DFT has proven to give reliable (semi-quantitative) description of several properties of transition metals complexes which are either relevant part of a natural enzyme or ad hoc built to mimic the behaviour of enzymes. The first example considered is the N,N'-ethylenebis(acetylacetonatiminato)Co(II) (Coacacen), a very famous synthetic oxygen carrier. We report results of a DFT investigation of Coacacen in its free form as well as in penta-coordinated form with a suitable axial ligand and, finally, in hexa-coordinated form bound to dioxygen. The problems related to the electronic structure of Coacacen derivatives are very old, and have been investigated (mainly experimentally) for several years. Coacacen has been the first bio-inorganic system investigated in the group of Renato Ugo in the 1970s. In addition, a short review will be presented concerning the “modern” problems of the bio-inorganics, as they are presently investigated in our research group based at the University of Milano-Bicocca (Italy): the catalytic cycle characteristic of Fe-Fe hydrogenases and the model compounds describing the interaction between copper and amyloid β-peptides.

International audience; FeFe hydrogenases catalyse H2 oxidation and production using a "H-cluster", where two Fe ions are bound by an aza-dithiolate (adt) ligand. Various hypotheses have been proposed (by us and others) to explain that the enzyme reversibly inactivates under oxidizing, anaerobic conditions: intramolecular binding of the N atom of adt, formation of the so-called Hox/inact state or non-productive binding of H2 to isomers of the H-cluster. Here we show that none of the above explains the new finding that the anaerobic, oxidative, H2-dependent reversible inactivation is strictly dependent on the presence of Cl- or Br-. We provide experimental evidence that chloride uncompetitively inhibits the enzyme: it reversibly binds to catalytic intermediates of H2 oxidation (but not to the resting "Hox" state), after which oxidation locks the active site into a stable, saturated, inactive form, the structure of which is proposed here based on DFT calculations. The halides interact with the amine group of the H-cluster but do not directly bind to iron. It should be possible to stabilize the inhibited state in amounts compatible with spectroscopic investigations to explore further this unexpected reactivity of the H-cluster of hydrogenase.

Catalytic H2 oxidation has been dissected by means of DFT into the key steps common to the Fe2 unit of both the [FeFe]-hydrogenase cofactor and selected biomimics. The aim was to elucidate the molecular details underlying the very different performances of the two systems. We found that the better enzyme performance is based on a single iron atom that is maintained electron-poor, favoring H2 binding, although embedded within a highly electron-rich cofactor, ensuring a facile oxidation of the Fe2 -H2 adduct. This is due to 1) CN- coordinating to both iron atoms, due to their amphipathic Lewis acid/base properties, and 2) the 4Fe4S subunit further withdrawing electrons from the Fe2 core. Preserving a moderate electron deficiency at a single iron also helps the cofactor preserve hydride affinity, which favors H2 cleavage. Such valuable characteristics allow the biocatalyst to turnover close to equilibrium conditions. All previous biomimicry has shown, in contrast, the impossibility to properly balance the two apparently contrasting aforementioned requisites, although evident progress has been made by the H2 -ase community. Disclosure of the differences identified could inspire the design of novel biomimics, for instance, reconsidering the use of CN- in the catalyst architecture. Indeed, in the presence of bases normally employed in oxidative catalysis, undesired stable protonation at coordinated CN- , which affects the opposite process (proton reduction), could be overcome.

The photochemistry of the [FeFe] hydrogenases model [Fe-2(edt)(CO)(4)(PMe3)(2)] (edt=1-2 ethane-dithiolate, (1) is investigated at Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory (TDDFT) level, focusing on the effect of the phosphine ligands on the early stages of the photodynamic of the system compared to that of the all CO model Fe-2(pdt)(CO)(6) (2) (pdt=1-3 propanedithiolate). We observed a role of the FeS charge transfer for the lower energy singlet transitions, unveiling a photoisomerization pathway between the lowest energy forms while the higher energy excitations are likely involved in the CO dissociation pathways. TDDFT shows that the average Fe-CO bond elongation in 1 is shorter than that observed in 2, providing the electronic structure rationale on the observation that diiron dithiolates are more photo-stable with respect to the CO photolysis than the all CO model. This is relevant for catalyst photo-stability and is an advantageous and thus desirable feature for practical applications of photo-hydrogen evolution

International audience; To learn from Nature how to create an efficient hydrogen-producing catalyst, much attention has been paid to the investigation of structural and functional biomimics of the active site of [FeFe]-hydrogenase. To understand their catalytic activities, the μ-S atoms of the dithiolate bridge have been considered as possible basic sites during the catalytic processes. For this reason, a series of [FeFe]-H2ase mimics have been synthesized and characterized. Different [FeFe]-hydrogenase model complexes containing bulky Si–heteroaromatic systems or fluorene directly attached to the dithiolate moiety as well as their mono-PPh3-substituted derivatives have been prepared and investigated in detail by spectroscopic, electrochemical, X-ray diffraction, and computational methods. The assembly of the herein reported series of complexes shows that the μ-S atoms can be a favored basic site in the catalytic process. Small changes in the (hetero)-aromatic system of the dithiolate moiety are responsible for large differences in their structures. This was elucidated in detail by DFT calculations, which were consistent with the experimental results.

DFT has been used to investigate viable mechanisms of the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) electrocatalyzed by [Fe2(CN){μ-CN(Me)2}(μ-CO)(CO)(Cp)2] (1) in AcOH. Molecular details underlying the proposed ECEC electrochemical sequence have been studied, and the key functionalities of CN- and amino-carbyne ligands have been elucidated. After the first reduction, CN- works as a relay for the first proton from AcOH to the carbyne, with this ligand serving as the main electron acceptor for both reduction steps. After the second reduction, a second protonation occurs at CN- that forms a Fe(CNH) moiety: i.e., the acidic source for the H2 generation. The hydride (formally 2e/H+), necessary to the heterocoupling with H+ is thus provided by the μ-CN(Me)2 ligand and not by Fe centers, as occurs in typical L6Fe2S2 derivatives modeling the hydrogenase active site. It is remarkable, in this regard, that CN- plays a role more subtle than that previously expected (increasing electron density at Fe atoms). In addition, the role of AcOH in shuttling protons from CN- to CN(Me)2 is highlighted. The incompetence for the HER of the related species [Fe2{μ-CN(Me)2}(μ-CO)(CO)2(Cp)2]+ (2+) has been investigated and attributed to the loss of proton responsiveness caused by CN- replacement with CO. In the context of hydrogenase mimicry, an implication of this study is that the dithiolate strap, normally present in all synthetic models, can be removed from the Fe2 core without loss of HER, but the redox and acid-base processes underlying turnover switch from a metal-based to a ligand-based chemistry. The versatile nature of the carbyne, once incorporated in the Fe2 scaffold, could be exploited to develop more active and robust catalysts for the HER.

International audience; FeFe hydrogenases catalyze H-2 oxidation and formation at an inorganic active site (the "H-cluster"), which consists of a [Fe-2(CO)(3)(CN)(2)(dithiomethylamine)] subcluster covalently attached to a Fe4S4 subcluster. This active site is photosensitive: visible light has been shown to induce the release of exogenous CO (a reversible inhibitor of the enzyme), shuffle the intrinsic CO ligands, and even destroy the H-cluster. These reactions must be understood because they may negatively impact the Use of hydrogenase for the photoproduction of H-2. Here, we explore in great detail the reactivity of the excited states of the H-duster under catalytic conditions by examining, both experimentally and using TDDFT calculations, the simplest photochemical reaction: the binding and release of exogenous CO. A simple dyad model can be used to predict which excitations are active. This could be used for probing other, aspects of the photoreactivity of the H-cluster.

It is successfully shown that photocatalytic proton reduction to dihydrogen in the presence of a sacrificial electron donor, such as trimethylamine (TEA) and ascorbate, can be driven by compact sensitizer–catalyst dyads, that is, dithiolate-bridged [FeFe] hydrogenase models tethered to organic sensitizers, such as fluorenes and silafluorenes (1 a–4 a). The sensitizer–catalyst dyads 1 a–4 a show remarkable and promising catalytic activities as well as enhanced stabilities during photocatalysis performed under UV-light irradiation. The photocatalysis was carried out both in non-aqueous and aqueous media. The latter experiments were performed by solubilizing the photocatalysts within micelles formed by either sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) or cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB). In this study a turnover number of 539 (7 h) is achieved under optimized conditions, which corresponds to an exceptionally high turnover frequency of 77 h−1. Theoretical investigations as well as emission decay experiments were performed to understand the observed phenomena together with the mechanisms of photocatalytic H2 generation.

In this work a density functional theory study of the CO addition reaction to FeIFeI and FeIFeII models of the active site of [FeFe] hydrogenases is presented. A series of model complexes, ranging from simple diiron model complexes of the binuclear [2Fe]H subcluster to the full H-cluster, have been investigated. For each system, the thermodynamic parameters for the CO adduct formation, a reaction that mimics the enzyme CO inhibition, were computed. Parallel to the investigation of the CO addition reaction, the structural features of the various FeIFeI and FeIFeII species have been evaluated, with particular attention to the issue of the ligand arrangement as a function of the redox state. CO affinity depends on the redox state of the model and the chemical nature of its ligands. FeIFeII species are more favorable to form the CO adducts than the reduced FeIFeI species. According to the computed free energies and enthalpies for the CO adduct formation from Fe2(pdt)(CO)5L models, the CO affinity follows the ligand sequence L = SCH3- > CN- > PPh3 > CO (FeIFeI) and L = CO > CN- > PPh3 > SCH3- (FeIFeII). As the models become more similar to the H-cluster, the CO affinity increases, although the FeIFeI CO -inhibited H-cluster is not stable. The bonding properties of the models considered have been investigated by means of the quantum theory of atoms in molecules approach. Upon CO addiction, the new Fe-C bond is formed to the detriment of the Fe-Fe bonds and, to a lesser extent, the Fe-S bonds. Regarding the FeIFeII systems investigated, the spin density is initially localized on the rotated Fe atom, and the formation of the CO adducts results in a delocalization of the spin density. Consequently, the FeIFeII CO-inhibited forms are better described as (Fe+1.5)2.

Fe(2)(S(2)C(3)H(6))(CO)(6) (a) is a simple model of the [FeFe] hydrogenase catalytic site. The topology of the potential energy surface (PES) of this complex, of its cationic and anionic species (a(+) and a(-)), and of its lowest triplet state was studied using density functional theory (DFT) with BP86 and B3LYP functionals, while selected low- and high-lying singlet excited states were studied with the time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT). The global minima of a and a(-) PESs are characterized by an all-terminal CO ligand arrangement, while the two rotated forms are transition states (TS). On the contrary, for the a(+) and lowest triplet state PES, the three forms considered are local minima, and the syn rotated form is the global minimum. The relative stability of the rotated forms and the all-terminal CO form on the a, a(+), and a(-) PESs is discussed in light of the Quantum Theory of Atoms in Molecules (QTAIM) analysis of the electron density. By comparing the Fe-Fe bond features of the three forms for each PES, we found that the global minimum structure is characterized by the shortest Fe-Fe bond distance and highest electron density at the Fe-Fe critical point. This approach gave evidence that in the a rotated forms, the weak Fe-C(mu) interaction between the Fe atom of the unrotated Fe(CO)(3) and the C atom of the semibridged CO is formed to the detriment of the Fe-Fe bond interaction. These results suggest that the stabilization of the rotated forms on the cationic PES might be due to the formation of the weak Fe-C(mu) interaction minimizing the weakening of the Fe-Fe bond. The low-lying and lowest triplet excited-state PES investigated are characterized by the stabilization of the rotated forms over the all-terminal CO ligand arrangement. On the first singlet 1(1)A'' excited-state PES, an Fe(CO)(3) semirotated structure is the lowest-energy stationary point, while the exploration of the 1(1)A' and 2(1)A'' singlet excited PESs evidences the stabilization of the rotated over the all-terminal CO forms. Singlet excited-state optimized geometry results are compared with excited-state nuclear distortions recently obtained from resonance Raman excitation profiles. Finally, the results of the exploration of the 6(1)A' and 9(1)A' high-lying excited PESs are discussed in light of the recent ultraviolet photolysis experiments on a.

Recently a growing interest in the photochemical aspects of [FeFe] hydrogenases catalytic site and their biomimetic models has emerged. The photochemical aspects investigated range from the CO photolysis of the CO inhibited form of the enzyme to the excited state properties of the H-cluster models. [1] Regarding this last point, many efforts have been devoted to the investigation of the photochemical properties of simple diiron models of the [FeFe] hydrogenases catalytic site. The present contribution is focused on the Time-Dependent Density Functional theory (TDDFT) investigation of CO photolysis and photoisomerization of the trimetilphosphine (PMe3) derivative Fe2(S2C2H4)(CO)4(PMe3)2 starting from the recent ultrafast time-resolved infrared spectroscopy measurements [2,3]. By exploring the potential energy surfaces of low energy singlet excited states [4,5] the photoisomerization pathways has been characterized. Our calculation also show that the nature of this mechanism depends on the type of ligands coordinated to the iron atoms. The photoinduced CO dissociation involved excited states at higher excitation energy with the formation of a solvent adduct

Density functional theory has been used to study diiron dithiolates [HFe2(xdt)(PR3)n(CO)5-nX] (n = 0, 2, 4; R = H, Me, Et; X = CH3S-, PMe3, NHC = 1,3-dimethylimidazol-2-ylidene; xdt = adt, pdt; adt = azadithiolate; pdt = propanedithiolate). These species are related to the [FeFe]-hydrogenases catalyzing the 2H+ + 2e- 虠 H2 reaction. Our study is focused on the reduction step following protonation of the Fe2(SR)2 core. Fe(H)s detected in solution are terminal (t-H) and bridging (μ-H) hydrides. Although unstable versus μ-Hs, synthetic t-Hs feature milder reduction potentials than μ-Hs. Accordingly, attempts were previously made to hinder the isomerization of t-H to μ-H. Herein, we present another strategy: in place of preventing isomerization, μ-H could be made a stronger oxidant than t-H (E°μ-H > E°t-H). The nature and number of PR3 unusually affect ΔE°t-H-μ-H: 4PEt3 models feature a μ-H with a milder E° than t-H, whereas the 4PMe3 analogues behave oppositely. The correlation ΔE°t-H-μ-H 虠 stereoelectronic features arises from the steric strain induced by bulky Et groups in 4PEt3 derivatives. One-electron reduction alleviates intramolecular repulsions only in μ-H species, which is reflected in the loss of bridging coordination. Conversely, in t-H, the strain is retained because a bridging CO holds together the Fe2 core. That implies that E°μ-H > E°t-H in 4-PEt3 species but not in 4PMe3 analogues. Also determinant to observe E°μ-H > E°t-H is the presence of a Fe apical σ-donor because its replacement with a CO yields E°μ-H < E°t-H even in 4PEt3 species. Variants with neutral NHC and PMe3 in place of CH3S- still feature E°μ-H > E°t-H. Replacing pdt with (Hadt)+ lowers E° but yields E°μ-H < E°t-H, indicating that μ-H activation can occur to the detriment of the overpotential increase. In conclusion, our results indicate that the electron richness of the Fe2 core influences ΔE°t-H-μ-H, provided that (i) the R size of PR3 must be greater than that of Me and (ii) an electron donor must be bound to Fe apically.

The [FeFe] hydrogenase is a highly sophisticated enzyme for the synthesis of hydrogen via a biological route. The rotated state of the H-cluster in the [FeIFeI] form was found to be an indispensable criteria for an effective catalysis. Mimicking the specific rotated geometry of the [FeFe] hydrogenase active site is highly challenging as no protein stabilization is present in model compounds. In order to simulate the sterically demanding environment of the nature's active site, the sterically crowded meso-bis(benzylthio)diphenylsilane (2) was utilized as dithiolate linker in an [2Fe2S] model complex. The reaction of the obtained hexacarbonyl complex 3 with 1,2-bis(dimethylphosphino)ethane (dmpe) results three different products depending on the amount of dmpe used in this reaction: [{Fe2(CO)5{μ-(SCHPh)2SiPh2}}2(μ-dmpe)] (4), [Fe2(CO)5(κ2-dmpe){μ-(SCHPh)2SiPh2}] (5) and [Fe2(CO)5(μ-dmpe){μ-(SCHPh)2SiPh2}] (6). Interestingly, the molecular structure of compound 5 shows a [FeFe] subsite comprising a semi-rotated conformation, which was fully characterized as well as the other isomers 4 and 6 by elemental analysis, IR and NMR spectroscopy, X-ray diffraction analysis (XRD) and DFT calculations. The herein reported model complex is the first example so far reported for [FeIFeI] hydrogenase model complex showing a semi-rotated geometry without the need of stabilization via agostic interactions (Fe⋯H-C). This journal is

The di-iron complex Fe-2(S2C3H6)(CO)(6) (a), one of the simplest functional models of the Fe-hydrogenases active site, is able to electrocatalyze proton reduction. In the present study, the H-2 evolving path catalyzed by a has been characterized using density functional theory. It is showed that, in the early stages of the catalytic cycle, a neutral mu-H adduct is formed; monoelectron reduction and subsequent protonation can give rise to a diprotonated neutral species (a-mu H-SH), which is characterized by a mu-H group, a protonated sulfur atom, and a CO group bridging the two iron centers, in agreement with experimental IR data indicating the formation of a long-lived mu-CO species. H-2 release from a-mu H-SH, and its less stable isomer a-H-2 is kinetically unfavorable, while the corresponding monoanionic compounds (a-mu H-SH- and a-H-2(-)) are more reactive in terms of dihydrogen evolution, in agreement with experimental data. The key species involved in electrocatalysis have structural features different from the hypothetical intermediates recently proposed to be involved in the enzymatic process, an observation that is possibly correlated with the reduced catalytic efficiency of the biomimetic di-iron assembly.

International audience; Carbon monoxide is often described as a competitive inhibitor of FeFe hydrogenases, and it is used for probing H-2 binding to synthetic or in silico models of the active site H-cluster. Yet it does not always behave as a simple inhibitor. Using an original approach which combines accurate electrochemical measurements and theoretical calculations, we elucidate the mechanism by which, under certain conditions, CO binding can cause permanent damage to the H-cluster. Like in the case of oxygen inhibition, the reaction with CO engages the entire H-cluster, rather than only the Fe-2 subsite.

[FeFe]-hydrogenases are highly efficient H(2)-evolving metalloenzymes that include cyanides and carbonyls in the active site. The latter is an Fe(6)S(6) cluster (the so-called H-cluster) that can be subdivided into a binuclear portion carrying the CO and CN(-) groups and a tetranuclear subcluster. The fundamental role of cyanide ligands in increasing the basicity of the H-cluster has been highlighted previously. Here a more subtle but crucial role played by the two CN(-) ligands in the active site of [FeFe]-hydrogenases is disclosed. In fact, QM/MM calculations on all-atom models of the enzyme from Desulfovibrio desulfuricans show that the cyanide groups fine-tune the electronic and redox properties of the active site, affecting both the protonation regiochemistry and electron transfer between the two subclusters of the H-cluster. Despite the crucial role of cyanides in the protein active site, the currently available bioinspired electrocatalysts generally lack CN(-) groups in order to avoid competition between the latter and the catalytic metal centers for proton binding. In this respect, we show that a targeted inclusion of phosphine ligands in hexanuclear biomimetic clusters may restore the electronic and redox features of the wild-type H-cluster.

Quantum chemical methods allow one to investigate chemical aspects that are often difficult to evaluate using only experimental approaches. In particular, the continuous increase in reliability and speed of quantum chemical methods has recently allowed the investigation of very complex molecular systems, such as biological macromolecules. In this contribution, we present applications of quantum chemical methods to the investigation of reaction paths of metalloenzymes and related biomimetic models, using hydrogenase models as a reference case. In particular, we discuss several examples from the literature, emphasizing the possibilities (and limitations) offered by present theoretical approaches to study structures, electronic properties and reactivity of metalloenzyme models. Some relevant aspects which have not yet been fully explored using theoretical methods, such as the role of antiferromagnetic coupling and photochemical reactions in [Fe] hydrogenases, are treated in more detail, with presentation and discussion of original data recently obtained in our laboratory.