1. Oral versus intramuscular administration of vitamin B12 for vitamin B12 deficiency in primary care: a pragmatic, randomised, non-inferiority clinical trial (OB12)
- Author
-
Teresa Sanz-Cuesta, Esperanza Escortell-Mayor, Isabel Cura-Gonzalez, Jesus Martin-Fernandez, Rosario Riesgo-Fuertes, Sofía Garrido-Elustondo, Jose Enrique Mariño-Suárez, Mar Álvarez-Villalba, Tomás Gómez-Gascón, Inmaculada González-García, Paloma González-Escobar, Concepción Vargas-Machuca Cabañero, Mar Noguerol-Álvarez, Francisca García de Blas-González, Raquel Baños-Morras, Concepción Díaz-Laso, Nuria Caballero-Ramírez, Alicia Herrero de-Dios, Rosa Fernández-García, Jesús Herrero-Hernández, Belen Pose-García, María Luisa Sevillano-Palmero, Carmen Mateo-Ruiz, Beatriz Medina-Bustillo, Monica Aguilar-Jiménez, Isabel Gutiérrez-Sánchez, Ángeles Fernández-Abad, José Antonio Granados-Garrido, Javier Martínez-Suberviola, Margarita Beltejar-Rodríguez, Carmen Coello-Alarcón, Susana Diez-Arjona, Ana Ballarín-González, Ignacio Iscar-Valenzuela, José Luis Quintana-Gómez, José Antonio González-Posada-Delgado, Enrique Revilla-Pascual, Esther Gómez-Suarez, Yolanda Fernández-Fernández, Fernanda Morales-Ortiz, Isabel Ferrer-Zapata, Esperanza Duralde-Rodríguez, Milagros Beamud-Lagos, Mª del Pilar Serrano-Simarro, Cristina Montero-García, María Domínguez-Paniagua, Sofía Causín-Serrano, Josefa San Vicente-Rodríguez, Germán Reviriego-Jaén, Margarita Camarero-Shelly, Rosa Gómez-del Forcallo, María Ángeles Miguel-Abanto, Lourdes Reyes-Martínez, Alejandro Rabanal-Basalo, Carolina Torrijos-Bravo, Pilar Gutiérrez-Valentín, Jorge Gómez-Ciriano, Susana Parra Román, Judit León-González, Mª José Nebril-Manzaneque, Juana Caro-Berzal, Alberto López-García-Franco, Sonia Redondo de-Pedro, Juan Carlos García-Álvarez, Elisa Viñuela-Beneitez, Marisa López-Martín, Nuria Sanz-López, Ana María Ibarra-Sánchez, Cecilio Gómez-Almodóvar, Javier Muñoz-Gutiérrez, Carmen Molins-Santos, Cristina Cassinello-Espinosa, Antonio Molina-Siguero, Rafael Sáez-Jiménez, Paloma Rodríguez-Almagro, Eva María Rey-Camacho, María Carmen Pérez-García, Antonio Redondo-Horcajo, Beatriz Pajuelo-Márquez, Encarnación Cidoncha-Calderón, Jesús Galindo Rubio, RosaAna Escriva Ferrairo, José Francisco Ávila-Tomas, Francisco De-Alba-Gómez, Mª Jesús Gómez-Martín, Alma María Fernández-Martínez, Rosa Feijoó-Fernández, José Vizcaíno-Sánchez-Rodrigo, Victoria Díaz-Puente, Felisa Núñez-Sáez, Luisa Asensio-Ruiz, Agustín Sánchez-Sánchez, Orlando Enríquez-Dueñas, Silvia Fidel-Jaimez, Rafael Ruiz-Morote-Aragón, Asunción Pacheco-Pascua, Belén Soriano-Hernández, Eva Álvarez-Carranza, Carmen Siguero-Pérez, Ana Morán-Escudero, María Martín-Martín, Francisco Vivas-Rubio, Rafael Pérez-Quero, Mª Isabel Manzano-Martín, César Redondo-Luciáñez, Nuria Tomás-García, Carlos Díaz-Gómez-Calcerrada, Julia Isabel Mogollo-García, Inés Melero-Redondo, Ricardo González-Gascón, María Carmen Álvarez-Orviz, María Veredas González-Márquez, Teresa SanClemente-Pastor, Amparo Corral-Rubio, Asunción Prieto-Orzanco, Cristina dela Cámara-Gonzalez, Mercedes Parrilla-Laso, Mercedes Canellas-Manrique, Maria Eloisa Rogero-Blanco, Paulino Cubero-González, Sara Sanchez-Barreiro, Mª Ángeles Aragoneses-Cañas, Ángela Auñón-Muelas, Olga Álvarez Montes, Petra María Cortes-Duran, Pilar Tardaguila-Lobato, Mar Escobar Gallegos, Antonia Pérez-de-Colosia-Zuil, Jaime Inneraraty-Martínez, María Jesús Bedoya-Frutos, María Teresa López-López, Nelly Álvarez-Fernández, Teresa Fontova-Cemeli, Josefa Marruedo-Mateo, Josefa Díaz-Serrano, Beatriz Pérez-Vallejo, Pilar Hombrados-Gonzalo, Marta Quintanilla-Santamaría, Yolanda González-Pascual, Luisa María Andrés-Arreaza, Soledad Escolar-Llamazares, Cristina Casado-Rodríguez, Luzdel Rey-Moya, Jesús Fernández-Valderrama, Alejandro Medrán-López, Julia Alonso-Arcas, Alejandra Rabanal-Carrera, Araceli Garrido-Barral, Milagros Velázquez-García, Azucena Sáez-Berlanga, Pilar Pérez-Egea, Pablo Astorga-Díaz, Carlos Casanova-García, Ana Isabel Román-Ruiz, Carmen Belinchón-Moya, Margarita Encinas-Sotillo, Virtudes Enguita-Pérez, Ester Valdés-Cruz, Consuelo Mayoral-López, Teresa Gijón-Seco, Francisca Martínez-Vallejo, Jesica Colorado-Valera, Ana Sosa-Alonso, Jeannet Sánchez-Yépez, Dolores Serrano-González, Beatriz López-Serrano, Inmaculada Santamaría-López, Paloma Morso-Peláez, Carolina López-Olmeda, Almudena García-Uceda-Sevilla, Mercedes delPilar Fernández-Girón, Leonor González-Galán, Mariano Rivera-Moreno, Luis Nistal Martín-de-Serranos, Mª Jesús López-Barroso, Margarita Torres-Parras, María Verdugo-Rosado, Mª Reyes Delgado-Pulpón, Elena Alcalá-Llorente, Sonsoles Muñoz-Moreno, Isabel Vaquero-Turiño, Ana María Sánchez-Sempere, FranciscoJavier Martínez-Sanz, Clementa Sanz-Sanchez, AnaMaría Arias-Esteso, Diego Martín-Acicoya, Pilar Kloppe-Villegas, Francisco Javier San-Andrés-Rebollo, Magdalena Canals-Aracil, Isabel García-Amor, Nieves Calvo-Arrabal, María Milagros Jimeno-Galán, Gloriade la Sierra-Ocaña, María Mercedes Araujo-Calvo, Julia Timoner-Aguilera, María Santos Santander-Gutiérrez, Alicia Mateo-Madurga, Ricardo Rodríguez-Barrientos, Milagros Rico-Blázquez, Juan Carlos Gil-Moreno, Mariel Morey-Montalvo, Amaya Azcoaga Lorenzo, Gloria Ariza-Cardiel, Elena Polentinos-Castro, Sonia Soto-Díaz, Mª Teresa Rodríguez-Monje, Susana Martín-Iglesias, Francisco Rodríguez-Salvanés, Marta García-Solano, Rocío González-González, María Vicente Herrero, Ramón Rodríguez-González, Irene Bretón-Lesmes, Martadel Alamo Camuñas, Anabel Sánchez Espadas, Marisa Serrano Olmeda, Mª Angeles Gálvez Múgica, University of St Andrews. School of Medicine, and University of St Andrews. Population and Behavioural Science Division
- Subjects
medicine.medical_specialty ,Primary health care ,NDAS ,injections intramuscular ,Administration, Oral ,administration oral ,Quality of life ,SDG 3 - Good Health and Well-being ,Oral administration ,RA0421 ,equivalence trial ,Internal medicine ,RA0421 Public health. Hygiene. Preventive Medicine ,medicine ,Humans ,Vitamin B12 ,Adverse effect ,Aged ,Primary Health Care ,business.industry ,Bayes Theorem ,Vitamin B 12 Deficiency ,General Medicine ,Patient preference ,Clinical trial ,Vitamin B 12 ,Equivalence Trial ,Spain ,Quality of Life ,Medicine ,business ,General practice / Family practice ,patient preference - Abstract
The trial was financed by Ministerio de Sanidad y Consumo Español through their call for independent clinical research, Orden Ministerial SAS/2377, 2010 (EC10-115, EC10-116, EC10-117, EC10-119, EC10-122); CAIBER—Spanish Clinical Research Network, Instituto de Salud Carlos III (ISCIII) (CAI08/010044); and Gerencia Asistencial de Atención Primaria de Madrid. This study is also supported by the Spanish Clinical Research Network (SCReN), funded by ISCIII-Subdirección General de Evaluación y Fomento de la Investigación, project number PT13/0002/0007, within the National Research Program I+D+I 2013-2016 and co-funded with European Union ERDF funds (European Regional Development Fund). This project received a grant for the translation and publication of this article from the Foundation for Biomedical Research and Innovation in Primary Care (FIIBAP) Call 2017 for grants to promote research programs. Objectives To compare the effectiveness of oral versus intramuscular (IM) vitamin B12 (VB12) in patients aged ≥65 years with VB12 deficiency. Design Pragmatic, randomised, non-inferiority, multicentre trial in 22 primary healthcare centres in Madrid (Spain). Participants 283 patients ≥65 years with VB12 deficiency were randomly assigned to oral (n=140) or IM (n=143) treatment arm. Interventions The IM arm received 1 mg VB12 on alternate days in weeks 1–2, 1 mg/week in weeks 3–8 and 1 mg/month in weeks 9–52. The oral arm received 1 mg/day in weeks 1–8 and 1 mg/week in weeks 9–52. Main outcomes Serum VB12 concentration normalisation (≥211 pg/mL) at 8, 26 and 52 weeks. Non-inferiority would be declared if the difference between arms is 10% or less. Secondary outcomes included symptoms, adverse events, adherence to treatment, quality of life, patient preferences and satisfaction. Results The follow-up period (52 weeks) was completed by 229 patients (80.9%). At week 8, the percentage of patients in each arm who achieved normal B12 levels was well above 90%; the differences in this percentage between the oral and IM arm were −0.7% (133 out of 135 vs 129 out of 130; 95% CI: −3.2 to 1.8; p>0.999) by per-protocol (PPT) analysis and 4.8% (133 out of 140 vs 129 out of 143; 95% CI: −1.3 to 10.9; p=0.124) by intention-to-treat (ITT) analysis. At week 52, the percentage of patients who achieved normal B12 levels was 73.6% in the oral arm and 80.4% in the IM arm; these differences were −6.3% (103 out of 112 vs 115 out of 117; 95% CI: −11.9 to −0.1; p=0.025) and −6.8% (103 out of 140 vs 115 out of 143; 95% CI: −16.6 to 2.9; p=0.171), respectively. Factors affecting the success rate at week 52 were age, OR=0.95 (95% CI: 0.91 to 0.99) and having reached VB12 levels ≥281 pg/mL at week 8, OR=8.1 (95% CI: 2.4 to 27.3). Under a Bayesian framework, non-inferiority probabilities (Δ>−10%) at week 52 were 0.036 (PPT) and 0.060 (ITT). Quality of life and adverse effects were comparable across groups. 83.4% of patients preferred the oral route. Conclusions Oral administration was no less effective than IM administration at 8 weeks. Although differences were found between administration routes at week 52, the probability that the differences were below the non-inferiority threshold was very low. Publisher PDF
- Published
- 2020