1. Comparison of Operating Microscope and Exoscope in a Highly Challenging Experimental Setting
- Author
-
Aki Laakso, Johannes Dillmann, Mika Niemelä, Ahmad Hafez, Roel H.L. Haeren, Martin Lehecka, HUS Neurocenter, Neurokirurgian yksikkö, Helsinki University Hospital Area, Department of Neurosciences, Clinicum, RS: MHeNs - R3 - Neuroscience, MUMC+: MA Med Staf Spec Neurochirurgie (9), MUMC+: MA AIOS Neurochirurgie (9), and Neurochirurgie
- Subjects
Microsurgery ,Microscope ,Bypass ,Neurosurgery ,Magnification ,Neurosurgical Procedures ,3124 Neurology and psychiatry ,law.invention ,03 medical and health sciences ,Imaging, Three-Dimensional ,0302 clinical medicine ,law ,Demanding situation ,Operating microscope ,Humans ,Medicine ,Computer vision ,3D exoscope ,Microscopy ,business.industry ,3112 Neurosciences ,3126 Surgery, anesthesiology, intensive care, radiology ,Visualization ,030220 oncology & carcinogenesis ,Surgery ,Ergonomics ,Neurology (clinical) ,Artificial intelligence ,business ,Depth effect ,030217 neurology & neurosurgery - Abstract
BACKGROUND: The use of a digital three-dimensional (3D) exoscope system in neurosurgery is increasing as an alternative to the operative microscope. The objective of this study was to compare a digital 3D exoscope system with a standard operating microscope as a neurosurgical visualization tool in a highly challenging experimental setting. METHODS: End-to-side bypass procedures, each at a depth of 9 cm, were performed in a simulation setting. The quality of the task and the depth effect, visualization, magnification, illumination, and ergonomics were evaluated. RESULTS: No major differences were noted between the microscope and the 3D exoscope in terms of the quality of the work. Working with the 3D exoscope was more time-consuming than working with the microscope. Changing the depth and focus was faster using the operative microscope. The 3D exoscope enabled higher magnification and offered better ergonomic features. CONCLUSIONS: In a highly challenging experimental setting, comparable procedural quality was found for the microscope and the 3D exoscope. Each visualization tool had advantages and disadvantages. Over time and with technologic advances, the digital 3D exoscope may become the main operative visualization system in microneurosurgery.
- Published
- 2021