1. Comparison of four diagnostic criteria for invasive pulmonary aspergillosis—A diagnostic accuracy study in critically ill patients
- Author
-
Maria Schroeder, Melanie Giese, Charles Wijaya, Sarah Winterland, Annika Nuechtern, Joern Grensemann, Hanna Matthews, Dominic Wichmann, Johannes Stamm, Holger Rohde, Martin Christner, Ann‐Kathrin Ozga, Stefan Steurer, Axel Heinemann, Marcel Simon, Marlene Fischer, and Stefan Kluge
- Subjects
Cohort Studies ,Invasive Pulmonary Aspergillosis ,Aspergillus ,Infectious Diseases ,Critical Illness ,Humans ,Dermatology ,General Medicine ,Sensitivity and Specificity ,respiratory tract diseases - Abstract
BACKGROUND: In the absence of lung biopsy there are various algorithms for the diagnosis of invasive pulmonary aspergillosis (IPA) in intensive care unit (ICU) patients that rely on clinical signs, underlying conditions, radiological features, and mycology. The aim of the present study was to compare four diagnostic algorithms in their ability to differentiate between probable IPA (i.e. requiring treatment) and colonization in critically ill patients. In addition, we determined their diagnostic accuracy to detect proven IPA.METHODS: For this diagnostic accuracy study, we included a mixed ICU population with a positive Aspergillus culture from respiratory secretions that were treated in a German quarternary care hospital between 2005 and 2020. Four different diagnostic algorithms were applied to all patients. We compared agreement among the four algorithms to discriminate probable IPA from colonization. In a subgroup of patients with lung tissue histopathology available we determined the sensitivity and specificity of the single algorithms to detect proven IPA. RESULTS: A total number of 684 critically ill patients were included. The mean age of the study population was 63 years (IQR 52-73). Sixty-nine percent (n=472) were medical and 31% (n=212) were surgical ICU patients. Overall, 79% (n=543) of patients fulfilled the criteria for probable IPA according to at least one diagnostic algorithm. Only 4% of patients (n=29) fulfilled the criteria for probable IPA according to all four algorithms. Agreement among the four diagnostic criteria was low (Cohen’s kappa 0.07-0.29). From 85 patients with histopathological examination of lung tissue 40% (n=34) had confirmed IPA. The new EORTC/MSGERC ICU working group criteria had high specificity (0.59 [0.41-0.75]) and sensitivity (0.73 [0.59-0.85]).CONCLUSIONS:In a cohort of mixed ICU patients, the agreement among four algorithms for the diagnosis of IPA was low. The 2021 EORTC/MSGERC ICU working group criteria achieved the highest specificity and sensitivity to detect proven IPA. Although improved by the latest diagnostic criteria, the discrimination of invasive fungal infection from Aspergillus colonization in critically ill patients remains challenging and may require further optimization.
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF