Search

The beginning of 2022 was a time of major changes in the perception of energy availability and security in European countries. The aggression of Russia against Ukraine destabilizing the European energy economy, combined with the withdrawal from fossil fuels which has been going on for a dozen years, has strengthened activities to introduce new energy technologies based on renewable energy sources. One of the most promising and stable sources of renewable energy is geothermal energy, in particular enhanced geothermal systems (EGS) in hot dry rocks (HDR). These deposits occur at a great depth in almost every place on Earth, but due to their low permeability, they require hydraulic fracturing, which results in high investment costs. This technology has been developed for several decades. The current situation in Europe seems to confirm that its rapid development to a level that guarantees stable and profitable operation is crucial. This is of particular importance in the case of former member states of the economic zone of the Council for Mutual Economic Assistance, which until recently were heavily dependent on Russian energy. This review, based on the latest available data, covers potential HDR prospective areas in the countries of the south-eastern Baltic basin, including Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia and Poland. It is specific to this region that the original heat flux density is lower as a result of the paleoclimatic effect associated with the youngest ice age; however, thermal conditions do not deviate too much compared to western Europe, especially Rhine Graben, and significantly exceed the conditions of Finland, where an EGS project is currently being operated. In Lithuania, the most prospective area is the ZNI intrusion (south of Klaipeda), characterized by a geothermal gradient of up to 40 °C/1000 m. In addition, the Precambrian batholith south of Liepāja (Latvia) and the Rapakivi granites in the north and center of Estonia are promising EGS sites. Poland has relatively the most explored EGS potential, in both volcanic, crystalline and sedimentary rocks, especially in the area of the Szczecin Trough, Gorzów Block, Moglino-Łódź Trough and Karkonosze Mountains. Unfortunately, local tectonic conditions, in particular the development of faults and natural fracture zones that affect the directions of fracture propagation during hydraulic fracturing, have not been sufficiently recognized, which is one of the main barriers to the expansion of EGS pilot projects in these countries. These issues present challenges for the researchers, especially in terms of petrophysical analyses of rocks in target zones and local stress conditions, which have a key impact on fracturing operations and profitability of the systems. Despite high investment costs on the one hand and a significant slowdown in the global economy in 2022 on the other, it remains hopeful that the authorities of individual countries will decide to accelerate research work, leading to the implementation of pilot projects of EGS installations, and that this technology will be further improved to ensure a stable clean energy supply. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

• Two-Well EGS Approach : Demonstrated a promising method for extracting heat from hot dry rock (HDR) systems using a two-well injection-production system. • Comparative Analysis : A comparative study between the Utah FORGE project and Fervo Energy's efforts showcases an interplay of advancements and methodologies in the field of Enhanced Geothermal Systems (EGS). • Laboratory Core Analysis : Utilized comprehensive core sample analysis to underpin field data interpretations, confirming key geothermal parameters like permeability and porosity. • Advanced Analytical Techniques : Utilized analytical techniques, routinely used in unconventional oil and gas reservoirs, to precisely measure effective formation permeability from pressure falloff analysis. • Numerical Modeling Insights : Provided critical insights through numerical modeling, particularly on the permeability enhancement via hydraulic fracturing of EGS systems for heat extraction purposes. In this paper, we present analyses of laboratory and field data indicating that the current two-well, injection-production system, connected with multiple hydraulic fractures, is a very promising method for extracting heat from hot dry rock (HDR) systems to generate electricity. The current two-well system could be expanded to a three-well system consisting of one injection well and two symmetric producing wells connected via the central hydraulic fracture emanating from the injection well. To improve a uniform distribution of the injected fluid among all hydraulic fracture stages in the injection well, we advocate for field implementation of a newly designed well stimulation technique, the GeoThermOPTIMAL. We first present an analysis of the post-fracturing flow data obtained from an HDR geothermal injection well at the Utah FORGE Enhanced Geothermal System (EGS) research field site. The site is adjacent to the Roosevelt hydrothermal (HT) field. The objective of the study is to assess the effectiveness of well stimulation in extracting heat from the low-permeability, hot dry granitoid rock in the Utah FORGE research site. The study includes interpreting pressure falloff data obtained during the well stimulation process and employing laboratory-measured core data as a major input in the interpretation of the field falloff data. As a confirmation of the robustness of our analysis in Utah FORGE, we reviewed and analyzed the flow test results published for an injection-production doublet at the Blue Mountain EGS (Project Red) commercial site in Nevada. From the analyses of these two field tests, we have concluded that the interpretation and findings of the Blue Mountain EGS pilot test are consistent with the interpretation and findings from the Utah FORGE field research project test results. In summary, our engineering assessments began with laboratory experiments conducted on various core samples, including those from a granite outcrop and the Utah FORGE geothermal reservoir. These experiments aimed to measure key parameters such as matrix and fracture permeabilities, and porosities (k m ≈ 10 − 18 m 2 , k f , e f f ≈ 10 − 15 m 2 , ϕ m ≈ 10 − 1 , and ϕ f ≈ 10 − 4 ). These data served as guides and inputs for analytical and numerical solutions used to match the field pressure response of the geothermal wells. While we did not have core samples from the Blue Mountain EGS wells, we successfully applied the Utah FORGE analysis approach to the Blue Mountain site with cautious optimism. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The beginning of 2022 was a time of major changes in the perception of energy availability and security in European countries. The aggression of Russia against Ukraine destabilizing the European energy economy, combined with the withdrawal from fossil fuels which has been going on for a dozen years, has strengthened activities to introduce new energy technologies based on renewable energy sources. One of the most promising and stable sources of renewable energy is geothermal energy, in particular enhanced geothermal systems (EGS) in hot dry rocks (HDR). These deposits occur at a great depth in almost every place on Earth, but due to their low permeability, they require hydraulic fracturing, which results in high investment costs. This technology has been developed for several decades. The current situation in Europe seems to confirm that its rapid development to a level that guarantees stable and profitable operation is crucial. This is of particular importance in the case of former member states of the economic zone of the Council for Mutual Economic Assistance, which until recently were heavily dependent on Russian energy. This review, based on the latest available data, covers potential HDR prospective areas in the countries of the south-eastern Baltic basin, including Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia and Poland. It is specific to this region that the original heat flux density is lower as a result of the paleoclimatic effect associated with the youngest ice age; however, thermal conditions do not deviate too much compared to western Europe, especially Rhine Graben, and significantly exceed the conditions of Finland, where an EGS project is currently being operated. In Lithuania, the most prospective area is the ZNI intrusion (south of Klaipeda), characterized by a geothermal gradient of up to 40 °C/1000 m. In addition, the Precambrian batholith south of Liepāja (Latvia) and the Rapakivi granites in the north and center of Estonia are promising EGS sites. Poland has relatively the most explored EGS potential, in both volcanic, crystalline and sedimentary rocks, especially in the area of the Szczecin Trough, Gorzów Block, Moglino-Łódź Trough and Karkonosze Mountains. Unfortunately, local tectonic conditions, in particular the development of faults and natural fracture zones that affect the directions of fracture propagation during hydraulic fracturing, have not been sufficiently recognized, which is one of the main barriers to the expansion of EGS pilot projects in these countries. These issues present challenges for the researchers, especially in terms of petrophysical analyses of rocks in target zones and local stress conditions, which have a key impact on fracturing operations and profitability of the systems. Despite high investment costs on the one hand and a significant slowdown in the global economy in 2022 on the other, it remains hopeful that the authorities of individual countries will decide to accelerate research work, leading to the implementation of pilot projects of EGS installations, and that this technology will be further improved to ensure a stable clean energy supply.

Enhanced geothermal system (EGS) provides a feasible way for extracting geothermal energy from hot dry rock (HDR) reservoirs, whereas seismic risk it might induce and enormous cost impair its prospects. For sustainability, circulating fluid in a closed loop to extract thermal energy from a deep geothermal reservoir seems more reasonable and receives increasing attention. With this aim, using a super long gravity heat pipe (SLGHP) to extract geothermal energy from HDR reservoirs was tried by several researchers due to its extremely extraordinary heat transport ability. Jiang et al. designed a SLGHP, by which a thermal power as high as 200 kW was achieved from a 3000 m depth HDR reservoir successfully. The pioneering work proves the feasibility of a safer way for harvesting geothermal energy other than EGS, more importantly, it does not consume power and avoids the toughest issue of pipe scaling in a conventional geothermal production system. The article reviews the latest advances in SLGHPs for geothermal energy extraction. Laboratory experiments and representative in-situ tests are thoroughly analyzed with respect to technologies employing natural circulation inclusive of gravity-assisted heat pipe (GHP) to harvest geothermal energy. Theoretical and numerical work is also reviewed as significant supplements to experimental investigation. Key factors involved are discussed to clarify the challenges of GHPs in engineering for geothermal energy extraction. Low thermal extraction power and economic benefits as well as lack of highly efficient technology to convert heat to electricity are the main barriers of the application of SLGHPs in geothermal energy extraction and utilization. Nonetheless, previous investigation on SLGHPs offers new insights into geothermal energy exploitation from HDR reservoirs. • Advances of geothermal energy extraction using of SLGHP are summarized. • Prospects of SLGHP in harvesting geothermal energy are discussed. • Measures to improve the performance of a SLGHP are suggested. • A combined heat and power cogeneration system is proposed for in-situ geothermal energy utilization. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

This article presents a parametric study of closed loop geothermal systems (CLGSs) design with multiple lateral horizontal wells, drilled in Hot Dry Rocks (HDRs), by developing a coupled finite element method (FEM) model for the problem of transient heat production in the reservoir and an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) model for electricity generation evaluation at the surface. The design parameters are well spacing and geometry, the number of wells, injection flow rate, energy losses along the well, and ORC working and cooling fluid mass flow rates. The study evaluates how these parameters affect the evolution of the spatial distribution of the temperature of the rock mass, the circulation fluid temperature leaving the reservoir, and the rate of electrical power generation with seasonal variations in surface air temperature. Analysis shows that the temperature evolution of the reservoir over a wide range of realistic properties is not influenced significantly by the rock and fluid properties, injection flow rate, nor well length and diameter and is a function of time only, and the initial rock mass and injection fluid temperatures. Therefore, in a CLGS with a hexagonal array of horizontal wells, the distance between the wells, beyond which the performance of a hexagonal array of wells is practically indistinguishable from that of a single isolated well, is 200 m over 30 years; i.e., the produced fluid temperature is practically unaffected by heat extraction from neighboring wells, regardless of reservoir properties. For smaller well spacing (100 m), the system shows practically negligible interaction in the first 15 years and only a small impact (∼ 1%) during the next 15 years of heat production. The performance of a CLGS mainly depends on the fluid temperature leaving the reservoir (falling rapidly in the first few months) and ambient surface temperature (varying over a year). Using data from the FORGE Utah site, analysis suggests that a CLGS with four 1 km horizontal wells operated at 2 m 3 /min/well can produce ∼ 5 MW of electrical power during cold months and none during hot months. • A parametric study of Closed Loop Geothermal Systems in hot dry rock. • Evaluated the effects of well spacing, diameter and flow rates on electrical power. • Determined an optimal inter-well spacing of 100m in a hexagonal array • Demonstrated the impact of seasonal air temperature on power generation. • Determined the optimum ORC mass flow rates for 5 MW CLGS. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]