Search

The differential diagnosis of epileptic seizures (ES) and psychogenic non-epileptic seizures (PNES) is often difficult. The diagnostic gold standard is video-EEG, but this procedure is limited because of its high cost and is not always available. Research groups from Germany and Britain have used conversation analysis (CA) of patients' descriptions of their seizures as a means of differentiating the type of seizure. The aim of this study was to verify the value of their considerations in relation to the Italian language. Ten subjects (five with ES and five with PNES) diagnosed by means of the video-EEG recording of one seizure were studied under blind conditions by a linguist. The patients with ES described their seizures in as much detail as possible and tried to reconstruct the experience as fully as they can, making an effort to describe their subjective symptoms, quantify the duration of the phases preceding and following the seizure, and use the image of an external entity overcoming them. On the contrary, the patients with PNES repeated their extraneousness to the events that occur, refused to reply, expressed amnesia, reconstructed the happening by referring to descriptions provided by witnesses, and often describe their seizures using the image of an internal entity of which they were victims. The linguist correctly identified nine cases out of ten using CA. © 2012 Elsevier Inc.

Psychogenic nonepileptic seizures (PNES) can be observed in patients with or without epilepsy (mixed and pure PNES). Patients with mixed PNES are usually considered to be a homogeneous group characterized by the coexistent epilepsy. Our study found that patients with mixed PNES were not homogeneous, but could be divided into three groups based on epilepsy type, mental level, comorbid psychiatric disorders, and history of traumatic experiences. Group 1 patients have pharmacoresistant epilepsy, normal cognition, and comorbid anxiety and/or depressive disorders. Here, PNES etiology is the epilepsy-related problems. In group 2 patients, the epilepsy is associated with mental retardation and dependent personality traits. PNES etiology is represented by the reduction or cessation of seizures. The PNES allow patients to continue receiving attention from caregivers. Group 3 patients have epilepsy, normal cognition, comorbid cluster B personality disorders and anxiety disorders, and psychic trauma. Here, PNES etiology is not related to the epilepsy, but to the psychic trauma.