Search

Over the past 30 years many cryopreservation procedures have been applied to oocytes, embryos, sperm, ovarian and testicular tissue. Over this time many, often specialized, terms have been developed for all aspects of these procedures. This can make it difficult for readers who are not familiar with the terminology or protocols to compare and evaluate different procedures. This paper describes the main cryopreservation procedures, the terminology associated with them, and briefly explains the underlying physical, chemical and biological processes. The aim is to help readers understand and interpret other papers on slow cooling, rapid cooling, ultrarapid cooling and vitrification.

Solutions used for vitrification or rapid cooling of embryos usually contain high concentrations of penetrating cryoprotectants. At these concentrations embryos can tolerate the penetrating cryoprotectants for only short periods of time without damage. This study designed and tested cryoprotectant solutions that combined high polymer concentrations with low penetrating cryoprotectant concentrations. Mouse 2-cell embryo development was not compromised by up to 15-min exposure to 30 wt% solutions of the polymers Ficoll 70,000 MW or dextran 69,000 MW at room temperature. However, our batches of polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) 10,000 and PVP 40,000 were embryo-toxic even after extensive dialysis against Milli-Q water. As both Ficoll and dextran contribute to a solution's physical vitrification properties, we formulated vitrifying solutions containing only 11 to 27 wt% ethylene glycol (EG) by including 34 to 49 wt% polymers (27 wt% EG + 34 wt% Ficoll, 27 wt% EG + 34 wt% dextran, 16 wt% EG + 39 wt% Ficoll, or 11 wt% EG + 49 wt% Ficoll, in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS)). Novel solutions were designed for 0.25 ml straw as a viscous matrix for encapsulation of embryos. These yielded high rates of development of 2-cell mouse embryos after rapid cooling and warming (> or = 96% expanded blastocysts in vitro and > or = 62% viable fetuses as assessed on day 15 of gestation in vivo) in all tested solutions. All control 2-cell embryos formed expanded blastocysts in vitro and 78% formed fetuses in vivo. Comparable results were obtained with both 4-cell and 8- to 16-cell mouse embryos. The lower toxicity of Ficoll and dextran may explain why these new solutions gave better results than had previously been reported for solutions containing 7.5% PVP and low concentrations of EG (2 M)., (Copyright 2001 Elsevier Science.)

Double packaging, in which an inner straw containing the specimen is inserted into an outer, larger straw (here termed 'straw-in-straw') to prevent the inner straw from coming into direct contact with liquid nitrogen provides a simple strategy for reducing or eliminating the potential contamination risk associated with storage in liquid nitrogen. This approach has in the past been used in conjunction with cryopreservation by slow cooling, but has not previously been tested for use throughout an entire rapid cooling and warming procedure. This study determined whether keeping the straw containing the embryos inside a second protecting container throughout the cryopreservation and storage protocol would compromise embryo viability. We established that a cryoprotectant containing a high polymer concentration (35% dextran or Ficoll) together with 25% ethylene glycol (as the penetrating cryoprotectant) was highly effective for day 2 and day 3 mouse embryos in both single and double straws. The survival and development of all cryopreserved embryos, as assessed both in vitro and in vivo, was not statistically different to their untreated controls. This established that a protein/serum-free cryoprotectant solution supplemented with polymers could provide complete protection of mouse embryos. It also shows, for the first time, that embryos can be cooled by direct immersion in liquid nitrogen and warmed by direct immersion into a waterbath within a double straw arrangement to reduce the likelihood of contamination.

A systematic approach was taken to assess the vitrification properties of ethylene glycol-based solutions supplemented with carbohydrates. Solutions were prepared by weight (gravimetrically) using ethylene glycol as the cryoprotectant, 0.9% NaCl in water, and six different sugars: d-glucose, d(-)-fructose, d-sorbitol, sucrose, d(+)-trehalose, and raffinose. Sugars were added on a molal basis (0. 1, 0.5, and 1 m). Characteristics of the solutions were measured during warming by differential scanning calorimetry using a cooling rate of 100 degrees C/min and a warming rate of 10 degrees C/min. In the absence of carbohydrates a 59 wt% EG-saline solution formed a stable glass. When EG was replaced by an equimolal concentration of glucose, fructose, or sorbitol (monosaccharides) at 0.1, 0.5, or 1.0 m there was no change in the total solute concentration at which vitrification occurred, but the glass transition (Tg) occurred at a higher temperature than in EG-saline alone. When EG was replaced by an equimolal concentration of sucrose or trehalose (disaccharides) both the Tg and the lowest total solute concentration required for vitrification became progressively higher as the molecular weight, or the ratio of sugar to EG in the solutions, increased. At the highest tested disaccharide concentration (1 m) vitrification was achieved at a total solute concentration of 65 wt% (sucrose) and 67 wt% (trehalose). The polysaccharide raffinose significantly modified the vitrification properties of ethylene glycol solutions. When 0.5 or 0.1 m raffinose replaced EG on an equimolal basis the glass transition point was raised more than with either the monosaccharides or the disaccharides. Raffinose allowed vitrification at a total solute concentration of 67 wt% (0.5 m) and 63 wt% (0.1 m). The maturation of immature mouse oocytes, and the development of embryos in media containing 5-7 mM of any sugar was comparable to controls, indicating that they are not toxic. Exposure of freshly collected GV or MII oocytes to sugar concentrations between 0.5 and 1.0 M, for up to 10 min had no significant effect on the proportion which subsequently formed two cells. We conclude that added sugars do contribute to a solutions overall vitrification properties, and their properties should be taken into consideration when vitrification solutions are being designed or modified., (Copyright 1999 Academic Press.)

Mouse pronuclear and 4-cell embryos were cryopreserved by slow cooling to -33 degrees C in 1.5 M 1,2-propanediol or 1.5 M ethylene glycol, with or without 0.1 M sucrose. Straws were thawed by immersion into a 37 degrees C water bath, immediately after their removal from liquid nitrogen (protocol 1), or after being held in air for 15 (protocol 2) or 30 s (protocol 3). Others were held in air until the ice melted (protocol 4). Embryos which formed blastocysts that hatched and attached to the Petri dish in vitro (plated) were considered viable. The thawing protocol did not significantly influence the viability of embryos frozen in propanediol with 0.1 M sucrose (52-72% of pronuclear and 69-97% of 4-cell embryos plated). In the other solutions tested, propanediol without sucrose and ethylene glycol with/without sucrose, only protocol 2 resulted in uniformly high development of both pronuclear (45-65% plating) and 4-cell embryos (70-97% plating). Thawing protocol 4 significantly reduced development, in particular for embryos frozen in ethylene glycol (0% 1-cell; 0-25% 4-cell plating). The difference between thawing protocols 2 and 4 was reduced by continuing slow cooling of ethylene glycol solutions to lower temperatures (-41 degrees C). Adding antifreeze proteins type I or III did not improve survival or development. Thus, although mouse pronuclear and 4-cell embryos can be frozen-thawed in either ethylene glycol or propanediol without significant loss of viability, an appropriate thawing protocol is essential for embryos frozen in ethylene glycol or propanediol-sucrose.

Two systems for measuring embryo development in vitro were evaluated. One was a 1-4 scale based on a subjective evaluation of embryo quality (EQ) from microscopic appearance. In addition, a formula for scoring embryo growth rate in vitro was developed. The embryo development rating (EDR) was based on the ratio between the time at which embryos were observed at a particular stage after insemination and the time at which they would be expected to reach that stage in a hypothetical "ideal" growth rate with a cell cycle length of 11.9 hr. Using this scoring system, "normally" growing embryos scored 100. This approach was aimed at partially normalizing the data and allowed all embryos to be analyzed similarly regardless of the time of observation. Analysis of 1539 embryo replacements resulting in 232 clinical pregnancies showed that both EDR and embryo-quality scores were of value in predicting success, with clinical pregnancy most likely to eventuate from a combination of moderate to good EQ scores (2-4) coupled with average or above-average growth rates (EDR scores from 90 to 129). Poor-quality and very slowly or very rapidly growing embryos were underrepresented in cycles that proceeded to pregnancy. These inferences were based on all embryos transferred (mean, 2.73 per transfer cycle), and they were substantiated by an analysis of 33 pregnancies resulting from replacement of a single embryo and from 18 pregnancies in which all embryos scored the same with both systems. EQ and EDR were significantly associated with each other and together provide a valuable guide in predicting pregnancy, in selecting embryos for freezing, and in monitoring day-to-day performance in the in vitro fertilization (IVF) program.

While optimizing the ultrarapid embryo freezing procedure we noted that embryo survival was lowest when gas bubbles formed in the straws. Here we report the influences of gassing the freezing solutions with 5% CO2 in air, degassing the solution, the pH of the medium and straw irradiation on the survival and development in vitro of 2-cell mouse embryos. Embryos were ultrarapidly frozen in medium M2 containing 3 M dimethyl sulphoxide and 0.25 M sucrose. Significantly fewer embryos survived freezing and thawing in gassed solutions. The subsequent development of intact embryos to blastocysts was similar in gassed and non-gassed solutions. Survival and development of embryos frozen in solutions of pH 7.0, 7.6 or 8.0 was similar, but fewer embryos developed to blastocysts after freezing in media at pH 6.0. In straws sterilized by gamma irradiation before use, embryo survival after freezing and thawing was dramatically reduced compared with that seen when non-irradiated straws were used. With non-gassed solutions significantly more gas bubbles formed in irradiated straws than in non-irradiated straws. Although bubble formation was significantly reduced in all straws by using degassed freezing solutions, this did not improve embryo survival. We conclude that under conditions normally used for ultrarapid freezing, dissolved gas and pH have less effect on embryo viability than the use of irradiated straws.