1. Weighing third-party fairness, efficiency, and self-interest in resource allocation decisions
- Author
-
Johansson, Lars-Olof, Gustafsson, Mathias, Olsson, Lars, and Garling, Tommy
- Subjects
Advertising, marketing and public relations ,Economics ,Psychology and mental health - Abstract
To link to full-text access for this article, visit this link: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.joep.2006.01.007 Byline: Lars-Olof Johansson, Mathias Gustafsson, Lars Olsson, Tommy Garling Keywords: Allocation decisions; Third-party fairness; Self-interest; Efficient resource use; Social dilemma; Goal conflicts Abstract: In two experiments participants allocated a resource between themselves, one privileged, and one unprivileged group. Conflicts were induced between 'third-party fairness' (difference in payoff to the two groups) and efficient resource use. Experiment 1 employed 42 undergraduates making multi-stage allocation decisions. Fairness was varied at three levels and self-interest, operationalized as the political motive of win votes, at two levels. Adverse effects of fairness on preserving the resource were found. In Experiment 2 another 48 undergraduates performed a similar task. Self-interest was now operationalized as a financial motive. The results showed that participants reduced their resource use when neither fairness nor self-interest was salient. A regression analysis demonstrated consistent adverse effects of fairness on resource use controlling for efficient resource use and total group payoff. It was concluded that fairness causes decision makers to overuse resources, although they are unwilling to totally deplete a resource and will make compromises. Author Affiliation: Goteborg University, Gothenburg, Sweden Article History: Received 6 July 2005; Revised 15 December 2005; Accepted 9 January 2006
- Published
- 2007