Search

The repair of 12-, 27-, 62-, and 216-nucleotide unpaired insertion/deletion heterologies has been demonstrated in nuclear extracts of human cells. When present in covalently closed circular heteroduplexes or heteroduplexes containing a single-strand break 3' to the heterology, such structures are subject to a low level repair reaction that occurs with little strand bias. However, the presence of a single-strand break 5' to the insertion/deletion heterology greatly increases the efficiency of rectification and directs repair to the incised DNA strand. Because nick direction of repair is independent of the strand in which a particular heterology is placed, the observed strand bias is not due to asymmetry imposed on the heteroduplex by the extrahelical DNA segment. Strand-specific repair by this system requires ATP and the four dNTPs and is inhibited by aphidicolin. Repair is independent of the mismatch repair proteins MSH2, MSH6, MLH1, and PMS2 and occurs by a mechanism that is distinct from that of the conventional mismatch repair system. Large heterology repair in nuclear extracts of human cells is also independent of the XPF gene product, and extracts of Chinese hamster ovary cells deficient in the ERCC1 and ERCC4 gene products also support the reaction.

A subset of sporadic colorectal tumors and most tumors developing in hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer patients display frequent alterations in microsatellite sequences. Such tumors have been thought to manifest replication errors (RER+), but the basis for the alterations has remained conjectural. We demonstrate that the mutation rate of (CA)n repeats in RER+ tumor cells is at least 100-fold that in RER- tumor cells and show by in vitro assay that increased mutability of RER+ cells is associated with a profound defect in strand-specific mismatch repair. This deficiency was observed with microsatellite heteroduplexes as well as with heteroduplexes containing single base-base mismatches and affected an early step in the repair pathway. Thus, a true mutator phenotype exists in a subset of tumor cells, the responsible defect is likely to cause transitions and transversions in addition to microsatellite alterations, and a biochemical basis for this phenotype has been identified.

The human lymphoblastoid MT1 B-cell line was previously isolated as one of a series of mutant cells able to survive the cytotoxic effects of N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG). MT1 cells nevertheless remain sensitive to mutagenesis by MNNG and display a mutator phenotype. These phenotypes have been attributed to a single genetic alteration postulated to confer a defect in strand-specific mismatch repair, a proposal that attributes the cytotoxic effect of DNA alkylation in wild-type cells to futile attempts to correct mispairs that arise during replication of alkylated template strands. Our results support this view. MNNG-induced mutations in the HPRT gene of MT1 cells are almost exclusively G.C-->A.T transitions, while spontaneous mutations observed in this mutator cell line are single-nucleotide insertions, transversions, and A.T-->G.C transitions. In vitro assay has demonstrated that the MT1 line is in fact deficient in strand-specific correction of all eight base-base mispairs. This defect, which is manifest at or prior to the excision stage of the reaction, is due to simple deficiency of a required activity because MT1 nuclear extracts can be complemented by a partially purified HeLa fraction to restore in vitro repair. These findings substantiate the idea that strand-specific mismatch repair contributes to alkylation-induced cytotoxicity and imply that this process serves as a barrier to spontaneous transition, transversion, and insertion/deletion mutations in mammalian cells.

Nuclear extracts prepared from a HeLa cell line have been previously shown to support strand-specific repair of heteroduplex DNAs containing a site-specific, strand-specific incision (Holmes, J.J., Clark, S., and Modrich, P. (1990) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 87, 5837-5841; Thomas, D.C., Roberts, J.D., and Kunkel, T.A. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 3744-3751). Further analysis of the substrate specificity of the reaction has shown that in addition to G-T, A-C, G-G, and C-C, nuclear extracts also recognize and correct in a strand-specific manner A-A, A-G, T-T, and C-T mismatches, with repair in each case being inhibited by aphidicolin. The rate of repair of a circular G-T heteroduplex was found to decrease monotonically with increasing separation between the mismatch and the strand break that targets repair, as viewed along the shorter path joining the two sites in the circular substrate. This decrease is independent of the polarity of the incised strand, suggesting that the human pathway of mismatch correction may possess a bidirectional excision capability similar to that of the Escherichia coli methyl-directed system. This possibility was confirmed by analysis of excision tracts associated with the reaction. Inhibition of DNA synthesis by aphidicolin or by omission of exogenous dNTPs leads to the mismatch-provoked formation of a single-strand gap that spans the shorter path between the strand break and the mismatch, irrespective of the polarity of the incised strand. Formation of these gaps, which extend from the site of the strand break to terminate at a number of discrete sites in the region 90 to 170 nucleotides beyond the mismatch, is therefore independent of the relative orientation of the two sites. Based on similar mismatch specificities and common features of mechanism, we have concluded that the human strand-specific mismatch repair system is functionally homologous to the bacterial methyl-directed pathway.