Search

CLC-ec1 is a Cl - /H + antiporter that forms stable homodimers in lipid bilayers, with a free energy of -10.9 kcal/mol in 2:1 POPE/POPG lipid bilayers. The dimerization interface is formed by four transmembrane helices: H, I, P and Q, that are lined by non-polar side-chains that come in close contact, yet it is unclear as to whether their interactions drive dimerization. To investigate whether non-polar side-chains are required for dimer assembly, we designed a series of constructs where side-chain packing in the dimer state is significantly reduced by making 4-5 alanine substitutions along each helix (H-ala, I-ala, P-ala, Q-ala). All constructs are functional and three purify as stable dimers in detergent micelles despite the removal of significant side-chain interactions. On the other hand, H-ala shows the unique behavior of purifying as a mixture of monomers and dimers, followed by a rapid and complete conversion to monomers. In lipid bilayers, all four constructs are monomeric as examined by single-molecule photobleaching analysis. Further study of the H-helix shows that the single mutation L194A is sufficient to yield monomeric CLC-ec1 in detergent micelles and lipid bilayers. X-ray crystal structures of L194A reveal the protein re-assembles to form dimers, with a structure that is identical to wild-type. Altogether, these results demonstrate that non-polar membrane embedded side-chains play an important role in defining dimer stability, but the stoichiometry is highly contextual to the solvent environment. Furthermore, we discovered that L194 is a molecular hot-spot for defining dimerization of CLC-ec1., Competing Interests: Declaration of Competing Interest The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper., (Copyright © 2021 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.)

Many ion channels are multisubunit complexes where oligomerization is an obligatory requirement for function as the binding axis forms the charged permeation pathway. However, the mechanisms of in-membrane assembly of thermodynamically stable channels are largely unknown. Here, we demonstrate a key advance by reporting the dimerization equilibrium reaction of an inverted-topology, homodimeric fluoride channel Fluc in lipid bilayers. While the wild-type channel is a long-lived dimer, we leverage a known mutation, N43S, that weakens Na+ binding in a buried site at the interface, thereby unlocking the complex for reversible association in lipid bilayers. Single-channel recordings show that Na+ binding is required for fluoride conduction while single-molecule microscopy experiments demonstrate that N43S Fluc exists in a dynamic monomer-dimer equilibrium in the membrane, even following removal of Na+. Quantifying the thermodynamic stability while titrating Na+ indicates that dimerization occurs first, providing a membrane-embedded binding site where Na+ binding weakly stabilizes the complex. To understand how these subunits form stable assemblies while presenting charged surfaces to the membrane, we carried out molecular dynamics simulations, which show the formation of a thinned membrane defect around the exposed dimerization interface. In simulations where subunits are permitted to encounter each other while preventing protein contacts, we observe spontaneous and selective association at the native interface, where stability is achieved by mitigation of the membrane defect. These results suggest a model wherein membrane-associated forces drive channel assembly in the native orientation while subsequent factors, such as Na+ binding, result in channel activation. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The CLC-ec1 chloride/proton antiporter is a membrane-embedded homodimer with subunits that can dissociate and associate, but the thermodynamic driving forces favor the assembled dimer at biological densities. Yet, the physical reasons for this stability are confounding as dimerization occurs via the burial of hydrophobic interfaces away from the lipid solvent. For binding of nonpolar surfaces in aqueous solution, the driving force is often attributed to the hydrophobic effect, but this should not apply in the membrane since there is very little water. To investigate this further, we quantified the thermodynamic changes associated with CLC dimerization in membranes by carrying out a van ‘t Hoff analysis of the temperature dependency of the free energy of dimerization, ΔG°. To ensure that the reaction reached equilibrium at different temperatures, we utilized a Förster resonance energy transfer assay to report on relaxation kinetics of subunit exchange as a function of temperature. Equilibration times were then applied to measure CLC-ec1 dimerization isotherms at different temperatures using the single-molecule subunit-capture photobleaching analysis approach. The results demonstrate that the dimerization free energy of CLC in Escherichia coli–like membranes exhibits a nonlinear temperature dependency corresponding to a large, negative change in heat capacity, a signature of solvent ordering effects such as the hydrophobic effect. Consolidating this with our previous molecular analyses suggests that the nonbilayer defect required to solvate the monomeric state is one source of the observed change in heat capacity and indicates the existence of a generalizable driving force for protein association in membranes. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Over two-thirds of integral membrane proteins of known structure assemble into oligomers. Yet, the forces that drive the association of these proteins remain to be delineated, as the lipid bilayer is a solvent environment that is both structurally and chemically complex. In this study, we reveal how the lipid solvent defines the dimerization equilibrium of the CLC-ec1 Cl-/H+ antiporter. Integrating experimental and computational approaches, we show that monomers associate to avoid a thinned-membrane defect formed by hydrophobic mismatch at their exposed dimerization interfaces. In this defect, lipids are strongly tilted and less densely packed than in the bulk, with a larger degree of entanglement between opposing leaflets and greater water penetration into the bilayer interior. Dimerization restores the membrane to a near-native state and therefore, appears to be driven by the larger free-energy cost of lipid solvation of the dissociated protomers. Supporting this theory, we demonstrate that addition of short-chain lipids strongly shifts the dimerization equilibrium toward the monomeric state, and show that the cause of this effect is that these lipids preferentially solvate the defect. Importantly, we show that this shift requires only minimal quantities of short-chain lipids, with no measurable impact on either the macroscopic physical state of the membrane or the protein's biological function. Based on these observations, we posit that free-energy differentials for local lipid solvation define membrane-protein association equilibria. With this, we argue that preferential lipid solvation is a plausible cellular mechanism for lipid regulation of oligomerization processes, as it can occur at low concentrations and does not require global changes in membrane properties. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The thermodynamic reasons why membrane proteins form stable complexes inside the hydrophobic lipid bilayer remain poorly understood. This is largely because of a lack of membrane-protein systems amenable for equilibrium studies and a limited number of methods for measuring these reactions. Recently, we reported the equilibrium dimerization of the CLC-ec1 Cl-/H+ transporter in lipid bilayers (Chadda et al. 2016. eLife. https ://doi.org /10 .7554 /eLife .17438), which provided a new type of model system for studying protein association in membranes. The measurement was conducted using the subunit-capture approach, involving passive dilution of the protein in large multilamellar vesicles, followed by single-molecule photobleaching analysis of the Poisson distribution describing protein encapsulation into extruded liposomes. To estimate the fraction of dimers (FDimer) as a function of protein density, the photobleaching distributions for the nonreactive, ideal monomer and dimer species must be known so that random co-capture probabilities can be accounted for. Previously, this was done by simulating the Poisson process of protein reconstitution into a known size distribution of liposomes composed of Escherichia coli polar lipids (EPLs). In the present study, we investigate the dependency of FDimer and ΔG° on the modeling through a comparison of different liposome size distributions (EPL versus 2:1 POPE/POPG). The results show that the estimated FDimer values are comparable, except at higher densities when liposomes become saturated with protein. We then develop empirical controls to directly measure the photobleaching distributions of the nonreactive monomer (CLC-ec1 I201W/I422W) and ideal dimer (WT CLC-ec1 cross-linked by glutaraldehyde or CLC-ec1 R230C/L249C cross-linked by a disulfide bond). The measured equilibrium constants do not depend on the correction method used, indicating the robustness of the subunit-capture approach. This strategy therefore presents a model-free way to quantify protein dimerization in lipid bilayers, offering a simplified strategy in the ongoing effort to characterize equilibrium membrane-protein reactions in membranes. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Interactions between membrane protein interfaces in lipid bilayers play an important role in membrane protein folding but quantification of the strength of these interactions has been challenging. Studying dimerization of ClC-type transporters offers a new approach to the problem, as individual subunits adopt a stable and functionally verifiable fold that constrains the system to two states - monomer or dimer. Here, we use single-molecule photobleaching analysis to measure the probability of ClC-ec1 subunit capture into liposomes during extrusion of large, multilamellar membranes. The capture statistics describe a monomer to dimer transition that is dependent on the subunit/lipid mole fraction density and follows an equilibrium dimerization isotherm. This allows for the measurement of the free energy of ClC-ec1 dimerization in lipid bilayers, revealing that it is one of the strongest membrane protein complexes measured so far, and introduces it as new type of dimerization model to investigate the physical forces that drive membrane protein association in membranes. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]