Search

Objectives: This study compared the rates of coronary artery bypass graft surgery and 15-year survival for men and women after initial medical or surgical management., Background: There has been concern that women with coronary artery disease are managed differently than men and that men and women have a different prognosis. The Coronary Artery Surgery Study (CASS) registry is a large data base of well characterized patients with long-term follow-up., Methods: Patients underwent cardiac catheterization at 1 of 15 hospitals during 1974 to 1979. Bypass surgery rates were based on 12,452 men and 2,366 women. Survival results were based on 6,018 men and 1,095 women with operable coronary artery disease and initial medical management and 6,922 men and 1,291 women initially managed surgically., Results: At 15 years, bypass surgery rates were 75% for men and 72% for women (p = 0.91). The rates remained similar after adjustment for clinical and angiographic variables. The 15-year survival rate was 50% for men and 49% for women with initial medical treatment (p = 0.53) and 52% for men and 48% for women (p = 0.004) with initial surgical treatment, a difference similar to that for operative mortality (men 2.5%, women 5.3%, p < 0.0001). Survival was improved by bypass surgery in most subgroups, with largest relative risks for high risk patients. Relative risks were similar for men and women., Conclusions: The rate of bypass surgery did not differ between men and women. There were few differences in the survival of men and women. In general, both men and women with initial surgical treatment survived longer, although benefits were clinically and statistically significant only in those at high risk. The benefit was similar in both men and women.

We carried out a systematic overview using individual patient data from the seven randomised trials that have compared a strategy of initial coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery with one of initial medical therapy to assess the effects on mortality in patients with stable coronary heart disease (stable angina not severe enough to necessitate surgery on grounds of symptoms alone, or myocardial infarction). 1324 patients were assigned CABG surgery and 1325 medical management between 1972 and 1984. The proportion of patients in the medical treatment group who had undergone CABG surgery was 25% at 5 years, 33% at 7 years, and 41% at 10 years: 93.7% of patients assigned to the surgery group underwent CABG surgery. The CABG group had significantly lower mortality than the medical treatment group at 5 years (10.2 vs 15.8%; odds ratio 0.61 [95% CI 0.48-0.77], p = 0.0001), 7 years (15.8 vs 21.7%; 0.68 [0.56-0.83], p < 0.001), and 10 years (26.4 vs 30.5%; 0.83 [0.70-0.98]; p = 0.03). The risk reduction was greater in patients with left main artery disease than in those with disease in three vessels or one or two vessels (odds ratios at 5 years 0.32, 0.58, and 0.77, respectively). Although relative risk reductions in subgroups defined by other baseline characteristics were similar, the absolute benefits of CABG surgery were most pronounced in patients in the highest risk categories. This effect was most evident when several prognostically important clinical and angiographic risk factors were integrated to stratify patients by risk levels and the extension of survival at 10 years was examined (change in survival -1.1 [SE 3.1] months in low-risk group, 5.0 [4.2] months in moderate-risk group, and 8.8 [5.4] months in high-risk group; p for trend < 0.003). A strategy of initial CABG surgery is associated with lower mortality than one of medical management with delayed surgery if necessary, especially in high-risk and medium-risk patients with stable coronary heart disease. In low-risk patients, the limited data show a non-significant trend towards greater mortality with CABG.

The clinical characteristics and long-term survival of 284 patients from the Coronary Artery Surgery Study (CASS) registry data base who had moderate to severe congestive heart failure symptoms and a left ventricular ejection fraction greater than or equal to 0.45 were studied. A control group consisting of registry patients with an ejection fraction greater than or equal to 0.45 who did not have heart failure was used for comparison. Patients who had heart failure were older and more likely to be female and to have a higher incidence of hypertension, diabetes and chronic lung disease than registry patients who did not have heart failure. As a group, patients with heart failure had more severe angina and were more likely to have had a prior myocardial infarction than were registry patients without heart failure. At 6 year follow-up, 82% of patients in the heart failure group survived compared with 91% of patients in the control group (p less than 0.0001). Multivariate analysis using the Cox proportional hazards model identified the following independent predictors of mortality: regional ventricular systolic dysfunction, number of diseased coronary arteries, advanced age, hypertension, lung disease, diabetes, increased left ventricular end-diastolic pressure and heart failure symptoms. Among patients with heart failure, the 6-year survival rate of those who had three-vessel coronary artery disease was 68% compared with 92% for the group without coronary artery disease. However, the 6-year survival rate for patients with heart failure who underwent surgical revascularization of diseased coronary arteries was not significantly improved compared with that of patients treated medically.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Multivariate linear discriminant function analysis on maximal exercise treadmill and angiographic data from 500 men with definite angina, 584 men with probable angina and 267 men with nonspecific chest pain identified independent predictors of presence and extent of coronary disease. We used the discriminant function to develop a clinical risk index and a clinical and exercise risk index for each patient subset. Probability curves were generated to predict the presence and extent of coronary disease. In definite angina cases, exercise testing provided more diagnostic information than clinical data alone. However, in the 10% of cases with the smallest risk indexes, half of the patients had coronary disease and one-quarter had multivessel disease. In men with probable angina, exercise testing added substantially more diagnostic information than clinical data. The probability of multivessel disease was reduced to less than 10% for 30% of patients with probable angina, an important diagnostic contribution. Exercise testing in men with nonspecific chest pain was of limited value because disease prevalence was already low.

To determine to what extent the diagnostic accuracy of stress testing is influenced by the prevalence of coronary artery disease, we correlated the description of chest pain, the ST-segment response to exercise, and the results of coronary arteriography in 1465 men and 580 women from the registry for the Coronary Artery Surgery Study (CASS). A positive ST-segment response increased the pre-test risk by only 7 to 20%, whereas a negative ST-segment response decreased the risk by only 2 to 28%. Although the percentage of false positive results differed between men and women (12 +/- 1% vs 53 +/-- 3%, p less than 0.001), this difference was not seen in a subgroup matched for prevalence of coronary artery disease. Thus, the ability of stress testing to predict coronary artery disease is limited in a heterogenous population in which the prevalence of disease can be estimated through classification of chest pain and the sex of the patient. Additional multivariant linear discriminant function analysis on treadmill and angiographic data from 500 men with definite angina, 584 men with probable angina and 267 men with nonspecific chest pain identified independent predictors of presence and extent of coronary disease. The discriminant function developed clinical, and clinical and exercise risk indices for each patient subset. Probability curves demonstrated that exercise testing provided more diagnostic information than clinical data alone in patients with definite and probable angina. However, exercise testing in men with nonspecific chest pain was of limited value since disease prevalence was already low. We conclude that (a) analysis of the ST-segment response to exercise provides limited information regarding the diagnosis of coronary artery disease when used alone, and (b) use of other exercise variables in addition to clinical data improves the diagnostic ability of the exercise test in men with definite or probable angina.

The prevalence of coronary artery stenoses greater than or equal to 70% or left main stenosis greater than or equal to 50% was evaluated in 20,391 patients who underwent angiography in the Coronary Artery Surgery Study from 1975-1979. After the patients with unstable angina or myocardial infarction were excluded, the disease prevalence in the 8157 patients with definite angina, probable angina, and nonspecific chest pain was 93%, 66% and 14% in men and 72%, 36% and 6% in women (p less than 0.001). The age and sex of the patients and character of chest pain were important determinants of disease prevalence and severity. Left main or three-vessel coronary disease occurred in more than 50% of middle-aged men and older women with definite angina and in more than 50% of men who had probable angina and were older than 60 years of age. In contrast, left main coronary disease occurred in less than 2% of 1282 men and less than 1% of 1397 women with nonspecific chest pain regardless of age. In this latter patient subset, less than 5% of men and less than 1% of women in each decade under 60 years had left main or three-vessel coronary artery disease. Thus, high-risk coronary disease is common in middle-aged patients with definite angina and older patients with probable angina, but is rare in patients with nonspecific chest pain. Indications and guidelines for diagnostic noninvasive tests and coronary angiography could be based on these results.

Apparent filling defects compatible with left ventricular thrombus are occasionally noted in equilibrium radionuclide angiocardiograms. To define the usefulness of the radionuclide angiogram in detecting left ventricular thrombus, the anterior and left anterior oblique radionuclide angiograms of 39 patients with proved presence or absence of thrombus were blindly interpreted. The presence of thrombus was proved at autopsy in 5 patients, at cardiac operation in 2, or on indium-111 platelet imaging in 6; the absence of thrombus was proved at autopsy in 24 or at cardiac operation in 2. Overall, 13 radionuclide angiograms were interpreted as positive (n = 10) or equivocally positive (n = 3) for thrombus, and 26 studies were judged negative. The sensitivity of a positive or equivocally positive radionuclide angiogram for detection of thrombus was 77 percent (10 of 13 patients), the specificity 88 percent (23 of 26 patients), the positive predictive value 77 percent the negative predictive value 88 percent. If the three equivocal studies are instead considered negative for thrombus, the sensitivity was 62 percent, the specificity 92 percent, the positive predictive value 80 percent and the negative predictive value 93 percent. All thrombi were visualized in the anterior view in an area of akinetic or dyskinetic wall motion. A small group of 13 patients (8 with thrombus, 5 without) underwent two dimensional echocardiography, which was 100 percent sensitive and specific. The finding of a discrete filling defect or squared or cutoff ventricular apex in an area of abnormal wall motion in the anterior view of the radionuclide angiogram should suggest the diagnosis of ventricular thrombus, which may be confirmed by other noninvasive studies.

To determine to what extent the diagnostic accuracy of stress testing is influenced by the prevalence of coronary-artery disease, we correlated the description of chest pain, the result of stress testing and the results of coronary arteriography in 1465 men and 580 women from a multicentered clinical trial. The pre-test risk (prevalence of coronary-artery disease) varied from 7 to 87 per cent, depending on sex and classification of chest pain. A positive stress test increased the pre-test risk by only 6 to 20 per cent, whereas a negative test decreased the risk by only 2 to 28 per cent. Aothough the percentage of false-positive results differed between men and women (12 +/- 1 per cent versus 53 +/- 3 per cent P less than 0.001), this difference was not seen in a subgroup matched for prevalence of coronary-artery disease. We conclude that the ability of stress testing to predict coronary-artery disease is limited in a heterogeneous population in which the prevalence of disease can be estimated through classification of chest pain and the sex of the patient.

Regional coronary blood flow distribution was studied by myocardial imaging after intracoronary injection of technetium-99m- and indium-113m-macroaggregated albumin at rest and during coronary hyperemia induced by intracoronary injection of Hypaque-M, 75 percent. The four- to five-fold increase in coronary flow after injection of radiographic contrast material was similar in magnitude to that occurring with maximal exercise stress. Experimentally, resting coronary blood flow and regional distribution of radioactive particles remains normal in spite of coronary stenosis of up to 85 percent. Less severe stenosis causes flow and distribution abnormalities only during periods of increased flow, and the degree of maldistribution is directly related to the physiologic severity of the stenosis. Of 49 patients with suspected coronary artery disease, 10 had no significant lesions by coronary arteriography and all had normal images at rest and during coronary hyperemia. Thirty-seven of 39 patients with significant obstructive coronary artery disease had abnormal images at rest or during contrast agent-induced hyperemia, or both. Patients with significant coronary artery disease without previous infarction usually demonstrated abnormalities in flow distribution only during coronary hyperemia. Patients with previous infarction demonstrated resting perfusion abnormalities that often became more abnormal during hyperemia. This technique provides a new method for assessing the physiologic effects of coronary stenosis in conjuntion with coronary arteriography.

Eight hundred seventy arteriograms from the Coronary Artery Surgery Study (CASS) were independently read by readers at two different clinics to evaluate the reproducibility of the interpretation of coronary arteriograms. Among proximal segments, the interpretation of lesions of the left main coronary artery were the least reproducible, P less than .02. When one angiographer reads a stenosis of 50% or more in the left main coronary artery, it is estimated that a second reader will report no lesion 18.6% of the time. In 94.7% of the films, the number of significantly (greater than or equal to 70% stenosis) diseased vessels was the same for both readers (72.1%) or differed by one vessel (22.6%). The reproducibility of interpretation of films of good or acceptable quality or completeness was better than the reproducibility of readings of arteriograms judged to be of poor quality or incomplete studies. The mean absolute difference between readings of the percent stenosis decreased over the time of the patient enrollment, 1975 to 1978. This may have resulted from major collaborative efforts made during the course of the study to improve the quality of angiography and to standardize the reading of the cine films.

During the past five years percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) and intracoronary infusion of streptokinase have been introduced and rapidly accepted as new methods for the treatment of patients with ischemic heart disease. Both of these methods hold great promise for the future. PTCA is established as useful in some selected patients while intracoronary streptokinase is still investigational.

A count-based method for measuring left ventricular (LV) volume using technetium-99m-labeled red cells and ungated single-photon emission computed tomography is described. The tomographic slices were used to determine the counts per milliliter in the center of the left ventricle and total LV counts, which were used to derive mean LV volume. End-diastolic and end-systolic volumes were calculated from the mean volume using the LV time-activity curve from planar gated blood pool images. Phantom evaluation with simulated LV volumes (50 to 400 ml) in air, in a phantom filled with water, with 10% background, and with a simulated right ventricle, showed excellent accuracy. For clinical validation, 30 patients underwent electrocardiographically gated planar and nongated tomographic acquisition of the cardiac blood pool followed by single-plane cineangiography. For end-diastolic and end-systolic volumes combined, the correlation with cineangiography showed a standard error of the estimate (SEE) of 24 ml and 14 ml, respectively. Mean intra- and interobserver deviation was 12 ml and 14 ml (SEE 13 ml and 16 ml), respectively. It is concluded that this noninvasive count-based technique, requiring no assumptions regarding LV geometry, is an accurate and reproducible way to measure LV volume.

The impact of randomized clinical trials of surgical therapy for treatment of coronary artery disease is evaluated. Trials are reviewed leading to the following suggestions: 1. Large multicenter trials have a major impact on clinical practice; 2. Small trials have less impact; 3. Findings in agreement with current practice are accepted enthusiastically; 4. Findings disagreeing with current practice are met very critically; and 5. Surgical trials have special problems because of a great variability between clinics, the potential of uneven learning curves, and potential "cross-over" from medical to surgical therapy.

This study compares the survival of men and women an average of 6 years after coronary artery bypass graft surgery (CABG) by means of the Coronary Artery Surgery Study (CASS) registry. Subjects included in these analyses were the 6100 men and 1097 women who survived surgery. Medical history and physical and laboratory information were collected from each patient at baseline. Men and women were compared for differences in baseline characteristics, long-term survival (by means of the Cox proportional hazards models), and predictors of long-term survival. In this study women, at baseline, were older and more likely to have hypertension and diabetes compared to men; whereas men were more likely to have had prior coronary heart disease. In this study of CASS participants there was no difference between men and women with regard to survival after CABG. There was also no difference between men and women in predictors of 6-year mortality. Two baseline variables were strongly related to subsequent mortality in both men and women: a high left ventricular wall motion score and taking both digitalis and diuretics (for women: relative risk = 2.31, confidence interval = 1.38 to 3.87; for men: relative risk = 1.90, confidence interval = 1.45 to 2.50).

The Collaborative Study in Coronary Artery Surgery (CASS) is a large multi-institutional study of the medical and surgical treatment of coronary artery disease (CAD). Fifteen cooperating institutes have carried out isolated coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) on 6,176 patients from August, 1975, through December, 1978. The operative mortality (OM) was 2.3%. In an effort to better understand the clinical and angiographic characteristics predictive of OM, we have done a multivariate discriminant analysis of variables associated with OM. Numerous clinical and angiographic variables were selected from the CASS data file and evaluated in a univariate manner for their relationship to OM. Twenty of these variables were then selected for multivariate discriminant analysis. Clinical variables of most predictive value were age, female sex, increased heart size, and congestive heart failure (CHF). Angiographic variables of importance included left ventricular wall motion abnormalities, and left main coronary disease (LMCD). The priority of operation (elective, urgent, or emergent) was also associated with OM. Six variables that contained the most predictive information were selected by discriminant analysis for a group of 6,176 patients who had isolated bypass operations. In descending order of importance they were age, left main coronary artery stenosis greater than or equal to 90%, female sex, left ventricular wall motion score, left ventricular end-diastolic pressure (LVEDP), and râles. Five other groups or subgroups of patients were also analyzed in a similar manner. There is a strong association of OM with advanced age, female sex, and variables associated with left ventricular dysfunction. The risk of OM for an individual patient may be estimated with the use of these clinical and angiographic characteristics.

Visual analysis of the severity of coronary stenosis is limited by observer variability. However, more complex techniques of proved accuracy are tedious and costly. Therefore, a new digital electronic caliper (DEC) was evaluated as a potentially more accurate, rapid and less costly alternative for measuring stenosis severity. Stenosis minimum diameter (Dmin) and percent diameter reduction (% S) were measured from the screen of the cine projector using a DEC. These measurements were compared with visual estimates (VIS) by 4 experienced angiographers and with measurements made by a computer-assisted method (QCA) of proved accuracy. In routine cineangiograms from 7 patients, 10 lesions were significant (greater than 50% S) and 8 were mild (less than 50% S). Variability, the standard deviation of multiple estimates of Dmin and % S, averaged 0.09 mm and 3.1% for QCA; 0.18 mm and 5.9% for DEC; and 0.26 mm and 7.4% for VIS. Compared with QCA, the visual determination of % S significantly underestimates (-5%; p less than 0.02) mild and overestimates (+11%; p less than 0.002) significant stenosis. VIS underestimates Dmin in significant lesions by 20% (p less than 0.04). In contrast, the mean error for DEC measurement of Dmin and % S was not significantly different from 0 in either lesion group. For the entire group of lesions, and particularly in significant lesions, the mean error for measurement of these 2 indexes of disease was significantly less with DEC than with VIS. Thus, variability and error with DEC are acceptably low for clinical use.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Reliability of angiographic assessment of the left main coronary artery segment was evaluated by review of 106 coronary cineangiograms from the Coronary Artery Surgery Study. The films were interpreted by three groups of angiographers: those at a clinical site, those at a quality control site, and those on a study census panel. Among the readings of these three groups, there was 41% to 59% agreement on the severity of the lesion, with 80% agreement on whether the lesion was greater or less than 50%. The severity of lesion, its location, or presence of ectasia or calcium did not affect the discrepancy rate, whereas segments that were unusually short, diffusely diseased, or obscured by overlapping vessels were especially difficult to interpret.

During a 14-month period, 75 deaths occurring in relation to 53,581 cardiac catheterizations were consecutively and prospectively reported to the Registry Committee of the Society for Cardiac Angiography. Three of the patients died several days after their catheterization from an unrelated cause and are excluded from this analysis. There were 21 patients (group I) who arrived at the laboratory in extremis and whose deaths were expected irrespective of the catheterization. Most of these patients suffered from recent myocardial infarctions and cardiogenic shock, or had complex congenital malformations. In 35 patients (group II), a cardiovascular complication occurring during the catheterization resulted in death. In 16 patients (group III) catheterization seemed uneventful, but death occurred suddenly 10 min to 10 h after the procedure. Of these 16 patients, eight had left main coronary artery obstruction greater than or equal to 90%, five had three-vessel disease all with 90% obstructions, one had 2-vessel disease both with 90% obstructions, and who had critical aortic stenosis. The 51 unexpected deaths (groups II and III) were considered to be causally related to the procedure, a mortality rate of 0.10%. Subsets with an increased mortality rate (M), were patients with: a) left main disease greater than 50% (M = 0.94%); b) ejection fraction less than 30% (M = 0.54%); c) NYHA class III or IV (m = 0.24%); d) age over 60 years (M = 0.23%); or e) three-vessel disease (M = 0.13%). In conclusion, catheterization related mortality occurs mostly in patients with far advanced cardiac disease. Nearly 1/3 of the unexpected deaths occurred suddenly after a seemingly uneventful procedure. Close monitoring after catheterization of patients with similar characteristics (left main disease greater than or equal to 90%, or three-vessel disease all greater than or equal to 90%) might disclose avenues for reducing mortality occurring after catheterization.

Data from the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute's Coronary Artery Surgery Study (CASS) are used to describe the types of persons who undergo coronary angiography for possible coronary artery bypass surgery, the reasons patients receive coronary bypass surgery, and operative mortality results, as well as changing trends in the therapy assigned. The review is designed to provide background material for those assessing coronary artery bypass technology.