1. Comparison of the interface pressure and stiffness of four types of compression systems.
- Author
-
Wong, I.K.Y., Man, M.B.L., Chan, O.S.H., Siu, F.C., Abel, M., and Andriessen, A.
- Subjects
SURGICAL dressings ,LEG ulcers ,COMPRESSION therapy ,COMPARATIVE studies ,ELASTICITY ,EXPERIMENTAL design ,MATERIALS testing ,MEDICAL equipment ,PRESSURE ,RESEARCH funding ,STATISTICAL sampling ,T-test (Statistics) ,U-statistics ,BODY movement ,DATA analysis software ,DESCRIPTIVE statistics ,EQUIPMENT & supplies ,PREVENTION - Abstract
Objective: To compare interface pressure (IP) and static stiffness index (SSI) of four different compression systems currently in use for the treatment of patients with venous leg ulcer. Method: Fifty-two ambulatory adults with healthy legs were recruited at random at a study centre after they had consented. The evaluated systems were: short-stretch system (SSB), Rosidal sys (Lohmann & Rauscher), multilayer bandaging (LSB) Profore (Smith & Nephew), Vari-stretch (VSB) ProGuide (Smith & Nephew) and tubular compression (CS) Rosidal Mobil (Lohmann & Rauscher). Interface pressure was measured using Kikuhime (Harada Corp.), placing a 3cm-diameter probe at the B1 point. IP recording took place in the supine and standing positions, while sitting and during walking, on application of the compression systems and every 15 minutes thereafter for 4 hours. Results: The IPs of SSB, LSB and VSB, measured immediately after bandage application, were significantly higher than that of CS (all p < 0.05). During the 4-hour study period, the IP for both VSB and LSB measured in the supine position initially increased to > 60mmHg. Their overall mean IPs in the supine position were 48.96 ± 3.99mmHg and 48.12 ± 4.57mmHg, respectively. SSB and CS demonstrated more tolerable IP levels in this position of < 40mmHg, which was similar to those when sitting. All systems maintained at least 40mmHg in walking. SSB had a high SSI of 20 throughout the study. LSB followed with an SSI of 18 at the start, which reduced to 13, while the SSI for VSB decreased from 17 to 12 and CS, with an SSI of 6, lagged behind. Conclusion: These results may contribute to the understanding of IP and SSI of the four different compression systems evaluated. The IP and SSI data presented give clinicians an indication of the appropriate frequency of re-application of compression, and preliminary data on choosing a safe and effective compression treatment for their patients. Declaration of interest: The investigators received an educational grant from Lohmann & Rauscher GmbH & Co KG for this study. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2012
- Full Text
- View/download PDF