Search

The pore-forming colicins, the first proteins that were capable of forming voltage-dependent ion channels to be sequenced, have turned out to be both less tractable and more mysterious than imagined; yet they have proved interesting at every step of their short journey from producing cell to vanquished target cell. Starting out as a remarkably extended water-soluble protein, the colicin molecule is designed to interact simultaneously with several components of the complex membrane of the target cell, transform itself into a membrane protein, and become an ion channel with inscrutable properties. Unraveling how it does all this appears to be leading us into the dark recesses of protein/protein and protein/membrane interaction, where lurk fundamental processes reluctantly waiting to be revealed.

Colicins translocate across the Escherichia coli outer membrane and periplasm by interacting with several receptors. After first binding to the outer membrane surface receptors via their central region, they interact with TolA or TonB proteins via their N-terminal region. Colicin N residues critical to TolA binding have been discovered, but the full extent of any colicin TolA site is unknown. We present, for the first time, a fully mapped TolA binding site for a colicin. It was determined through the use of alanine-scanning mutants, glutathione S-transferase fusion peptides and Biacore/fluorescence binding studies. The minimal TolA binding region is 27 residues and of similar size to the TolA binding region of bacteriophage g3p-D1 protein. Stopped-flow kinetic studies show that the binding to TolA follows slow association kinetics. The role of other E. coli Tol proteins in colicin translocation was also investigated. Isothermal titration microcalorimetry (ITC) and in vivo studies conclusively show that colicin N translocation does not require the presence of TolB. ITC also demonstrated colicin A interaction with TolB, and that colicin A in its native state does not interact with TolAII-III. Colicin N does not bind TolR-II. The TolA protein is shown to be unsuitable for direct immobilisation in Biacore analysis., (Copyright 2000 Academic Press.)

Colicin N kills sensitive Escherichia coli cells by first binding to its trimeric receptor (OmpF) via its receptor binding domain. It then uses OmpF to translocate across the outer membrane and in the process it also needs domains II and III of the protein TolA. Recent studies have demonstrated sodium dodecyl sulfate- (SDS) dependent complex formation between trimeric porins and TolA-II. Here we demonstrate that colicin N forms similar complexes with the same trimeric porins and that this association is unexpectedly solely dependent upon the pore-forming domain (P-domain). No binding was seen with the monomeric porin OmpA. In mixtures of P-domain and TolA with OmpF porin, only binary and no ternary complexes were observed, suggesting that binding of these proteins to the porin is mutually exclusive. Pull-down assays in solution show that porin-P-domain complexes also form in the presence of outer membrane lipopolysaccharide. This indicates that an additional colicin-porin interaction may occur within the outer membrane, one that involves the colicin pore domain rather than the receptor-binding domain. This may help to explain the role of porins and TolA-II in the later stages of colicin translocation.

The pore-forming colicins N and A require the porin, OmpF, in order to translocate across the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. We investigated the hypothesis that in vivo, colicins N and A may traverse the outer membrane through the OmpF channel. In order to accommodate a polypeptide in the pore, the mid-channel constriction loop of OmpF, L3, would need to undergo a conformational change. We used five OmpF cystine mutants, which fix L3 in the conformation determined by X-ray crystallography, to investigate L3 movement during colicin activity in vivo. Sensitivity to colicins N and A of E. coli cells expressing these OmpF cystine mutants was determined using cell survival and in vivo potassium efflux and fluorescence assays. Results indicate that gross movement of L3 is not required for colicin N or A activity and that neither of these colicins crosses the outer membrane of E. coli through the lumen of the OmpF pore.

Background: Pore-forming colicins are water-soluble bacteriocins capable of binding to and translocating through the Escherichia coli cell envelope. They then undergo a transition to a transmembrane ion channel in the cytoplasmic membrane leading to bacterial death. Colicin N is the smallest pore-forming colicin known to date (40 kDa instead of the more usual 60 kDa) and the crystal structure of its membrane receptor, the porin OmpF, is already known. Structural knowledge of colicin N is therefore important for a molecular understanding of colicin toxicity and is relevant to toxic mechanisms in general., Results: The crystal structure of colicin N reveals a novel receptor-binding domain containing a six-stranded antiparallel beta sheet wrapped around the 63 A long N-terminal alpha helix of the pore-forming domain. The pore-forming domain adopts a ten alpha-helix bundle that has been observed previously in the pore-forming domains of colicin A, la and E1. The translocation domain, however, does not appear to adopt any regular structure. Models for receptor binding and translocation through the outer membrane are proposed based on the structure and biochemical data., Conclusions: The colicin N-ompF system is now the structurally best-defined translocation pathway. Knowledge of the colicin N structure, coupled with the structure of its receptor, OmpF, and previously published biochemical data, limits the numerous possibilities of translocation and leads to a model in which the translocation domain inserts itself through the porin pore, the receptor-binding domain stays outside and the pore-forming domain translocates along the outer wall of the trimeric porin channel.

Colicins translocate across the Escherichia coli outer membrane and periplasm by interacting with several receptors. After first binding to outer membrane surface receptors via their central region, they interact with TolA or TonB proteins via their N-terminal regions. Finally, the toxic C-terminal region is inserted into or across the cytoplasmic membrane. We have measured the binding of colicin N to TolA by isothermal titration microcalorimetry (ITC) and tryptophan fluorescence. The isolated N-terminal domain exhibits a higher affinity for TolA (Kd = 1 microM) than does the whole colicin (18 microM), and similar behaviour has been observed when the N-terminal domain of the g3p protein of the bacteriophage fd, which also binds TolA, is examined in isolation and in situ. This may indicate a similar mechanism in which a cryptic TolA binding site is revealed after primary receptor binding. The isolated colicin N N-terminal domain appears to be unstructured in circular dichroism and fluorescence studies. We have used mutagenesis and ITC to characterize the TolA binding site and have shown it to be of a different sequence and much further from the N-terminus than previously thought.

Colicin N is a three-domain pore-forming colicin which kills enterobacterial cells following an initial binding to its receptor, the outer membrane porin OmpF. The receptor-binding domain of colicin N alone, and attached to the translocation domain, was overexpressed and purified using a hexahistidine tag. The receptor domain attached to the pore-forming domain was obtained by enzymatic digestion. Circular dichroism spectroscopy showed that the domains have structure in keeping with the known structure of colicin N. The receptor domain was stable, retaining both secondary and tertiary structure in 2 M guanidine hydrochloride and at low pH. It bound to both OmpF and PhoE porin-producing Escherichia coli with no toxicity and protected sensitive E. coli against intact colicin N toxicity at high domain/ colicin N ratios. Its in vitro affinity for OmpF, as determined by isothermal titration microcalorimetry, was found to be approximately 50-fold weaker than that of native colicin N. The receptor domain was readily out-competed by native colicin N in in vivo fluorescence assays which, coupled with its structural stability, suggests that its interaction with OmpF is one of weak, reversible binding. Since neither of the double domain constructs shows wild-type binding affinity either, it appears that the molecular recognition is a property of the receptor domain but that affinity is influenced by the entire molecule.

Colicins A, B, and N form a family of membrane pore-forming toxins with > 50% sequence identity in their toxic C-terminal domains. The colicin A C-terminal domain has been shown to insert into model membranes via an acidic molten-globule insertion intermediate, and thus this family provides a means to compare acid unfolding of related proteins. Unlike the domains of colicins A and B which are acidic, that of colicin N is very basic with fewer Asp and Glu residues. If surface positive charge density is the crucial factor in acidic molten globule formation, colicin N should begin to unfold at higher pH values than colicins A or B. However, comparison of their CD spectra reveals that colicins A and B both form acidic molten globules but colicin N does not. None of the proteins forms a denaturant-induced molten globule at neutral pH where the proteins exhibit very similar stabilities. The acidic unfolding cannot therefore be due to excess positive surface charge and may be caused by a subset of acidic residues as has been predicted for myoglobin. The difference between the colicins is confirmed by their in vivo membrane insertion, with colicins A and B inserting much faster than colicin N. Stopped-flow circular dichroism measurements of colicin A insertion into vesicles confirmed that a molten globule insertion intermediate occurs at the membrane surface.

A specific receptor is a requirement for most protein toxins and OmpF, a trimeric porin, was previously considered to be the unique membrane-receptor for colicin N. We show by qualitative in vivo analysis that the related porins OmpC or PhoE act as much less effective receptors. To elucidate receptor function, the in vitro binding of the 42 kDa toxin to each of the 120 kDa porin trimers was determined quantitatively using isothermal titration calorimetry. Colicin N binds to OmpF with Ka approximately 5 x 10(5) M-1 and a stoichiometry consistent with about three per trimer but it also binds to PhoE and OmpC with surprisingly similar affinities and stoichiometry. However, thermodynamic analysis of these hitherto unmeasured interactions suggests an unexpected entropic difference between these protein import receptors.

Colicins are unusual bacterial toxins because they are directed against close relatives of the producing strain. They kill their targets in one of three distinct ways; via a ribonuclease or deoxyribonuclease activity or by forming pores in the target cell's membrane. This review deals with the steps involved in pore-forming colicin activity including, initial synthesis of the toxin, toxin release, receptor binding, translocation across the periplasm and pore formation in the cytoplasmic membrane. Special reference is made to the role of colicin in vivo, the structural changes occurring during pore formation and the role of the immunity protein.

The bacterial toxin colicin A binds spontaneously to the surfaces of negatively charged membranes. The surface-bound toxin must subsequently, however, become an acidic 'molten globule' before it can fully insert into the lipid bilayer. Clearly, electrostatic interactions must play a significant role in both events. The electrostatic field around the toxin in solution was calculated using the finite-difference Poisson-Boltzmann method of the Delphi programme and the known X-ray structure. A large positively charged surface was identified which could be involved in the binding of colicin to negatively charged membranes. The applicability of the result was tested by also calculating the fields around modelled structures of the closely related colicins B and N. Surprisingly, colicin N showed a similar charge distribution in spite of its isoelectric point of pI 10.20 (colicin A has pI 5.44). One reason for this is the strong conservation of certain negative charges in all colicins. There is a single highly conserved aspartate residue (Asp78) on the positively charged face which provides a small but discrete region of negative charge. This residue, Asp78, was replaced by asparagine in the mutant D78N. D78N binds faster to negatively charged vesicles but inserts only half as fast as the wild-type protein into the membrane core. This indicates that, first, the initial membrane binding has a significant electrostatic component and, second, that the isolated charge on Asp78 plays a role in the formation of the insertion intermediate.

The ion-channel-forming C-terminal fragment of colicin A binds to negatively charged lipid vesicles and provides an example of the insertion of a soluble protein into a lipid bilayer. The soluble structure is known and consists of a ten-helix bundle containing a hydrophobic helical hairpin. In this study fluorescence resonance energy transfer spectroscopy was used to determine the position of this helical hairpin in the membrane bound state. An extrinsic probe, N'-(iodoacetyl)-N'-(5-sulpho-1-naphthyl)ethylenediamine (I-AEDANS) was attached to mutant proteins each of which bears a unique cysteine residue. Five mutants I26C (helix 1), F105C (between helices 4 and 5), G166CJ (helix 8), A169C (helix 8-9), G176C (helix 9) were used. All mutants show wild-type binding activity to phosphatidylglycerol vesicles as judged by fluorescence polarization anisotropy, emission wavelength changes and brominated lipid quenching. The three tryptophan residues were used as a compound donor to AEDANS in resonance energy transfer distance determinations. The distances obtained for the soluble form were equal to those found in the crystal structure. On adding vesicles under conditions where intermolecular transfer was avoided the indicated distances increased; I26(10.9 A) F105(3.4 A), G166(3.3 A), A169(1.9 A) and G176(2.9 A). This confirms that, in the absence of a membrane potential, helices 1 and 2 open out onto the membrane surface whilst the helical hairpin remains closely packed against the rest of the structure. The insertion of this hairpin is thus not the driving force behind colicin membrane binding.

The interaction of colicin-A thermolytic fragment with negatively charged liposomes was studied by fluorescence spectroscopy. 1,2-Dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho-1-sn-glycerol (Ole2GroPGro) containing liposomes do not significantly alter the fluorescence properties of the protein, and thus cannot give much information about this interaction. 1,2-Bis(9,10-dibromooleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho-1-sn-glycerol (Br4Ole2GroPGro) is easily synthesized by addition of bromine atoms to the double bond located at the mid-point of the fatty-acid acyl chain of Ole2GroPGro. The brominated phospholipid forms vesicles that strongly quench the protein fluorescence emission. The results presented here show that conversion of Ole2GroPGro to Br4Ole2GroPGro does not change either the affinity for the protein or the extent of lipid binding. This observation allows for the estimation of the distribution of the quenching phospholipid molecules around the fluorophores [Yeager, M. D. & Feigenson G. W. (1990) Biochemistry 29, 4380-4392]. Binding of the protein to the vesicles is an irreversible process, since inserted molecules do not dissociate from the vesicle. From steady-state measurements, it can be concluded that in the membrane-bound form, the tryptophans are located within quenching distance of the bromine atoms, i.e. close to the lipid head-group/hydrocarbon boundary, completely accessible to the quencher, protected from the polar phase and that the maximum number of phospholipid molecules in contact with the fluorescent domain of the protein is nine.

Thermal stability of the pore-forming domain of colicin A was studied by high sensitivity differential scanning calorimetry and circular dichroism spectroscopy. In the pH range between 8 and 5, the thermal denaturation of the protein in solution occurs at 66-69 degrees C and is characterized by the calorimetric enthalpy of approximately 90 kcal/M. At pH below 5, there is a rapid pH-dependent destabilization of the pore-forming domain resulting in the lowering of the midpoint denaturation temperature and a decrease in the calorimetric enthalpy of denaturation. Circular dichroism spectra in the near and far ultraviolet show that the thermotropic transition is associated with collapse of the native tertiary structure of the pore-forming domain, although a large proportion of the helical secondary structure remains preserved. The present data indicate some similarity also between acid-induced and temperature-induced denaturation of the pore-forming domain of colicin A. Association of the pore-forming domain with phospholipid vesicles of dioleoylphosphatidylglycerol results in total disappearance of the calorimetric transition, even at pH values as high as 7. Since lipid binding also induces collapse of the near ultraviolet circular dichroism spectrum, these data indicate that interaction with the membrane facilitates a conformational change within the pore-forming domain to a looser (denaturated-like) state. These findings are discussed in relation to the recent model (van der Goot, F. G., Gonzalez-Manas, J. M., Lakey, J. H., Pattus, F. (1991) Nature 354, 408-410) which postulates that a flexible "molten globule" state is an intermediate on the pathway to membrane insertion of colicin A.

The intrinsic fluorescence of the colicin A thermolytic fragment does not change after insertion into normal phospholipid vesicles and is thus an unsuitable probe for monitoring the membrane insertion process. In this paper, we report the results of studies on the quenching of this fluorescence by brominated dioleoylphosphatidylglycerol (Br-DOPG) vesicles. Bromine atoms located at the midpoint of the phospholipid acyl chain quench the tryptophan fluorescence, indicating contact between fluorophores of the protein and the bilayer's hydrophobic core. Addition of Br-DOPG vesicles to a protein solution quenches the tryptophan fluorescence in a time-dependent manner. This quenching can be fitted to a single-exponential function, and thus interpreted as a one-step process. This allows calculation of an apparent rate constant of protein insertion into the membrane. Parameters known to affect the insertion of the thermolytic fragment into phospholipid monolayers or vesicles (pH and negative charge density) also affect the rate constant in comparable ways. In addition to the information gained concerning membrane exposure in the steady state, this approach provides the first real-time method for measuring the insertion of colicin into membranes. It is highly quantitative and can be used on all versions of the protein, e.g., full size, proteolytic fragments, and mutants. Brominated lipids provide experimental conditions identical to normal lipids and allow for great flexibility in protein/lipid ratios and concentrations. The kinetic analysis shows clearly the existence of a two-step process involving a rapid adsorption of the protein to the lipid surface followed by a slow insertion.

Pore-forming toxins, such as colicin A, are water-soluble proteins that insert into lipid bilayers. The water-soluble structure of Colicin A is known at a high resolution and this review describes the kinetic and structural steps involved in its soluble-to-membrane bound transformation.

The 'molten' globular conformation of a protein is compact with a native secondary structure but a poorly defined tertiary structure. Molten globular states are intermediates in protein folding and unfolding and they may be involved in the translocation or insertion of proteins into membranes. Here we investigate the membrane insertion of the pore-forming domain of colicin A, a bacteriocin that depolarizes the cytoplasmic membrane of sensitive cells. We find that this pore-forming domain, the insertion of which depends on pH, undergoes a native to molten globule transition at acidic pH. The variation of the kinetic constant of membrane insertion of the protein into negatively charged lipid vesicles as a function of the interfacial pH correlates with the appearance of the acidic molten globular state, indicating that this state could be an intermediate formed during the insertion of colicin A into membranes.

The ion-channel-forming C-terminal fragment of colicin A binds to negatively charged lipid vesicles and provides an example of insertion of a soluble protein into a lipid bilayer. The soluble structure is known from X-ray crystallography and consists of a ten-helix bundle containing a hydrophobic helical hairpin. In this work fluorescence spectroscopy was used to study the membrane-bound structure. An extrinsic probe, N'-(iodoacetyl)-N'-(5-sulfol-naphthyl)ethylenediamine (IAEDANS) was attached to mutant proteins each of which bears a unique cysteine residue. Three mutants K39C (helix 2), T127C (between helices 6 and 7) and S16Crpt (helix 1, which bears a decapeptide repeat before the mutation) gave useful derivatives. In the soluble protein they showed emission wavelengths decreasing in the order K39C greater than T127C greater than S16Crpt and although all showed blue shifts on addition of dimyristoylphosphatidylglycerol (DMPG) this order was maintained in the membrane-bound state. These shifts were not indicative of deep membrane insertion. Polarization of IAEDANS revealed differences in mobility between mutants. The three tryptophan residues were used as a compound donor to IAEDANS in resonance energy transfer distance determinations. The values obtained for the soluble form were 1.2 A to 3.2 A longer than in the crystal structure. On addition of lipids the indicated distances increased: S16Crpt-I(AEDANS) 6.45 A (22%), K39C-I 5.45 A (18%) and T127C-I 2.4 A (14%). N-bromosuccinimide (NBS) completely abolishes the tryptophan emission from the thermolytic fragment. When lipids were added to a mixture containing ten NBS-treated channel-forming fragments to one IAEDANS labelled fragment the indicated distances increased rather more: S16Crpt-I 9.7 A (38%), K39C-I 8.1 A (36%) and T127C-I 2.5 A (16%). This showed that intermolecular transfer reduces the distance estimated in samples containing only labelled protein. The ensemble of results shows that the amphipathic helices of the C-terminal fragment open out on the surface of the lipid bilayer during the initial phase of membrane insertion.

In order to gain some insight into the mechanism of insertion into membranes of the pore-forming domain of colicin A and the structure of its membrane-bound form, circular dichroism (in the near and far ultraviolet), fluorescence and ultraviolet spectroscopy experiments were carried out. Because the structure of the water-soluble form of this fragment has been determined by X-ray crystallography, these spectroscopic methods provided valuable information on the secondary structure and the environment of aromatic residues within the two forms of the peptide. These results strongly suggest that the pore-forming domain of colicin A does not undergo drastic unfolding upon insertion into membrane. The conformational change associated with this process is triggered by the negatively charged lipids and probably consists of a reorientation of helix pairs with respect to each other. Exposure of the aromatic residues to the aqueous phase decreases on binding to lipids whilst the exposure of the tryptophans to the membrane phase increases. This cannot occur without a reorientation of helices 3-10. All data from this study support the model presented previously in which the known crystal structure opens like an 'umbrella' inserting the hydrophobic hairpin (helix 8-9) perpendicular to the membrane plane and the helical pair 1-2 and the domain containing the three tryptophans (helices 3-7) lying more or less parallel to the membrane plane. Lipids are bound more tightly to the protein at acidic pH than at neutral pH although a similar lipid protein complex is formed with 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero(3)-phospho(1)- -sn-glycerol at both pH values.

DNA regions encoding the various domains of a protein can be expressed as separate entities by inserting at appropriate sites a 'STOP-Shine-Dalgarno-sequence-ATG' cassette encoding a termination codon, a Shine-Dalgano sequence and an initiation codon within the structural gene. This technique has been used to obtain a 137-amino-acid-residue pore-forming protein designated DA70C comprising the final 136-amino-acid-residue COOH-terminal of colicin A preceded by an NH2-terminal methionine. Da70C was correctly expressed but poorly released to the extracellular medium. Its purification involved, as a final step, a partition in Triton X-114 thus demonstrating that hydrophobic regions are exposed in this protein. The ability of DA70C to form ion channels in planar lipid bilayers was investigated and pore properties were analyzed. The results indicate that helices 1-3 of the 204-amino-acid-residue colicin pore-forming domain (containing 10 alpha-helices) are not involved in ion conduction through the channel. However, they are important in maintaining the stability of the soluble state of the COOH-terminal domain.

Colicins are plasmid-encoded protein antibiotics which kill bacteria closely related to the producing strain (generally Escherichia coli). The study of the function of colicins has revealed many features which reflect common targeting and translocation mechanisms with bacteriophages and toxins. Like many toxins, colicins are composed of structural domains specialized in one of the different steps of the activity, targeting, translocation and killing. The major group comprises those colicins which permeabilize the cytoplasmic membrane, thereby destroying the cell's membrane potential. These colicins form well-defined voltage-gated ion channels in artificial membranes. The scope of this review is to describe some of the more recent findings concerning the structure and mode of action of pore-forming colicins with a special attention to models of membrane insertion and pore structure based on the recently determined three-dimensional structure of the pore-forming domain of colicin A.