Search

To determine the protective efficacy (PE) of three doses of oral B subunit-killed whole cell (BS-WC) or killed whole cell-only (WC) vaccines against cholera, a clinical trial was conducted among 62285 children over 2 years and adult women in rural Bangladesh. During 5 years of follow-up, there were 144 cases of cholera in the BS-WC group (PE = 49%; P < 0.001), 150 in the WC group (PE = 47%; P < 0.001), and 283 in the K12 group. Protection by each vaccine was evident only during the first three years of follow-up; long-term protection of young children was observed only against classical but not El Tor cholera; 3-year protection against both cholera biotypes occurred among older persons, but at a higher level against classical cholera.

Antigenic similarity between the oral cholera B subunit-whole cell (BS-WC) and whole-cell only (WC) vaccines and strains of the family Vibrionaceae was studied by crossed immunoelectrophoresis. A reference system consisting of Vibrio cholerae Inaba E1 Tor antigenic extract and homologous rabbit antiserum was applied in the study. The system was represented by 30 anodically migrating antigens forming distinct precipitation bands. Antigenic extracts of other members of the family Vibrionaceae showed the following numbers of cellular antigens shared in common with the reference system: Vibrio cholerae non-01-30, V. mimicus-23, V. fluvialis-15, V. parahaemolyticus-10, Aeromonas hydrophila-7, A. sobria-5, A. caviae-4 and Plesiomonas shigelloides-5 antigens. Homologous rabbit antiserum reacted with 11 antigens of BS-WC vaccine and 10 antigens of WC vaccine. The number of antigens which members of the family Vibrionaceae shared in common with those preserved in the WC component of the vaccines were as follows: Vibrio cholerae non-01, 7; V. mimicus, 5; V. fluvialis, 3; V. parahaemolyticus, 3; Aeromonas hydrophila, 2; A. sobria, 2; and A. caviae, 2; Plesiomonas shigelloides, 1. None of the strains produced an antigen reacting with anti-cholera toxin antibodies. The presence of common antigens in the vaccine and among members of family Vibrionaceae indicates that the oral cholera vaccine could stimulate immunity effectively against other members of the family.

Because of demonstrable cross-reactivity of cellular antigens contained in B subunit-killed whole-cell (BS-WC) and killed whole-cell-only (WC) oral cholera vaccines with antigens of various non-cholera species of the family Vibrionaceae (NCV), the protection conferred by the vaccines against diarrhoea associated with NCV was evaluated during a randomized, double-blind field trial in Bangladesh. Children aged 2-15 years and women aged greater than 15 years (62,285 in number) received three doses of BS-WC vaccine, WC-only vaccine, or a placebo consisting of Escherichia coli K12 strain (K12). During 1 year of follow-up, the incidence of treated episodes of diarrhoea associated with non-cholera vibrios known to be enteric pathogens (non-01 Vibrio cholerae, V. fluvialis, V. parahaemolyticus, V. mimicus) in the placebo group was low (1.9 cases per 10,000 recipients) and identical to that for the two vaccine groups combined. The incidence (per 10,000 recipients) of treated diarrhoeal episodes associated with Aeromonas species was considerably higher, but nearly identical in the three groups (26.1 cases for BS-WC, 26.0 cases for WC; 25.9 cases for K12). Pleisiomonas shigelloides was not isolated from any participant. It is concluded that NCV other than Aeromonas were rarely isolated from diarrhoeal patients in our study population and that killed oral vaccines which were effective against cholera exhibited no detectable cross-protection against diarrhoea associated with NCV organisms.

The B subunit (BS) of cholera toxin and that of the heat-labile enterotoxin (LT) of enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli (ETEC) are antigenically similar. We therefore assessed whether a combined cholera toxin BS/whole-cell (BS-WC) oral vaccine against cholera conferred cross-protection against LT-producing ETEC (LT-ETEC) diarrhea in a randomized, double-blind field trial among rural Bangladeshi children and women. The 24,770 persons who ingested two or more doses of BS-WC vaccine were compared with 24,842 controls who took two or more doses of killed whole-cell (WC) oral cholera vaccine. Sixty-seven percent fewer episodes of LT-ETEC diarrhea were noted in the BS-WC group than in the WC group during short-term (three-month) follow-up (P less than .01), but no reduction was evident during the ensuing nine months. Short-term protection was particularly notable against LT-ETEC diarrhea causing life-threatening dehydration (protective efficacy, 86%; P less than .05).

We assessed the protective efficacy (PE) of three doses of B subunit-killed whole cell (BS-WC) and killed whole cell-only (WC) oral cholera vaccines in a randomized, double-blind trial among 62,285 children and women residing in rural Bangladesh. After one complete year of surveillance, 110 cases of cholera were detected in the placebo group, 52 in the WC group (PE, 53%; P less than .0001), and 41 in the BS-WC group (PE, 62%; P less than .0001). Protection was greater for BS-WC recipients than for WC recipients only during the initial eight months of observation. Both vaccines conferred equivalent protection against cholera associated with life-threatening dehydration and against less severe cholera. High-grade, sustained protection was observed in persons vaccinated when older than five years; in younger persons protection was transient. We conclude that BS-WC and WC vaccines confer significant protection against cholera, particularly in persons vaccinated when older than five years.

The impact of B subunit killed whole-cell (BS-WC) and killed whole-cell-only (WC) oral cholera vaccines was assessed in a randomised double-blind trial in rural Bangladesh. 62,285 children aged 2-15 years and women aged over 15 ingested three doses of one of the vaccines or placebo. During the first year of follow-up there was a 26% reduction of all visits for treatment of diarrhoea in the BS-WC group and a 22% reduction in the WC group. The reduction of all admissions for fatal or severely dehydrating diarrhoea was 48% in the BS-WC group and 33% in the WC group. Overall mortality rates were 26% lower in the BS-WC group and 23% lower in the WC group during the first year, and reductions of mortality were observed only in women vaccinated at ages over 15 years. However, no differences in cumulative mortality were evident at the end of the second year of surveillance.

The protective efficacy of oral B subunit killed whole-cell (BS-WC) and killed whole-cell (WC) cholera vaccines was assessed in 63 498 Bangladeshi children aged 2-15 years and women aged over 15 years. Each received three doses of BS-WC, WC, or placebo in a randomised, double-blinded fashion. Surveillance for cases seeking medical care up to six months after the third dose revealed 26 cases of confirmed cholera in the placebo group, 4 cases in the BS-WC group (protective efficacy 85%; p less than 0.0001), and 11 cases in the WC group (protective efficacy 58%; p less than 0.01). For each vaccine protective efficacy was consistent in different age-groups (2-10 years versus greater than 10 years) and for different severities of cholera.