Janet M. McNicholl, Katherine Butler, Dorothy L. Patton, W. Evan Secor, Harlan D. Caldwell, Gail L. Sturdevant, Yetunde F Fakile, James Mitchell, Debra L. Hanson, Christi Phillips, Tara R. Henning, Shanon Ellis, John R. Papp, Elizabeth M. Sweeney, Frank Deyounks, Carol E. Farshy, and Ellen N. Kersh
Sexually transmitted infection (STI) can increase the risk of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection by 2–5-fold [1–5]. It is unclear whether this association is largely attributable to sexual or behavioral practices or to an underlying STI-associated biological mechanism. Human studies of STI coinfection and HIV susceptibility are often precluded because of study size, confounding behaviors, and ethical considerations. The use of a macaque model of STI and HIV coinfection would help to address these questions and also provide a model for preclinical testing of biomedical HIV prevention strategies. Because of the high STI prevalence among individuals at high risk for HIV infection [3, 4, 6], rigorous testing of these strategies in the context of STIs would help to ensure broad efficacy of prevention methods among varying populations. A current focus of HIV prevention research is identifying effective preexposure prophylaxis (PrEP) strategies for high-risk groups. PrEP with Truvada was recently approved by the Food and Drug Administration for use in men who have sex with men (MSM), HIV-discordant couples, and other high-risk populations (eg, injection drug users) [7, 8]. However, some PrEP strategies in women have shown limited efficacy (as in the CAPRISA cohort) or no efficacy (as in the VOICE and FemPrEP cohorts) [9–11]. In addition to addressing adherence issues, it is also important to investigate biological factors that could lower PrEP efficacy in women, such as reproductive hormone levels, coinfections, and inflammation in the female genital tract. We and others have used female pig-tailed macaques to study topical and systemic PrEP efficacy [12, 13] and HIV susceptibility factors unique to the female host [14]. These macaques model human female reproductive tract physiology, have year-round lunar menstrual cycles, and can be vaginally infected with simian/HIV (SHIV) without progestin treatment. In these macaques, using a repeat, low-dose SHIV challenge model, we showed that susceptibility to SHIV infection is inconsistent throughout the menstrual cycle and peaks during the late-luteal and menses phases [14, 15]. With repeated low-dose exposures in pig-tailed macaques, we can carefully study factors affecting HIV susceptibility by evaluating completed menstrual cycles during virus exposures (as opposed to challenges required for infection) to account for the varying susceptibility a woman experiences throughout her menstrual cycle [13, 16–18]. We recently established a pig-tailed macaque model of concomitant STI and HIV infection [19], providing an effective system with which to assess effects of both STIs and hormonal changes on susceptibility to vaginal SHIV transmission. Studies of macaques with concomitant STI and HIV infection are limited, with only Crostarosa et al reporting on the effect of herpes simplex virus type 2 (HSV-2) infection on SHIV susceptibility in Depo-Provera-treated rhesus macaques [20]. Yet a macaque STI model could be used to conclusively assess whether these infections do in fact increase the risk of HIV infection, to investigate associated mechanisms, and to rigorously assess HIV prevention methods. The study described here uses our previously developed pig-tailed macaque triple infection STI-SHIV model [19] to evaluate the effect of non-ulcerative STIs (ie, Chlamydia trachomatis and Trichomonas vaginalis infections) on SHIV susceptibility. Patton et al have established C. trachomatis infection models in several macaque species, investigated Chlamydia and SHIV coinfection in pig-tailed macaques, and have also studied T. vaginalis infection in pig-tailed macaques [21–24]. C. trachomatis and T. vaginalis were also selected because infections with these pathogens are epidemiologically associated with an increased risk of HIV infection and are highly prevalent among individuals at high risk for HIV [3, 6, 25, 26]. From an early report by Laga et al, women with Chlamydia or Trichomonas infections were almost 4 and 2 times as likely, respectively, to become HIV-positive [3]. These pathogens induce tissue inflammation and may also cause abrasions to the genital tract epithelium, potentially facilitating access of virus to target cells [27–30]. Cell populations involved in clearing STIs are also targets for HIV infection (and for simian immunodeficiency virus [SIV] and SHIV infections), particularly in the case of C. trachomatis and T. vaginalis [30–34]. It is hypothesized these combined factors increase susceptibility to mucosal HIV transmission. This current study incorporates methods developed in our laboratory [19] and the Patton laboratory and reports increased susceptibility to SHIV infection among macaques coinfected with C. trachomatis and T. vaginalis, introduces possible mechanisms for enhanced susceptibility in vaginal transmission, and indicates a definitive role for these coinfections in the risk of HIV infection, apart from sexual or behavioral practices alone. Moreover, this study establishes a macaque model of genital tract inflammation for studies of high-risk HIV transmission and prevention.