1. Opposing reactions in coenzyme A metabolism sensitize Mycobacterium tuberculosis to enzyme inhibition
- Author
-
Jeffrey Aubé, Curtis A. Engelhart, Elaine Ballinger, Kyu Y. Rhee, Allison Fay, Guangbin Yang, Laurent Fraisse, Kristin Burns-Huang, Jennifer A McConnell, Dirk Schnappinger, Isabelle Le Blanc, Cedric Couturier, Julien Vaubourgeix, Roxanne Morris, James C. Sacchettini, Carl Nathan, Thomas R. Ioerger, Laurent Goullieux, Sarah M. Scarry, Stéphanie Sans, Sophie Lagrange, Eric Bacqué, Ben Gold, Travis Hartman, John W. Mosior, Kathrine McAulay, Christine Roubert, and Ouathek Ouerfelli
- Subjects
Operon ,Hydrolases ,ACYL CARRIER PROTEIN ,Transferases (Other Substituted Phosphate Groups) ,01 natural sciences ,chemistry.chemical_compound ,Mice ,Loss of Function Mutation ,Catalytic Domain ,CELL-WALL ,Urea ,chemistry.chemical_classification ,0303 health sciences ,Mice, Inbred BALB C ,Multidisciplinary ,biology ,Multidisciplinary Sciences ,Acyl carrier protein ,TARGET ,Biochemistry ,ESCHERICHIA-COLI ,Science & Technology - Other Topics ,Female ,Phosphopantetheine ,CRYSTALLIZATION ,PHOSPHODIESTERASE ,Protein Binding ,General Science & Technology ,Coenzyme A ,Mycobacterium tuberculosis ,Small Molecule Libraries ,03 medical and health sciences ,Biosynthesis ,Bacterial Proteins ,Hydrolase ,Drug Resistance, Bacterial ,Animals ,BIOSYNTHESIS ,Guanidine ,030304 developmental biology ,Science & Technology ,PURIFICATION ,010405 organic chemistry ,TRANSFERASE PPTT ,biology.organism_classification ,Lipid Metabolism ,0104 chemical sciences ,Protein Structure, Tertiary ,Enzyme ,chemistry ,biology.protein ,BIOCHEMISTRY - Abstract
INTRODUCTION Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) is the leading global cause of lethal infection in humans and accounts for the largest number of drug-resistant infections by a single bacterial pathogen. Resistance is particularly high against the most widely prescribed tuberculosis (TB) drug, isoniazid. Isoniazid blocks synthesis of mycolates, ultralong-chain fatty acids that provide structure to the waxy coat that surrounds Mtb cells and are incorporated into some of its virulence lipids. There is currently no known method to block the synthesis of both mycolates and nonmycolate-containing virulence lipids of Mtb at a single point of control. One such control point is phosphopantetheinyl transferase (PptT). PptT transfers 4′-phosphopantetheine (Ppt) from coenzyme A (CoA) to acyl carrier proteins (ACPs) that synthesize the lipids critical to Mtb structural integrity and virulence. RATIONALE TB drug discovery often begins with whole-cell, high-throughput screens that yield compounds that kill Mtb by unknown means. Selection of Mtb mutants resistant to these compounds can indicate candidate targets of the active compound, but experimental validation is required to confirm the functionally relevant target, which is often an enzyme. A suitable target must be essential in vivo, such that its inhibition precludes development of TB in animal models, but also “vulnerable,” meaning that a pharmacologically attainable level of inhibition should be lethal to Mtb within a patient. The inhibitor should act only on Mtb, and resistance should be rare. RESULTS Screening a chemical library revealed an amidino-urea compound called “8918” that kills Mtb, including drug-resistant clinical isolates. 8918 inhibits Mtb in mice and spares other bacteria, yeast, and mammalian cells. Rare Mtb mutants resistant to 8918 bore a point mutation in the PptT gene rv2794c, altering an amino acid residue overlying the Ppt-binding pocket of PptT. When Mtb carried the mutant allele as an extra copy of rv2794c, the Mtb was protected from 8918. 8918 inhibited recombinant PptT, albeit noncompetitively and incompletely. The impact of 8918 on the Mtb metabolome and lipids was consistent with inhibition of PptT in the intact cell. A crystal structure of the PptT-8918 complex at 1.8-Å resolution confirmed that 8918 binds within the Ppt binding pocket, adjacent to the phosphoadenosine phosphate portion of CoA. Intact CoA remained in the PptT-8918 complex, but the Ppt arm was displaced, decreasing but not abolishing PptT’s catalytic activity. Strains of Mtb producing reduced amounts of PptT became hypersensitive to 8918. It was puzzling that even partial inhibition of PptT killed Mtb. We observed that mutants with disruption of rv2795c, a gene encoding a hypothetical protein, were also highly resistant to 8918. Recombinant Rv2795c protein hydrolyzed Ppt from a mycolate-building holo-ACP that is a substrate for PptT. The action of this Ppt hydrolase (PptH) resembled that of nonhomologous enzymes called ACP hydrolases that remove Ppt from ACPs in vitro but whose physiological function is unknown. CONCLUSION We identified a small molecule that kills Mtb by inhibiting PptT, demonstrating that a key enzyme in CoA metabolism is a viable target for TB drug development. Even partial inhibition of PptT is toxic to Mtb, likely because PptH synergizes with the inhibitor by undoing the PptT reaction. PptT and PptH are co-regulated by translation from the same operon, and thus Mtb cannot respond to inhibition of PptT by making more PptT without also generating more PptH. The joint functioning of PptT and PptH suggests that Mtb closely regulates the activation of ACPs. The transcriptional co-regulation and constitutive function of both members of the PptT-PptH couple suggests that a posttranslational signal that impairs PptT more than PptH could allow Mtb to rapidly reverse a prior commitment to synthesis of its metabolically most costly lipids.
- Published
- 2019
- Full Text
- View/download PDF