1. Return of Participants' Incidental Genetic Research Findings: Experience from a Case-Control Study of Asthma in an American Indian Community.
- Author
-
Best, Lyle G., O'Leary, Marcia, O'Leary, Rae, Lawrence, Wendy, and Torgerson, Dara G.
- Subjects
NATIVE American studies ,RURAL Americans ,MEDICAL genetics ,CASE-control method ,TRIBAL government ,HUMAN experimentation ,COMMUNICATIVE disorders - Abstract
The proper communication of clinically actionable findings to participants of genetic research entails important ethical considerations, but has been challenging for a variety of reasons. We document an instance of the return of individual genetic results in the context of a very rural American Indian community, in hopes of providing insight to other investigators about potentially superior or inferior courses of action. This was a case/control study of asthma among 324 pediatric participants. Subsequently, microarray genotype data became available, providing over 2 million variants, incidentally including some conferring risk for conditions for which the American College of Medical Genetics recommends return of results. The study investigators engaged in extensive consultation with the IRB, the tribal government, and local clinicians to better inform our approach. We were able to notify the two participants heterozygous for the one clinically actionable variant identified. One participant welcomed this information and proceeded to obtain further clinical work-up; the other participant declined further follow-up. While demanding considerable time and effort, the return of clinically actionable genetic results is important from both an ethical perspective and to provide an improved trust relationship with the community of research participants. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2023
- Full Text
- View/download PDF