Search

Caffeine has been widely described as a chemo/radiosensitizing agent, presumably by inhibiting DNA repair, and affecting preferentially cells with an altered p53 status. We evaluated the effects of caffeine using isogenic and isophenotypic K1 cells derived from a papillary thyroid carcinoma and displaying either a wild type or a mutated p53 status. Apoptosis and clonogenic survival were examined after exposure of the cells to cisplatin or UVc irradiation. We find that at the most currently used concentration, 2mM, caffeine hinders cisplatin or UVc induced apoptosis in K1 cells. In addition, at this already barely achievable concentration in vivo, caffeine does not decrease their clonogenic survival. Hence in our cellular model, caffeine does not behave as a chemo- or a radiosensitizer. Although surprising, these results (1) are in agreement with the delayed G2/M block caused by caffeine that we previously observed in normal human fibroblasts and K1 cells and (2) allow us to elucidate some discrepancies concerning this molecule throughout the literature such as increase or decrease of apoptosis and clonogenic survival, activation or deactivation of molecules involved in DNA damage repair and proliferation inhibition but accelerated G2/M traverse.

In the literature the sensitization of DNA to radiation-induced damage by caffeine has been attributed to an override of the G2/M block. This process was supposed to involve the tumor suppressor gene p53 as it was described that p53 negative cells were more sensitive to checkpoint inhibition by caffeine than the wildtype phenotype. We have recently shown that caffeine does not cause an override of the G2/M block induced by radiation in normal human fibroblasts. We demonstrate here that this also applies to a human transformed cell line, the thyroid carcinoma K1, when submitted to gamma- rays irradiation. Within 9 hr after irradiation over 70% of the cells accumulated in the G2/M phase. This block persisted at 16 hr. In caffeine containing cultures the percentage of cells attaining the G2/M phase was reduced by over 30% at 16 hr. This was reflected in an accumulation of the cells in G1 phase and an inhibition of the S phase traverse. Cell cycle analyses from further time points combined with cell proliferation measurements confirmed these data. These results were independent of p53 status as experiments performed with variant K1 cell lines having defective p53 functions, led to similar conclusions. In addition, caffeine restored a G1 delay after irradiation in the cell lines with abrogated p53 functions. The effects of caffeine undeniably cumulate with damages induced by irradiation but probably by inhibiting DNA repair mechanisms or by intervening with purine and pyrimidine metabolisms and not by causing a G2/M block override., (Copyright 2001 Wiley-Liss, Inc.)

Caffeine has for many years been known to be involved in the sensitization of DNA to damage. One potential mechanism recently put forward is an override of the G2/M block induced by irradiation, which would leave the cells less time for DNA repair prior to mitosis. However, different cell types display a variety of responses and no clear pathway has yet emerged, especially as little is known about the capacity of this agent to enhance DNA damage in normal, untransformed cells. Continuous exposure to commonly used caffeine concentrations (1-5 mM) inhibited the proliferation of normal human fibroblasts (NHFs) in a dose-dependent manner to up to 80% at 5 mM. Exposure of exponentially growing NHFs to UVc radiation (20 J m(-2)) or gamma radiation (2.5-8 Gy) led to a 45-60% inhibition of proliferation and protracted accumulation of cells in the G2/M phase. Addition of 2 mM caffeine after irradiation induced slowing of the S phase passage, with a resultant delay in G2/M accumulation mimicking a G2/M block override. These results were confirmed by stathmokinetic studies, which showed delayed entry of the cells into mitosis in the presence of caffeine. Our data demonstrate that caffeine primarily inhibits replicative DNA synthesis and suggest that, at least in normal cells, caffeine potentiates the cytotoxicity of radiation by intervening in DNA repair rather than by overriding the G2/M block.