Search

International audience; Several features of cardiovascular devices raise considerations for clinical trial conduct. Prospective, randomized, controlled trials remain the highest quality evidence for safety and effectiveness assessments, but, for instance, blinding may be challenging. In order to avoid bias and not confound data interpretation, the use of objective endpoints and blinding patients, study staff, core labs, and clinical endpoint committees to treatment assignment are helpful approaches. Anticipation of potential bias should be considered and planned for prospectively in a cardiovascular device trial. Prospective, single-arm studies (often referred to as registry studies) can provide additional data in some cases. They are subject to selection bias even when carefully designed; thus, they are generally not acceptable as the sole basis for pre-market approval of high risk cardiovascular devices. However, they complement the evidence base and fill the gaps unanswered by randomized trials. Registry studies present device safety and effectiveness in day-to-day clinical practice settings and detect rare adverse events in the post-market period. No single research design will be appropriate for every cardiovascular device or target patient population. The type of trial, appropriate control group, and optimal length of follow-up will depend on the specific device, its potential clinical benefits, the target patient population and the existence (or lack) of effective therapies, and its anticipated risks. Continued efforts on the part of investigators, the device industry, and government regulators are needed to reach the optimal approach for evaluating the safety and performance of innovative devices for the treatment of cardiovascular disease.

Background The Rheos™ System is a chronically implanted carotid sinus baroreflex activating system with a pulse generator and bilateral perivascular carotid sinus leads (CSLs) that is being evaluated in prospective clinical trials for the treatment of drug-resistant hypertension. We evaluated carotid artery structural integrity after implantation of the CSLs. Methods To assess the effect of chronic CSL attachment, 29 CSLs were implanted on the common carotid arteries of eight sheep. The studies were terminated at 3 and 6 months postimplantation to assess anatomic and histologic changes. Additionally, 10 patients with resistant hypertension were enrolled in the Rheos Multicenter Feasibility Trial. Duplex ultrasound (DUS) was performed before device implantation and at 1 and 4 months postimplantation in this patient cohort. An independent core laboratory assessed all DUSs. Results Ovine carotid angiography revealed no significant stenoses, while anatomic and histologic evaluations demonstrated electrode encapsulation in a thin layer of connective tissue with no evidence of stenosis, erosion, or inflammation. DUS evaluation revealed no significant increase in peak systolic velocities of the common and internal carotid arteries 1 and 4 months after initial implantation, indicating a lack of injury, remodeling, or stenosis. Conclusion The current data suggest that the CSLs used with the Rheos System are not associated with the development of carotid stenosis or injury. These short-term data support the concept of CSL placement and merit long-term investigation in a larger multicenter prospective trial.

Le systeme Rheos™ est un systeme implantable d’activation du baroreflexe du sinus carotidien comprenant un generateur d’impulsion et des electrodes implantees bilateralement au niveau du sinus carotidien (ESC) qui est actuellement en cours d’evaluation dans des etudes prospectives pour le traitement de l’hypertension arterielle resistante au traitement medical. Nous avons evalue l’integrite structurale de la carotide apres implantation d’ESC. Methodes Pour evaluer l’effet de l’implantation chronique d’ESC, 29 ESC ont ete implantes sur les arteres carotides communes de huit moutons. Les etudes se sont terminees a 3 et 6 mois apres implantation pour evaluer les changements anatomiques et histologiques. De plus, 10 patients presentant une hypertension resistante ont ete inclus dans l’etude multicentrique de faisabilite Rheos. Un echo-Doppler (ED) a ete realise avant implantation de dispositif et a 1 et 4 mois apres implantation dans cette population. Un laboratoire independant a evalue tous les ED. Resultats L’angiographie carotidienne chez les moutons n’a revele aucune stenose significative, alors que les etudes anatomiques et histologiques montraient l’encapsulation des electrodes dans une fine couche de tissu conjonctif sans stenose, erosion, ou inflammation. L’evaluation ED n’a montre aucune augmentation significative des pics de vitesse systolique au niveau des carotides communes et internes a 1 et 4 mois apres implantation, indiquant l’absence de lesions, de remodelage ou de stenose. Conclusion Ces donnees suggerent que les ESC utilisees avec le systeme Rheos ne sont pas associes au developpement de stenoses ou de lesions carotidiennes. Ces donnees a court terme soutiennent le concept du placement d’ESC et de la realisation d’etudes a long terme dans un essai prospectif multicentrique.

Prolonged electrical activation of the carotid baroreflex produces sustained reductions in sympathetic activity and arterial pressure in normotensive dogs. The main goal of this study was to assess the influence of prolonged baroreflex activation on arterial pressure and neurohormonal responses in 6 dogs with obesity-induced hypertension. After control measurements, the diet was supplemented with cooked beef fat for 6 weeks, whereas sodium intake was held constant. After 4 weeks of the high-fat diet, there were increments in body weight from 25.8+/-0.7 to 38.6+/-1.0 kg, mean arterial pressure from 97+/-2 to 110+/-3 mm Hg, heart rate from 67+/-3 to 91+/-4 bpm, and plasma norepinephrine concentration from 141+/-35 to 280+/-52 pg/mL. Plasma glucose and insulin concentrations were elevated, but increases in plasma renin activity during the initial weeks of the high-fat diet were not sustained. During week 5, baroreflex activation resulted in sustained reductions in mean arterial pressure, heart rate, and plasma norepinephrine concentration; at the end of week 5, these values were 87+/-2 mm Hg, 77+/-4 bpm, and 166+/-45 pg/mL, respectively. These suppressed values returned to week 4 levels during a 7-day recovery period after baroreflex activation. There were no changes in plasma glucose or insulin concentrations, or plasma renin activity during prolonged baroreflex activation. These findings indicate that baroreflex activation can chronically suppress the sympathoexcitation associated with obesity and abolish the attendant hypertension while having no effect on hyperinsulinemia or hyperglycemia.

Recent studies indicate that suppression of renal sympathetic nerve activity and attendant increments in renal excretory function are sustained baroreflex-mediated responses in hypertensive animals. Given the central role of the kidneys in long-term regulation of arterial pressure, we hypothesized that the chronic blood pressure-lowering effects of the baroreflex are critically dependent on intact renal innervation. This hypothesis was tested in 6 dogs by bilaterally activating the carotid baroreflex electrically for 7 days before and after bilateral renal denervation. Before renal denervation, control values for mean arterial pressure and plasma norepinephrine concentration were 95+/-2 mm Hg and 96+/-12 pg/mL, respectively. During day 1 of baroreflex activation, mean arterial pressure decreased 13+/-1 mm Hg, and there was modest sodium retention. Daily sodium balance was subsequently restored, but reductions in mean arterial pressure were sustained throughout the 7 days of baroreflex activation. Activation of the baroreflex was associated with sustained decreases in plasma norepinephrine concentration ( approximately 50%) and plasma renin activity (30% to 40%). All of the values returned to control levels during a 7-day recovery period. Two weeks after renal denervation, control values for mean arterial pressure, plasma norepinephrine concentration, plasma renin activity, and sodium excretion were comparable to those measured when the renal nerves were intact. Moreover, after renal denervation, all of the responses to activation of the baroreflex were similar to those observed before renal denervation. These findings demonstrate that the presence of the renal nerves is not an obligate requirement for achieving long-term reductions in arterial pressure during prolonged activation of the baroreflex.

Several device-based approaches to autonomic nervous system modulation are under investigation for the treatment of resistant hypertension and heart failure (Table 1).1 This line of research has evolved from the recognition that these diseases originate or are worsened by excess sympathetic activity and loss of parasympathetic tone.9–13 Drug therapies, including β-blockers, α-blockers, and centrally acting antihypertensive drugs, can modulate these neurohormonal systems, but they are often insufficient to control blood pressure (BP) or are limited by side effects or nonadherence. Technological innovations have produced devices that modulate the autonomic nervous system, including renal denervation, carotid baroreceptor stimulation, vagal nerve stimulation, and spinal cord stimulation. View this table: Table 1. Select Completed and Ongoing Clinical Trials of Autonomic Modulation Therapies in Hypertension and Heart Failure In Europe, several autonomic modulation therapy devices have received the Conformite Europeenne mark.14 US Food and Drug Administration evaluation of these devices is ongoing. The need for adequately powered, randomized, controlled studies with longer follow-up to capture definitive evidence of safety and effectiveness has been noted.14–17 The 9th and 10th Global Cardiovascular Clinical Trialists Forum (Paris, France, December 2012 and December 2013) convened a panel of primary investigators of ongoing trials, along with biostatisticians, National Institutes of Health scientists, European, and United States regulators, and medical device and pharmaceutical industry scientists to discuss the strengths and limitations of current clinical trials, optimal designs for future trials, approvability of new devices, and considerations for integrating these technologies into practice. This article summarizes the key discussion points and identifies knowledge gaps in this field that need to be addressed by additional research. The mechanisms of autonomic modulation are complex, and a comprehensive review of these mechanisms is outside the scope of this article. Briefly, all existing strategies aim to decrease central sympathetic outflow. Renal …

Background— Autonomic abnormalities exist in heart failure and contribute to disease progression. Activation of the carotid sinus baroreflex (CSB) has been shown to reduce sympathetic outflow and augment parasympathetic vagal tone. This study tested the hypothesis that long-term electric activation of the CSB improves left ventricular (LV) function and attenuates progressive LV remodeling in dogs with advanced chronic heart failure. Methods and Results— Studies were performed in 14 dogs with coronary microembolization-induced heart failure (LV ejection fraction ≈25%). Eight dogs were chronically instrumented for bilateral CSB activation using the Rheos System (CVRx Inc, Minneapolis, Minn) and 6 were not and served as controls. All dogs were followed for 3 months, and none received other background therapy. During follow-up, treatment with CSB increased LV ejection fraction 4.0±2.4% compared with a reduction in control dogs of −2.8±1.0% ( P P 1 -adrenergic receptors, β-adrenergic receptor kinase, and nitric oxide synthase and reduced interstitial fibrosis and cardiomyocyte hypertrophy. Conclusions— In dogs with advanced heart failure, CSB activation improves global LV function and partially reverses LV remodeling both globally and at cellular and molecular levels.

Myocardial Anisotropy in Ischemia and Infarction. Anisotropy is defined as any property of a system that differs depending on the direction in which it is measured. In the heart, the structure of the cardiac myocytes and their electrical coupling via gap junctions confer an anisotropy in the intracellular resistance to current flow in myocardial tissue. This in turn is responsible for anisotropy in conduction in which the velocity and uniformity of impulse conduction is dependent on its direction relative to the normal myocardial fiber orientation and any underlying pathological nonuniformities in cell orientation and coupling. How cells are coupled also influences refractoriness and excitability. Recent experimental evidence has implicated uniform and nonuniform myocardial anisotropy as important substrates that play a role in the initiation and maintenance of arrhythmias in the setting of ischemia and infarction. These studies may provide a focus for the development of new antiarrhythmic modalities that depend on the modulation of cell electrical coupling.

Abnormalities in cellular coupling, modulated in part by intracellular gap junctions, have an important role in the genesis of reentrant arrhythmias in the setting of chronic myocardial infarction. The effects of heptanol, which has a relatively selective action on gap junctional resistance at low concentrations, and potassium, which primarily affects active membrane properties, were assessed using a localized intracoronary infusion system in 11 normal dogs in vivo. Both agents caused a dose-related slowing of conduction. Programmed stimulation during potassium infusion resulted in ventricular fibrillation in two of six animals treated with a low dose (5.0-5.5 meq/l) and five of six animals treated with a high dose (7.0-7.5 meq/l). During the infusion of 1.0 mM heptanol, uniform ventricular tachycardia was induced in four of eight animals. Infusion of heptanol, but not potassium, increased the susceptibility to presumably reentrant ventricular tachycardia in normal myocardium. This suggests that agents that affect cellular coupling may have markedly different arrhythmogenic consequences than agents that primarily alter active membrane properties.

Much of the current pharmacological therapy for chronic heart failure targets neurohormonal activation. In spite of recent advances in drug therapy, the mortality rate for chronic heart failure remains high. Activation of the carotid baroreceptor (BR) reduces sympathetic outflow and augments vagal tone. We investigated the effect of chronic activation of the carotid BR on hemodynamic and neurohormonal parameters and on mortality in dogs with chronic heart failure. Fifteen dogs were instrumented to record hemodynamics. Electrodes were applied around the carotid sinuses to allow for activation of the BR. After 2 weeks of pacing (250 bpm), electrical carotid BR activation was initiated in 7 dogs and continued for the remainder of the study. The start of BR activation was used as a time reference point for the remaining 8 control dogs that did not receive BR activation. Survival was significantly greater for dogs undergoing carotid BR activation compared with control dogs (68.1±7.4 versus 37.3±3.2 days, respectively; P P P

OBJECTIVES: To assess perioperative outcomes and blood pressure (BP) responses to an implantable carotid sinus baroreflex activating system being investigated for the treatment of resistant hypertension. METHODS: We report on the first seventeen patients enrolled in a multicenter study. Bilateral perivascular carotid sinus electrodes (CSL) and a pulse generator (IPG) are permanently implanted. Optimal placement of the CSL is determined by intraoperative BP responses to test activations. Acute BP responses were tested postoperatively and during the first four months of follow-up. RESULTS: Prior to implant, BP was 189.6+/-27.5/110.7+/-15.3 mmHg despite stable therapy (5.2+/-1.8 antihypertensive drugs). The mean procedure time was 202+/-43 minutes. No perioperative strokes or deaths occurred. System tests performed 1 or up to 3 days postoperatively resulted in significant (all p < or = 0.0001) mean maximum reduction, with standard deviations and 95% confidence limits for systolic BP, diastolic BP and heart rate of 28+/-22 (17, 39) mmHg, 16+/-11 (10, 22) mmHg and 8+/-4 (6, 11) BPM, respectively. Repeated testing during 3 months of therapeutic electrical activation demonstrated a durable response. CONCLUSIONS: These preliminary data suggest an acceptable safety of the procedure with a low rate of adverse events and support further clinical development of baroreflex activation as a new concept to treat resistant hypertension.

BackgroundA large number of patients have hypertension that is resistant to currently available pharmacologic therapy. Electrical stimulation of the carotid sinus baroreflex system has been shown to produce significant chronic blood pressure decreases in animals. The phase II Rheos Feasibility Trial was performed to assess the response of patients with multidrug-resistant hypertension to such stimulation.MethodsThe system consists of an implantable pulse generator with bilateral perivascular carotid sinus leads. Implantation is performed bilaterally with patients under narcotic anesthesia (to preserve the reflex for assessment of optimal lead placement). Dose-response testing at 0 to 6 V is assessed before discharge and at monthly intervals thereafter; the device is activated after 1 month’s recovery time. This was a Food and Drug Administration–monitored phase II trial performed at five centers in the United States.ResultsTen patients with resistant hypertension (taking a median of six antihypertensive medications) underwent implantation. All 10 were successful, with no significant morbidity. The mean procedure time was 198 minutes. There were no adverse events attributable to the device. Predischarge dose-response testing revealed consistent (r = .88) reductions in systolic blood pressure of 41 mm Hg (mean fall is from 180-139 mm Hg), with a peak response at 4.8 V (P < .001) and without significant bradycardia or bothersome symptoms.ConclusionsA surgically implantable device for electrical stimulation of the carotid baroreflex system can be placed safely and produces a significant acute decrease in blood pressure without significant side effects.

The role of baroreflexes in long-term control of arterial pressure is unresolved. To determine whether chronic activation of the baroreflex produces sustained hypotension, we developed a method for prolonged activation of the carotid baroreflex in conscious dogs. This was achieved by chronically implanting electrodes around both carotid sinuses and using an externally adjustable pulse generator to electrically activate the carotid baroreflex. Control values for mean arterial pressure (MAP) and heart rate were 93+/-3 mm Hg and 64+/-4 bpm, respectively. After control measurements, the carotid baroreflex was activated bilaterally for 7 days at a level that produced a prompt and substantial reduction in MAP, and for day 1 MAP was reduced to 75+/-4 mm Hg. Moreover, this hypotensive response was sustained throughout the entire 7 days of baroreflex activation (day 7, MAP=72+/-5 mm Hg). During prolonged baroreflex activation, heart rate decreased in parallel with MAP, although the changes were not as pronounced (day 7, heart rate=51+/-3 bpm). Prolonged baroreflex activation was also associated with approximately 35% reduction in plasma norepinephrine concentration (control=87+/-15 pg/mL). After baroreflex activation, hemodynamic measures and plasma levels of norepinephrine returned to control levels. Interestingly, despite the pronounced fall in MAP, plasma renin activity did not increase during prolonged baroreflex activation. These data indicate that prolonged baroreflex activation can lead to substantial reductions in MAP by suppressing the sympathetic nervous system. Furthermore, sustained sympathoinhibitory effects on renin secretion may play an important role in mediating the long-term hypotensive response.

Background —Dual-chamber pacing (DDD) has been proposed as a treatment alternative to surgery for severely symptomatic patients with obstructive hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM), based largely on uncontrolled studies. Methods and Results —This prospective, multicenter trial assessed pacing in 48 symptomatic HCM patients with ≥50 mm Hg basal gradient, refractory to drug therapy. Patients were randomized to 3 months each of DDD pacing and pacing backup (AAI-30) in a double-blind, crossover study design, followed by an uncontrolled and unblinded 6-month pacing trial. With randomization, no significant differences were evident between pacing and no pacing for subjective or objective measures of symptoms or exercise capacity, including NYHA functional class, quality of life score, treadmill exercise time or peak oxygen consumption. After 6 additional months of unblinded pacing, functional class and quality of life score were improved compared with baseline ( P P P= NS). Conclusions —(1) Pacing cannot be regarded as a primary treatment for obstructive HCM; (2) with randomization, perceived symptomatic improvement was most consistent with a substantial placebo effect; (3) longer, uncontrolled pacing periods were associated with some subjective benefit but unaccompanied by objective improvement in cardiovascular performance and should be interpreted cautiously; (4) modest reduction in outflow gradient was achieved in most patients; and (5) a small subset (12%) ≥ 65 years of age showed a clinical response, suggesting that DDD pacing could be a therapeutic option for some elderly patients.

Background —Dual-chamber pacing can improve symptoms in hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM), but the mechanism remains unclear. We hypothesized that pacing generates discoordinate contraction and a rightward shift of the end-systolic pressure-volume relation (ESPVR) and that benefits from this mechanism do not depend on the presence of resting outflow pressure gradients or obstruction. Methods and Results —Eleven patients with NYHA class III symptoms, 5 with HCM, and 6 with hypertensive hypertrophy and cavity obliteration, were studied by invasive conductance catheter methods. No patient had coronary artery or primary valvular disease. Pressure-volume relations were recorded before and during VDD pacing by use of a short (75-millisecond) PR interval to achieve preexcitation. Left ventricular cavity pressure was simultaneously recorded at basal and apical sites, with pressure at the basal site used to generate the ESPVRs. VDD pacing shifted the ESPVR rightward, increasing end-systolic volume by 45% (range, 17% to 151%; P =0.002). Resting and provokable gradients declined by 20% (range, −56% to +3%) and 30% (range, −65% to −12%), respectively ( P P Conclusions —VDD pacing shifts the ESPVR rightward in HCM patients with cavity obliteration with or without obstruction, increasing end-systolic volumes and reducing apical cavity compression and cardiac work. These effects likely contribute to reduced metabolic demand and improved symptoms.

Carotid sinus hypersensitivity (CSH) has been studied in subjects in sinus rhythm, but it has never been studied in patients with chronic atrial fibrillation (AF). After a finding of CSH in a patient with chronic AF and syncope, we studied the effects of carotid sinus stimulation in a group of patients with AF. Ten patients with chronic AF and normal ventricular rates who complained of dizziness or loss of consciousness underwent right and left carotid sinus massage (CSM) during ECG monitoring. A control group of ten patients with AF but without neurological symptoms was likewise investigated. CSH was present in eight symptomatic patients (5 patients presented right CSH, 1 left and 2 bilateral CSH), but only in three of the control patients. The mean duration of asystole induced by right CSM was 5.94 ± 2.10 seconds; the mean asystolic interval induced by left CSM lasted 8.58 ± 1.42 seconds. Six patients in the symptomatic group had a recurrence of spontaneous symptomatology during CSM, so that a diagnosis of carotid sinus syndrome was established. All symptomatic patients (8 patients with CSH, 2 patients with ventricular standstills but without CSH) received a permanent ventricular pacemaker. Following pacing, all patients, except for one with a significant drop of systolic blood pressure during CSM. became completely asymptomatic. In elder patients with chronic AF, CSH can induce prolonged ventricular asystole, which may be responsible for neurological symptoms such as dizziness, presyncope, or syncope, as observed in patients in sinus rhythm with carotid sinus syndrome. Abnormal sensitivity of the carotid sinus could, therefore, be one of the causes of increased morbidity and mortality in patients with chronic AF. Permanent ventricular pacing may help reduce these complications.

Substances structurally and functionally similar to digitalis glycosides are produced by several vertebrate species. There also is evidence for a digitalis-like substance of human origin. Standard microelectrode techniques were used to study the direct effects on the cellular electrophysiology of canine Purkinje fibers of 1) bufalin, an unconjugated cardiotonic steroid molecule that is produced by the toad Bufo marinus, and 2) an extract of human bile that showed digitalis-like immunoreactivity on radioimmunoassay. The goal of this study was to determine whether these substances have arrhythmogenic effects comparable with those seen with toxic doses of digitalis glycosides. Bufalin, 2 x 10(-8) M, significantly (p less than 0.05) reduced maximal diastolic potential, action potential amplitude and duration and maximal rate of rise of phase 0 (Vmax) within 40 min of onset of exposure. All six fibers developed delayed afterdepolarizations and two developed triggered rhythms. Ouabain was less potent, in that a 2 x 10(-7) M concentration was required to comparably reduce maximal diastolic potential, action potential amplitude and duration and Vmax within 30 min. These Purkinje fibers also developed delayed afterdepolarizations and triggered rhythms. A sample of an extract of human bile that showed digitalis-like immunoreactivity with an antibufalin serum also reduced maximal diastolic potential, action potential amplitude and duration and Vmax, and produced delayed afterdepolarizations and triggered activity. In contrast, immunologically unreactive bile extracts had no appreciable effect on the action potential. In summary, the cardiac toxicity of digitalis substances produced by lower vertebrates is comparable with that induced by the glycosides. Moreover, it appears that humans may produce digitalis-like substances that may be cardiotoxic.

Standard microelectrode techniques were used to study bigeminal rhythms occurring during otherwise stable triggered activity in ouabain-toxic canine Purkinje fibers. The basis for the bigeminy appeared to be an al-ternans phenomenon in the delayed afterdepolarizations that induced the triggered activity, as well as in the maximal diastolic potential. The occurrence of bigeminy, previously thought to result from reentry, from single delayed afterdepolarizations coupled to a triggered action potential or from parasystole, can also be considered a manifestation of sustained triggered activity.