1. Erectile dysfunction management: a critical appraisal of clinical practice guidelines with the AGREE II instrument
- Author
-
Hakan Bahadir Haberal, Ahmet Gudeloglu, Asif Muneer, Ahmet Asci, and Berk Hazir
- Subjects
medicine.medical_specialty ,030219 obstetrics & reproductive medicine ,business.industry ,Urology ,030232 urology & nephrology ,MEDLINE ,medicine.disease ,Clinical Practice ,03 medical and health sciences ,Critical appraisal ,0302 clinical medicine ,Erectile dysfunction ,Family medicine ,Sexual medicine ,medicine ,Agree ii ,Medical journal ,business ,National Guideline Clearinghouse - Abstract
Our study aimed to assess the methodological strengths and weaknesses of erectile dysfunction clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) for individuals using the AGREE II tool. Erectile dysfunction related CPGs were identified from three databases: the National Guideline Clearinghouse, the Guidelines International Network, and PubMed between 2000 and 2020. We designed an independent assessment for each of the erectile dysfunction related CPGs using the AGREE II tool. Four appraisers performed these assessments. The literature search identified 8 CPGs that met our inclusion criteria. The evaluation of the AGREE II domains of each individual revealed that the median scores of domains related to applicability were quite low (39%). Also, the median scores of domains related to the rigour of development and the stakeholder involvement were relatively low (53% and 63%). We determined the highest median scores in three AGREE II domains: clarity of presentation (80.5%), editorial independence (77%), and scope and purpose (89.5%). We found that the European Association of Urology (EAU), the American Urological Association (AUA), and the British Society for Sexual Medicine (BSSM) guidelines had >60% in >4 domains and that their average AGREE II scores were over 70%. In the Canadian Diabetic Association (CDA) and the Japanese Society for Sexual Medicine (JSSM) guidelines, we found that >4 domains were >60%, but their average AGREE II scores were below 70%. The British Medical Journal (BMJ), the Canadian Urologic Association (CUA), and the Malaysian Urologic Association (MUA) guidelines had >60% in
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF