1. Reliability of alternative devices for postoperative patient temperature measurement: two prospective, observational studies*
- Author
-
Eloise Broadbent, Philip J Peyton, and Verna M Aykanat
- Subjects
Male ,Urinary Bladder ,Temperature measurement ,Body Temperature ,Postoperative management ,Pacu ,03 medical and health sciences ,0302 clinical medicine ,030202 anesthesiology ,Nasopharynx ,Bladder temperature ,medicine ,Humans ,Forehead ,Postoperative Period ,Prospective Studies ,030212 general & internal medicine ,Reliability (statistics) ,Aged ,Monitoring, Physiologic ,biology ,business.industry ,Limits of agreement ,Middle Aged ,biology.organism_classification ,Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine ,medicine.anatomical_structure ,ROC Curve ,Area Under Curve ,Female ,Observational study ,Nuclear medicine ,business - Abstract
Peri-operative hypothermia is associated with significant morbidity, yet limitations exist regarding non-invasive temperature assessment in the post-anaesthesia care unit (PACU). In this prospective study of 100 patients, we aimed to determine the reliability of two commonly used temperature measurement devices, forehead temporal artery temperature and tympanic measurement, in addition to an indwelling urinary catheter with temperature probe, in comparison with the final nasopharyngeal core temperature at the end of surgery. Agreement of forehead measurement with nasopharyngeal temperature showed a mean bias (±95% limits of agreement) of 0.15 °C (±1.4 °C), with a steep slope of the relationship on the Bland-Altman plot of -0.8, indicating a tendency to normalise patient temperature readings to 36.4 °C. Only 54% of hypothermic cases were correctly detected by the forehead measurement device. Agreement of tympanic measurement with nasopharyngeal core temperature measurement was marginally improved with a mean bias of 0.13 °C (95% limits of agreement ±1.15 °C). In contrast, agreement of bladder temperature with nasopharyngeal temperature showed a mean (SD) bias of 0.19 (0.28) °C (95% limits of agreement ±0.54 °C), with a relatively flat line of best fit. We demonstrated that two commonly used temperature measurement devices, forehead temporal artery temperature and tympanic measurement, compared with nasopharyngeal core temperature, were imprecise and unreliable following major surgery. However, the indwelling catheter with temperature sensor was precise and acceptable for continuous core temperature measurement in the PACU.
- Published
- 2020